Badlyshavedmonkey equation is dissproved!

Dr. MAS said:
We claim homeopathic potencies available in the market for treatment purpose have starting material otherthan the solvent. Avogadros law is not applicable in the right way as you are applying on the potencies which are available in the shops for sale.
Click to expand...
So, if you do claim that homoeopathic remedies are different from stock solvent, then could you please tell us the influence that manufacturing method has on this? If a remedy is produced with the Hahnemannian method with new glasses for every step and as much care as possilbe to avoid contamination, will that remedy not be as effective as remedies produced with the Korsakov method, with lots of contaminants?
 
steenkh said:
So, if you do claim that homoeopathic remedies are different from stock solvent
Click to expand...
Actually, he has stated quite clearly that he doesn't claim this: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=1404943#post1404943
Originally Posted by Dr. MAS:
Originally Posted by Mojo:
For the JREF challenge, you have to prove that there is a difference between a homoeopathic preparation of over, say, 13c and the stock solvent used in its preparation.

...
Click to expand...
We will only prove that thing which we claim.

we do not claim what you have written in your post.
Click to expand...
 
Mojo, if he does not claim that there is any difference between the remedy and the stock solvent, it must include the healing effect, right? So ... the stock solvent cures just as well as the remedy!

MAS, do you agree?
 
steenkh said:
Mojo, if he does not claim that there is any difference between the remedy and the stock solvent, it must include the healing effect, right?
Click to expand...
Yes, that's what I thought. At least, that's what he seems to be claiming at the moment. He also, in the same post, indicated that he doesn't claim that homoeopathy actually works.
 
juninho said:
Famous? Are you sure?

A quick google suggests otherwise. All the hits either point to this forum or the nch forum. Me thinks you are trolling yet again.
Click to expand...

Hint: unless you know what "A" is stand for, google will not give you anything. Ask to administrator he knows everything. :p
 
Dr. A Sheikh said:
Hint: unless you know what "A" is stand for, google will not give you anything. Ask to administrator he knows everything. :p
Click to expand...

Ok then, I was only taking Dr MAS's (your) word for it that you post here under your real name.

Mind you, there is a Dr Sheikh homeopath in Pakistan here

I can understand now, no wonder you are disinclined to think critically about anything that crosses your path, you could end up on death row. Not only that, he is a homeopath AND called Dr Sheikh as well. If you ever emigrate perhaps you can "come clean" about what you really believe. My thoughts are with you brother.

BTW: I like the bit about "Mubarik Ahmad, friend of Dr. Sheikh, reports that he visited Dr. Sheikh in his death row cell on December 2, 2002. He reports that Dr. Sheikh is having problems with his eyes and teeth due to his diabetes. Mr. Ahmad told Dr. Sheikh about his visit to the PHR office in September." Couldn't he have smuggled in some water, er sorry, homeopathic remedies to help him with his condition?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Back
Top Bottom