Bad ideas in war

The 15" with supercharges and improved shells still packed a big hit and the Vanguard range was 37,870 yards at 30°, with supercharges.
But, RN doctrine was to close the range as quickly as possible and fight fairly close in where the guns would pierce any main belt in service.
The KGV class and Vanguard (which was a modified Lion class hull) had a main belt thickness capable of stopping a 16" shell, they had the best armour layout and steel quality of any battleship in service.
Vanguard was however a compromise, a way of getting one more fast, modern battleship in service quickly. The Lions were cancelled because their new 16" guns wouldn't have been available until in to 1944. It was also realised with the Italians dropping out of the war there wouldn't be any need for six new ships.
Resources were allocated to other things.
For example 48 twin 5.25 or 4.5 inch dual purpose turrets that would have been the secondary armament would outfit a good number of cruisers and destroyers.
Opportunity cost is a thing.

Which is why the almost certainly doomed Trump class was such a bad idea.

Whilst we're on US Naval procurement. Putting steam catapults onto a class of carrier designed for electromagnetic catapults, seemingly for no better reason than because the President likes steam catapults.
 
Vanguard was my Uncle Martin's last ship after the war. He was a Chief Petty Officer in the gunnery branch.
His job was to keep the STAAG (Stabilised Tachymetric Anti-Aircraft Gun) Bofors AA mounts working for more than a few hours at a time .
They were a self contained mount with their own fire control radar. Once laid on to a target by either main fire control directors or the crew on the mount they could independently track a target.
They were the first self contained AA system and quite temperamental, vibration from the guns firing broke the radar and the hydraulics and gyro stabiliser were complex.
They were replaced fairly quickly with a Mk2 version that had a radar that could be mounted remotely and the complex hydraulics that stabilised the entire mount was changed to just gun stabilisation.

Their benefit was each mount could engage a seperate target under its own radar control.

STAAG with shield removed showing the amount of travel in the stabilisation
1794949266520.png

Modified STAAG with stabilisation removed and new radar.
1794949095512.png

With shield
(the cage work was for its protective canvas covers.
1794949162123.png

There was a STAAG mount at the RN Gunnery School at HMS Excellent when I was there, it wasn't operational.
 
Last edited:
And for Iran to a launch a Major Attack on US soil would be a very bad idea. In fact, I could not think of a dumber thing for Iran to do.
It would cause a good many Americans to chance their attitudes towards the war and change it from a war of choice to a war of necessity.
But we are dealing with religious fanatics here, and they don't think rationally.
 
So USA can bomb Iran but not the other way round?
Attacking targets in the USA is exactly what I would be trying to do in their place.
 
So USA can bomb Iran but not the other way round?
Attacking targets in the USA is exactly what I would be trying to do in their place.
Considering we lost our doodoo after 9-11, and invaded two countries, one with justification, and the other not so much, and have conducted military operation in the Philippines, Somalia, Sudan, Kenya, Nigeria, and Syria in the name of counter-terrorism because we didn't have a state target, a direct attack on CONUS by Iran would be ill-advised.

We'd go nuclear, which is what Iran wants us to do. They're weird that way.
 
Or Trump's battleship for that matter. I mean, I'm ok with calling the ship with the biggest guns a battleship, but... if everyone gave up on building battleships with 12" of belt armour because of missiles, what makes him think that his 6 inches is so great?
The greatest threat to the United States Navy is the United States Navy. We are almost 40 years behind where we could be, technologically speaking. They hate the Zumwalts not because they went all in on a railgun that didn't exist yet, and turned out to be infeasible, but mostly because it looks funny. The key to survival for any surface vessel is not being found. If you can't see it, you can't hit it, and the Zumwalt has a small RCS which means it's hard to find, harder to get a missile lock on, and can show up within range an enemy target without compromise until it unloads its weapons.

We should have had three different classes of this style of destroyer, and cruiser. But no, too weird. Lockheed tested the Sea Shadow in 1984, and the Navy goofed around with it until 2006. This was a large craft with almost no radar signature. The team that designed the Sea Shadow also designed an aircraft carrier with 6 square meter radar cross section (approx.), but they were told, "The Navy doesn't build ships that look like that". The team also had a submarine design that had a zero sonar return, but the design made it too slow for the Bubble-heads.

So now we pivot to the Pacific to face an enemy whose navy is designed to destroy our mid-1990s navy because our leadership doesn't have an imagination.

End rant.
 
Considering we lost our doodoo after 9-11, and invaded two countries, one with justification, and the other not so much, and have conducted military operation in the Philippines, Somalia, Sudan, Kenya, Nigeria, and Syria in the name of counter-terrorism because we didn't have a state target, a direct attack on CONUS by Iran would be ill-advised.

We'd go nuclear, which is what Iran wants us to do. They're weird that way.
Bollocks nuclear 🤣
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom