Moderated Bigfoot- Anybody Seen one?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Actually, just to clarify my position I have no idea what he smelled and don't want to say that it might've emanated from a bear.
I just feel that a physical source of odour cannot be ruled out as less likely than a hallucinated one.

I do have to ask for some clarification from someone who knows the area in question, the swamps I've been to here in Australia all smell bloody awful for the most part does the one in question have a similar sort of odour?

As I understand it the odour that occurs in swamps can be attributed to the rotting vegetation and animals, coupled with the moistness of the area.
The rotting process can lead to build ups of noxious smelling gases, especially if trapped under the usual layer of mud that is in a swamp.

If expelled this could create a small pocket of less oxygenated air, which could potentially have a foul smell (ie swamp gas).

The lack of oxygen in the area could bring on some of the symptoms that WGBH described (ie nausea etc) and if he was feeling faint enough it's also possible that he may have started to hallucinate things.

It could also explain why the rest of the group did not smell anything by the time they got back, it had dissipated.

Note:
I'm not claiming this is what happened, nor that it's even likely just that it might be another possible explanation.

WGBH,
(if you've addressed this I missed it) Have you given any serious thought to Archangel's ideas? When you visit the swamp I sure would ask about Archangel's questions. This is an avenue that I should think you wouldn't consider insulting to you: " I am either a daydreamer,a hallucinator or a nut case, a liar, ..." Maybe you'll find someone in the know there who could corroborate what Archangel is proposing and it could clear it all up for you.
Don't just get your info from the net, talk to someone who knows the place.
Who knows what you might find out?


btw Kitakaze, I understand what you are saying about "vast" and "remote" But "McPark" is being a little rough on Salt Fork. It really is a nice place, many like it and it can feel remote for some of us when compared to the surrounding megalopolis that is ClevelandColumbusCincinnatiPittsburgh. Hey, we got what we got.:)

ap
 
Last edited:
P.S. WGBH, You don't have to mention bf at all to whomever you talk to. Just describe your symptoms in the stand and mention Archangel's points. It could prove cathartic.
ap
 
b41628bd.jpg
 
P.S. WGBH, You don't have to mention bf at all to whomever you talk to. Just describe your symptoms in the stand and mention Archangel's points. It could prove cathartic.

Right, never mention the B- word when talking to people. This I am well aware of.


btw Kitakaze, I understand what you are saying about "vast" and "remote" But "McPark" is being a little rough on Salt Fork. It really is a nice place, many like it and it can feel remote for some of us when compared to the surrounding megalopolis that is ClevelandColumbusCincinnatiPittsburgh. Hey, we got what we got.

ap

Right, its not the PNW, but it is a nice state park with TONS of wildlife.
 
Right, its not the PNW, but it is a nice state park with TONS of wildlife.

Yes, the Salt Fork State Park and Wildlife Area has...


Major Wildlife Game Species
Life Histories
Beaver


Bobwhite Quail

Coyote

Deer

Fox Squirrel

Gray Fox

Gray Squirrel

Grouse

Mink

Mourning Dove

Muskrat

Opossum

Pheasant

Rabbit

Raccoon

Red Fox

River Otter

Turkey

Woodchuck

Woodcock

Major Waterfowl Species Life Histories
Black Duck


Blue-winged Teal

Canada Goose

Canvasback

Green-winged Teal

Mallard

Wood Duck


Common
Non-game Birds
American Kestrel


Bald Eagle

Great Blue Heron

Northern Harrier

Osprey

Red-tailed Hawk

Turkey Vulture


Major Fish Game Species Life Histories
Black Crappie


Bluegill

Bullhead

Channel Catfish

Common Carp

Flathead Catfish

Green Sunfish

Hybrid Striped Bass

Largemouth Bass

Longear Sunfish

Muskellunge

Northern Pike

Pumpkinseed Sunfish

Rainbow Trout

Redear Sunfish

Saugeye

Smallmouth Bass

Walleye

White Bass

White Crappie

Yellow Perch

Salt Fork Wildlife Area

http://www.dnr.state.oh.us/Portals/9/Images/hunting/Wildlife Area Maps/pub155.gif

You'll see that first link features species histories for all the game species including track images, sounds, and even some nice wild game recipes. I don't know about you but the Mommy's Rabbit Nuggets, Squirrel Pot Pie, and Crunchy Doves look delish! :drool::forks:

What that list does not include is a species of massive 9ft bipedal wood apes. Forget the Bigfoots, where's the bears? If a population of bears with their ultra-sensitive nose, digging paws with claws, sharp teeth and hearing can not maintain some breeding numbers in the 70 km² of the park, why should I believe that a big loping wood ape can do it for at least 40 years and not make it on the game list? The park doesn't have a problem with Bigfoots, it has a problem with silly Bigfooters.
 
Last edited:
.
What that list does not include is a species of massive 9ft bipedal wood apes. Forget the Bigfoots, where's the bears? If a population of bears with their ultra-sensitive nose, digging paws with claws, sharp teeth and hearing can not maintain some breeding numbers in the 70 km² of the park, why should I believe that a big loping wood ape can do it for at least 40 years and not make it on the game list? The park doesn't have a problem with Bigfoots, it has a problem with silly Bigfooters.

Actually the park pimps it Bigfoot sightings.

Silly Bigfooters rule! Skeptics drool.

PS. You did a awesome job on that list!
 
Last edited:
Yes, the Salt Fork State Park and Wildlife Area has...


Major Wildlife Game Species
Life Histories
Beaver


Bobwhite Quail

Coyote

Deer

Fox Squirrel

Gray Fox

Gray Squirrel

Grouse

Mink

Mourning Dove

Muskrat

Opossum

Pheasant

Rabbit

Raccoon

Red Fox

River Otter

Turkey

Woodchuck

Woodcock

Major Waterfowl Species Life Histories
Black Duck


Blue-winged Teal

Canada Goose

Canvasback

Green-winged Teal

Mallard

Wood Duck


Common
Non-game Birds
American Kestrel


Bald Eagle

Great Blue Heron

Northern Harrier

Osprey

Red-tailed Hawk

Turkey Vulture


Major Fish Game Species Life Histories
Black Crappie


Bluegill

Bullhead

Channel Catfish

Common Carp

Flathead Catfish

Green Sunfish

Hybrid Striped Bass

Largemouth Bass

Longear Sunfish

Muskellunge

Northern Pike

Pumpkinseed Sunfish

Rainbow Trout

Redear Sunfish

Saugeye

Smallmouth Bass

Walleye

White Bass

White Crappie

Yellow Perch

Salt Fork Wildlife Area

http://www.dnr.state.oh.us/Portals/9/Images/hunting/Wildlife Area Maps/pub155.gif

You'll see that first link features species histories for all the game species including track images, sounds, and even some nice wild game recipes. I don't know about you but the Mommy's Rabbit Nuggets, Squirrel Pot Pie, and Crunchy Doves look delish! :drool::forks:

What that list does not include is a species of massive 9ft bipedal wood apes. Forget the Bigfoots, where's the bears? If a population of bears with their ultra-sensitive nose, digging paws with claws, sharp teeth and hearing can not maintain some breeding numbers in the 70 km² of the park, why should I believe that a big loping wood ape can do it for at least 40 years and not make it on the game list? The park doesn't have a problem with Bigfoots, it has a problem with silly Bigfooters.

as a counter argument, a typical NW CT state forest, the stuf there; fisher cats, black bears, moose, deer, coyete, bobcat

hat is there and not generally known: mountain lion and timber wolves, bodies of later taken by the CT dep....

official records never tell the whole story, there are feral llamas as well, they escape occasionally from local farms
 
as a counter argument, a typical NW CT state forest, the stuf there; fisher cats, black bears, moose, deer, coyete, bobcat

hat is there and not generally known: mountain lion and timber wolves, bodies of later taken by the CT dep....

official records never tell the whole story, there are feral llamas as well, they escape occasionally from local farms

Mike, do you mean there have been cougar and wolf bodies found by wildlife officials in CT?

I know there was a hoaxed cougar sighting.

http://connecticuthuntingtoday.com/...nnecticut-cougar-sighting-revealed-as-a-hoax/

http://berealct.wordpress.com/2008/03/08/cry-wolf-in-connecticut-lately-you-may-be-right/
 
Mike, do you mean there have been cougar and wolf bodies found by wildlife officials in CT?

I know there was a hoaxed cougar sighting.

http://connecticuthuntingtoday.com/...nnecticut-cougar-sighting-revealed-as-a-hoax/

http://berealct.wordpress.com/2008/03/08/cry-wolf-in-connecticut-lately-you-may-be-right/

cougars unconfirmed, wolves raiding a sheep farm, two shot, two bodies confirmed. This is information I came by unofficially, I dont if the DEP would officially admit it, I would hope so.
 
Actually the park pimps it Bigfoot sightings.

I was told it is one of the few state parks where the rangers will talk about the bigfoot sightings there, seen by staff and visitors.

Though rare they are increasing:
In 1999, there was a sighting of a bear bounding across the Cambridge (10 miles from Salt Fork) Country Club. In the same year, a bear was killed by a vehicle on U.S. Route 52 in Scioto County.--from Wildlife Haven of Crestline Ohio.
ap
 
cougars unconfirmed, wolves raiding a sheep farm, two shot, two bodies confirmed. This is information I came by unofficially, I dont if the DEP would officially admit it, I would hope so.

So nothing solid regarding cougars (though there are bobcats which people could mistake for cougars). As for the wolves, how reliable is that information you have regarding the shot dead animals? If confirmed that would be an example of an extirpated species returning to an area it once inhabited. I think you might agree this is a very far cry from massive undiscovered wood apes loping about Salt Fork State Park tossing rocks over by where the pavilion is, would you not?
 
1) Rival association? LOL! Yeah, we do water balloon fights and panty raids during our park sleepovers.....jeez.

2) Everywhere we research is a known target for Bigfoot hoaxers.

3) The supposed print was found in a deep ravine at least a half mile from any known trail. No report will be done on it if it turns out to be from a known animal or a hoax.

Sasquatch Watch Radio: Guests are the ABS Expedition Team. ABS Salt Fork State Park Expedition - April 16th-18th, 2009 (Following time codes in pink refer to this show)

1) I don't understand your sarcasm. By your own group's admission there were other Bigfoot organizations active in the area prior to and during the time you were there (27:30). Billy Willard mentioned he believes MonsterQuest Ohio Grass Man episode has greatly increased the number of Bigfoot enthusiasts in the area and that he was amazed the number of other footers that were in the area even on a Thursday night in the park (50:00). Member Toby Tollman noted the situation was particularly bad with other Bigfoot groups in the area on Friday and Saturday. He noted that Friday night alone while gearing up in the parking lot that 4 or 5 other Bigfoot researchers had stopped there. He goes on to say that it got so bad that proper radio communication was not possible because of other Bigfoot searchers messing around on the expedition's radio channel (51:20) and that he later saw 4 flashlights in the area he was researching.

You sarcastically brush off the idea of rival Bigfoot groups and yet Toby noted how every Bigfoot searcher from another group out there had something bad to say about Don Keating of the Eastern Ohio Bigfoot Investigation Center who briefly visited your expedition and was the organizer of the Ohio Bigfoot conference happening May 1st-3rd in Salt Fork only two weeks after your expedition.

What kind of Bigfoot gong show was going on out there? You were in the handicapped picnic area which was said to have multiple encounters and said to be the place where most Bigfoot researchers go (30:20) that was chosen because Eric Altman had a sighting in area (45:07). This is the same freakout sighting that Eric Altman speaks about here where he's right in the exact area of the sighting pointing to the bush at 7:40 the Bigfoot stood behind. Earlier in response to that video you said this:

WGBH said:
Yes they are talking to Bigfoot enthusiasts. It is a Bigfoot conference. What they are discussing had nothing to do with the ABS. The encounter they are discussing happened in October 2008 and neither of them are ABS members. The crowd is very interested because that is what they come there for, to hear Bigfoot encounter stories. As silly as that may seem to scoftics.

What you don't see is the crowd of Bigfoot researchers standing waaay in the rear with bored looks on their faces. What you do not see is that someone had placed a hoaxed Bigfoot print in a spot during the tour that it would be found. You do not see Don Keating pointing it out and pointing out why the print is fake to all of those people. When I told my encounter story I was shocked by the reaction. I always expect laughs and ridicule. What I expect is what I received in that article from New Zealand.

Do not use a Bigfoot conference as a example of what goes on in Bigfoot research. Promoting a DVD and conference and giving a crowd what they came there for is not the same thing.

You just before said the park pimps the idea they have Bigfoot sightings to you guys. Did it ever occur to you that park staff might be doing some of the hoaxing? A little funny business can go a long way amongst Bigfoot enthusiasts and they stand to greatly profit from it with the big annual conference and flood of paying footers.

2) A group of Bigfoot hoaxers was known to be active in the area. A giant stick structure was found 75 yards from the picnic area that measured 12 ft high by 18 ft across, required multiple people to create, and literally had bark squareknots used in its construction (25:50). Multiple similar structures were seen around the park 28:50. Now in 2006 one of your fellow ABS expedition members, Joedy Cook (MonsterQuest Ohio Grassman episode - from 4:20), found a baboon skull in a roost area of the park where he had seen buzzards featured by MQ. The skull was perfectly clean and fleshless and identified as being a baboon by Esteban Sarmiento. How interesting. A nice perfect baboon skull left out in the open in a place where Bigfoot enthusiasts poke about. How easy to hoax is that?

3) At least half a mile from any known trail? What happened to in your group's own words at least 300 feet from the trail (16:40)? The sounds like a bit of exaggeration. The apparent track was 6 inches long (20:10) with only two clear digits and was found by Joedy Cook in a creek area after a noise was heard in that general direction. 20 feet away from where that imprint was found up on a bank Joedy Cook found what was the second imprint which in your group's words was what the group believed to be probably a knuckle print (17:40) which was said to be in very good condition with clear digits.

BTW, Melissa said that there would be a full report with pictures released to the general public (33:50). I feel confident that no such report will be released to the general public.

This is nothing but a weak attempt by you to discredit the ABS, but I will play along. The park is closed to the general public at dark. Yes there are
Bigfoot researchers running around sometimes, but the Park Rangers will chase you back to the lodge or out of the park if you act stupid or they don't know you. You are acting like Salt Fork is our club house. THe ABS has had ONE outing. We are a brand new Organization. We have another outing planned this summer and it's not at Salt Fork.

I am not seeking to discredit the ABS. I am laying out the events by your group's own words and setting them against the realities of the area. Here are the park's hours:

SFSP FAQ said:
Q. What are the park hours?
A.
Day use areas are open from 6 a.m. to 11:00 p.m. with the exception of John Bryan, Headlands Beach, Nelson Kennedy Ledges, Crane Creek, and Hocking Hills. The hours for the parks noted are one half-hour before sunrise to one half-hour after sunset. Swimming areas are open from daylight to dusk, where swimming is available. Campgrounds are open 24 hours daily, with visiting hours from 6 a.m. to 10 p.m.

http://www.dnr.state.oh.us/parks/faq/tabid/84/Default.aspx

Billy Willard states that he had searched for Bigfoot in the park before with Eric Altman and the Pennsylvania Bigfoot Society (49:30). He also says that he ran into fellow Bigfoot enthusiasts from other groups that he had been in the field with (Blue Tracker, Phil Brocko (SP), Nancy from West Virginia who was poking about shining her flashlight on ABS people asking who they were) (51:45). The fact is that in this video from 1:30 we see Treba and Terry Jahn (they were featured witnesses in the Ohio Grassman episode seen here from 7:00) along with Don Keating discussing how they are in the park every weekend till 3 or 4 am. The MQ clip says that when they had their sighting it was not until just after midnight when a ranger had come to visit them asking them when they were going to leave.

I think I've made my point overwhelmingly clear. By the facts as your own group acknowledged, SFSP was a pretty ridiculous place to have an expedition. It seems like it was a location influenced most of all by convenience.

No, that is a different picnic area, not the handicapped one. But that area shown has had encounters.

Are you sure? Because in that video it starts out with Don Keating motioning towards the nearby pavilion and later in the video Eric Altman is recounting his sighting tale and is definitely in the area where you guys were as is made clear by Billy Willard's own words speaking to Eric where he acknowledges that they went to that handicapped area due to Eric's sighting there (45:07). If you look closely it seems to be the same area as the beginning of the video and Don Keating can barely be made out standing off-frame to the side of Eric and Mike. I don't think I was mistaken.

Why don't you just use the Google map or one of the other two I posted and indicate where the handicapped picnic area you were in? You just said the ABS won't return there so it's not like it affects your report and you admit that there already is hoaxing in the area.

Here, I'll even give you a SFSP camprground map to make it even easier:

http://www.dnr.state.oh.us/Portals/2/parkmaps/saltforkcampmap.pdf

Of course its not the PNW or Vancouver Island, but VERY few places are! You are trying to paint a picture of Salt Fork not being a remote wilderness and it is.

Yes, VI is one of those very special places in the world. I'm not painting SFSP as something it's not. It may be Ohio's biggest park but it's still relatively quite wee. If you think it's remote, just take the google map I linked and zoom around so you can see the way the land actually looks. It may feel remote but it's not remote. Most importantly is ludicrous to think that a species of 9 ft wood ape could slink around the park and get the many thousands of calories it needs in a day without ever being discovered by science. Really, really silly.

You love trolling you tube for silly video.

Yes. Yes, I do. I love checking out silly Bigfoot enthusiast videos on youtube because they love putting them up. Youtube killed Bigfoot, don't you know? Here's some great silly video - cop talks to West Virginia footers:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IDIAe-VWl-0

I love that lady's voice starting at 00:50. Recognize anybody?

I never made claims to be unique. I am addressing my demons.

Thanks for being concerned.

See, Im trying to get some kind of answer from you about when you will...

a) Seek counselling.

And...

b) Get in touch with the appropriate wildlife officials to get some concrete answers.
 
WGBH,
You said your friends spend most of their time debunking. Obviously they have debunked everything since they have not offered anything, so when do you all say when?

Why don’t researchers spend two weeks- no tents, no provisions- in the woods linked arm in arm two-by-two or three-by-three wearing three-foot hats, and see how that works and what they leave behind? I am not being a smart a**. That may prove to be an eye-opening evidential expedition. Stop trying to prove to the world bf exists. Prove it to yourselves using what you do “know” about bf.

Stop the tunnel vision and look at the really BIG picture that is bf when out in the woods or desert or neighborhood or anywhere else its been seen.

Bf does not leave any “normal” animal evidence, it leaves something “else” and we are going to find that “else”. Does that really make sense to you?

The next time you walk through the woods do so with an open mind not just of what you think is, but what quite obviously isn‘t.

ap
 
Last edited:
WGBH,
(if you've addressed this I missed it) Have you given any serious thought to Archangel's ideas? When you visit the swamp I sure would ask about Archangel's questions. This is an avenue that I should think you wouldn't consider insulting to you: " I am either a daydreamer,a hallucinator or a nut case, a liar, ..." Maybe you'll find someone in the know there who could corroborate what Archangel is proposing and it could clear it all up for you.
Don't just get your info from the net, talk to someone who knows the place.
Who knows what you might find out?

Peace, I agree that Angel's idea bears investigations as well. The nausea mentioned comes to mind first.


btw Kitakaze, I understand what you are saying about "vast" and "remote" But "McPark" is being a little rough on Salt Fork. It really is a nice place, many like it and it can feel remote for some of us when compared to the surrounding megalopolis that is ClevelandColumbusCincinnatiPittsburgh. Hey, we got what we got.:)

ap

I think going between Tokyo and Vancouver Island is about as extreme as one can get going from different ends of the spectrum. Peeing behind a bush feels remote when you live in Tokyo. I'm sure if you live in Cincinnati or there abouts and have been having one too many bouts of road rage lately, Salt Fork is a nice place to get away to if you get that urge to ventilate a coyote, teach the kids a fun new activity for Easter, do some 4x4in', or go be a hermit for a while. I just think it might be about one of the silliest places to go look for 9 ft monkey men. That's even without all the Bigfooters and hoaxers on the loose there.

But, hey... that's just me.
 
I think going between Tokyo and Vancouver Island is about as extreme as one can get going from different ends of the spectrum. Peeing behind a bush feels remote when you live in Tokyo. I'm sure if you live in Cincinnati or there abouts and have been having one too many bouts of road rage lately, Salt Fork is a nice place to get away to if you get that urge to I just think it might be about one of the silliest places to go look for 9 ft monkey men. That's even without all the Bigfooters and hoaxers on the loose there.

But, hey... that's just me.

I was not disagreeing with you. I was just defending Salt Fork as not deserving the "McPark" moniker (at least to us city folks), that's all.
No harm no foul.
ap
 
I was told it is one of the few state parks where the rangers will talk about the bigfoot sightings there, seen by staff and visitors.

Though rare they are increasing:
In 1999, there was a sighting of a bear bounding across the Cambridge (10 miles from Salt Fork) Country Club. In the same year, a bear was killed by a vehicle on U.S. Route 52 in Scioto County.--from Wildlife Haven of Crestline Ohio.
ap

I was born and raised in Scioto County Ohio on a large farm in a very rural area near the Shawnee State Forest and do not recall any sightings. All of us boys roamed the woods both hunting and just for fun; in the winter with the snow on a favorite game was to let someone have a 10 minute head start and then track him. We never saw BF tracks.
 
WGBH,
You said your friends spend most of their time debunking. Obviously they have debunked everything since they have not offered anything, so when do you all say when?

We are not quitters.

Why don’t researchers spend two weeks- no tents, no provisions- in the woods linked arm in arm two-by-two or three-by-three wearing three-foot hats, and see how that works and what they leave behind? I am not being a smart a**. That may prove to be an eye-opening evidential expedition. Stop trying to prove to the world bf exists. Prove it to yourselves using what you do “know” about bf.

Why does it matter to you so much what we do? I don't care what you do in your spare time.


Stop the tunnel vision and look at the really BIG picture that is bf when out in the woods or desert or neighborhood or anywhere else its been seen.

Bf does not leave any “normal” animal evidence, it leaves something “else” and we are going to find that “else”. Does that really make sense to you?

I am not into paranormal Bigfoot. :D

The next time you walk through the woods do so with an open mind not just of what you think is, but what quite obviously isn‘t.

ap


This is what I do.
 
[

1) I don't understand your sarcasm. By your own group's admission there were other Bigfoot organizations active in the area prior to and during the time you were there (27:30). Billy Willard mentioned he believes MonsterQuest Ohio Grass Man episode has greatly increased the number of Bigfoot enthusiasts in the area and that he was amazed the number of other footers that were in the area even on a Thursday night in the park (50:00). Member Toby Tollman noted the situation was particularly bad with other Bigfoot groups in the area on Friday and Saturday. He noted that Friday night alone while gearing up in the parking lot that 4 or 5 other Bigfoot researchers had stopped there. He goes on to say that it got so bad that proper radio communication was not possible because of other Bigfoot searchers messing around on the expedition's radio channel (51:20) and that he later saw 4 flashlights in the area he was researching.

You understand my sarcasm all to well. You are a master of it. The radio problems are not bad if you just change the channel on the radio. :D The date for the ABS expedition in Mid April was set for over six months. Don Keating's conference was originally scheduled on May 16. Because they scheduled the Yakima Round-up that same day, Don unfortunately had to move his conference up to May 2. This moved the ABS expedition closer to conference time and thus is a reason for there being so many yahoos in the woods doing their pre-conference hoaxing. Also, there was a BFRO pay per camp expedition that weekend in near-by Beaver Creek. Yes it sucked that there were too many people around.

Right? It was unfortunately crowded. The thing is you are trying to make it seem like there were 100 people running around the area when there were 20.But yes even that many were too much. I am used to just going out with 2 or 3 people. What can we do? We are there we may as well try.

You sarcastically brush off the idea of rival Bigfoot groups and yet Toby noted how every Bigfoot searcher from another group out there had something bad to say about Don Keating of the Eastern Ohio Bigfoot Investigation Center who briefly visited your expedition and was the organizer of the Ohio Bigfoot conference happening May 1st-3rd in Salt Fork only two weeks after your expedition.

Right? Don is a gruff old man, lots of people don't like that. The ABS has no problem with and work with Don.

What kind of Bigfoot gong show was going on out there? You were in the handicapped picnic area which was said to have multiple encounters and said to be the place where most Bigfoot researchers go (30:20) that was chosen because Eric Altman had a sighting in area (45:07). This is the same freakout sighting that Eric Altman speaks about here where he's right in the exact area of the sighting pointing to the bush at 7:40 the Bigfoot stood behind. Earlier in response to that video you said this:

Bigfoot gong show:D...and I am the one being sarcastic? That is funny though.

We did plenty of good things that weekend. There were training seminars for the new researchers in the group. There were great hikes in a beautiful park.

Eric did not freak out, the person he was with did. Eric still does not say that he saw anything except a large shadowy figure. He does not say it was a Bigfoot


You just before said the park pimps the idea they have Bigfoot sightings to you guys. Did it ever occur to you that park staff might be doing some of the hoaxing? A little funny business can go a long way amongst Bigfoot enthusiasts and they stand to greatly profit from it with the big annual conference and flood of paying footers.

Of course they promote the conference to bring in guests.



2) A group of Bigfoot hoaxers was known to be active in the area. A giant stick structure was found 75 yards from the picnic area that measured 12 ft high by 18 ft across, required multiple people to create, and literally had bark squareknots used in its construction (25:50). Multiple similar structures were seen around the park 28:50. Now in 2006 one of your fellow ABS expedition members, Joedy Cook (MonsterQuest Ohio Grassman episode - from 4:20), found a baboon skull in a roost area of the park where he had seen buzzards featured by MQ. The skull was perfectly clean and fleshless and identified as being a baboon by Esteban Sarmiento. How interesting. A nice perfect baboon skull left out in the open in a place where Bigfoot enthusiasts poke about. How easy to hoax is that?


If the park staff is doing the hoaxing what can we do about that? Hoaxing is hoaxing, it is a hurdle we always deal with no matter where you research. It is easily identified in most cases. The yahoos who fall for some of the easily spotted hoaxes deserve it. The structure was hilarious it even had square knots used to tie it together. We spent half the conference weekend explaining to casual Bigfoot enthusiasts who did not know better that it was a hoax.I remember some one mentioning it during the conference presentations to NOT present anything found that weekend as evidence.

3) At least half a mile from any known trail? What happened to in your group's own words at least 300 feet from the trail (16:40)? The sounds like a bit of exaggeration. The apparent track was 6 inches long (20:10) with only two clear digits and was found by Joedy Cook in a creek area after a noise was heard in that general direction. 20 feet away from where that imprint was found up on a bank Joedy Cook found what was the second imprint which in your group's words was what the group believed to be probably a knuckle print (17:40) which was said to be in very good condition with clear digits.

There are hiking trails, game trails and then there are marked trails that are used by the park guests. The print was found at least a half mile or even more off the marked trails used by the park guests. It was not an exaggeration. When Billy says the print was 300 feet off trail, he meant a game trail.

I was not present in the area when the tracks were found, so I can't comment on what happened. I was hiking in a different area. I arrived in the area after getting a call on my radio they were already casting them.


BTW, Melissa said that there would be a full report with pictures released to the general public (33:50). I feel confident that no such report will be released to the general public.

We shall see.

I am not seeking to discredit the ABS. I am laying out the events by your group's own words and setting them against the realities of the area. Here are the park's hours:

Yes you are seeking to discredit the ABS, stop fibbing. If you are out in that park ANYWHERE after dark the Rangers will stop you, ask you what you are doing. Sometimes they will ask you to return to the lodge, your camp site or LEAVE the park. I have gotten stopped several times when driving to a area. We tell them we are with Don and they leave us alone.




http://www.dnr.state.oh.us/parks/faq/tabid/84/Default.aspx

Billy Willard states that he had searched for Bigfoot in the park before with Eric Altman and the Pennsylvania Bigfoot Society (49:30). He also says that he ran into fellow Bigfoot enthusiasts from other groups that he had been in the field with (Blue Tracker, Phil Brocko (SP), Nancy from West Virginia who was poking about shining her flashlight on ABS people asking who they were) (51:45). The fact is that in this video from 1:30 we see Treba and Terry Jahn (they were featured witnesses in the Ohio Grassman episode seen here from 7:00) along with Don Keating discussing how they are in the park every weekend till 3 or 4 am. The MQ clip says that when they had their sighting it was not until just after midnight when a ranger had come to visit them asking them when they were going to leave.

The people you mentioned came out there to say hi to all of us because they are our friends. After saying goodbye they went to another area of the park or left. Sometimes the Rangers do not see you sometimes they do. It is a large park.Terry and Treba were in the actual picnic area sitting at a bonfire when their encounter happened. A Ranger will not ask you to leave if you are just sitting around a fire and you are a frequent park visitor.


I think I've made my point overwhelmingly clear. By the facts as your own group acknowledged, SFSP was a pretty ridiculous place to have an expedition. It seems like it was a location influenced most of all by convenience.

That depends on what you expect to get from it. We got to meet friends and teach new researchers techniques and experience a great wildlife area. It is a good place to research when there are not too many people around. This is just a negative spin from a skeptic.


Are you sure? Because in that video it starts out with Don Keating motioning towards the nearby pavilion and later in the video Eric Altman is recounting his sighting tale and is definitely in the area where you guys were as is made clear by Billy Willard's own words speaking to Eric where he acknowledges that they went to that handicapped area due to Eric's sighting there (45:07). If you look closely it seems to be the same area as the beginning of the video and Don Keating can barely be made out standing off-frame to the side of Eric and Mike. I don't think I was mistaken.

Yes, I was mistaken. That is the handicapped area. I was just able to watch the video. I cannot watch you tube videos at work. I thought you were talking about the video with Don standing on the picnic table.

The one where he is standing on the picnic table is the area where Terry and Treba had their encounter.


Why don't you just use the Google map or one of the other two I posted and indicate where the handicapped picnic area you were in? You just said the ABS won't return there so it's not like it affects your report and you admit that there already is hoaxing in the area.

You will need to get someone more experienced at map reading to point out the area to you. I can only get there myself by driving. Remember I am inexperienced in the woods


Here, I'll even give you a SFSP camprground map to make it even easier:

http://www.dnr.state.oh.us/Portals/2/parkmaps/saltforkcampmap.pdf



Yes, VI is one of those very special places in the world. I'm not painting SFSP as something it's not. It may be Ohio's biggest park but it's still relatively quite wee. If you think it's remote, just take the google map I linked and zoom around so you can see the way the land actually looks. It may feel remote but it's not remote. Most importantly is ludicrous to think that a species of 9 ft wood ape could slink around the park and get the many thousands of calories it needs in a day without ever being discovered by science. Really, really silly.

That is just your opinion.



Yes. Yes, I do. I love checking out silly Bigfoot enthusiast videos on youtube because they love putting them up. Youtube killed Bigfoot, don't you know? Here's some great silly video - cop talks to West Virginia footers:

Yes I can see that you love watching silly you tube Bigfoot videos. I don't.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IDIAe-VWl-0

I love that lady's voice starting at 00:50. Recognize anybody?



See, Im trying to get some kind of answer from you about when you will...

a) Seek counselling.

And...

b) Get in touch with the appropriate wildlife officials to get some concrete answers.

When and if I seek counseling is my private business. I will let you know of course. If you mean when I will talk to Dismal Swamp officials, whenever I get the chance.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top Bottom