Personally I tend to refrain from judgment if there has been one accusation against someone (with no proof). If there's been a whole bunch of similar accusations, that's enough for me to conclude that they're probably true.
I'd suggest a slightly different model.
After all, in the witch trials, or the satanic abuse daycare scandal, there were multiple accusers, but the charges were bogus.
For me, the issue isn't just the number of accusers, but the comparable plausibility of two explanations for the accusations. One explanation is that the accusations are true, and the other is that the accusation is fabricated or mistaken.
One accuser may be crazy, may have a plot to discredit or get money from someone or may have, for whatever reason misremembered the events. These are not extraordinary circumstances. People suffer mental illness, lie for personal gain and have poor memories every day.
As accusers multiply, the plausibilty drops. Two people may be crazy, but sharing the same specific delusion is far more rare, more people even rarer especially if they're unconnected.
But that doesn't discount the possibility. For instance, if multiple women claimed to have been raped by Elvis and to be carrying his child just after his death, I wouldn't find it completely implausible that all of them were either crazy lying or wrong, because Elvis was a gigantic part of the public psyche at that moment in time and there was much attention, and possible money to be gained by making those claims.
If a highly vocal critic of scientology were accused of rape by several women with connections to scientology, I might be skeptical of the accusations, since the organization has been involved with elaborate and disgusting conspiricies to punish their perceived enemies in the past.
In the case of Jian Ghomeshi, the accusers are numerous, there's no clear gain for accusers to lie about this, at least in the context of the way these accusations have been made. Any version of the story where they're all crazy, lying or mistaken ends up meshing far more poorly with the evidence than the conclusion that the accusations are at least somewhat correct.