Bigfoot: The Patterson Gimlin Film - Part 3

Status
Not open for further replies.
Just a quick comparison for now.....highlighting the difference in upper-body widths...


[qimg]http://i172.photobucket.com/albums/w28/SweatyYeti/Patty%20Elbow%20Analysis/ManglersMess1.jpg[/qimg]


From some measurements I made last night, it looks as though Patty's actual elbow-to-elbow span, in some frames, is approx. 40-44".....while, at the same time, her elbows are still relatively low in the arm swing...a relatively long length down from the head.


Try replicating that feat, yourself...;)

:boggled:

Elbow span? Am I reading this right? Exactly what kind of anatomical measurement is this elbow span?

Sweaty, does mangler's animation depict an averagely proportioned human? Yes or no?
 
kitakaze wrote:
Elbow span? Am I reading this right? Exactly what kind of anatomical measurement is this elbow span?



Well, that would be..."elbow span"....:boggled:....:boggled:......

:).....:).....:)...
 
Well, that would be..."elbow span".

Yeah, see, here's the problem - my humerus is 38 cm and my radius/ulna is 28 cm. That is a reliable measurement. Every time I stick up a measuring tape to my arm, the numbers don't change. My arms don't change length.

Does this elbow span thing you're talking about vary? Yes or no.

Can you tell me how I can measure my elbow span?

Also, why are you pulling out conceptual art and using the word "actual"?

Sorry, kitty....but I'm just not interested in proving the VR skeleton's validity....to the "skeptics"....(scoftics, actually)...of Jref. From the overlays of the skeleton over Patty....in LMS....it looks to me to be a very good fit.

PattyVR2.jpg


:dl:
 
Why are people still trying to get accurate and specific measurements of Patty from the PGF?

Obviously because Patty is a reliable subject to measure. Duh.

Here she is pre and post piano...

picture.php


picture.php


Please note that she has about $12 in quarters in her pocket there.
 
Nope. You don't get to set the rules I use. The overlay is perfect for what it is.
So a poser is allowed to "not fit" and it still proves that it "fits" in the suit? Ok. At what point do you know it fits well enough for proof?

I get the impression that my criticisms are aimed toward mangler's work. On the contrary, mangler has supplied a reviewable animation that likely demonstrates the "best fit" possible. I have confidence that he has fit the poser as well as anyone could. The results just aren't the proof you are looking for. In fact, now we can examine the discrepancies instead of not acknowledging them. But mangler's major contribution here is to provide a reviewable animation with semi-transparent overlays. IMO, this was the best possible way to present a poser animation.

My only concern about the software is not knowing how the poser is being scaled. What distance from the camera is the poser supposed to be? I suspect between 10 and 30 feet. In which case, the poser's scale does not match Patty's. This is crucial to overlaying the images. It's probably why the left shoulder has some issues. At any rate this type of information must be available to properly evaluate a graphic.

Skeptical Greg said:
I'm wondering what an EXACT average is

I had a double take when I saw your handle was Skeptical Greg. I didn't notice when you changed it.

The term "average" isn't really accurate in this case. It's actually more of a convergence on a solution. Line up the poser for a sequence of frames, as mangler did and use avg proportions for pass 1. Then adjust the body proportions for the sequence (automated in the software) and observe the fit. Adjust individual frames using the new proportions to achieve another best possible fit. Note the frames that still wouldn't quite fit and repeat the refinement process. This will likely take 3 or 4 passes to match up the poser exactly to Patty's images in the sequence.

However, I'm not sure how flexible the Poser/DAZ software is for this process. Since this process relies on many frames to converge on a solution, within tolerances, the word "average" was misused to describe it. But the objective is to achieve an exact fit (if possible) over all frames. Would you believe Patty was accurately measured without an exact fit? What if I could make the Steindorf skeleton fit just about as well?
 
So a poser is allowed to "not fit" and it still proves that it "fits" in the suit? Ok. At what point do you know it fits well enough for proof?

The point where anyone can determine with their own eyes that any imperfections in a perfect fit would not take whatever the actual skeleton is out of normal human range.

That is how I know that it is proof that an average human can fit Patty.
 
"Seeing with my own eyes" seems a little too subjective for my liking. What you see isn't always what you get. ;)

But I agree that LMS skeleton overlay is embarassing. But that sequence of frames wasn't used to build the model. It was a screwed up presentation graphic for LMS. It shot its own validity (if any) in the bigfoot.
 
"Seeing with my own eyes" seems a little too subjective for my liking. What you see isn't always what you get. ;)

Fair enough, but here is where what I'm talking about goes from the subjective view of seeing with my own eyes that any minute imperfections in the fit of the skeleton in mangler's animation does not exceed normal human range to some objective in terms of reliable measurements to prove it...

I can take any given frame of the overlay and you can say "There. Right there the leg doesn't fit perfectly." Then I can go ahead and subtract on screen however many milimeters from the leg bones would be required to get what we agree is an absolutely perfect fit. Then I can go ahead and instead of saying subjectively "that looks like a perfectly normal human skeleton to me," I could go and actually measure the bones themselves to determine that their ratios, percentages, etc are within human norms.

Doing that at any frame or angle with whatever imperfection in the fit you have an issue with can allow us to make sure what we see is what we get when saying "Yes, a normal human body can fit Patty."
 
:boggled:

Elbow span? Am I reading this right? Exactly what kind of anatomical measurement is this elbow span?

Sweaty, does mangler's animation depict an averagely proportioned human? Yes or no?
Well, that would be..."elbow span"..

BTW, Sweaty, is there some difficulty you have with the very simple question I asked you in bold there? You see, you gave me a cryptic answer on this elbow span thing of yours but you chose not to answer the second question at all. I've asked you this question a number of times and you don't seem to want to answer it. It's really easy, all you have to do is tap the keyboard either 2 or 3 times: y e s or n o. Easy breezy.
 
BTW, Sweaty, is there some difficulty you have with the very simple question I asked you in bold there? You see, you gave me a cryptic answer on this elbow span thing of yours but you chose not to answer the second question at all. I've asked you this question a number of times and you don't seem to want to answer it. It's really easy, all you have to do is tap the keyboard either 2 or 3 times: y e s or n o. Easy breezy.


The answer is.....I don't know. I haven't made enough measurements yet, to say whether it has 'average' proportions, or not.
 
kitakaze wrote:
Does this elbow span thing you're talking about vary? Yes or no.


Yup.....it changes.



Can you tell me how I can measure my elbow span?


Not right at the moment.

I'm still working on this 'elbow position/reach analysis', and I'll be posting something more complete about it...(than I've already posted), sometime in the near future....and it'll explain how I'm measuring it.



Also, why are you pulling out conceptual art and using the word "actual"?


I used the word 'actual' in relation to Patty's visible dimensions....not the dimensions of her internal skeleton.


Here's what I said again...

From some measurements I made last night, it looks as though Patty's actual elbow-to-elbow span, in some frames, is approx. 40-44".....while, at the same time, her elbows are still relatively low in the arm swing...a relatively long length down from the head.


The measurements were made from certain images of Patty, not of the VR skeleton.
 
So a poser is allowed to "not fit" and it still proves that it "fits" in the suit? Ok. At what point do you know it fits well enough for proof?

Stop trying to rape my mind with the idea that the poser skeleton doesn't fit Patty. That's your idea, not mine. Quit stating it as if it were a fact that I have to accept.

If you keep stating things as factual when they are actually just your opinion, I'm going to start thinking of you as Sweaty Junior.

Why would I need, or even look for, proof that the subject of the PGF could be a human in a suit?

I just need a ballpark idea. I have no intention of looking for proof and feel no need to look for proof. There's little burden on me and lots on Sweaty.

The PGF is quite low quality and low res anyway. If, for some strange reason, I should decide I need proof, it isn't going to be found in the PGF. Too poor and too many unknowns/variables.

I am unlikely to be looking for proof at all, let alone in any details in the PGF.
 
LT said

Why would I need, or even look for, proof that the subject of the PGF could be a human in a suit?

Come on, you don't understand the burden of proof? There is ALOT of pressure on you, Kitz, and others who claim Patty MUST be a suit
 
LT said



Come on, you don't understand the burden of proof? There is ALOT of pressure on you, Kitz, and others who claim Patty MUST be a suit

No, YOU don't understand the burden of proof. Try actually looking up the definition, for a change.
 
LT said



Come on, you don't understand the burden of proof? There is ALOT of pressure on you, Kitz, and others who claim Patty MUST be a suit

Mak, are you ever going to answer the question about whether it's the teacher or the student who must prove the dog ate the homework?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom