William Parcher
Show me the monkey!
- Joined
- Jul 26, 2005
- Messages
- 27,680
OK, back to this...
Roger said that the 16mm film reel ran out at the very last frame we see showing Patty (this is designated as Frame 952). The 16mm filmstrip snaked through the camera and (presumably) every last frame that could be exposed, was exposed. I think this leaves no ending frames that could be used as something like a 'leader' (since we're talking about the ending, we should choose a different term such as 'trailer').
When you watch the National Geographic episode, you see a hand-marked 'trailer', but no hand-marked 'leader'. When you watch the Henry May clip, you see a hand-marked 'leader' and 'trailer' - and those two bits appear to be literally identical at least for some of the written characters. The writing appears to have been done with some kind of ink pen or marker. I was able to freeze the 'leader' and 'trailer' and found literally identical markings. These are under high magnification, so you can see that these written characters are truly identical in the leader and trailer.
At this point, I've got numerous questions. The most fundamental one asks about what exactly was given to NG. Then there is the question about whether NG did any editing (manipulation) upon the copy that they received. We can see that the Henry May clip is different than the NG episode, because it shows a marked leader (not seen in NG) in addition to the marked trailer (seen in NG).
There is another difference. The NG episode has their 'vertical yellow rectangle' logo in the upper left along with their name. The Henry May clip has the rectangle logo in the lower right with no name.
Your turn now...
It's probably 3/4" tape, rather than 1". It is likely digital, although there certainly were 1" video tape formats in wide use in the professional broadcast industry in the past.
Somebody obviously allowed NG to use a film copy of the PGF for the show. That somebody would have been paid, and received a copy of the show, and it's very possible that part of the deal was that NG would provide them with a high quality videotape of the PGF.
Getting a high quality film to tape scan done would otherwise be pricey, I'd think. It would sweeten the deal nicely for whoever let NG use their copy of the PGF.
LTC said:Portable 1" type C video tape machine. (Photo of machine shown)
LTC said:WP, just looking around at different transfer sites, it looks like a film scan often requires a leader at both ends.
LTC said:I guess if you want the frames right at the beginning and end transferred, you need the leaders, WP.
Roger said that the 16mm film reel ran out at the very last frame we see showing Patty (this is designated as Frame 952). The 16mm filmstrip snaked through the camera and (presumably) every last frame that could be exposed, was exposed. I think this leaves no ending frames that could be used as something like a 'leader' (since we're talking about the ending, we should choose a different term such as 'trailer').
When you watch the National Geographic episode, you see a hand-marked 'trailer', but no hand-marked 'leader'. When you watch the Henry May clip, you see a hand-marked 'leader' and 'trailer' - and those two bits appear to be literally identical at least for some of the written characters. The writing appears to have been done with some kind of ink pen or marker. I was able to freeze the 'leader' and 'trailer' and found literally identical markings. These are under high magnification, so you can see that these written characters are truly identical in the leader and trailer.
At this point, I've got numerous questions. The most fundamental one asks about what exactly was given to NG. Then there is the question about whether NG did any editing (manipulation) upon the copy that they received. We can see that the Henry May clip is different than the NG episode, because it shows a marked leader (not seen in NG) in addition to the marked trailer (seen in NG).
There is another difference. The NG episode has their 'vertical yellow rectangle' logo in the upper left along with their name. The Henry May clip has the rectangle logo in the lower right with no name.
Your turn now...
