Bad ideas in war

Even in Germany it was a complete screw up. Opel had to get special dispensation to even get enough gas to test their truck engines made for the ARMY, because otherwise nobody even knew if they actually work.
 
Even in Germany it was a complete screw up. Opel had to get special dispensation to even get enough gas to test their truck engines made for the ARMY, because otherwise nobody even knew if they actually work.
Counterpoint: The Nazis annexed Austria with a rag-tag circus and sheer ◊◊◊◊◊◊◊ gall, scoring a timely propaganda victory in the process.

Which brings me back to my question: Is it a bad idea to take big risks for big rewards in war? Or only when it doesn't pay off?
 
Which brings me back to my question: Is it a bad idea to take big risks for big rewards in war? Or only when it doesn't pay off?
Obviously, it is only a bad idea when it doesn't pay off. Otherwise, it is genius.

In general, great military campaigns, or battles are not analysed to show how extremely lucky the winner was, although it does happen.
 
Which brings me back to my question: Is it a bad idea to take big risks for big rewards in war? Or only when it doesn't pay off?
Generally I'm not going to argue with results, but we've studied strategy and tactics for two centuries. Wargaming it was invented in 1780 by Johann Christian Ludwig Hellwig, for Pete's sake.

And the importance of logistics was well understood even by Napoleon.

We can have a pretty good idea when it shouldn't have worked, even in many cases it still did by sheer blind luck.


And to return to your example of annexing Austria: Austria actually had a chunk of population who WANTED to join Germany. The Austro-Hungarian Empire had built most industry in Bohemia. When it broke apart, Austria was left as a backwards nation. It already had people literally starving to death in the 20's, for Pete's sake. It was fertile grounds to be infiltrated by the Austrian national socialist party, and it was. It also was guaranteed only by Italy, who had just switched sides on them, and their army was symbolic at best. And also thoroughly infiltrated by the national-socialists. It was a safe bet that they would fall to Germany in no time.

France had a similar but different political crisis, where the whole country distrusted the army and crippled it intentionally. It also had thoroughly obsolete doctrines. And Belgium had just broken their alliance with them, leaving their northern border wide open. Also, most of their industry was concentrated near the German border, and it was predictable that it would quit fighting once that falls. Yeah, that did them in more than the fall of Paris. And even then Hitler expected a longer war.

By contrast, the invasion of the USSR was a crap-show in more than one way. Ignored the logistic corps that actually wargamed it, was based on racial beliefs more than any actual intel, and the invasion plan drawn up by Halder ignored any strategic objective. It was predictable that it would fail.
 
Last edited:
Obviously, it is only a bad idea when it doesn't pay off. Otherwise, it is genius.
I disagree.

In general, great military campaigns, or battles are not analysed to show how extremely lucky the winner was, although it does happen.
In general, if we're going to judge whether an idea was good or bad, I think we should consider the risk and reward at stake.

I think it's at best disingenuous, and at worst bizarrely ignorant, to say an idea is good enough to be worth trying, even if there's a risk it doesn't succeed, and then turn around and say it was a bad idea all along after it's been tried and failed.
 
And to return to your example of annexing Austria: Austria actually had a chunk of population who WANTED to join Germany. The Austro-Hungarian Empire had built most industry in Bohemia. When it broke apart, Austria was left as a backwards nation. It already had people literally starving to death in the 20's, for Pete's sake. It was fertile grounds to be infiltrated by the Austrian national socialist party, and it was. It also was guaranteed only by Italy, who had just switched sides on them, and their army was symbolic at best. And also thoroughly infiltrated by the national-socialists. It was a safe bet that they would fall to Germany in no time.
It was a combination of that and the effects of the great depression. I had a friend who was Austrian, and a sophomore in university in 1936. Germany paid to bus him and much most of his classmates to Berlin for the Olympics. He said crossing the border into Nazi Germany from Austria was night-and-day. In Austria everyone was broke, hungry, out of work with no hope. Germany was back on its feet, Swastikas in their red banners and buntings decorated the streets, people had jobs, people had money. When they got off the bus the Austrians were fed, and had access to all the food and beer they could handle during their stay.

He told me everyone on all the busses were chanting "Heil Hitler!" all the way back home. They told their friends and their families what they saw in Nazi Germany. It was an easy annex,
 
Yeah the anschluss was more luck than skill.

I wonder... was it a bad idea in war? One could certainly argue that it was stupid to try to annex Austria without having an army capable of doing so. That it was damn lucky for Hitler that the Austrians were so willing to be annexed that they let it happen anyway. But was it really luck? Or did Hitler accurately read the Austrian mood, and execute a successful operation on that basis?

Certainly the success there had a huge payoff in terms of propaganda and momentum.
I keep coming back to an article after the millionaires sub was crushed. He kept proceeding on the basis of “what if the bad thing didn’t happen?” . For a lot of them it doesn’t work but each one who survives is more convinced and convinces others they are special. It explains a lot but then so do many other ideas applied after the fact.
 
It was a combination of that and the effects of the great depression. I had a friend who was Austrian, and a sophomore in university in 1936. Germany paid to bus him and much most of his classmates to Berlin for the Olympics. He said crossing the border into Nazi Germany from Austria was night-and-day. In Austria everyone was broke, hungry, out of work with no hope. Germany was back on its feet, Swastikas in their red banners and buntings decorated the streets, people had jobs, people had money. When they got off the bus the Austrians were fed, and had access to all the food and beer they could handle during their stay.
The great depression sure made it even worse, and Austria was hit pretty hard by it in 1931, and was one of the slowest to recover from it.
 
Last edited:
Perun's latest video suggests that the change to the BBG(x) and FF(x) are even worse than they were at their announcements.

The unit cost of the frigate based on the legend class the FF(x) is going to be more than the Constellation class for the first few years.

And the Defiant class is going to be more expensive because of the (somewhat reasonable) decision to make it nuclear.

In itself that's not a bad thing for such a ship, and if you are going to have such a ship , is possibly even a sensible move, but it does make it even more expensive.



What seems to me as a layperson to be a good analysis of what the USN actually wants by Dr Alexander Clarke

Arguing that they don't really want low end frigates, because the US has a significant coastguard force. He suggests that they want medium end frigates instead. Which tallies with what went wrong with the Constellation Class.



 
Frigates are in a weird position these days. Pretty much any naval warship has to able to work against submarines, air attacks, and surfwce/shore targets. It's hard to pack a sustainable amount of such diverse firepower into a "frigate" sized hull.
 
Frigates are in a weird position these days. Pretty much any naval warship has to able to work against submarines, air attacks, and surfwce/shore targets. It's hard to pack a sustainable amount of such diverse firepower into a "frigate" sized hull.
Well, you pretty much answered your own question. You can pack it, just a lot less of it than on a destroyer. And there is some advantage in distributing it among several targets. If an anti-ship missile hits your destroyer, you lost all that firepower, but if it hits one of two frigates, you only lost half. It's kinda like why nobody sane builds battleships anymore. (I obviously don't count Trump as sane.)

Plus, Aegis links ships, their radars, and their weapons, plus any AWACS you have in the air, so it can fire a missile from any other ship in that fleet.
 
Last edited:
Well, speaking of funny ships, Romania's communist-time "battlecruiser." It was really frigate sized, and fairly obsolete even for that time. But if Ceausescu, "the genius of the Carpathians," wants to show the size of his penis by having a battlecruiser just like the USSR, who's gonna tell him that his idea is stupid? (Kinda like Trump and his battleship, I guess.)

Or Trump's battleship for that matter. I mean, I'm ok with calling the ship with the biggest guns a battleship, but... if everyone gave up on building battleships with 12" of belt armour because of missiles, what makes him think that his 6 inches is so great?
 
Last edited:
They gave up on building battleships because of aircraft carriers, long before missiles. The GMS Vanguard was the last one and it was only built because enough 15-inch guns and turret already existed in storage. All six Lion Class 16" gun ships were cancelled in 1942, including the two under construction.
 
They gave up on building battleships because of aircraft carriers, long before missiles. The GMS Vanguard was the last one and it was only built because enough 15-inch guns and turret already existed in storage. All six Lion Class 16" gun ships were cancelled in 1942, including the two under construction.
I thought it had 14" guns. But yes it wouldn't have been ordered from scratch.
 
I thought it had 14" guns. But yes it wouldn't have been ordered from scratch.
Assuming we're still talking about HMS Vanguard, she had WW1 era 15" guns that Britain had in storage. She was the most modern battleship in all other aspects, but equipped with fairly obsolete guns. Don't get me wrong British naval guns were probably the finest in the world, but... time takes its toll.
 
I thought it had 14" guns. But yes it wouldn't have been ordered from scratch.
No Vanguard used four twin 15" turrets as fitted to the Queen Elizabeth and Royal Sovereign class battleships, Courageous and Renown-class battlecruisers, HMS Hood and several Monitors.
Vanguard's turrets were modified to have greater strength and elevation to take the shock from 'supercharge' propellants and shells to give increased range.
 
Last edited:
Assuming we're still talking about HMS Vanguard, she had WW1 era 15" guns that Britain had in storage. She was the most modern battleship in all other aspects, but equipped with fairly obsolete guns. Don't get me wrong British naval guns were probably the finest in the world, but... time takes its toll.
The 15" with supercharges and improved shells still packed a big hit and the Vanguard range was 37,870 yards at 30°, with supercharges.
But, RN doctrine was to close the range as quickly as possible and fight fairly close in where the guns would pierce any main belt in service.
The KGV class and Vanguard (which was a modified Lion class hull) had a main belt thickness capable of stopping a 16" shell, they had the best armour layout and steel quality of any battleship in service.
Vanguard was however a compromise, a way of getting one more fast, modern battleship in service quickly. The Lions were cancelled because their new 16" guns wouldn't have been available until in to 1944. It was also realised with the Italians dropping out of the war there wouldn't be any need for six new ships.
Resources were allocated to other things.
For example 48 twin 5.25 or 4.5 inch dual purpose turrets that would have been the secondary armament would outfit a good number of cruisers and destroyers.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom