Black Swan Event Under Way

Fed dropped interest rate to zero.
Might help the stock a little on Monday,but any gains will be erased by the end of thw week as the bad virus news continues.
 
Calif. just announced large scale mitigation efforts. All people with health issues OR are over 65 are to be quarantined at home. All bars and clubs are to be closed. Restaurants are to reduce capacity 50% and re-seat based on extreme social distancing. Selected schools are to be closed based on the local situation. Further measures may be necessary and the state has the legal power to enforce things if required.
 
All people with health issues OR are over 65 are to be quarantined at home.

Not quite accurate. They are being urged to stay indoors;not the same thing as a quarantine.. I don't think you could enforce a quarantine in practical terms.
 
Last edited:
All people with health issues OR are over 65 are to be quarantined at home.

Not quite accurate. They are being urged to stay indoors;not the same thing as a quarantine.. I don't think you could enforce a quarantine in practical terms.

Requested to stay at home.

"SACRAMENTO — Gov. Gavin Newsom called Sunday for all senior citizens and residents with chronic conditions to isolate themselves at home."


That's what I heard listening to the Gov. It was also stated that if people didn't comply that authority existed to enforce it should that be necessary. It is arguably a "voluntary" quarantine. Currently.
 
SP500 on first limit down but curiously opened near unchanged and took several minutes.
 
Fed cuts rates to zero, and does a bunch of other stuff that involves throwing money at the problem. (No link, but you can look it up yourselves. It's easy to find.)

I'm not an economist. I know more about interest rates and economics than the average person does, but that's a bit like saying I know more about economics than a teaspoon knows.

It just seems to me that what they are doing is recognizing the enormous economic impact of this virus and/or the "social isolation" policies that are being used to slow its spread, but they are trying to treat the economic problem as if it were some sort of financial event, using the usual tools. It seems like a bad idea, and the primary effect will be to alter the value of currency, which just doesn't seem like a good idea.

The economy is going to suck for a while because people aren't working. When they don't work, they don't produce. When they don't produce, there's not much stuff.

Normally, this is caused by some strange conditions within the financial world, and perhaps triggered by a natural, or man made, disaster. e.g. the crisis of 2008 happened because people were mortgaged to the hilt, but the lenders were hiding the risk of the loans. When a sudden rise in gas prices caused some people to miss a few payments, the scam was exposed and the economy collapsed. That's kind of normal. That particular event was more extreme than normal, but the pattern was normal.

The solution involved putting a bunch of money out there so that companies had the cash to start producing again, and hire the people needed to produce.

This isn't like that. They could throw all the money they want at this crisis, and if people are afraid to go to work, they won't go to work. To my very naïve eye, it looks like a recipe for inflation, but I would await a verdict from actual knowledgeable people on that.

I don't know. Seems like a very bad idea, but I admit that is an uninformed opinion.
 
Fed dropped interest rate to zero.
Might help the stock a little on Monday,but any gains will be erased by the end of thw week as the bad virus news continues.

It's not going to help today - futures are down 1000 after the announcement.

The only thing it might do is cost me $10 by taking more than 5 minutes to hit the stop button.

Where's that bloke who was lecturing me that governments know what to do? If my maths is right, once you start cutting rates after zero, the bank is paying you to take their money.

Calif. just announced large scale mitigation efforts. All people with health issues OR are over 65 are to be quarantined at home.

See Japan, mate - if you want to slow this sucker down, SHUT THE DAMNED SCHOOLS!

I am convinced that's the reason other countries are passing them like an F1 car with a flat tyre.
 
I'd been meaning to say - all the way so far there's been talk of China undergoing lower growth rates.

Today, for the first time, I see commentators suggesting they will show a contraction in the March quarter.

I feel like I need some kind of eye-popping emoji, but it would need to be one that pops out of the screen. That is just gob-smackingly bad economic news.
 
Requested to stay at home.

"SACRAMENTO — Gov. Gavin Newsom called Sunday for all senior citizens and residents with chronic conditions to isolate themselves at home."


That's what I heard listening to the Gov. It was also stated that if people didn't comply that authority existed to enforce it should that be necessary. It is arguably a "voluntary" quarantine. Currently.

And if someone over 65 has to go out for Gorceries?
 
And if someone over 65 has to go out for Gorceries?

Get them delivered.

That's why I'm frantically hiring people to do just that.

You'd better be in NZ, though - the peas will be a bit mushy by the time they get to USA.
 
Just in case anyone's interested, I just sent this email to newspapers in NZ, along with the Prime Minister and Treasurer:

It's now clear that Covid-19 is an earth-changing event. The sky virtually clear of planes, pollution at record lows and massive numbers of deaths that were not expected as short as 4 weeks ago, at which time, it was a Chinese problem and share markets were still humming along at near-record levels.

In the space of four weeks, thousands have died, hospital services near outbreaks have been crushed and the world economy has taken a hit that has already lost in excess of $20 trillion from share values. The hit to the world's GDP is conservatively estimated to be $2 trillion.

Around the world, billions in wages are being lost, and that will increase quickly as more jobs shut down. We will soon be running the country on a skeleton crew and most people won't be working. Kids will be at home for extended periods and daycares will be shut. The hit to the spending power of people will be unlike anything in all our history.

Then comes the bigger issue - people will be unable to pay rents and mortgages. If they're not earning, they will struggle to buy food, let alone pay for shelter.

Given that central bank rates have been slashed to zero, it seems to me that a strong case could be made for them to actually slash them to zero. That would be on the basis that banks put every mortgage on hold, at zero interest rates themselves. Mortgagees would then not need to pay their mortgage, and it would cost them nothing.

At the same time, property owners would agree to collect no rent for as long as the mortgage rates stay at zero - logically until the epidemic has passed.

That way, nobody is out of pocket, nobody is kicked out of their dwelling for non-payment and it will enable people to continue buying the basics.

If you see anything wrong with my case or maths, fire away!
 
Just in case anyone's interested, I just sent this email to newspapers in NZ, along with the Prime Minister and Treasurer:



If you see anything wrong with my case or maths, fire away!

Here's what's wrong with your case.

You say it would cost banks nothing to cut mortgage rates to zero.

So, how do bank employees get paid? Do mortgage statements still get generated? Do ATMs still get stocked? Do all the things that banks do keep happening? If so, how? Volunteers?



I can see doing some sort of thing to prevent foreclosures during this period, and that, too, will hurt banks, but not nearly as much.
 
Here's what's wrong with your case.

You say it would cost banks nothing to cut mortgage rates to zero.

So, how do bank employees get paid?

What work needs to be done still gets done and those people get paid.

Others are laid off and paid by the government by way of unemployment or other benefit, exactly the same as:

Restaurant & cafe workers
Fast food workers
Airline staff
Cruise ship staff
Disneyland & other attraction staff
.... a very long list of people whose income will be zero, and governments will need to take up the slack.
 
Meanwhile, I think my 5 minutes looks a wild over-estimate. 5 seconds will be more like it.

Fed cuts rates to near zero. Dow futures are at limit down half an hour later.

Goldman Sachs predicts a -5% contraction in Q2. There aren't any words to describe how massive that is.
 
What work needs to be done still gets done and those people get paid.

Others are laid off and paid by the government by way of unemployment or other benefit, exactly the same as:

Restaurant & cafe workers
Fast food workers
Airline staff
Cruise ship staff
Disneyland & other attraction staff
.... a very long list of people whose income will be zero, and governments will need to take up the slack.

Then you have all the businesses that supply restaurants&cafes etc. And all the small service businesses from the guy who operates a hot-dog stand to hairdressers, manicurists, massage parlors and so on...
 
Then you have all the businesses that supply restaurants&cafes etc. And all the small service businesses from the guy who operates a hot-dog stand to hairdressers, manicurists, massage parlors and so on...

Hell yeah, that's why I didn't try to make a complete list - it includes lots and lots of business types, including many that don't seem troublesome. Construction is one - with so much commercial electronics manufactured in China, tech companies are hitting supply problems, and if you don't have controls for the lights, aircond, lifts, security, etc, you don't have a building that can be used.

And I know that sort of thing is already happening. It will only get worse.

Then talk about jails. I wouldn't want to be holding shares in jail operators right now - they are going to see some serious **** happen.
 
TVIX buyers are pretty confident the Dow hits the floor tomorrow - currently trading at $488.

This ain't no roller-coaster, it's Journey to the Centre of the Earth.

How low can it go?

It's like a reverse auction. Who will give me 20,000? 18,000? 15,000?

I thought it was starting to look oversold. Obviously not.
 
TVIX buyers are pretty confident the Dow hits the floor tomorrow - currently trading at $488.

This ain't no roller-coaster, it's Journey to the Centre of the Earth.

How low can it go?

It's like a reverse auction. Who will give me 20,000? 18,000? 15,000?

I thought it was starting to look oversold. Obviously not.

18,000.

Just a hunch.

But there's a factor that might make it even worse. Conventional wisdom is that if you need the money now, you keep it in cash. If you are willing to wait, you put it in stocks. People, and corporations, are going to need the money right now, so no matter how low it goes, people won't flood the market with buy orders.

In other words, I think with the recent bear market, a lot of companies are undervalued right now. However, I won't be buying them because I want to keep a cash reserve in case I'm laid off and need the money right now.

Also, as layoffs start happening, 401k orders dry up.

The only thing I don't know is when the bottom hits.

This week will tell us a lot, actually. One week ago, people were a bit nervous, but coronavirus was still not at the forefront of everyone's mind. Now, it is the only thing people are thinking about. A week from now will we be calming down, or panicking more? The number of cases is about to explode in the US. Is the panic over those cases already happening, or will it get even worse as the reality hits home?

My greatest long term fear is that the efforts to prop up the stock market will fail, but will leave a big scar, and no option to recover it when the epidemic is over, and my saved up cash will turn out not to be the best investment.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom