Boys castrated by Catholic church

catsmate

No longer the 1
Joined
Apr 9, 2007
Messages
37,315
An investigation by Dutch newspaper NRC Handelsblad and published this weekend claims that up to eleven boys were castrated while in the care of the Dutch Roman Catholic church in the 1950s, supposedly to rid them of homosexuality
Also reported is that one young man was castrated in 1956 after telling police he was being abused by priests, the newspaper reported.

According to media reports the Dutch Catholic church has said it is willing to co-operate with an investigation to find out whether the reports are true.

More info.
NY Times
BBC
Reuters
 
After official report after report of the most horrific, systematic abuse of every kind known to humanity and of the subsequent cover-ups by the RCC I find myself no longer being surprised never mind shocked by any new incidents that come to light.

How anyone can still profess to follow this corrupt organisation is beyond me.
 
Last edited:
After official report after report of the most horrific, systematic abuse of every kind known to humanity and of the subsequent cover-ups by the RCC I find myself no longer being surprised never mind shocked by any new incidents that come to light.

How anyone can still profess to follow this corrupt organisation is beyond me.



Your question set me thinking about the Leucochloridium parasite (also see this link) that infests a snail and makes it behave in such a way so as to become easier pray for birds which then eat it and their droppings filled with the parasite infect more snails and thus the cycle is completed, perpetuated and spread.


For a sad list of some of the crimes against humanity Christianity has perpetrated see this post. But at the very least have a look at this list.

The story of Hypatia (see below) has been made into a nice must-see movie.

They officially apologized about Galileo but since Bruno is not very well known they were never PRESSURED to apologize about SNUFFING his life and the resulting loss to humanity, not to mention the loss of his GENES that may have benefited humanity along the last 400+ years.

The egregious harm that religion causes is not just of a direct effect to its victims....rather it is an all pervasive chronic retardation of humanity due to direct suppression of knowledge and even more importantly due to the LOSS of opportunities that may have evolved the human condition a long time ago.

For examples of this consider the RETARDATION and VITIATION with which Christianity eventually plagued the human race.

Among the very deeply pensive and poignant short stories in the marvelous book Galileo's Children: Tales of Science Vs. Superstition , the one by Keith Roberts called The will Of God expresses most exquisitely the effects of Christianity on the world.

Roberts' short story explores the possibility of an inventive mind that creates the phonograph during the Inquisition era and is burnt on the stake as a witch along with his demon-summoning contraption, his scribblings, as well as the only witness to the facts, his maid that snitched on him to the Grand Inquisitor after being terrified out of her mind by the demon voices coming out of the device.

This fictional account is quite illustrative of what Christianity managed to do across the board to all SCIENCE and KNOWLEDGE in REALITY, not just in a fictional ponderings. Giordano Bruno being one example among many.

A REAL historical parallel to the above story is the MURDER of Hypatia by Christians.

Hypatia was an amazing mind. Who knows what more she could have accomplished had not "the mob of Christian monks flayed her body with ostraca (pot shards), and then burned her remains". All because of Christian Love and Tolerance.


Also see this illuminating albeit tragic information. Not to mention the persecution of women throughout the Christian ages (also see this).
 
Last edited:
Castration as punishment for complaining about being raped. Gotta love God's representatives. (Or they'll cut your balls off.)
The Church may simply have wanted castrati singers, which it had plenty of in the past for the soprano range, as women were not permitted in choirs. One of them, Alessandro Moreschi, lived recently enough to be recorded, about a century ago.
 
The Church may simply have wanted castrati singers, which it had plenty of in the past for the soprano range, as women were not permitted in choirs. One of them, Alessandro Moreschi, lived recently enough to be recorded, about a century ago.



Well, they should take advantage to develop some castrati* in any case.














* Add to dictionary.
 
Yeah, treating humans like stereo gear. That's makes me love them that much more.
In 1861 the newly-unified (and secular) Italian state banned the custom of castrating boys for church choirs, up to then practiced in the Papal States and the south-Italian Kingdom of the Two Sicilies. About the turn of the 20th century Pope Leo XIII finally renounced the practice on behalf of the Church, although in other respects he was very much opposed to "modernist" innovations. So your goolies are now safe, even in Rome.

Curiously, this castration of boy singers is not of ancient date; it seems to have started in the 1500s.
 
Last edited:
The Church may simply have wanted castrati singers, which it had plenty of in the past for the soprano range, as women were not permitted in choirs. One of them, Alessandro Moreschi, lived recently enough to be recorded, about a century ago.

Chemical castration is all that's required for that. Ask Michael Jackson.

On second thought, don't...
 
After official report after report of the most horrific, systematic abuse of every kind known to humanity and of the subsequent cover-ups by the RCC I find myself no longer being surprised never mind shocked by any new incidents that come to light.

How anyone can still profess to follow this corrupt organisation is beyond me.

I think that is sort of like saying how can anyone want to be a US citizen because of US torture in Iraqi prisons, waterboarding, and things like the Tuskegee syphilis experiment.
 
I think that is sort of like saying how can anyone want to be a US citizen because of US torture in Iraqi prisons, waterboarding, and things like the Tuskegee syphilis experiment.


Not exactly.
One is a government, the other a religion. Religions are easy to leave. No passports, no countries, no laws. Just obscenely self-absorbed patriarchal systems obsessed with sex.

Nonetheless, many people are very angry about what the U.S. government as done, too.

As for me, I'm not American. But Canada has it's share of human rights violations. Residential schools, for example (which were religious, 60% Catholic, 30% Anglican, 10% a mixture that became the United Church). Funny how the Catholics seem to keep cropping up in human rights violations...



In regard to the OP: How many times will we hear of an abhorrent action undertaken by the church, before people stop sending their money to Pope Ratzinger? I honestly don't think many Catholics see themselves as members of the whole organization, but rather only as members of their neighbourhood church. I suspect most Catholics simply don't associate their local parish with the evil institution that the Catholic Church has become. At least, I never hear them talk about the Institution. On the rare occasions they do talk about the church, it is the one they attend. And on an even less-frequent basis, they may mention Ratzinger.



ETA: Another difference: Governments don't claim to be teachers of the only true source of morality. Religions do.
 
Last edited:
In 1861 the newly-unified (and secular) Italian state banned the custom of castrating boys for church choirs, up to then practiced in the Papal States and the south-Italian Kingdom of the Two Sicilies. About the turn of the 20th century Pope Leo XIII finally renounced the practice on behalf of the Church, although in other respects he was very much opposed to "modernist" innovations. So your goolies are now safe, even in Rome.

Curiously, this castration of boy singers is not of ancient date; it seems to have started in the 1500s.

As I was born in 1951...
 
How anyone can still profess to follow this corrupt organisation is beyond me.

Simple they just tell the parishioners how much they love them and that they will not do it again ... until the next time.

Seriously, I think it is akin to the same dynamic in an abusive relationship, just writ large.
 
Your question set me thinking about the Leucochloridium parasite (also see this link) that infests a snail and makes it behave in such a way so as to become easier pray for birds which then eat it and their droppings filled with the parasite infect more snails and thus the cycle is completed, perpetuated and spread.

And what were your conclusions from your thinking?

For a sad list of some of the crimes against humanity Christianity has perpetrated see this post. But at the very least have a look at this list.

The story of Hypatia (see below) has been made into a nice must-see movie.
I am in full agreement with what Darat and mostly with what you pointed out in your previous post, particularly because I was a member of the RCC until the late 60s. I do have to wonder what a "must-see" movie based on the extremely thin evidence available from 1700 years ago has to do with evidence for anything else though. The church, the Romans, volcanoes and bacteria in the water killed thousands in that time, perhaps even more than the Republicans do today :) . (Sorry for the near Godwin).
 
Last edited:
Let's try to keep the sides straight here.

snork.gif
 
X said:
How many times will we hear of an abhorrent action undertaken by the church, before people stop sending their money to Pope Ratzinger?
Considering that over a billion people say they get their morals from this organization?

It's an old problem for the Church--is God good because He does good things, or because He defines what good means? The Church seems to hold that the Church is good because it defines what good means, which means that anything they do is moral because they say so. With the strict adherance to the hierarchy that the Church demands a lot of people simply won't question it. Plus, they can always play the "It's a few bad apples" angle, which is surprisingly effective.
 
I honestly don't think many Catholics see themselves as members of the whole organization, but rather only as members of their neighbourhood church. I suspect most Catholics simply don't associate their local parish with the evil institution that the Catholic Church has become. At least, I never hear them talk about the Institution. On the rare occasions they do talk about the church, it is the one they attend. And on an even less-frequent basis, they may mention Ratzinger.

I'd have to argue about that one. The members of the church certainly do feel emotionally attached not only to their local church but also to their diocese and to the Holy See. All the local catholics read the diocesan newspaper, and especially the list of movie ratings it contained before letting their kids go to the Saturday matinees. It was emotional and not mainly intellectual, and of course I was experiencing it 40 years ago at a rather more impressionable age, but also when it was a damned-sight more liberal than it is today.

There was, of course, the well known separation between the Catholic bishops and the papacy concerning birth control at the time. Most catholic families in my neighborhood use birth control in one form or another, quite in contrast to the previous generation; the difference sunk down even to the level of teenagers. That may have marked a sea change, but I, alas for the purposes of being a devil's advocate, didn't partake.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom