Black Swan Event Under Way

What they won't see is what would have happened without the necessary social distancing with a million plus deaths.

Well, they won't have to look too far to see it, because it's just starting to take hold on some countries with very poor healthcare.

I listen to right wing talk radio. They're already saying it. Whether they continue to say it will depend on how it plays out.

Might depend on if Der Fuhrer has it, too.
_______________________________

Meanwhile, the PM of Singapore has been talking to Captain Obvious: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/arti...ncial-crisis-singapore-says?srnd=premium-asia

The economic fallout from the coronavirus could be more serious than the damage done by the 2008 global financial crisis for Singapore, according to Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong.

I think he's well under the mark.

The entire shutdown of Italy will be a massive jolt to the EU, and I believe Spain's about to go down the same path.

The whole thing with the shutdowns is that it's not going to make the virus magically disappear. It'll slow it down just enough to build up steam again later.
 
Meanwhile, the PM of Singapore has been talking to Captain Obvious:

...

The whole thing with the shutdowns is that it's not going to make the virus magically disappear. It'll slow it down just enough to build up steam again later.
The Singapore PM isn't the only one talking to Captain Obvious. Your post also strikes me as both a straw man and a goal post move. I doubt if serious people believe it will magically disappear. Summer in the northern hemisphere may also slow it down.

And here's something else: Yes, the hospitality business, sports leagues, airlines will be hard hit. But the closures mean some people will save money. And some industries will be stimulated. Home entertainment systems, for example. There is likely to be pent-up demand eventually. Not soon enough to benefit Trump, I hope.

There is also the weird non-linear and even non-exponential behavior of the virus. You admit you're not sure what's going on in New Zealand, which has apparently been doing business pretty much as usual.
 
An aside, people forget the ending of the Andromeda Strain. The virus mutates into something more benign, despite being the scariest **** in the world at first. Granted, that is fiction. But viruses are weird.

The scariest one IMO is smallpox.
 
Something that's missing in the whole, "flattening the curve", discussion is that social distancing not only flattens the curve, it also reduces the area under the curve. And hence total infections and deaths.

For instance if R0 is initially 3.0 with no mitigation and no existing immunity, then here's what happens if social distancing reduces R0 to 1.5.

The peak is pushed further out and now occurs when approx. 1/3 have been infected. Ultimately 50% or so will get infected.

If R0 is reduced to 1.0 the peak occurs at T=0 when social distancing produces that R0 and infections decrease in a long downward ramp.

If R0 is reduced to .5, the peak will have already occurred and new infections will decline by 50% every week.

China has gotten it down to .3 and one can see the results in the daily WHO situation reports. The curve has not only been flattened, but totally squashed. It may go the route of SARS and simply effectively disappear in a few months. At least in China. Because it is so global and will be extant in many countries, China will have to keep vigilant and re-institute strong social distancing locally to keep it at bay. This should be relatively easy though because they will be identified quickly.
 
Your post also strikes me as both a straw man and a goal post move.

No, you just don't read for context - I clarified what I meant in the very next sentence and was clearly using metaphorical licence.

Do tell me what happens when the lockdowns end, though.

Also, check out the unbelievable level of restrictions still in place in China and South Korea and they haven't stopped new infections. Restrictions will go on for months and months.

Summer in the northern hemisphere may also slow it down.

"May". It also "may" not. You don't base real world decisions on "may" and "might", aside from Trump, and even he's changed his tune.

And here's something else: Yes, the hospitality business, sports leagues, airlines will be hard hit. But the closures mean some people will save money. And some industries will be stimulated. Home entertainment systems, for example.

Holy Zarquon, I have no idea where you studied economics, but the infinitesimal increase in a couple of businesses won't even begin to make up for the economic damage of millions of businesses losing money. You are so far from reality it's not even funny.

There is also the weird non-linear and even non-exponential behavior of the virus.

I put that down to simply the lack of testing being done in many places.

If you look at countries like France, Germany, Switzerland and Norway, where they understand testing and counting, they all show exponential growth, so don't be fooled.

You admit you're not sure what's going on in New Zealand, which has apparently been doing business pretty much as usual.

Until yesterday, we were.

NZ is an unusual case, because it takes at least a day to fly here from most places, so we have far fewer asymptomatic cases arriving, and whether it's seasonal or not, the outbreaks outside China all started in skiing areas and it's summer here.
 
TOday's wave of bad news guarantees another bloodbath when the Markets open on Monday.
I am betting all of yesterday's gains will be erased.
 
The Singapore PM isn't the only one talking to Captain Obvious. Your post also strikes me as both a straw man and a goal post move. I doubt if serious people believe it will magically disappear. Summer in the northern hemisphere may also slow it down.

And here's something else: Yes, the hospitality business, sports leagues, airlines will be hard hit. But the closures mean some people will save money. And some industries will be stimulated. Home entertainment systems, for example. There is likely to be pent-up demand eventually. Not soon enough to benefit Trump, I hope.

There is also the weird non-linear and even non-exponential behavior of the virus. You admit you're not sure what's going on in New Zealand, which has apparently been doing business pretty much as usual.
New Zealand is a catastrophe. 20% of exports (tourism) cancelled. 70% of workers renting housing at record rent levels, many with no income now.
This is a complete disaster.
 
TOday's wave of bad news guarantees another bloodbath when the Markets open on Monday.
I am betting all of yesterday's gains will be erased.

Hell, I wouldn't take any bets on that - I think another trading break in the first 10-20 minutes is an absolute certainty.

The dead cat bounce on Friday was all about people desperately seeking a reason to be positive and once one bought, lots chipped in. It was always going to be fool's gold, because until this virus is gone one way or another, markets have nothing to build on.

The financial fallout is going to be astronomical, and an entire order of magnitude worse than the GFC.

When whichever talking head I quoted said $2 trillion I said it was still light. I'd hate to try to work out what the final cost will be.
 
Hell, I wouldn't take any bets on that - I think another trading break in the first 10-20 minutes is an absolute certainty.

In fact, with the amount of bad news already this weekend, and half of it still to go before opening on Monday for people who live in odd time zones, I think 10-20 minutes is a gross over-estimate.

Under 5 minutes is my guess, and I'm going to add that trading will end up being suspended more than once.

I pity the fools who bought at +1500 on Friday. They're going to have some explaining to do.
 
In fact, with the amount of bad news already this weekend, and half of it still to go before opening on Monday for people who live in odd time zones, I think 10-20 minutes is a gross over-estimate.

Under 5 minutes is my guess, and I'm going to add that trading will end up being suspended more than once.

I pity the fools who bought at +1500 on Friday. They're going to have some explaining to do.
At least you make testable predictions.
 
Holy Zarquon, I have no idea where you studied economics, but the infinitesimal increase in a couple of businesses won't even begin to make up for the economic damage of millions of businesses losing money. You are so far from reality it's not even funny.
Economics baffles me. To me, civilization seems to be hanging by a thread all the time. I'm surprised it works at all. Maybe that's why I'm not as doom-y. Of all the people infected, most are recovering. And they in turn infected other people ... most of whom will recover. At some point fear is going to recalibrate into something else, because physiologically, terror isn't particularly sustainable. A lot of congregating that would have happened over the next couple of months won't happen, and that is bound to slow things down, and beyond that I really have no predictions.
 
Hell, I wouldn't take any bets on that - I think another trading break in the first 10-20 minutes is an absolute certainty.

The dead cat bounce on Friday was all about people desperately seeking a reason to be positive and once one bought, lots chipped in. It was always going to be fool's gold, because until this virus is gone one way or another, markets have nothing to build on.

The financial fallout is going to be astronomical, and an entire order of magnitude worse than the GFC.

When whichever talking head I quoted said $2 trillion I said it was still light. I'd hate to try to work out what the final cost will be.

The sacry thng is you seem to be taking great joy in this.
 
At least you make testable predictions.

And they've been pretty well on target so far.

Of all the people infected, most are recovering. And they in turn infected other people ... most of whom will recover.

No question, but when you've got something that is killing old people at rates of up to and over 10% of infections, and is also nailing the odd younger, healthy person, it's considered to be pretty serious.

The other problem is that it will kill a lot of other people, through operations being postponed, sick doctors and lack of ICU facilities.

And if you haven't thought about it yet, imagine what things will be like when the disease gets into a maximum security prison with 25% guard shortages.

They all seem like good reasons to try to stop the epidemic.

I'm just not at all sure it's possible.
 
The sacry thng is you seem to be taking great joy in this.

And you're seeing things that aren't there.

You've made this accusation several times and I even went as far to explain why you're wrong, but you clearly didn't bother reading thar, so I'm not about to do it again.

Just accept that I'm laughing my head off at a major recession and 50 million deaths and you won't need to post it again, ok?
 
And you're seeing things that aren't there.

You've made this accusation several times and I even went as far to explain why you're wrong, but you clearly didn't bother reading thar, so I'm not about to do it again.

Just accept that I'm laughing my head off at a major recession and 50 million deaths and you won't need to post it again, ok?

I honestly believe you. But I must also honestly tell you your posts have often come off as expressing a certain, um, enthusiasm as the magnitude of the epidemic and its impact have been revealed. I think this is really a combination of a natural human amazement with a novel, massive event and the difficulty of communicating nuance through the internet.

Sorry!
 
I think markets will recover fairly rapidly once the disease sweeps past (which will IMHO only truly be complete after an effective vaccine is deployed). With only one
big concern: that investors will take this event to finally ask if the past decades of soaring stocks were only a fevered dream and an enormous over evaluation of their true values.
 
I think this is really a combination of a natural human amazement with a novel, massive event and the difficulty of communicating nuance through the internet.

That's fine, although I suspect it's also a lot that I use language very explicitly and that can come across as passionate.

I repeat that I called this a world-changing event a long while ago and was roundly condemned for it, so while I'm taking no satisfaction from the disease, I will enjoy rubbing faces in it on the way through.

Now we can maybe stick to the subject and not me.

Like this:

I think markets will recover fairly rapidly once the disease sweeps past (which will IMHO only truly be complete after an effective vaccine is deployed).

I'm not sure it will come back fast, because so many companies and employers will be so far in the red and governments will struggle to keep people afloat. If we manage to get a vaccine this calendar year, it will be an amazing and unlikely effort.

This is going to last for a long time, and it's going to be an appallingly bad time for many. We might find the worst time is when 50% of people have had it and are sick of caring about others.


With only one
big concern: that investors will take this event to finally ask if the past decades of soaring stocks were only a fevered dream and an enormous over evaluation of their true values.

There are going to be a lot of pension funds shrunk by incredible amounts, too, and those people's appetite for risk may well change.
 
That's fine, although I suspect it's also a lot that I use language very explicitly and that can come across as passionate.

I repeat that I called this a world-changing event a long while ago and was roundly condemned for it, so while I'm taking no satisfaction from the disease, I will enjoy rubbing faces in it on the way through.

Now we can maybe stick to the subject and not me.

Like this:



I'm not sure it will come back fast, because so many companies and employers will be so far in the red and governments will struggle to keep people afloat. If we manage to get a vaccine this calendar year, it will be an amazing and unlikely effort.

This is going to last for a long time, and it's going to be an appallingly bad time for many. We might find the worst time is when 50% of people have had it and are sick of caring about others.




There are going to be a lot of pension funds shrunk by incredible amounts, too, and those people's appetite for risk may well change.

However, this doesn't fundamentally change the economics of the world. Factories will still produce. Distribution centers will still operate. This is temporary.

And yes, some companies will go out of business just because they were running too close to the edge, and will fall off, and that will have ripple effects, and things will be bad economically. And then, everything will be ok, because at the end of the day, we still know how to make automobiles and televisions, and this disease is not so incredibly bad that even if it just becomes part of our lives, it won't eliminate all economic activity. It might alter the way we live a little bit, and it will take time to adjust to that, but once the initial shock wears off, schools will reopen and people will start going to restaurants again. The restaurants might be more expensive because of higher government mandated sanitation standards.
 
This is temporary.

Absolutely - whatever happens, 99% of people will survive and things will return to normal.

However, the depth of the trough will take some time to grow out of.

Today's going to be an interesting opening.
 
I think markets will recover fairly rapidly once the disease sweeps past (which will IMHO only truly be complete after an effective vaccine is deployed). With only one
big concern: that investors will take this event to finally ask if the past decades of soaring stocks were only a fevered dream and an enormous over evaluation of their true values.

Experts are saying at least a year before a vaccine is effectively deployed. And that is assuming a vaccine is discovered very soon.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom