Bill Cosby's social media ploy backfires

I think it's okay and actually very healthy to have a show about a black family and not make their race an issue. It's kind of a drag for black people that anytime something is "black" the "blackness" has to be an issue.

As a child, I knew several upper class black families (was close friends with their children) who lived lives similar to the Huxtables. I spent lots of time in their homes. It seemed realistic enough to me (as realistic as a sitcom can be, that is).

Were you there when the seven-year-old came home in tears because someone called her a *******.

Sorry, but I don't believe those fairy tales. I've known upper class and successful blacks, also. While they may not have trotted them out at all occasions, every one of them had stories of dealing with blatant racism or bigotry in their daily lives. The family of Dr. Huxtable lived in NYC. Ask a black man in New York how easy it is to get a cab to stop for them! Their kids (and the parents) would have dealt with racism.

That show was basically Leave it to Beaver in blackface. And LitB at least had the reprehensible and unctuous Eddie Haskell going for it. The Huxtables were from Never Never Land.
 
I agree with you for the most part, but it always kind of irks me when people talk about the "presumption of innocence" this way. As Vincent Bugliosi has frequently pointed out, "presumption of innocence" is strictly a legal concept, meant only to apply in the context of charging, trying, and convicting someone of a crime. and in no way is expected to be granted to a public figure simply because they have not yet been convicted of a crime. If the preponderance of evidence suggests that they are guilty, then there is absolutely no moral obligation on the part of the public to apply a "presumption of innocence."

This is absolutely correct. The uber-skeptic approach here sometimes has us tying ourselves into intellectual pretzels because we can't get a double-blinded peer reviewed test to determine the entire context and meaning of a Tweet.

Presumption of Innocence goes to treatment under the law. It is not actually a requirement of the population, but of the system of justice we've chosen in most western countries. (And it doesn't even hold forth in all, of course.) Whether its Shermer or Cosby or Gary Glitter, at some point an individual is entitled to an informed opinion without having to do back flips to be "fair".
 
Were you there when the seven-year-old came home in tears because someone called her a *******.

Sorry, but I don't believe those fairy tales. I've known upper class and successful blacks, also. While they may not have trotted them out at all occasions, every one of them had stories of dealing with blatant racism or bigotry in their daily lives. The family of Dr. Huxtable lived in NYC. Ask a black man in New York how easy it is to get a cab to stop for them! Their kids (and the parents) would have dealt with racism.

Doesn't seem like you're saying anything contradictory to the person you're responding to.

That show was basically Leave it to Beaver in blackface. And LitB at least had the reprehensible and unctuous Eddie Haskell going for it. The Huxtables were from Never Never Land.

Blackface? :confused:
 
<snip> If the preponderance of evidence suggests that they are guilty, then there is absolutely no moral obligation on the part of the public to apply a "presumption of innocence."

I think there is some moral obligation for people to refrain from deciding someone's guilty just because there has been an accusation. There's certainly no moral obligation to assume the person is guilty. I was responding to comments wondering how people could or would still go to Cosby's shows. His fans are going to give him the benefit of the doubt. They're fans. That seems perfectly acceptable to me.

Accusations do damage though, no question about that. Over time I'm sure Cosby's marketability will decline.
 
I think there is some moral obligation for people to refrain from deciding someone's guilty just because there has been an accusation. There's certainly no moral obligation to assume the person is guilty.

Personally I tend to refrain from judgment if there has been one accusation against someone (with no proof). If there's been a whole bunch of similar accusations, that's enough for me to conclude that they're probably true. However, it really doesn't matter what I think and I don't know if it's appropriate to assign morality to it. If one is doing something like harassing Bill Cosby or harassing his accusers then it becomes more morally significant what they base their conclusions on.

I was responding to comments wondering how people could or would still go to Cosby's shows. His fans are going to give him the benefit of the doubt. They're fans. That seems perfectly acceptable to me.

If it doesn't hurt anyone then it's acceptable, sure.
 
Doesn't seem like you're saying anything contradictory to the person you're responding to.

Do we have to point everything out with big bright red blinking neon signs. I'm disagreeing with the post I'm replying to in that I think (as was pretty clear in the post that said poster quoted) that ignoring "black" entirely is a form of lie on the part of the producers and writers, and thus Cosby himself.

I don't insist that every show had to be "Good Times" and every episode contain a social crisis, but the idea that "blackness" never came up, ever, in the lives of this family is a fantasy. Well, except that it's a fantasy family, of course, so anything is possible when you suspend reality for thirty minutes every week.



Blackface? :confused:

What confuses you? I'm here to help. Do you not know the term? I'm pretty sure everyone recognizes it.

Do you not understand the metaphor? Leave it to Beaver, Father Knows Best, The Donna Reid Show, etc... all presented an idealized version of growing up in suburban America in the 50s. They never dealt with any issue more serious than Kitten passing a note in class and having to do detention, or Beaver losing his new baseball glove and not knowing how to tell dad. Cosby's version was those same upper middle class kids and parents, just played by black people, but still ignoring anything that was going on in the world around them other than "Synopsis: In this episode, youngest kid has trouble with a spelling test."
 
Were you there when the seven-year-old came home in tears because someone called her a *******.

Sorry, but I don't believe those fairy tales. I've known upper class and successful blacks, also. While they may not have trotted them out at all occasions, every one of them had stories of dealing with blatant racism or bigotry in their daily lives. The family of Dr. Huxtable lived in NYC. Ask a black man in New York how easy it is to get a cab to stop for them! Their kids (and the parents) would have dealt with racism.

That show was basically Leave it to Beaver in blackface. And LitB at least had the reprehensible and unctuous Eddie Haskell going for it. The Huxtables were from Never Never Land.

This is kind of like saying that they weren't "black enough" for you. They didn't conform to your preconceived notions of what black people would talk about and deal with in daily life. Just because real people might deal with certain problems or issues in life doesn't mean that they have to be included in the show. Isn't it healthy for people to see a black family just being a family without having the race issue brought up?
 
Last edited:
Were you there when the seven-year-old came home in tears because someone called her a *******.

Sorry, but I don't believe those fairy tales. I've known upper class and successful blacks, also. While they may not have trotted them out at all occasions, every one of them had stories of dealing with blatant racism or bigotry in their daily lives. The family of Dr. Huxtable lived in NYC. Ask a black man in New York how easy it is to get a cab to stop for them! Their kids (and the parents) would have dealt with racism.

That show was basically Leave it to Beaver in blackface. And LitB at least had the reprehensible and unctuous Eddie Haskell going for it. The Huxtables were from Never Never Land.

I would think that even if it is true that it's Utopian to think that a black family could live their lives unmolested by concerns of race as they do in The Cosby Show, there is still a place for that kind of show among people who want to be entertained rather than having to be exposed to gritty true-to-life hardship. It is probably for a similar reason that people in India tend to enjoy watching Bollywood movies rather than Slumdog Millionaire. Most people in India don't need to be reminded of depressing realities.
 
Do you not understand the metaphor? Leave it to Beaver, Father Knows Best, The Donna Reid Show, etc... all presented an idealized version of growing up in suburban America in the 50s. They never dealt with any issue more serious than Kitten passing a note in class and having to do detention, or Beaver losing his new baseball glove and not knowing how to tell dad. Cosby's version was those same upper middle class kids and parents, just played by black people, but still ignoring anything that was going on in the world around them other than "Synopsis: In this episode, youngest kid has trouble with a spelling test."

I understand the metaphor, and I agree with you that it was basically as you describe. But what's wrong with that? I still think it's a good thing that millions of Americans, especially American children, got to see black people just being a family doing normal things that they could relate to. I think it's okay and healthy for there to be a show about blacks where they're just portrayed as people, outside of their "blackness" and outside of the issues that they may or may not deal with because of their "blackness".

As a side note, the show branched off with "A Different World", where one of the daughters went off to a black college. Also, the Huxtable parents sometimes referenced going to a black college (it was the backstory about where they met). So it's not true that there was never any acknowledgement that the family was a "black" family.

For better or worse, I think that the show would not have been as popular if it had dealt explicitly with "the race issue". As angrysoba pointed out, sometimes people just want to be entertained. I am almost certain that the show did far, far more good than harm in exposing people of all races to the concept of black people leading responsible, "normal" lives that viewers could relate to.

Obviously this is all a pretty big thread derail.
 
Last edited:
In spite of becoming known for wearing busily patterned sweaters, Cliff just as often wore sweatshirts emblazoned with the names of black colleges such as Wilberforce and Fisk. Cliff and Clair were college sweethearts at Hillman College, the show’s fictional historically black college, which took the focus in this episode, the backdoor pilot for Bonet’s Hillman-set spinoff A Different World.

http://www.avclub.com/article/how-emthe-cosby-showem-spoke-to-race-and-class-in--87848

Not saying that this is "addressing racism", just pointing out that they were identified as "black" and having a "black past".
 
Last edited:
Do we have to point everything out with big bright red blinking neon signs.

Sometimes. I think my reading comprehension is usually pretty good, but it isn't always. Occasionally I fail to pick up on things. If you find it annoying to clarify you can opt not to respond.

I'm disagreeing with the post I'm replying to in that I think (as was pretty clear in the post that said poster quoted) that ignoring "black" entirely is a form of lie on the part of the producers and writers, and thus Cosby himself.

I don't insist that every show had to be "Good Times" and every episode contain a social crisis, but the idea that "blackness" never came up, ever, in the lives of this family is a fantasy. Well, except that it's a fantasy family, of course, so anything is possible when you suspend reality for thirty minutes every week.

Okay.

I didn't think Doghouse was claiming that it was realistic for a black family in the US to never have to deal with racism or for the issue of race to never come up. I thought he was just saying that not every show is obligated to deal with it as part of its subject matter and that the subject matter it did deal with was handled realistically. You are saying that it was not okay for the show to ignore racial issues and that is the primary area of disagreement if I understand correctly. Thanks for clarifying.

What confuses you? I'm here to help. Do you not know the term? I'm pretty sure everyone recognizes it.

I know the term. What confused me was that your usage of it did not make any sense, given my understanding of what blackface means. I've never heard it used in reference to people who simply have naturally dark skin.

Do you not understand the metaphor? Leave it to Beaver, Father Knows Best, The Donna Reid Show, etc... all presented an idealized version of growing up in suburban America in the 50s. They never dealt with any issue more serious than Kitten passing a note in class and having to do detention, or Beaver losing his new baseball glove and not knowing how to tell dad. Cosby's version was those same upper middle class kids and parents, just played by black people, but still ignoring anything that was going on in the world around them other than "Synopsis: In this episode, youngest kid has trouble with a spelling test."

No, not really. I thought that blackface and black minstrel shows were known for caricaturing and stereotyping black people, which I don't think the Cosby show did. But I'm no expert on the history of blackface so I could be wrong. Anyway I understand what you're saying, so agreeing on whether or not it has anything to do with blackface is probably unimportant at this point.
 
Last edited:
Why does it have to be about him being a black rapist? Or even a male rapist? Can't we just stick to the right category, which is scary enough?

Ladies, think twice before you allow yourself to be alone with a comedian.
 
Personally I tend to refrain from judgment if there has been one accusation against someone (with no proof). If there's been a whole bunch of similar accusations, that's enough for me to conclude that they're probably true.


I'm not sure how you can accept that to be a "probably" if the person is both extremely rich and popular.

In that situation I would need to know a bit of background history on each accuser to try and surmise if they are just seeing some interview revenue in their future (or the almighty "book deal") before going anywhere close to "probably".
 
Cliff Huxtable and his wife and their adorable children were as believable as My Mother the Car. "Stay tuned for episode sixty three of The Cosby Show; four years and never a mention of the word "black" or "knee-grow" by anyone remotely associated with the show."


You clearly and provably are not familiar with The Cosby Show. At all.

It is, in fact, nearly exactly the opposite of what you describe. There were literally dozens of episodes dealing with black issues.

Why in the world would you type something like that without being familiar with the subject?
 
He's a serial rapist who drugged his victims so they couldn't fight back.

Think about this for a second. Most of the accusations stem from the sixties to the eighties and Bill Cosby was a man of influence one wealth. Would he really had need to drug women to get them to sleep with him?

Yeah, me neither.
 
You clearly and provably are not familiar with The Cosby Show. At all.

It is, in fact, nearly exactly the opposite of what you describe. There were literally dozens of episodes dealing with black issues.

Why in the world would you type something like that without being familiar with the subject?

They had one episode that I can recall having a civil rights theme. If you can recall others, I'm all ears (and not denying that it's very possible that I've forgotten them). I don't think I saw every episode, but my first wife was a big fan, so if I was home the night it was on, we were watching it.

Over to you. Here are all the episodes. You can just refer to the "dozens" by Season # and Episode #.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_The_Cosby_Show_episodes
 
Think about this for a second. Most of the accusations stem from the sixties to the eighties and Bill Cosby was a man of influence one wealth. Would he really had need to drug women to get them to sleep with him?

Yeah, me neither.

Actually, rich and successful people have still been known to rape people. There have been numerous celebrities recently brought to trial in the UK for sexually assaulting women in the seventies and other decades even though they were pretty wealthy and could surely have afforded prostitutes.
 
Actually, rich and successful people have still been known to rape people. There have been numerous celebrities recently brought to trial in the UK for sexually assaulting women in the seventies and other decades even though they were pretty wealthy and could surely have afforded prostitutes.

Well that's remarkably short sighted. Paying for a prostitute would be cheaper than facing charges of rape, certainly.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom