Bigfoot: The Patterson Gimlin Film - Part 3

Status
Not open for further replies.
You know what?

I've come to the conclusion at this point that anyone who tries to determine conclusively whether or not Patty is a suit is drawing more information from the footage than is actually there. It's a remarkably poor piece of footage, really, and much of the "analysis" I've seen, from skeptics as well as Footers, involve blowing it up to the point where the image quality is, IMO, too poor to really be able to tell anything. I really and truly think that both the "zipper" that some skeptics have seen, and the "muscles" that SweatyYeti claims to see, are both akin to paredolia--people seeing what they expect to see.

It's just a piss-poor image. It could be a suit, IMO it almost certainly is, but I can't see conclusively determining that one way or the other from the footage itself.

Whoa, this is the first I've heard of a zipper. Where is it?
 
Well if you're in the modality that its gotta be a suit then that's where your orbit is going to remain. You are of course welcome to what ever modality you choose. However comparing the limb ratos of a couple of tall human beings involved in the topic of this film simply having a look around the cemetary knowing that Grant is burried in Grant's Tomb.

I love it! I think I just almost understood what is being conveyed hear. Tell you what, since we're trying to get away from Bigfoot science let's try something. First we try and reliably establish Patty height. Oops, that's going to be tough. OK, for the time being we'll spot you huge and work on the major assumption that the PGF casts actually belong to Patty. Using those casts and the film we have Patty at about 6'2". Now instead of Sweaty's entirely ridiculous sample base of one, why don't you try getting a significant number of people at that height and put them in various positions shown in the PGF. Maybe even have them in gorilla suits for effect.

Then you and Sweaty won't look utterly foolish when talking about inhuman proportions. I mean, come on you guys. What are you thinking?
 
Oh, anyone with a brain can see you are trying again to evade and hide the fact that your claims are based on nothing but beliefs and heavilly-biased poorly-made evaluations.

Anyone with a brain can see you are -once again- using obfuscation tactics in an attempt to evade these requests:

Please show us the methodology and criteria you used to rule out the possibility of a play of light, shadows and perspective being responsible for what you claim to be bulging muscles.

Please show us the methodology and criteria you used to rule out the possibility of motion blur being responsible for what you claim to be moving toes.

Please show us the methodology and criteria you used to choose your impressions of extreme fluidity of movements and not-yet-matched realism to my impressions of a regular man-in-a-suit filmed from far away on substandard exposure and stability settings.

As usual, its not working here Sweaty. You'll have to sweat a lot to improve your arguments...

Correa

Everything we see on the PGF is a play of light and shadows. Photography is a light activated medium its all light, shadows and albetio. In so far as Patty's long arms nothing is going to change the limb ratio. You can stretch the photo and the limb will not change its relation to the ground and you can compress the photo and it will remain in ratio. Camera perspective is always either at the same plane as the Subject or it is lower. At no point is Patterson higher than Patty which could perhaps have created a false perspective of arm lenght

As it happens whether anyone likes it or not there are movements present in the PGF subject's body that are easily more attributed to muscle movement than suit anamolies. There is a wealth of poor resolution crummy videos of all kinds of suits both professional and amateur that are avilable for viewing. I find it interesting that no matter how degraded the videos are they don't begin exibiting features such as muscle movement. If the PGF were prought into "Hollywood" resolution there is every chance that there would be even more detail pointing to a real animal than there is now.
 
Whoa, this is the first I've heard of a zipper. Where is it?

The bell-shaped zipper claim was not made by a skeptic. It was made by Bigfoot enthusiast and known hoaxer Cliff Crook:

Claims against Bigfoot film set enthusiasts at odds
By JOHN M. HUBBELL
Associated Press

BOTHELL, Wash. (AP) - In the hearts and minds of true believers, Bigfoot's existence has long been enshrined in a single minute of jerky, grainy footage of a startled sasquatch retreating into the upper California woods.
But two enthusiasts of the legendary being are alleging four magnified frames of the 16 mm footage show tracings of a bell-shaped fastener at Bigfoot's waist. They say the creature in the so-called Patterson-Gimlin Film can finally be dismissed as a man in a monkey suit.

"It was a hoax,'' said Cliff Crook, a longtime Bigfoot tracker who devotes rooms to sasquatch memorabilia in this suburb north of Seattle. "How can an artificial, manmade object end up on a Bigfoot?''

http://www.oregonbigfoot.com/patterson.php
 
Well if you're in the modality that its gotta be a suit then that's where your orbit is going to remain.

Any objective person will be in that "modality", as will science, until some evidence is presented that changes that "modality".

No such evidence has ever come to light, to my knowledge.
 
Crowlogic wrote:



The word "and", in that statement of yours, Crow, is a key word.

What you're saying is right in-line with what I said a couple of days ago....about certain things on Patty occuring in combination with each other....





This principle applies to a few specific movements that we see on Patty....like the finger movement, the toe movement, and the calf and thigh movements.

A short explanation, for now...concerning Patty's finger movement...
The combination of finger movement and the exceptionally long arms requires a more complex suit to create this feature, than would be required if only one (finger movement), or the other (extra-long arms), attribute was present on Patty.

So Patty has specified complexity?
 
You're argument is beyond stupid. Not only can you not differentiate the fingers, even if you could it in no way makes a reall Bigfoot more likely.



We can see Patty wiggling her toes? No, we see a blur at her feet. There is a part of the PGF where the bottom of her foot is visible and you can see the toes. If the blur you point out is Patty's real foot moving, then because the toes are much shorter than the blur it means that Patty has an insane inexplicable joint that for some useless mystifying reason seen in no other primate, move upward like clown shoes. It is so fantasically stupid that you can't get that.



You mean the softballs and horizontal subducting line on the upper thigh? That movement? Fail.



Bigfoot enthusiasts like Sweaty often rely on intellectually dishonest tactics such as stating things as fact that they have been show many times not to be a fact. Sweaty is one of the most intellectually dishonest people here and relies on this constantly.

Patty's arms are not exceptionally long but Sweaty's lame tactic is exceptionally pathetic:

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_82644935db696440a.jpg[/qimg]

[qimg]http://i172.photobucket.com/albums/w28/SweatyYeti/Patty%20and%20Bob/GooGooGaaGaa2.jpg[/qimg]

http://ca.youtube.com/watch?v=oKqBaPwhUPU

The need to believe leads one to deceive.
 
Thanks for spotting that "e" I missed and keeping me sharp, MOTS. I don't usually have a problem with that:



There is something you can help with with since you're being generous. What I do have a consistent bad habit with and lamented about here in the "What do you want to do?" threa":



So if you could keep an eye out for my wayward "r"s I would really appreciate the help. Cheers.

ETA: BTW, you have me as a self-proclaimed Buddhist disciple and now as a self-proclaimed science teacher. This is an interesting character you're creating for me. What shall we name him? I know! We take Buddhist disciple/teacher Nichiren Daishonin and ol' Albert Einstein to create "Nichireinstein!" I'll wander about the lands dodging feudal lords and Neils Bohr fans while expounding on the Mystic Law of the Lotus Sutra and Special Relativity.

If you can expound on the wisdom of non-violence while making hamburger of your enemies we may have a TV show. As a bonus you can have BF as a sidekick. When he throws that pig the villains muscles will turn to jelly.
 
Well if you're in the modality that its gotta be a suit then that's where your orbit is going to remain. You are of course welcome to what ever modality you choose. However comparing the limb ratos of a couple of tall human beings involved in the topic of this film simply having a look around the cemetary knowing that Grant is burried in Grant's Tomb.

I'm in the modality that it's to blurry to see the details you say are there.
 
Sorry crow, but I must disagree with some of your statements...

Correa

Everything we see on the PGF is a play of light and shadows.
Photography is a light activated medium its all light, shadows and albetio.
Crow, the problem lies within the over interpretation of the play of light and shadows. Bullet impacts, moving toes, ears, moving fingers, bulging muscles, opening mouths, etc. All the features used to interpret these things are not within the resolution limits - not the theoretical but the practical one. The limit imposed by under and overexposure, focus and blur. Sharp imagery allows one to interpret the light/shadows play with an accuracy degree which cannot be reached in PGF. Note that I am only talking about factors limiting resolution. Some of the claimed features extrapolate plausibility and possibility limits. Try, for example, to think about the time which each PGF frame represents and you will eventually understand what I mean.

In so far as Patty's long arms nothing is going to change the limb ratio. You can stretch the photo and the limb will not change its relation to the ground and you can compress the photo and it will remain in ratio.
Sorry, but this would be true only if the limbs were positioned orthogonal or parallel to the "stretch direction".

BTW, I fail to see any reason why I should mind too much about the size of Patty's arms. Costumes can change this, making ridiculously small or long arms.

Camera perspective is always either at the same plane as the Subject or it is lower. At no point is Patterson higher than Patty which could perhaps have created a false perspective of arm lenght
I am really not sure that this can be demonstrated. Not to mention when one takes in to accounts the tales about the shooting.

Please note that perspective effects can change apparent lengths depending on the camera's angle in respect to the imaged subject. In this case, by changing the angle of the arm in respect o the film plane. If it’s not parallel, perspective will give you an apparent length, the non-orthogonal projection of the arm over the film plane.

As it happens whether anyone likes it or not there are movements present in the PGF subject's body that are easily more attributed to muscle movement than suit anamolies.
It’s not a matter of liking or not. It’s a matter of not liking the method (or perhaps the lack of a method) used to reach this conclusion.

Please demonstrate how you reached these conclusions. Crow, remember to take in to account the time represented by each frame and the plausibility of a real creature being able to perform the proposed movement.

There is a wealth of poor resolution crummy videos of all kinds of suits both professional and amateur that are avilable for viewing. I find it interesting that no matter how degraded the videos are they don't begin exibiting features such as muscle movement.
Here's the catch crow... It’s your opinion. I see a costume of the same level of some others (older, same age, younger). Personally I think many a movie have sequences matching PGF "quality", some with better some with worse costumes.

What should anyone use (emotional attachments and bias apart) to evaluate if my opinion better or worse than yours?

If the PGF were prought into "Hollywood" resolution there is every chance that there would be even more detail pointing to a real animal than there is now.
Changed your mind regarding of PGF being a fake?
What was the reason? Bill Munn's work?
I don't mean to poke you; I just want to know your position. I see no problem in changing mind.

Sorry, but your statement regarding what a more detailed image would reveal is nothing but speculation. My speculation is that it would reveal lots of flaws. What should anyone use (emotional attachments and bias apart) to evaluate if my opinion better or worse than yours?
 
Last edited:
Kit, you have an amazing amount of bigfoot lore, does that ever worry you. :D

I know a mere fraction of what Kit and some others on here know about bigfoot lore and it worries me greatly.

I talk to sane people in the real world and it's a completely different perspective. No one seems to think there's any possibility that bigfoot is a real creature. They've seen the PGF (but usually don't know it by name). They're all sure it's fake. Not only do they not think it could be anything other than a man in a suit, they refuse to believe that anyone could actually be so deluded as to think otherwise. They're sure anyone who posts that they believe it's a real creature is just messing with people. To most of the world, people like Sweaty, Crow, etc. are as mythical as bigfoot itself.

That's why I worry about spending as much time as I do reading this nonsense.
 
Kit, you have an amazing amount of bigfoot lore, does that ever worry you. :D

Believe me, it's a cause for the occasional pause and keeps me humble. Whenever I start acting like the bee's knees someone can remind me I spend obscene amounts of time talking about Bigfoot.
 
If you can expound on the wisdom of non-violence while making hamburger of your enemies we may have a TV show. As a bonus you can have BF as a sidekick. When he throws that pig the villains muscles will turn to jelly.

Ha! :D

Any misspellings I do are actually a Jim Callahan-style boobytraps that allow me to create realities and mess with people's minds.
 
Last edited:
If you spend more than one minute per year thinking about Bigfoot... you are plumb crazy.


And if we were to save a close relative from extinction, as a by-product of our time spent thinking about Bigfoot....our "craziness" would have been, in fact, an act of love. :)
 
Sweaty, you can do your part right now by telling everyone you encounter in the world to not kill Bigfoot.
 
I talk to sane people in the real world and it's a completely different perspective. No one seems to think there's any possibility that bigfoot is a real creature. They've seen the PGF (but usually don't know it by name). They're all sure it's fake. Not only do they not think it could be anything other than a man in a suit, they refuse to believe that anyone could actually be so deluded as to think otherwise. They're sure anyone who posts that they believe it's a real creature is just messing with people. To most of the world, people like Sweaty, Crow, etc. are as mythical as bigfoot itself.

As Sweaty will no doubt point out, these "sane" people are brainless dolts who couldn't possibly detect the difference between the frames that show Patty's rippling muscles and the frames that show her being hit by a high-powered rifle. Is it any wonder they think she's a guy in a suit? Sheesh!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom