SpuriaMaxima
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Mar 2, 2009
- Messages
- 25,819
Well, I didn't want to turn it into a history lesson again, but yes, you are correct.
Opportunity cost is a thing.The 15" with supercharges and improved shells still packed a big hit and the Vanguard range was 37,870 yards at 30°, with supercharges.
But, RN doctrine was to close the range as quickly as possible and fight fairly close in where the guns would pierce any main belt in service.
The KGV class and Vanguard (which was a modified Lion class hull) had a main belt thickness capable of stopping a 16" shell, they had the best armour layout and steel quality of any battleship in service.
Vanguard was however a compromise, a way of getting one more fast, modern battleship in service quickly. The Lions were cancelled because their new 16" guns wouldn't have been available until in to 1944. It was also realised with the Italians dropping out of the war there wouldn't be any need for six new ships.
Resources were allocated to other things.
For example 48 twin 5.25 or 4.5 inch dual purpose turrets that would have been the secondary armament would outfit a good number of cruisers and destroyers.



Yes, but mankind has been fighitng wars for a long as there has been mankind; some anthropoligist think war was one of Mankind's first organized activties.War in general is a bad idea.
Considering we lost our doodoo after 9-11, and invaded two countries, one with justification, and the other not so much, and have conducted military operation in the Philippines, Somalia, Sudan, Kenya, Nigeria, and Syria in the name of counter-terrorism because we didn't have a state target, a direct attack on CONUS by Iran would be ill-advised.So USA can bomb Iran but not the other way round?
Attacking targets in the USA is exactly what I would be trying to do in their place.
The greatest threat to the United States Navy is the United States Navy. We are almost 40 years behind where we could be, technologically speaking. They hate the Zumwalts not because they went all in on a railgun that didn't exist yet, and turned out to be infeasible, but mostly because it looks funny. The key to survival for any surface vessel is not being found. If you can't see it, you can't hit it, and the Zumwalt has a small RCS which means it's hard to find, harder to get a missile lock on, and can show up within range an enemy target without compromise until it unloads its weapons.Or Trump's battleship for that matter. I mean, I'm ok with calling the ship with the biggest guns a battleship, but... if everyone gave up on building battleships with 12" of belt armour because of missiles, what makes him think that his 6 inches is so great?
Bollocks nuclearConsidering we lost our doodoo after 9-11, and invaded two countries, one with justification, and the other not so much, and have conducted military operation in the Philippines, Somalia, Sudan, Kenya, Nigeria, and Syria in the name of counter-terrorism because we didn't have a state target, a direct attack on CONUS by Iran would be ill-advised.
We'd go nuclear, which is what Iran wants us to do. They're weird that way.
At this point, we are that unhinged.Bollocks nuclear![]()