Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's not up to the skeptic to prove anything; it's up to the individual making the extraordinary claim to provide evidence of said claim.

That sounds right until you look at the actual situation at hand between BF skeptics and believers.

Both sides generally agree that: Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence (proof).

The reason that skeptics experience continual attempts to reverse the 'burden of proof' from believers is because the two sides do not agree upon what is considered an extraordinary claim.

  • Skeptic says that the extraordinary claim is: The Bigfoot animal actually exists.
  • Skeptic says that the extraordinary claim is: The figure in the Patterson-Gimlin Film is an actual Bigfoot animal.


  • Believer says that the extraordinary claim is: The Bigfoot animal does not actually exist.
  • Believer says that the extraordinary claim is: The figure in the Patterson-Gimlin Film is a person in a costume.

This is why Bigfoot and Patty believers habitually switch the burden of proof to the skeptic.
 
Mangler I think I know why you go by the name Mangler. That said where I come from the quickest way to incrudulity is to use the word "dude". Once again I challange you to produce a photograph of Northern CA taken first week in September that shows dropping leaves and significant Autumn color. Both the photos you've posted and the photos I've posted go very far in dismissing some extravagant posts made here and elsewhere that point to the PGF having been shot during the first week of September 1967.

I still don't recall anyone here suggesting that the PGF was filmed in early September. I think at best it was one person.

Crowlogic's claim seems to be that the PGF cannot have been filmed in early September because of the foliage visible in the film.

I wish he'd just support the claim already. Let's see the parts of the PGF that clearly show bare trees on the hillsides, for example. So far all I've seen are bare trees in the river's course in one still.

IIRC, nothing is too clear in the PGF, the film was not exposed correctly, the colors are out of whack, and most of what you can find today has been zoomed and enhanced.
 
Last edited:
This is why Bigfoot and Patty believers habitually switch the burden of proof to the skeptic.

Yep, William, I got that.

Thing is, I see that as more evidence of willful BF-proponent obstinacy. Until there is actual proof that such an animal as sasquatch really exists, the burden of proof for all sasquatch-related claims lies solely in BF-believer's hands.

Given that no such proof has been forthcoming for the past, what, fifty-odd years, the rational place to proceed with all discussions relating to the big bipedal monkey is from a skeptical standpoint.

At least it seems clear to me. On the BFF, though, there are hundreds of pages of rationalizations (some of which involve Olympian leaps of logic), graphs of questionable origin, red lines on Peyote-vision images, piled together to form an argument of sorts to the contrary.

Does it matter to these individuals that those arguments, when considered rationally, all have the logical weight of a kid stamping their foot and yelling "Nuh-uh!"? Probably not.

That's why the entire topic is just funny to me now. Thousands of man-hours wasted, all due to a few seconds of grainy, jumpy 16 mm film. It's just astonishing.

I do have one interesting observation, though. One comment I've seen offered by skeptics, over and over again goes something like this: "I'd love to be wrong." Indeed, I think it's a given that all skeptics on this thread would happily -- nay, gleefully -- say "Oops! You were right all along!" should someone produce a real, live stinky ape that looked like Patty. Heck, I'd even wager that a few of us want to be wrong.

By contrast, PGF-proponents, when offered clear examples of how the film was faked, or how the costume was made, and heck, even who wore the costume, cling to the narrowest of threads to avoid admitting the possibility that maybe -- just maybe -- Mr. Gimlin isn't telling the truth, and that Roger Patterson did hoax the world.

Which of these world views, I wonder, would be seen to be more rational by an impartial observer?

Avindair
 
"Heironimus' story of shooting the Patty footage the previous Labor Day weekend when loggers were off makes perfect sense. Gimlin's story of traveling to Bluff Creek during Labor Day weekend to observe prints doesn't. Just as Heironimus stated, Patterson and Gimlin made those prints themselves before and during the Labor Day weekend to support the later pretend filming of Patty on Oct. 20, 1967."

Here is the very quote made by Dfoot over at the BBF. Actually as I stated earlier he makes the most compelling argument against the PGF. Or at least he drops the most names. So he's "da man". But I've been asked to post photos of why I think PGF was shot way later than Labor Day Weekend. And I have. I posted the full shot of frame 352. Scroll back to it. If it satisfies you that that's what early September Bluff Creek 1967 looked like then you have your mystery solved.
 
Here is the very quote made by Dfoot over at the BBF.

So why the ranting and raving at the rest of us?

Actually as I stated earlier he makes the most compelling argument against the PGF. Or at least he drops the most names. So he's "da man". But I've been asked to post photos of why I think PGF was shot way later than Labor Day Weekend. And I have. I posted the full shot of frame 352. Scroll back to it. If it satisfies you that that's what early September Bluff Creek 1967 looked like then you have your mystery solved.

This is the very first time I ever heard that Heironimous made any Labor Day claims.

Dfoot doesn't even claim the PGF was shot on Labor Day weekend in that quote, does he? He just says it makes sense, and that Gimlin traveling to observe prints doesn't make sense.

Now that part about Gimlin traveling to look at prints I can agree with. It doesn't make sense to me, either.

Patterson said they'd been there only a little over a week, and Gimlin said he'd never seen a track at all before he saw Patty.

JG So when you saw it, up until that moment you had never seen a track?
BG Never. Never seen a track at all, that's right.
 
But I've been asked to post photos of why I think PGF was shot way later than Labor Day Weekend. And I have. I posted the full shot of frame 352. Scroll back to it. If it satisfies you that that's what early September Bluff Creek 1967 looked like then you have your mystery solved.

I don't see what you see, though. Here is frame 352 again, with mostly gree behind Patty. Markedly different from the frame you posted. Which is correct?

http://www.cryptomundo.com/wp-content/patterson_bigfoot.jpg
 
Mostly Agreeable

At least it seems clear to me. On the BFF, though, there are hundreds of pages of rationalizations


By contrast, PGF-proponents, when offered clear examples of how the film was faked, or how the costume was made, and heck, even who wore the costume, cling to the narrowest of threads to avoid admitting the possibility that maybe -- just maybe -- Mr. Gimlin isn't telling the truth, and that Roger Patterson did hoax the world.

Which of these world views, I wonder, would be seen to be more rational by an impartial observer?

Avindair

I suspect most of the current interest in sasquatch is related to current day information technology. A lot of the encounters have been documented and researched. I compare it to the "six degrees phenomenon'. Almost everyone knows of someone or someone's friend who has encountered this phenomenon. Having no specimen to examine, people are left to rationalize these encounters. Invariably, you'll have wild speculations, but also a more rational consensus will be arrived at. The amount of entertainment interest by way of television will help solve this hopefully.

I'd also offer up for comparison this example. The overally 'range' of African gorillas seems rather small for the continent as a whole. They could literally have expanded across the whole eastern hemisphere, in comparison to North America. But their habitat and discovery, concerning some gorilla species were only in the last century. There could be isolated populations of an ape species in north america.
 
LTC86K

I posted the full frame 352 not the color enhanced close up. Dfoot posted the words I've quoted. He's saying that what Bob H. says makes sense so he is in agreement with the Labor Day Weekend film shoot is he not?. Its as if you say the sky is blue and I quote you and say LTC86K says the sky is blue and that makes the most sense that it is
 
All I can see in Crowlogic's frame 352 post regarding bare trees are the dead ones in the river bed, and the bottoms of the trunks of the live tall ones on the hill side beyond Patty.

Would we expect to see greenery near the bottoms of these trees?
 
Or to put it another way here's what the Bluff Creek filmsite looks like in late August 27-28 2007. What do you suppose it would look like in say 2 weeks around the Sept 10?

 
What do you suppose it would look like in say 2 weeks around the Sept 10?

This isn't 1967, so what's your point?

Why aren't you arguing with dfoot?

I'm only here waiting for you to show how the PGF could not have been shot in early September since that is your claim.
 
What do you mean by color enhanced?


William ,

Oh come on now you mean you've not seen the enhancemants made to the PGF? The DVD Legend Meets Science or LMS has an excellent enhancement. The L MS PGF footage has been cleaned up quite a bit.
 
I see a lot of green beyond Patty in the clips of the PGF available online.

IIRC, right at the beginning of the film we once discussed some tent pole looking items in the frames. Maybe I am imagining things, but I rememeber a lot of greenery there too. It's been a while since I have seen those opening frames.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom