Crowlogic
Graduate Poster
- Joined
- Aug 7, 2007
- Messages
- 1,147
Sorry crow, but I must disagree with some of your statements...
Crow, the problem lies within the over interpretation of the play of light and shadows. Bullet impacts, moving toes, ears, moving fingers, bulging muscles, opening mouths, etc. All the features used to interpret these things are not within the resolution limits - not the theoretical but the practical one. The limit imposed by under and overexposure, focus and blur. Sharp imagery allows one to interpret the light/shadows play with an accuracy degree which cannot be reached in PGF. Note that I am only talking about factors limiting resolution. Some of the claimed features extrapolate plausibility and possibility limits. Try, for example, to think about the time which each PGF frame represents and you will eventually understand what I mean.
Sorry, but this would be true only if the limbs were positioned orthogonal or parallel to the "stretch direction".
BTW, I fail to see any reason why I should mind too much about the size of Patty's arms. Costumes can change this, making ridiculously small or long arms.
I am really not sure that this can be demonstrated. Not to mention when one takes in to accounts the tales about the shooting.
Please note that perspective effects can change apparent lengths depending on the camera's angle in respect to the imaged subject. In this case, by changing the angle of the arm in respect o the film plane. If it’s not parallel, perspective will give you an apparent length, the non-orthogonal projection of the arm over the film plane.
It’s not a matter of liking or not. It’s a matter of not liking the method (or perhaps the lack of a method) used to reach this conclusion.
Please demonstrate how you reached these conclusions. Crow, remember to take in to account the time represented by each frame and the plausibility of a real creature being able to perform the proposed movement.
Here's the catch crow... It’s your opinion. I see a costume of the same level of some others (older, same age, younger). Personally I think many a movie have sequences matching PGF "quality", some with better some with worse costumes.
What should anyone use (emotional attachments and bias apart) to evaluate if my opinion better or worse than yours?
Changed your mind regarding of PGF being a fake?
What was the reason? Bill Munn's work?
I don't mean to poke you; I just want to know your position. I see no problem in changing mind.
Sorry, but your statement regarding what a more detailed image would reveal is nothing but speculation. My speculation is that it would reveal lots of flaws. What should anyone use (emotional attachments and bias apart) to evaluate if my opinion better or worse than yours?
Correa
Poke away. To poke is human to prod is divine! I'm in 100% agreement that folks are seeing things, like bullet hits, braids, sticks and mystery objects and virtually all of them are IMO worthless over analysis.
My current opinion concerning the what I see on the film and what I think it is has to do with what I see on the film. First I take the backstory away and simply observe the film in its simplicity. Then I observe the analysis and the arguments over the analysis and where the arguments lead. I measure the arguments and mood of the arguments as well. At this point in time the arguments rendered not only fail to settle the issue but all too often decay into a kind of disfunction that if there was a solid grain of truth to the arguments it would have transended the disfunction by now. I'm also left to wonder whether or not we're actually dealing with adults much of the time for much of the time the tone of the offerings are the tones I recall during 7th grade or thereabouts. I keep this in mind when reviewing the exchanges of fire between viewpoints.
So I'm left to my own devices which is not such a bad thing. I can look at the PGF and observe what appears to be a muscle flexing. I can reach down to my own leg and feel the movements of my own muscles and determine what I feel with respect to what I'm seeing. When 10,000 words and diagrams fail to outweigh six like these "its a muscle contracting under load" then OK its a muscle contracting under load. When I can see the same thing happening in a costume then I'll re evaluate my position. But I've re evaluated my position several times already. I'm comfortable with that because each time the arguments gets nailed down to one side or the other another aspect emerges to counter it.
Lastly about the backstory. Roger Patterson isn't the only person that's ever engaged in a pursuit that was part adventure, part documentary and part art. Countless film makers, artists and musicians have fouled in order to follow their passion and or desire to create. Yet frequently enough the end result of the "foul" has resulted in a genuine legitimate result.

to wealthy investors, and fund an extensive search that can effectively end the debate...or, at least throw a huge bucket of cold water on it.
