Bigfoot: The Patterson Gimlin Film - Part 3

Status
Not open for further replies.
Patterson's drawing of a female squatch should be considered irrelevant to the film subject. What if it was a male? Would people still be making a big deal out of nothing?
 
Apeman on BFF said:
Can anyone (based on experience) speak to the notion that the casts Patterson is holding by the tree are fresh/still wet based on color? Could they just be unclean and still gray from the sand?


Here are some casts that are presumably "dry", yet still have the gray color. One of them appears to be the Titmus cast of the famous Laverty print. Also included is Patterson with his two casts.
 

Attachments

  • Cast display small.jpg
    Cast display small.jpg
    122.2 KB · Views: 4
  • Green dark casts.jpg
    Green dark casts.jpg
    70.8 KB · Views: 4
  • Green dark cast.jpg
    Green dark cast.jpg
    75.1 KB · Views: 3
  • Krantz dark casts.jpg
    Krantz dark casts.jpg
    46.6 KB · Views: 4
As I'm sure everyone has noticed, the Patty vs Bob Heironimus has been set to moderated status, temporarily at least. That is unfortunate but understandable. There is an issue that recently surfaced in that thread that was in actuality appropriate for this thread and had precious little discussion. It has long been claimed by Bigfoot enthusiasts that Patty displays inhuman proportions and could not possible be a man in a suit. The arms are too long to be without extensions used, the shoulders too wide, the legs too short, etc.

A few days ago mangler posted an animation that demonstrated once and for all that this is simply not the case and that an average human can in fact fit Patty's proportions quite well. This is not proof that Patty was a man in a suit, but rather that she could have been a man in a suit; one that requires special technology. It was very welcome contribution for mangler and a victory for all the people that look at the film and see nothing inhuman about Patty's proportions. mangler indicated that he could only keep the animation up on his site for a couple days and offered it for download to anyone who requested it, which I did. The following is a series of stills from the animation that mangler posted...



It is a fact, Patty is not inhumanly proportioned.
 
This is not proof that Patty was a man in a suit, but rather that she could have been a man in a suit; one that requires special technology.

Wow. I skroodd up big. Why i not tipingz gud? tri ugen...

This is not proof that Patty was a man in a suit, but rather that she could have been a man in a suit; one that does not require special technology.

So solly.:boggled:
 
Technically speaking you are correct. What I was refering to is the direction the subject chooses as its path was not the opposite direction of Patterson and Gimlins approach. (which wouldve been directly away from Patterson and Gimlin) Instead the subject goes out into the open instead of into any sort of cover. I'm sure there are many diagrams out there as to which direction the two men were alleged to have been traveling upon their encounter in reference to the subjects path.


Actually, there aren't. The logging road approach to that timber pile in the creek (concealing Patty) is not properly documented. P&G describe it in various ways and give different versions of the "distance at first sight". You can even find a version that says Patty stood and looked at them for half a minute before beginning to walk away.

She does move away from their approach. She begins walking towards the forest (cover), but then makes a right turn and stays within the creek wash. This makes sense for a costumed person, but not a wild animal. A guy in a suit is going to look very fakey if he tries to negotiate forest and related natural litter while on film. As Patterson planned it, Patty would stay on relatively flat open ground with occasional and obvious obstacles. You do not want to have your actor fall or stumble. The costume can only be used for upright walking. Any other move (esp. bending) would even more obviously reveal that it is a guy in a suit.
 

Attachments

  • Titmus map.jpg
    Titmus map.jpg
    64.5 KB · Views: 7
As I'm sure everyone has noticed, the Patty vs Bob Heironimus has been set to moderated status, temporarily at least. That is unfortunate but understandable. There is an issue that recently surfaced in that thread that was in actuality appropriate for this thread and had precious little discussion. It has long been claimed by Bigfoot enthusiasts that Patty displays inhuman proportions and could not possible be a man in a suit. The arms are too long to be without extensions used, the shoulders too wide, the legs too short, etc.

A few days ago mangler posted an animation that demonstrated once and for all that this is simply not the case and that an average human can in fact fit Patty's proportions quite well. This is not proof that Patty was a man in a suit, but rather that she could have been a man in a suit; one that requires special technology. It was very welcome contribution for mangler and a victory for all the people that look at the film and see nothing inhuman about Patty's proportions. mangler indicated that he could only keep the animation up on his site for a couple days and offered it for download to anyone who requested it, which I did. The following is a series of stills from the animation that mangler posted...

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_82644ae1dfb929d64.gif[/qimg]

It is a fact, Patty is not inhumanly proportioned.

Well, if you want to get down to the nitty-gritty then answer me this:

Poser_fit.gif

  • What's with the feet? Or were the legs too long to fit?
  • Looks like it would be difficult to put a helmet and costume head on the poser's head and still fit Patty
  • Why is the skeleton's left humerus not in the poser's arm? Note the left elbow.
  • Why is the right shoulder so high and the left so low?
What is this supposed to prove again? The ENTIRE body must fit reasonably well, else it must be assumed that it couldn't be made to fit. Which would demonstrate (not prove) that the guy in the suit could have had anomalous proportions. But it certainly doesn't prove that the proportions were not inhuman. Only a perfect fit would prove your point. No excuses.
 
What's with the feet? Or were the legs too long to fit?
Looks like it would be difficult to put a helmet and costume head on the poser's head and still fit Patty
Why is the skeleton's left humerus not in the poser's arm? Note the left elbow.
Why is the right shoulder so high and the left so low?

I don't see a problem with the feet. Other than being the same. They look about where Patty's are if they were fully visible.

This is about an average human fitting in the suit, not BH. Only BH mentioned an old football helmet. However, I think an old leather football helmet is within the m.o.e. even though I discount BH's story of wearing the suit.

I don't see a problem with the placement.

Not sure what you mean? I'll just refer you to Mangler, who seems to have already answered.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=5235968&postcount=2436
 
Just a quick comparison for now.....highlighting the difference in upper-body widths...


ManglersMess1.jpg



From some measurements I made last night, it looks as though Patty's actual elbow-to-elbow span, in some frames, is approx. 40-44".....while, at the same time, her elbows are still relatively low in the arm swing...a relatively long length down from the head.


Try replicating that feat, yourself...;)
 
I don't see a problem with the feet. Other than being the same. They look about where Patty's are if they were fully visible.

This is about an average human fitting in the suit, not BH. Only BH mentioned an old football helmet. However, I think an old leather football helmet is within the m.o.e. even though I discount BH's story of wearing the suit.

I don't see a problem with the placement.

Not sure what you mean? I'll just refer you to Mangler, who seems to have already answered.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=5235968&postcount=2436
You really think that the insteps/ankles match up? Imagine if Sweaty was making that claim. Confirmation bias perhaps? ;)

It appears to me that BH is normally proportioned. The poser seems to fit his entire body quite well, legs included. This overlay must be EXACT to claim an average human (poser) fits. Anything less doesn't cut it. No excuses.
 
Yet the claims that Patty's arms/shoulders/legs are inhumanly possible keep getting trotted out as though they've been proven. (not you specifically... just sayin')

RayG
 
Just a quick comparison for now.....highlighting the difference in upper-body widths...


ManglersMess1.jpg



From some measurements I made last night, it looks as though Patty's actual elbow-to-elbow span, in some frames, is approx. 40-44".....while, at the same time, her elbows are still relatively low in the arm swing...a relatively long length down from the head.


Try replicating that feat, yourself...;)
Shouldn't be a problem, since you are using made up numbers..:rolleyes:


Nice cartoon skeleton on the right, though ..
 
Skeptical Greg wrote:
Shouldn't be a problem, since you are using made up numbers..:rolleyes:


In reality.....I'm using real numbers.

Grover Krantz calculated, using several frames of the film, Patty's upper-body/shoulder width as approx. 28"...based on a walking height of 6'0".

And.....there are more.......REAL numbers to come...:rolleyes:.......:rolleyes:....
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom