Bill Munns
Banned
- Joined
- Mar 3, 2008
- Messages
- 449
Correa Neto Your new post today #12292:
"I must stand by my statements; basically I feel that a person, specially if used to hard work, could perform as Patty, specially because he (whoever he was) would have two helpers. Or at the very least, one. Not to mention that the "Patty performance" was not very long.
Now, do you agree or not? If not, why?"
Agree.
"I partially agree with you, and my posts on the issue shows why. Of course the building and filming techiches are different. The true question is: Considering seams can be hidden in miniatures filmed at close range (by a number of means) would the seams of a full-sized costume be visible at PGF's resolution?
My opinion is no or barely."
Depends on the seam, where it is, how it was designed. Seams on costumes are far more varied in design that in stop motion models, especially closure seams (to get a person into and out of the costume. I have doubts about how well the film can resolve seams, and would like to test that more reliably, taking actual seamed fur structures, photographing them at similar resolution, and seeing exactly what does show and what doesn't. with knowledge of the original seam placement as the callibration data.
seams running parallel to the hair lay are harder to hide than seams running perpendicular to the hair lay. Zig Zag seams running overall parallel to the hair lay help better than straight seams running parallel, but are a lot more work tailoring. And seamed sections are stiffer than fur unseamed areas, so the difference in rigidity makes curious motion artifcats in the seam locations that may magnify the effect (when the suit person moves on camera), and so magnify the prospect of being seen.
Back to the breasts now:
"Bill, here's the problem:
"I didn't see"
Its the very same issue we've been dealing with for a long time. Personal impressions. As you just said, you did not see anything particulary unatural. Well, I see. In this particular issues, saying "it looks real for me" is just not enough. You certainly are familiar with Monty Python's "The meaning of life". Well, there's a scene of several bare breasted women running. No silicone. Please point me to a single one whose breasts move like Patty's breasts. "
You seem to fail to grasp that I simply don't think the whole breast thing is an issue, because I know anything on the screen can be faked with the 1960's technology, and I've said so repeatedly.
Seems like now, you're trying to prove a negative, that it's "impossible" for breasts of a living creature to move as you see them in the PG film. A skeptic would say, no matter how many human female breasts you look at running topless in a movie, there are still some human females who have not done so and thus you haven't seen the full range of potential human female breast motion or lack of same, so you've proven nothing. And the film shows a walk (maybe brisk, but a walk, not a run).
I'm frankly amused at why you want to keep returning to the breast thing, trying to prove an impossible, while others here suggest I can't or shouldn't try to prove an impossible (that it's not a suit). That "can't prove an impossible" cuts both ways.
Can we agree with this?
Your opinion: The breasts in the film do not move as you expect or have observed any real human female breasts moving.
My opinion: The apparent subtle motion (or lack of more motion) simply suggests, if the figure is real (qualified here), than the subcutenious connective fibers in the skin around the breast are particularly well connected, a condition many a woman would envy. And if it's a suit, everything I see in the breasts could be replicated with 1967 technology, no sweat.
"Bill, I think I was clear from my posts. I see I wasn't. So, I will try to be more clear.
I think that regardless of your qualifications, personal bias have seeped in your analysis of Patty's breasts. Please understand that qualifications apart, what impress me and can make me change my mind are evidence and arguments. So far, the reasons you exposed to back your positions on how hard it would be to build a Patty costume, specially the parts I have outlined, have failed to convince me, regradless of your CV. These are two things apart."
You are not convinced. I respect that.
I will be most happy to set aside CVs and resumes, and allow each person's opinion to have real consideration, if you (all collectively) will drop that dumb "incredulaity" word from these discussions. Fair trade?
The following is catching up on past posts and answers. In some cases, people piled quotes upon quotes, so I don't have here the true original person making the original remark, just reference to which post it occured in, so interested persons can look it up. Hope that's okay.
Correa Neto #10082 Jan. 4
"Aniway, he's pretty dead on spot when he says Gimlim must have been a part of the hoax."
I never said Bob Gimlin was in on a hoax. I said if it was a hoax, I could not imagine it being done without Gimlin being part of it - Means I did not imagine a way to hoax Gimlin himself. Does not conclude there was one.
Correa Neto #10135
"Oh, Munns' ideas.
So far, he exposed arguments on why he thinks its unlikely that the patterns seen on Patty's hair or fur could have been made by Patterson and eventual colaborators."
I never made any appraisal of the skill or lack of same for Patterson to make a fur hair pattern, other than to apprease what I felt were professional skills an amateur would not likely posses.
AtomicMysteryMonster #10191
"Getting back on topic, I'm rather confused by some of Mr. Munns' comments over at those BFF threads. Didn't Dfoot do a fur-covered muscle padding demo using fake fur? So why doesn't Munns think that foam padding under fake fur can show muscle movement (according to this site, it can)? "
My notes on muscle padding and muscle simulation suits explain this quite thoroughly? Furcloth of the time moves it's own way, like cloth, and little (if any) movement can be transmitted through it by some other force?
AtomicMysteryMonster #10237
"After all, that's how the Marx film got debunked. Humorously enough, the suit used for that film (Along with the Kong suit in "King Kong vs. Godzilla") had short fur, something that Mr. Munns seems to think would be an odd choice for a hoaxer."
Seams are harder to hide with short hair. It's an odd choice for anybody trying to make a suit with 1960's hair materials.
"A good example of this is how he dismisses the idea of the "rippling leg muscle" as being loose fabric since he can't imagine someone leaving part of the costume loose. "
I said if it's a suit, the leg thing could be explained as a flap of furcloth loose. I acknowledged that, which you obviously missed. I wondered why nobody would have missed re-gluing it before the cameras roll. I can't imagine that, because if I were there, I'd never let it happen. Amateurs working a suit can do any fool thing wrong. Never said they couldn't.
"During his descriptions
seems to have forgotten the existence of water bags (which also kinda contradicts some of the comments he made about nobody thinking of using fluid filled sacks while discussing breasts) "
I acknowledged being aware of water pouches suposedly used by Charlie Gamora for a 40's gorilla suit. And I explained exactly how fluid filled breasts could be made with 60's technology. I said I was unaware of anybody actually doing so (fluid sacks to make bouncing breasts) at that time.
"and appears to be unaware of the "muscle movement" trick described here. He doesn't seem to know about the "muscle movement" created by hip waders, either."
I made no claim to know every way to create muscle movement. But I know how furcloth moves, and I explained the physical dynamics of it. And the furcloth overpowers any attempt to create muscle movement beneath the cloth. So the movement dynamics of the furcloth are critical, moseso than the underlying attmpt at muscle movement.
"His comments about the extreme difficulty a person would have in such a costume (he implies that they'd probably faint) are also odd. Although I'm sure they'd agree that wearing monster costumes is hard work, Crash Corrigan (I love how that article notes the cowboy/gorilla costume connection) and the men who played Godzilla would beg to differ on the issue of how far one could go without a cooling system. Simply filling the suit with bags of ice prior to filming would also make things much easier for someone in a costume. "
Did you miss my explanation of actually working in a suit myself, for Swamp Thing", and having crew squirt cold water into my suit with Hudson Sprayers? Or did you miss the part of my notes where I said specifically that people can train and condition themselves to endure longer in suits?
"I find it odd that he seems to say that he doesn't think a hoaxer would have the foresight to train someone to endure being in a suit and yet thinks that a film crew would be needed to make such a hoax. Am I missing something here?"
Are you talking about a professional Hollywood hoax or a "two cowboys and a friend" hoax? Each person can speculate about how elaborate a hoax might have been, and any one's speculation is equal in merit, none prevailing. Did I ever say my opinion was the end of the argument? Never.
"I also think that he hasn't done much research on the film's backstory. "
All of my analysis is pertaining to building suits. I have avoided any consideration of a backstory, and focused on the material skills, processes and techniques of building suits. It's called "focus on the hypothesis". Can a suit appearing like the figure in the film have been made with 1960's suit technology, and if so, how? That's my hypothesis.
AtomicMysteryMonster #10317
"Heh, that actually reminds me of something Bill Munns said in part four of his Patty analysis. In it, he discusses how Hollywood makeup men of the day felt threatened by amateur upstarts whose work rivaled/surpassed theirs. "
Not in my Part 4 analysis, found here:
Page 6, Post 144, D foot thread BFF
My comment:
They (the Hollywood makeup establishment) were a little concerned that Dick Smith, an "outsider" from a New York TV background, was starting to prove a true prosthetic master and a more innovative leader in the craft than they. They were very intimidated by Stuart Freeborn's 2001 Space Oddessy ape makeups, because they were all patting John Chambers on the back for his Planet of The Apes work, even though John didn't do anything that was substantially better than what was done in the Wizard of Oz thirty years before, while Stuart was boldly innovating (with what has finally become industry standard mask technology).
They were intimidated by Rick Baker, a new kid and non-union artist who's work along side union trained Stan Winston on "The Autobiography of Miss Jane Pitman" lead to attempts to deny Rick proper credit and recognition for his part of the job, because he was a non-union "outsider".
AtomicMysteryMonster #10392
"While looking through the pictures posted by Bill Munns over at the BFF, I noticed that the hands of his Gigantopithecus statue looked quite similar to the "reconstruction" of a Bigfoot hand
2. When did Munns make that statue?"
It was made in 1988, when I worked at Creative Presentations.
"3. What could've inspired the look of the hand casts if it wasn't the statue?"
It's called artistic speculation, based on studying various primate and human hands, and realizing that no fossil hands (or anything below the jaw) exists for Giganto. Read "Other Origins" for how I speculated about the body skeletol design. I just had to make a plausible estimation of how it might look.
"Was Bill Munns a Bigfoot proponent when he made the statue?"
I was interested in cryptids in general, but not a proponent of any conclusion.
"I've seen a post on the BFF implying that Munns attended some Bigfoot conference prior to his recent posts on the P/G film, but I don't know if he was a proponent prior to the creation of that statue."
I've never attended any Bigfoot conference. I attended one for the Americal Association of Physical Anthropologists (where I met Grover Kranz) in 1988, and when he had his photo taken beside one of my Giganto figures. Perhaps someone made an assumption my meeting Grover was at a Bigfoot event, because he went to them.
William Parcher #10612
Hey Dfoot,
Why is Bill Munns putting "Michael 3's" fingers all the way into Patty's fingers? "
I explained that I was exploring how a human might fit into the figure, and for one analysis, I scaled the human to approximate the eyes and knees of Patty as callibration points, and a normal Michael 3 model had shorter hands than Patty. So I also tested an approximation of aligning the Poser figure eyes and an approximation of the wrist (since fingertips were vague) to the Patty image (as best I could determine them), to see how the legs scaled, and found I'd need to scale the legs shorter to align the knees.
The conclusion was if it were a person inside, with human hands in the suit hands, the human would need a body to armspan ratio of 112% to 115%, while human norn is more like 100%.
William Parcher #10715
Originally Posted by Bill Munns
"I see in the film three "lines" of fur shadow marks (1. around the waist, 2. the line between pelvic area and thigh, and 3. a third across the mid thigh itself) any of which can be argued as a "seam" of a suit, but no professional suitmaker would ever put obvious seams in all three places in one suit. To argue all are seams makes no sense. (end Bill Munns quote)
"What about an unemployed Yakima rodeo cowboy? Might a guy like Patterson do things that a professional suitmaker wouldn't? "
Of course, amateurs can do anything they want. I can only discuss what makes sense for a pro, based on 30 years as one. Amateurs can do every fool thing in the world, and often do.
"But where is Munns going with this? "
I assume my notes on this board answer that.
"If it was a hoax, then the hoaxer would be sure to get everything perfect to prevent detection."
Don't most hoaxers try to do it well enough to escape detection? As I understand it, the essential goal of a hoax is to deceive, and to deceive, one must escape detection.
AtomicMysteryMonster #10726
"Originally Posted by kitakaze
Bill Munns:Is this some kind of joke?
I'm afraid not. Judging from his posts at the BFF, Mr. Munns seems convinced that 4-way stretch fabric with short, dense fur didn't exist at the time. Not being up on the history of stretch fur, I can't say whether or not that's correct. Does anyone here have any info on the matter?"
4 way stretch spandex fur was introduced to the industry in the early 1980's by National Fibre Technology of Lawrence, MA. Confirmed fact.
Sorry this one is so long. had a lot of stuff to respond to.
Just one simple question, if I may. If you were so determined to wonder about me, my motive, and my notes, why not just go over to the BFF and ask me directly?
Don't you like going to the source for a direct first person answer? Just curious here.
"I must stand by my statements; basically I feel that a person, specially if used to hard work, could perform as Patty, specially because he (whoever he was) would have two helpers. Or at the very least, one. Not to mention that the "Patty performance" was not very long.
Now, do you agree or not? If not, why?"
Agree.
"I partially agree with you, and my posts on the issue shows why. Of course the building and filming techiches are different. The true question is: Considering seams can be hidden in miniatures filmed at close range (by a number of means) would the seams of a full-sized costume be visible at PGF's resolution?
My opinion is no or barely."
Depends on the seam, where it is, how it was designed. Seams on costumes are far more varied in design that in stop motion models, especially closure seams (to get a person into and out of the costume. I have doubts about how well the film can resolve seams, and would like to test that more reliably, taking actual seamed fur structures, photographing them at similar resolution, and seeing exactly what does show and what doesn't. with knowledge of the original seam placement as the callibration data.
seams running parallel to the hair lay are harder to hide than seams running perpendicular to the hair lay. Zig Zag seams running overall parallel to the hair lay help better than straight seams running parallel, but are a lot more work tailoring. And seamed sections are stiffer than fur unseamed areas, so the difference in rigidity makes curious motion artifcats in the seam locations that may magnify the effect (when the suit person moves on camera), and so magnify the prospect of being seen.
Back to the breasts now:
"Bill, here's the problem:
"I didn't see"
Its the very same issue we've been dealing with for a long time. Personal impressions. As you just said, you did not see anything particulary unatural. Well, I see. In this particular issues, saying "it looks real for me" is just not enough. You certainly are familiar with Monty Python's "The meaning of life". Well, there's a scene of several bare breasted women running. No silicone. Please point me to a single one whose breasts move like Patty's breasts. "
You seem to fail to grasp that I simply don't think the whole breast thing is an issue, because I know anything on the screen can be faked with the 1960's technology, and I've said so repeatedly.
Seems like now, you're trying to prove a negative, that it's "impossible" for breasts of a living creature to move as you see them in the PG film. A skeptic would say, no matter how many human female breasts you look at running topless in a movie, there are still some human females who have not done so and thus you haven't seen the full range of potential human female breast motion or lack of same, so you've proven nothing. And the film shows a walk (maybe brisk, but a walk, not a run).
I'm frankly amused at why you want to keep returning to the breast thing, trying to prove an impossible, while others here suggest I can't or shouldn't try to prove an impossible (that it's not a suit). That "can't prove an impossible" cuts both ways.
Can we agree with this?
Your opinion: The breasts in the film do not move as you expect or have observed any real human female breasts moving.
My opinion: The apparent subtle motion (or lack of more motion) simply suggests, if the figure is real (qualified here), than the subcutenious connective fibers in the skin around the breast are particularly well connected, a condition many a woman would envy. And if it's a suit, everything I see in the breasts could be replicated with 1967 technology, no sweat.
"Bill, I think I was clear from my posts. I see I wasn't. So, I will try to be more clear.
I think that regardless of your qualifications, personal bias have seeped in your analysis of Patty's breasts. Please understand that qualifications apart, what impress me and can make me change my mind are evidence and arguments. So far, the reasons you exposed to back your positions on how hard it would be to build a Patty costume, specially the parts I have outlined, have failed to convince me, regradless of your CV. These are two things apart."
You are not convinced. I respect that.
I will be most happy to set aside CVs and resumes, and allow each person's opinion to have real consideration, if you (all collectively) will drop that dumb "incredulaity" word from these discussions. Fair trade?
The following is catching up on past posts and answers. In some cases, people piled quotes upon quotes, so I don't have here the true original person making the original remark, just reference to which post it occured in, so interested persons can look it up. Hope that's okay.
Correa Neto #10082 Jan. 4
"Aniway, he's pretty dead on spot when he says Gimlim must have been a part of the hoax."
I never said Bob Gimlin was in on a hoax. I said if it was a hoax, I could not imagine it being done without Gimlin being part of it - Means I did not imagine a way to hoax Gimlin himself. Does not conclude there was one.
Correa Neto #10135
"Oh, Munns' ideas.
So far, he exposed arguments on why he thinks its unlikely that the patterns seen on Patty's hair or fur could have been made by Patterson and eventual colaborators."
I never made any appraisal of the skill or lack of same for Patterson to make a fur hair pattern, other than to apprease what I felt were professional skills an amateur would not likely posses.
AtomicMysteryMonster #10191
"Getting back on topic, I'm rather confused by some of Mr. Munns' comments over at those BFF threads. Didn't Dfoot do a fur-covered muscle padding demo using fake fur? So why doesn't Munns think that foam padding under fake fur can show muscle movement (according to this site, it can)? "
My notes on muscle padding and muscle simulation suits explain this quite thoroughly? Furcloth of the time moves it's own way, like cloth, and little (if any) movement can be transmitted through it by some other force?
AtomicMysteryMonster #10237
"After all, that's how the Marx film got debunked. Humorously enough, the suit used for that film (Along with the Kong suit in "King Kong vs. Godzilla") had short fur, something that Mr. Munns seems to think would be an odd choice for a hoaxer."
Seams are harder to hide with short hair. It's an odd choice for anybody trying to make a suit with 1960's hair materials.
"A good example of this is how he dismisses the idea of the "rippling leg muscle" as being loose fabric since he can't imagine someone leaving part of the costume loose. "
I said if it's a suit, the leg thing could be explained as a flap of furcloth loose. I acknowledged that, which you obviously missed. I wondered why nobody would have missed re-gluing it before the cameras roll. I can't imagine that, because if I were there, I'd never let it happen. Amateurs working a suit can do any fool thing wrong. Never said they couldn't.
"During his descriptions
seems to have forgotten the existence of water bags (which also kinda contradicts some of the comments he made about nobody thinking of using fluid filled sacks while discussing breasts) "
I acknowledged being aware of water pouches suposedly used by Charlie Gamora for a 40's gorilla suit. And I explained exactly how fluid filled breasts could be made with 60's technology. I said I was unaware of anybody actually doing so (fluid sacks to make bouncing breasts) at that time.
"and appears to be unaware of the "muscle movement" trick described here. He doesn't seem to know about the "muscle movement" created by hip waders, either."
I made no claim to know every way to create muscle movement. But I know how furcloth moves, and I explained the physical dynamics of it. And the furcloth overpowers any attempt to create muscle movement beneath the cloth. So the movement dynamics of the furcloth are critical, moseso than the underlying attmpt at muscle movement.
"His comments about the extreme difficulty a person would have in such a costume (he implies that they'd probably faint) are also odd. Although I'm sure they'd agree that wearing monster costumes is hard work, Crash Corrigan (I love how that article notes the cowboy/gorilla costume connection) and the men who played Godzilla would beg to differ on the issue of how far one could go without a cooling system. Simply filling the suit with bags of ice prior to filming would also make things much easier for someone in a costume. "
Did you miss my explanation of actually working in a suit myself, for Swamp Thing", and having crew squirt cold water into my suit with Hudson Sprayers? Or did you miss the part of my notes where I said specifically that people can train and condition themselves to endure longer in suits?
"I find it odd that he seems to say that he doesn't think a hoaxer would have the foresight to train someone to endure being in a suit and yet thinks that a film crew would be needed to make such a hoax. Am I missing something here?"
Are you talking about a professional Hollywood hoax or a "two cowboys and a friend" hoax? Each person can speculate about how elaborate a hoax might have been, and any one's speculation is equal in merit, none prevailing. Did I ever say my opinion was the end of the argument? Never.
"I also think that he hasn't done much research on the film's backstory. "
All of my analysis is pertaining to building suits. I have avoided any consideration of a backstory, and focused on the material skills, processes and techniques of building suits. It's called "focus on the hypothesis". Can a suit appearing like the figure in the film have been made with 1960's suit technology, and if so, how? That's my hypothesis.
AtomicMysteryMonster #10317
"Heh, that actually reminds me of something Bill Munns said in part four of his Patty analysis. In it, he discusses how Hollywood makeup men of the day felt threatened by amateur upstarts whose work rivaled/surpassed theirs. "
Not in my Part 4 analysis, found here:
Page 6, Post 144, D foot thread BFF
My comment:
They (the Hollywood makeup establishment) were a little concerned that Dick Smith, an "outsider" from a New York TV background, was starting to prove a true prosthetic master and a more innovative leader in the craft than they. They were very intimidated by Stuart Freeborn's 2001 Space Oddessy ape makeups, because they were all patting John Chambers on the back for his Planet of The Apes work, even though John didn't do anything that was substantially better than what was done in the Wizard of Oz thirty years before, while Stuart was boldly innovating (with what has finally become industry standard mask technology).
They were intimidated by Rick Baker, a new kid and non-union artist who's work along side union trained Stan Winston on "The Autobiography of Miss Jane Pitman" lead to attempts to deny Rick proper credit and recognition for his part of the job, because he was a non-union "outsider".
AtomicMysteryMonster #10392
"While looking through the pictures posted by Bill Munns over at the BFF, I noticed that the hands of his Gigantopithecus statue looked quite similar to the "reconstruction" of a Bigfoot hand
2. When did Munns make that statue?"
It was made in 1988, when I worked at Creative Presentations.
"3. What could've inspired the look of the hand casts if it wasn't the statue?"
It's called artistic speculation, based on studying various primate and human hands, and realizing that no fossil hands (or anything below the jaw) exists for Giganto. Read "Other Origins" for how I speculated about the body skeletol design. I just had to make a plausible estimation of how it might look.
"Was Bill Munns a Bigfoot proponent when he made the statue?"
I was interested in cryptids in general, but not a proponent of any conclusion.
"I've seen a post on the BFF implying that Munns attended some Bigfoot conference prior to his recent posts on the P/G film, but I don't know if he was a proponent prior to the creation of that statue."
I've never attended any Bigfoot conference. I attended one for the Americal Association of Physical Anthropologists (where I met Grover Kranz) in 1988, and when he had his photo taken beside one of my Giganto figures. Perhaps someone made an assumption my meeting Grover was at a Bigfoot event, because he went to them.
William Parcher #10612
Hey Dfoot,
Why is Bill Munns putting "Michael 3's" fingers all the way into Patty's fingers? "
I explained that I was exploring how a human might fit into the figure, and for one analysis, I scaled the human to approximate the eyes and knees of Patty as callibration points, and a normal Michael 3 model had shorter hands than Patty. So I also tested an approximation of aligning the Poser figure eyes and an approximation of the wrist (since fingertips were vague) to the Patty image (as best I could determine them), to see how the legs scaled, and found I'd need to scale the legs shorter to align the knees.
The conclusion was if it were a person inside, with human hands in the suit hands, the human would need a body to armspan ratio of 112% to 115%, while human norn is more like 100%.
William Parcher #10715
Originally Posted by Bill Munns
"I see in the film three "lines" of fur shadow marks (1. around the waist, 2. the line between pelvic area and thigh, and 3. a third across the mid thigh itself) any of which can be argued as a "seam" of a suit, but no professional suitmaker would ever put obvious seams in all three places in one suit. To argue all are seams makes no sense. (end Bill Munns quote)
"What about an unemployed Yakima rodeo cowboy? Might a guy like Patterson do things that a professional suitmaker wouldn't? "
Of course, amateurs can do anything they want. I can only discuss what makes sense for a pro, based on 30 years as one. Amateurs can do every fool thing in the world, and often do.
"But where is Munns going with this? "
I assume my notes on this board answer that.
"If it was a hoax, then the hoaxer would be sure to get everything perfect to prevent detection."
Don't most hoaxers try to do it well enough to escape detection? As I understand it, the essential goal of a hoax is to deceive, and to deceive, one must escape detection.
AtomicMysteryMonster #10726
"Originally Posted by kitakaze
Bill Munns:Is this some kind of joke?
I'm afraid not. Judging from his posts at the BFF, Mr. Munns seems convinced that 4-way stretch fabric with short, dense fur didn't exist at the time. Not being up on the history of stretch fur, I can't say whether or not that's correct. Does anyone here have any info on the matter?"
4 way stretch spandex fur was introduced to the industry in the early 1980's by National Fibre Technology of Lawrence, MA. Confirmed fact.
Sorry this one is so long. had a lot of stuff to respond to.
Just one simple question, if I may. If you were so determined to wonder about me, my motive, and my notes, why not just go over to the BFF and ask me directly?
Don't you like going to the source for a direct first person answer? Just curious here.
