Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Diogenes:

"I pointed out some problems in that thread, and you dodged it their also."

I have tried to answer your questions as best I can. If my answers aren't to your satisfaction, maybe you should ask somebody else the question.

Now ask yourself, are you really just trying to get an answer, knowledge, because if so, you should go to others with your same questions and see if they can do better than I. But if you are simply testing my knowledge, I've given it my best shot, taken your test, so to speak, and you may grade the exam in your mind as you like.

Bill


It's not a matter of answering to my satisfaction ..

You are the suit expert.. When you say it is unlikely a feature of the subject could have been incorporated in a suit, I am in no position to argue with you other than to point out a problem I see with with what you claim to be sound morphology .. ( sound morphology being the only alternative to a suit )

At BFF I showed you this..

You said would be getting back to me ...

Would this be a good time ?

First I present a graphic of a primate shoulder ( human in this case ) compared to what we see on the subject in
the film.

shouldz.gif


I have outlined the deltoid muscle group in blue, and the shape we see in the film in red .
( I have also added the blue outline to the film subject to point out the difference )

Not a very good match; but it could be argued that the true underlying muscle structure is being
obscured by fur/hair ..

It can be shown that the deltoid group, is normally firmly attached to the upper arm, and as the upper
arm swings while walking, the deltoid group will move as a whole, following the arm ..

Shoulder.gif


I have isolated a couple of consecutive frames from the MK Davis enhancements to illustrate my point.
It can be seen, that as the arm moves to the rear, there is some independent movement between the
upper arm and the shoulder area above it ..This same disconnect can be seen in other parts
of the film, but I picked these two frames as one of the better examples . It’s subtle, but it’s there.. ( It is easier to see in the rear area of the upper arm .. )

Someone could point out that there is a continuous dark area, that spans the upper arm and shoulder area
and moving in unison . But, that is what you would expect with a continuous covering, be it fabric or skin .
It is the discontinuity between the underlying structure that presents a problem.
Greg


If there is a reasonable indication that shoulder pads are being used, the problems of the unlikelihood, of whatever materials or techniques were available in '67 become somewhat moot.

All you have to do is show that any part of the subject is most likely a suit, based on the way real flesh would behave or look, and the other parts of the suit that may be more realistic no longer matter .. They must be a suit also, no matter what they are made of or how they were put together ..
The fact that someone cannot see or understand how it was done, doesn't make it more likely either.. That's called an argument from incredulity ..


You also indicated you would get back to me on the bulges seen on the left leg ..

hernia2.gif


Along with the shoulder pad effect, we have two pretty good examples of - ' Not real ' ...
 
Diogenes - What you are pointing out about the shoulder is very true. It's an old style technique that some of the guys making creature suits used to do. Basically they'd wrap the foam undersuit around like a vest with short sleeves. The sleeve portion would then be glued to the arm section. This caused the shoulder to curve the wrong way. In real life an arm couldn't be raised without the proper attachment of the muscle. That's a dead give-a-way that this is a suit.

To anyone familiar with anatomy (and also today's top creature fx people) that would be a no-no. However, in the 50's and 60's it happened a lot and people paid little attention to it. Look at the example of the last time CRASH CORRIGAN wore a creature suit for a film. The shoulder pads curve in the way that Patty's does. This suit was made from a pair of long johns with bits of latex glued on to them. Foam padding was used to create the shapes underneath.


Look closely here and you'll see the elbow pad too. The "skin" is glued to the foam body - just as described by Janos Prohaska. This was something Wah Chang did often. Notice the wrinkles that occur behind the shoulder and on the body. I've seen this before with Wah's guys.


The top photo shows a Morlock on the far right who is wearing FABRIC rather than simply having the hair section applied to his skin. That's because he's a stuntman and will be falling and burning as you can see in the two bottom pics. You can also see the wrinkle in the fabric.

Janos, Wah and Chambers all used to glue grey fabric to foam and then lay hair onto that. It's a very old school thing that you'd never see today.


Something else to look for is the way foam is wrapped around the hips and then a circular butt pad is placed over that. Top LEFT shows foam hip wrapping and top RIGHT shows a circular pad. These two techniques are used to make what you see on Patty. It's an old gorilla/bear suit technique from way back.

Here's what I used to recreate some of the lines seen in the Patty suit. Green is the circular butt pad and red shows the outline of the hip pad. The blue is a standard carpenter's knee pad - the same type used by Wah Chang and Janos for their suits.

Here is the demo that Academy Award-winning creature fx artist CHRIS WALAS gave to the BFF. An old Gemora gorilla used that type of butt padding. The top also pulled down over the bottom section just as it did with most of the ape and bear suits of the day.

Can you see the small bulge on the right thigh. This is where the skin that was glued to the foam thigh pad is loose. As the leg move it flexes outward. That is what causes the thing many have called a "thigh injury". That can happen if you use the glue method. One tiny bubble can appear if you miss a spot.

Here is an example. I glued the tee-shirt to foam padding but two tiny bubbles appear. That is where the "skin" popped loose from the foam. In motion it looks like what happened to Patty's thigh.

Sometimes it's not "genius" but merely a happy accident that those already inclined to believe will make into something else. This is the con artist's favorite occurance. Hoaxers hope that smart people will come up with excuses for their mistakes and help them out.


On the left is just a fat suit being made for theater work, but it can help to show how foam works beneath the skin and hair. The buttocks and thigh are very similar in construction to what was used on Patty.

ATOMIC MYSTERY MONSTER - I don't know if any of these are the kinds of pics you requested or not. If not let me know and I'll dig up the ones you are looking for. Just an experiment with foam, big feet and an upsidedown shoulder. I may do one with hair in the future.



This is the old gorilla suit a young Rick Baker made for auditions many, many years ago that you'd asked about.


Notice here the shortness of the upper arm as compared to the forearm. I can promise you that the stuntman in the suit doesn't have a short upper arm. It's just the suit. His real shoulder is much higher and deeper. On camera the shoulder of the suit moves and appears to be the shoulder of the "creature" but that has nothing to do with the guy beneath it. It's just foam rubber moving.

If you look closely at Janos' white gorilla on the left you'll see the line where the top of the suit fits over the legs. More important though is the fact that Janos is using exactly the same type of kneecap that is found on Patty. See if you can spot it.


If I had the right hair on hand I might do something like this.


WORM -- btw - I was able to check my clearer copy of Roger on DVD. This is the correct position based on the buttons on his shirt.


Example of a 1960's foot from Mr. Janos Prohaska.



Here is further explanation.... I made a mold in Plaster of Paris for a breast. I used standard bathroom caulking to create a breast. I then painted over the breast as it lay on foam. Voila! A Patty breast in 10 minutes.

I realize Bill Munns has gone to alot of time and effort to explain how he would build fluid movement into breasts and all that. It's very informative for people interested in the subject and good to know all you can about it. Yet none of that has anything to do with how Patty was made and might actually distract people from understanding what is really going on right in front of them, unfortunately.

People are still repeating the line that Bob Heironimus claimed it was made of horse hide. The fact is that he never said that. He said his brother told him that Roger had told his brother this. Probably another Patterson fib. Not unusual. However, if people cannot keep these simple stories straight you can see how easily complex things can be taken out of context and twisted to mean something... anything... to support the idea that Patty must be real.

The truth is that Patty's breast is just like the one below...

It was made by Janos in the 50's. The breasts don't bounce on Patty. They are stiff and only move as the top of the entire suit moves.

Let's focus on what Patty really is first by going to those who used these techniques and methods in the 60's. Then experiment and demonstrate. This is much more scientific than simply forming a click and attacking anyone who questions the honesty of Bob Gimlin. Bending over backwards to make something fake sound real won't bring Patty out of the woods.:blush:
 
Last edited:
If you look at this by doing an overlay of Frame 339 with Frame 350, it is completely obvious.

If required I can knock up an animated gif later.

What I'm not sure on is the shadow which seems to come from the middle of Patty's hand, heading down and to the right, although it's possibly an artifact from the filming.

nothumb.gif
 
Diogenes: Post #12601

"If there is a reasonable indication that shoulder pads are being used, the problems of the unlikelihood, of whatever materials or techniques were available in '67 become somewhat moot."

"You also indicated you would get back to me on the bulges seen on the left leg .."


I haven't had time to do any study on the leg yet. And I see irregularities of form and light and shadow in the right shoulder, around the deltiod area, as you point out.

I don't have any conclusion of analysis on either point yet. So I can't answer your questions.

Bill
 
Crow, I don't understand how your mind works. You have serious problems with abstract thought. You are like a troll among PGF researchers.

I know damn well that a poncho is mentioned as a light blocker (change film). I question the poncho because he is never seen with it at any time. I even offered an explanation (kept in his pack in case of rain).

So then why did you go into the snit about how does anyone know Roger was wearing a poncho? Since there is no footage of Patterson in cold and wet weather why would he have ever donned the poncho? But any cowboy out in the "range" will have one. I bet Roger was wearing socks too even though he's never seen in socks.
 
But there still is the possibility, at least, that this was exactly what he wanted people to say. What dumb luck! An elaborately faked accident must look accidental, after all. And even though we lack much of the footage, and what remains is edited, I don't recall hearing any allegations that it is spliced out of order (or did I miss anything on that in this long long thread); additional takes would have been extremely hard to conceal, even from the characteristically generous bigfoot community.

How do we know this is the first take? A fuzzy film from a known flim-flam artist.

Note to all bigfooters:

Go into the woods bigfoot does not lurk here.
 
Last edited:
How do we know this is the first take? A fuzzy film from a known flim-flam artist.

Note to all bigfooters:

Go into the woods bigfoot does not lurk here.

Everybody knows Bigfoot is spending its time at the beach these days. Who's gonna be silly enough to look for it in the woods? I've booked passage to San Trope' to get my confirmed sighting.
 
We know that on more than one occasion during the Patty walk scene, Patterson either stopped the camera or sections of the walk scene were intentionally removed.

We have seen the repeated driftwood scene in the National Geographic full-frame version. But now I notice that this version is missing about 10 seconds as Patty is moving through the trees. These 10 seconds can be seen in another full-frame version (Discovery Channel). This is meaningful because it shows that RP moved a considerable distance without filming (or this was removed) from his position at Frame 352 and then when he films Patty from behind (in the trees). The landmark that shows this is the big log laying across the scene between RP and Patty at 352. I'll call this the "big log".

You need to compare these two versions to see this:

Discovery Channel full-frame (DC)

National Geographic full-frame (NG)

Both are full-frame and seem to be identical when Patty walks behind big log (352 comes then). They are significantly different after she is beyond big log.

When you are watching DC, things are different after :41. You get to see about 10 seconds of footage that is not shown in NG. In DC, you will see how far RP have moved when you watch :49 -:51. During those 3 seconds, RP pans downwards and he is nearly on top of big log. At :52, it looks like he may even put his left foot on big log itself.

When you watch NG, the downwards pan to show (now very close) big log should come at about :41. But it doesn't happen. It's missing in this version. There is also about 7 seconds immediately prior to :41 that are missing as well.

This shows that the Titmus/Krantz map is very wrong for the movements of RP before the last frame is shown (952). They show him moving about 10 feet. Instead, he may have moved at least 30 feet (I think even more).

Mangler's map is much closer to accurate (for pathways and distances) as compared to Titmus/Krantz.
 
There's much to be compared with these two clips. First off the Discovery version is of infinately better quality. Right off the bat one question is answered as to what the "tent pole" frames actualy are which is nothing more than a couple of skinny trees part of an uncut camera pan off of the horse and rider. I don't care who'se site map is correct if its a proven fake. I meant what's there to be correct about when anything is a fake. But the fact that both videos are at two different speeds makes them worth viewing. The fast Discovery version shows Patty booking at a pretty good clip especially if she's a goon in a suit. When viewing the slow version she looks way too slow and casual. The earliest versions I've ever seen which go back to 1970 were the fast pace and more likely a more accurate pace
 
Diogenes:

"I'm confused.
You have a problem with a real animal pelt as a covering for a real animal ?"


Not at all. I am referring to a tanned hide of a former real animal that is no longer living tissue and used a fur for something a person fabricates. When it was living tissue on the real animal, it had splendid elasticity.

"I's funny how that works.. When I have pointed problems with the musculature on the subject, the argument was it must be long hair giving an unnatural look . Where do you think the musculature looks normal; showing through what must be short hair ?"

I personally have not said or thought "it must be long hair giving it an unnatural look". So i can only suggest you approach whoever offered that argument. I certainly wouldn't agree with the quote. I don't see what I would classify "long hair"

Remember I said "musculature or soft tissue deposits" and I tend to see what I feel is more of the second, less of the first. But it can be simplified as seeing "flesh tissue" (which would include both muscle and soft tissue) as opposed to fur and light artifacts caused by light reflected off the hair.

Bill

So all you have is an "argument from authority"

Sorry don't accept it.

You might want to study optics with esp attention to resolving power>
 
Last edited:
TSIG

"So all you have is an "argument from authority"

Sorry don't accept it.

You might want to study optics with esp attention to resolving power>"


I've stated repeatedly I hope to do research to precisely take the determination out of "argument from authority" because that's what currenly just puts the issues on the "this expert said this, that expert said that" level, and everybody deserves better. So how about we throw out all the expert opinion from every side and just focus on material facts?

Works for me.

Actually, I am studying optics with attention to resolving power. Been doing that for awhile now.

Bill
 
TSIG

"So all you have is an "argument from authority"

Sorry don't accept it.

You might want to study optics with esp attention to resolving power>"







I've stated repeatedly I hope to do research to precisely take the determination out of "argument from authority" because that's what currenly just puts the issues on the "this expert said this, that expert said that" level, and everybody deserves better. So how about we throw out all the expert opinion from every side and just focus on material facts?

Works for me.

Actually, I am studying optics with attention to resolving power. Been doing that for awhile now.

Bill

How long is your optics course going to take?

Do you know why Hubble cannot see the lunar lander?
 
Have always found the poncho story perplexing, also. As mentioned, it is hardly a sound method for changing rolls. Very risky. Why the hell would you not have a purpose-made black bag? That film is not particularly cheap. Furthermore, they say that after the film ran out, after the Patty walk, they changed the rolls, to document the casting etc?

That is a hell of a risk to take, with your "bigfoot" film secure, and safely in the can. Particularly with still cameras on hand that could have sufficed.
As I recall, reloading 16 mm does not require total darkness, such as a changing bag. It just is better done in dim light. A poncho might well make sense for this purpose if there's a chance you'll be stuck in direct sun when reloading.
 
As I recall, reloading 16 mm does not require total darkness, such as a changing bag. It just is better done in dim light. A poncho might well make sense for this purpose if there's a chance you'll be stuck in direct sun when reloading.

Did the model employ enclosed cartridge, or open spools? If open spool, it is understood that that type of loading is possible for tough conditions, like combat recording, difficult nature shoots etc, but from what I recall about camerawork (it's been a long time) like Astro says, it is not something that is done unless you really, really have to (in the middle of the action etc). Pushing luck that hard seems pretty cavalier to me. This is not just your average doco. They had supposedly captured bigfoot live, on film, for the first, and possibly last time. The roll had run out, Patty was gone. Even if she had miraculously shown up again, one can reach for the still cameras. They had one each, at least. There was nothing to shoot that they couldn't do the next day. Yes, maybe they were "cowboys", but it seems like incredible overconfidence, for someone who wasn't all that experienced. With a rented, fairly unfamiliar camera. Unless of course, there were more takes in the equation.
 
Last edited:
Did the model employ enclosed cartridge, or open spools? If open spool, it is understood that that type of loading is possible for tough conditions, like combat recording, difficult nature shoots etc, but from what I recall about camerawork (it's been a long time) like Astro says, it is not something that is done unless you really, really have to (in the middle of the action etc). Pushing luck that hard seems pretty cavalier to me. This is not just your average doco. They had supposedly captured bigfoot live, on film, for the first, and possibly last time. The roll had run out, Patty was gone. Even if she had miraculously shown up again, one can reach for the still cameras. They had one each, at least. There was nothing to shoot that they couldn't do the next day. Yes, maybe they were "cowboys", but it seems like incredible overconfidence, for someone who wasn't all that experienced. With a rented, fairly unfamiliar camera. Unless of course, there were more takes in the equation.

I wonder about this. They trek off into the woods lugging a monkey suit and a third person to wear it and only make one take? I'm beginning to think that they happened onto somebody elses bigfoot hoax and managed to film it without ever knowing they were filming another person's hoax.
That Patterson thought to field load another roll of film is either not true or he was impressed enough take the chance. Nothing about this thing makes any sense.
 
Did the model employ enclosed cartridge, or open spools? If open spool, it is understood that that type of loading is possible for tough conditions, like combat recording, difficult nature shoots etc, but from what I recall about camerawork (it's been a long time) like Astro says, it is not something that is done unless you really, really have to (in the middle of the action etc). Pushing luck that hard seems pretty cavalier to me. This is not just your average doco. They had supposedly captured bigfoot live, on film, for the first, and possibly last time. The roll had run out, Patty was gone. Even if she had miraculously shown up again, one can reach for the still cameras. They had one each, at least. There was nothing to shoot that they couldn't do the next day. Yes, maybe they were "cowboys", but it seems like incredible overconfidence, for someone who wasn't all that experienced. With a rented, fairly unfamiliar camera. Unless of course, there were more takes in the equation.


How many takes will it take till we know

That many bigfeet have filmed

The answer my friend is blowing in the grain

The answer is blowing in the grain.
 
Tsig:

"How long is your optics course going to take?"

Why does it concern you if you don't value my opinion?

Bill
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom