Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
OK, back to this...

It's probably 3/4" tape, rather than 1". It is likely digital, although there certainly were 1" video tape formats in wide use in the professional broadcast industry in the past.

Somebody obviously allowed NG to use a film copy of the PGF for the show. That somebody would have been paid, and received a copy of the show, and it's very possible that part of the deal was that NG would provide them with a high quality videotape of the PGF.

Getting a high quality film to tape scan done would otherwise be pricey, I'd think. It would sweeten the deal nicely for whoever let NG use their copy of the PGF.

LTC said:
Portable 1" type C video tape machine. (Photo of machine shown)

LTC said:
WP, just looking around at different transfer sites, it looks like a film scan often requires a leader at both ends.

LTC said:
I guess if you want the frames right at the beginning and end transferred, you need the leaders, WP.

Roger said that the 16mm film reel ran out at the very last frame we see showing Patty (this is designated as Frame 952). The 16mm filmstrip snaked through the camera and (presumably) every last frame that could be exposed, was exposed. I think this leaves no ending frames that could be used as something like a 'leader' (since we're talking about the ending, we should choose a different term such as 'trailer').

When you watch the National Geographic episode, you see a hand-marked 'trailer', but no hand-marked 'leader'. When you watch the Henry May clip, you see a hand-marked 'leader' and 'trailer' - and those two bits appear to be literally identical at least for some of the written characters. The writing appears to have been done with some kind of ink pen or marker. I was able to freeze the 'leader' and 'trailer' and found literally identical markings. These are under high magnification, so you can see that these written characters are truly identical in the leader and trailer.

At this point, I've got numerous questions. The most fundamental one asks about what exactly was given to NG. Then there is the question about whether NG did any editing (manipulation) upon the copy that they received. We can see that the Henry May clip is different than the NG episode, because it shows a marked leader (not seen in NG) in addition to the marked trailer (seen in NG).

There is another difference. The NG episode has their 'vertical yellow rectangle' logo in the upper left along with their name. The Henry May clip has the rectangle logo in the lower right with no name.

Your turn now...
 
Can anyone confirm the rumor that Parcher has gone into the fetal position, and is mumbling about 'Meldrum was right' and things such as 'Sweaty was right about the helmet not fitting'?

Once again, just a rumor, but can anyone confirm?

I can confirm that. But it is not the classic 'fetal position', because my head is in the position of a turn-to-look. As if some rodeo cowboy is filming me inside the womb.
 
I'm not THAT dense but I have lost all sense of where this thread is going. I mentioned this a few pages back. So nothing coming from anyone no matter how much it flys in the face of their known position is going to surprise me even if Wp or you announces this afternoon that they've become a believer. I think perhaps its time for someone to assess all the information on this thread and distill it down into some sort of managable hypothesis.

Crowlogic, my friend, don't you start away uneasy. You poor old sod, you see, it's only me.
 
But your head isn't really turning, it's your whole upper torso right?

Did someone just yell 'COVER ME!'?
 
Last edited:
Your turn now...

Well, I guess you'd splice a leader and a trailer on if it was necessary for the equipment to properly scan the very first and last frames of the bit of film you want scanned.

I think you also add the leader and trailer to prevent the first and last few frames from being damaged in projectors. The first frames tend to get damaged when people thread the film and the last ones when people forget to stop the projector, iirc.

Why the leaders would be identical I can't say.

I am certain that the leader appears in that Truth or Scare episode, though.

Why they show the leaders on TV shows is just a guess, but could it be for copyright purposes?
 
Well, I guess you'd splice a leader and a trailer on if it was necessary for the equipment to properly scan the very first and last frames of the bit of film you want scanned.

You are talking about celluloid film, not digital tape, right?

I think you also add the leader and trailer to prevent the first and last few frames from being damaged in projectors. The first frames tend to get damaged when people thread the film and the last ones when people forget to stop the projector, iirc.

Again, this is when you are working with celluloid film, not digital tape, right?

Why the leaders would be identical I can't say.

The 'why' part is a secondary issue (but no less intriguing) to the fact that they are identical.

I am certain that the leader appears in that Truth or Scare episode, though.

So, you will pay attention and hopefully record the "T or S" episode that will air on Discovery Kids (March 14th at 1am). I have no way to watch this or record it. Don't you just love these demands that I place on my fellow PGF students?

Why they show the leaders on TV shows is just a guess, but could it be for copyright purposes?

Explain, please. Is this to enforce a Patterson copyright, or a National Geographic copyright, or what?
 
William say again in English. We're awash in a sea of data so its kinda hard to tell when someone has gone native. :crowded:

I am using English.

6c251322.jpg
 
You are talking about celluloid film, not digital tape, right?

Yes.

NG wants to do a show on bigfoot. They want to feature the PGF incident. They ask around for copies of the movie that they can use. Some people have crappy video copies. This is NG and they want a high quality version. Somebody who has one of the film copies steps up. NG says we need to digitize this for use in our studio so it'll need leaders. Identical leaders are created and spliced on to the ends. Somebody realizes that this is a good opportunity to get their film made into a high quality tape for free, so they add that in as part of the payment.

The copyright would only belong to Somebody, I presume.

NG only needs to show the leader once on the show, so that's all they do.

When the film was digitized, it probably had the plain NG logo in the lower right as a standard mark for an NG video creation. Possibly automatically done by the equipment.

For broadcast, that would probably interfere with other logos that often appear there, so the logo was moved to the upper left. Once it's been digitized, moving the logo or changing it is probably easy.

Something like that.
 
I think perhaps its time for someone to assess all the information on this thread and distill it down into some sort of managable hypothesis.
Let me try. Skeptics are generally of the opinion that Bigfoot is most likely not a real creature. Bigfoot proponents say that's nonsense, there's loads of evidence. Skeptics ask for the best piece of evidence and quite often (although not universally) Bigfoot proponents name the PGF. So, we have this thread to examine the quality of the PGF as evidence for the existence of Bigfoot as a real creature. 297 pages later no one is convinced of anything that they didn't believe before starting this thread.

Except possibly me. I used to accept the fact that there WAS a PGF -- that probably showed a man in a suit. Now, I'm no longer sure if the PGF really exists. All we have are a bunch of fabrications and reconstructions of what the PGF once showed, but no strong evidence that it still exists, if in fact it ever did.
 
In 20 words or less, no suit = no proven hoax; no body = no proven bigfoot.

Yes, and this is also why the schoolboy excuse of "the dog ate my homework" is treated so poorly by the teacher and the boy. A very bad precendent is set in early school and it leads to enduring mysteries.

There is no reason why a dog cannot eat paper (some do), and there is no reason why a dog eating paper cannot be a honest and functional excuse for not turning in homework. If the teacher rolls their eyes :rolleyes: and gives a failing grade, they have done a disservice to critical inquiry, a quest for facts, and an opportunity to teach something important to 2nd Graders. The question of what happened to the homework of this particular student can remain an intriguing mystery for generations on end, without ever providing any genuine resolution.

It is incumbant upon the teacher to ask the student for factual evidence to support this claim (dog ate my homework) before giving a failing grade. It is also incumbant upon the student to provide factual evidence such as properly-collected feces placed into things like Ziploc bags. These steps are necessary to prevent enduring mysteries that cannot be solved without such demands and evidences. Eventually, the dog, the student, and the teacher will die. Anyone looking into the mystery of what happened to this student's homework will face obstacles justified by a lack of factual evidences. A fellow student in that classroom may outlive the primary characters (dog-student-teacher) and remain locked in a wonderous lifetime intrigue of wanting to know what actually happened with the homework.

The issue of no required homework being presented in the 2nd Grade seems trivial in the real world. But failing grades in any level of education can affect the real-life future of a student and their potential for earning income. Millions of students throughout the ages may have simply lied when claiming that their dog ate the homework. But just like with Bigfoot, any number of them might be telling the truth. The more of them that make the claim, the less likely it is that all of them are liars. Resolution and proper outcomes fall entirely upon the teacher (who is older and should use proper means of inquiry), and they really do need to demand the presentation of the doggie feces. The student should be taught, and subsequently understand that, bringing dog poop into the classroom is a necessary way to support and preserve their integrity if such a thing would bring benefit to themselves, the teacher and the entire world society.

A dog is no less likely to eat homework, than a Bigfoot is less likely to exist.

Is Patty a Bigfoot? Does Bigfoot exist? Did the dog eat the homework?

We will all wait for Godot.
 
I'm actually more certain now than I was that the PGF is a hoax, although I was pretty certain already.

I have learned a lot in this thread and the other threads that have firmed up my opinions about the PGF.
 
I'm actually more certain now than I was that the PGF is a hoax, although I was pretty certain already.

I have learned a lot in this thread and the other threads that have firmed up my opinions about the PGF.

It's actually done the opposite for me. I started reading this thread thoroughly convinced that the PGF was a hoax. I'm no longer sure. Can something that doesn't exist be a hoax? The hoax may be that there is no PGF.

I'm no longer prepared to debate what the PGF shows unless someone can prove there is a PGF.

(Skeptics should be allowed free movement of goalposts if they believe the situation warrants it.)
 
William Parcher wrote:
It is incumbant upon the teacher to ask the student for factual evidence to support this claim (dog ate my homework) before giving a failing grade.


Well the dawn was coming...heard him ringing on my bell
He said, "My name's the teacher...that is what I call myself...
And I have a lesson, that I must impart to you
It's an old expression, but I must insist it's true...

"If you want what you claim to carry some weight....back it up with something. That goes for everyone...regardless of what their claim is."
 
When I was small I believed in santa claus
Though I knew it was my dad
And I would hang up my stocking at christmas
Open my presents and Id be glad

But the last time I played father christmas
I stood outside a department store
A gang of kids came over and mugged me
And knocked my reindeer to the floor

They said:
Father christmas, give us some money
Dont mess around with those silly toys.
Well beat you up if you dont hand it over
We want your bread so dont make us annoyed
Give all the toys to the little rich boys

Dont give my brother a sasquatch outfit
Dont give my sister a bigfoot toy
We dont want a picture or a blurry movie
We only want the real mccoy

...
 
NG wants to do a show on bigfoot. They want to feature the PGF incident. They ask around for copies of the movie that they can use.

They do this by looking in the phone book for "Patterson-Gimlin Film".

Some people have crappy video copies. This is NG and they want a high quality version.

So, NG painstakingly views everything they get from the various people they found in the phone book. Yes, there are all kind of people who can legally sell a copy of the PGF to NG, in spite of there being a legal copyright on the PGF.

High quality version? Did you look at the NG or Henry May clips? The color is washed out and it's really very crappy. The Mysterious Monsters and LMS versions put this one to shame. Put this one to shame!

Somebody who has one of the film copies steps up.

Steps up from the rest of the people that NG contacted? Or, their copy was the best one that was submitted? Step up... or chosen by NG?

NG says we need to digitize this for use in our studio so it'll need leaders. Identical leaders are created and spliced on to the ends. Somebody realizes that this is a good opportunity to get their film made into a high quality tape for free, so they add that in as part of the payment.

NG decides to not use the Universal Film Leader, and instead just copies the ink-written 'old school' leader that was part of the original PGF copy submission. Of course, NG cannot even begin to digitally copy the old school ink writing leader until they load the 16mm celluloid PGF copy into their digital copier.

The copyright would only belong to Somebody, I presume.

And that somebody is....?

NG only needs to show the leader once on the show, so that's all they do.

But NG sends a digital copy back to the provider with the old school leader on the front and back because they are nice people.

When the film was digitized, it probably had the plain NG logo in the lower right as a standard mark for an NG video creation. Possibly automatically done by the equipment.

Or something else happened.

For broadcast, that would probably interfere with other logos that often appear there, so the logo was moved to the upper left. Once it's been digitized, moving the logo or changing it is probably easy.

Or something else is going on.

Something like that.

Yeah, something like that. Watch the legal copyright and cash transactions, if you can. Keep your eyes on Patricia Patterson, John Green, Rick Noll and MK Davis. Can anyone account for Erik Dahinden these days?
 
They do this by looking in the phone book for "Patterson-Gimlin Film".

No, they go online and research who might have legal access to a copy.
It might be that they simply put the word out that they were making the show and waited for the folks with copies of the film to show up.

So, NG painstakingly views everything they get from the various people they found in the phone book. Yes, there are all kind of people who can legally sell a copy of the PGF to NG, in spite of there being a legal copyright on the PGF.

I don't see why there couldn't be a bunch of people in that category. Roger sold rights to the film willy nilly, didn't he? Somebody was turning out copies, too.

High quality version? Did you look at the NG or Henry May clips? The color is washed out and it's really very crappy. The Mysterious Monsters and LMS versions put this one to shame. Put this one to shame!

High quality is relative. They would have wanted to scan the original, if possible. If not, they would of course have to take what they could get.

Steps up from the rest of the people that NG contacted? Or, their copy was the best one that was submitted? Step up... or chosen by NG?

I see no way to tell precisely how it happened except for identifying the copy NG used and even then...

NG decides to not use the Universal Film Leader, and instead just copies the ink-written 'old school' leader that was part of the original PGF copy submission. Of course, NG cannot even begin to digitally copy the old school ink writing leader until they load the 16mm celluloid PGF copy into their digital copier.

Again, no way to be sure. We can only suggest possibilities. My guess is that the film holder would not let NG do anything regarding adding leaders, possibly because it meant letting NG borrow the film, or the leaders were already there from long ago when amateurs were making copies and edits.

And that somebody is....?

Perhaps if the leader can be read it would be a clue? You'll recall that was the first thing I wanted. :D

But NG sends a digital copy back to the provider with the old school leader on the front and back because they are nice people.

No, I think the scan included both leaders, and I think NG saw no reason to have both in the program, and I already told you why I thought NG would provide the copy.

Can anyone account for Erik Dahinden these days?

It wasn't my turn to watch him.
 
NG used a full frame version, correct? How many people supposedly had full frame, unenlarged, film copies of the PGF.

Maybe we can narrow this down a bit?

Now where's that "official" PGF film copy chart? :D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom