August 2007 Stundie Nominations

Goal Post, anyone?

A rebut on Ron W's post, by Freaky D'oh P! Always a laugh!
Ron W.
Why are you pretending that Dr. Greening is a fantasist? He has destroyed the bogus science of Jim Hoffman and Gordon Ross. He showed in his paper on sulfur that Steven Jones's assumptions are flawed. He demonstrated that the energy available for a gravity-driven collapse was more than sufficient.

His quirky, contrarian attitude rankles some people on the JREF, but Frank Greening is first and foremost a scientist.

D'oh P's response, I guess...
Dr Greening admits he doesnt know what hit the pentagon. He believes in many conspiracies, including manmade AIDS and Waco.

Wipe that egg off your chin and own up Ron.

http://z10.invisionfree.com/Loose_Change_Forum/index.php?showtopic=14173&st=0&#entry14456074

What size engine is that? I never saw a goal post move that fast!
 
Can't leave out this Gem from Do-Over Dylan:

Dylan Avery said:
I'd like to be able to say that everything we're saying is backed up by fact

From the History Channel 9/11 Conspiracy Show....sorry no online link available yet.
 
A thread's OP challenged truthers to explain what they think actually happened, rather than just picking holes in the "official story". RedIbis responds:


Oh RedIbis has another, IMO better, statement for consideration of a stundie.

Originally Posted by RedIbis
No, I'm alluding to the preposterous NIST claim that the removal of fireproofing in the towers accelerated the steel temp.

It must be common sense that fireproofing insulation actually has no function in a fire.
 
MJD does it again!
You have no interest in this whatsoever, you are happy to continue being deceitful, and thus you are complicit in your deceit

Would this be propitious to policy of deceitfulness?
 
mjd's entire gist (with a momentary waver towards opinion polls towards the bottom of page 4) was that CTists are more likely to be reported/yellow-carded/banned here that OTists. Might not be true, dunno.

as Stundie nominations go, this one is p#ss-poor.

You seem to have utterly missed the point. It is irrelevant whether ctists are reported or carded more often. It is irrelevant whether there really is a bias. Aboslutely everything is irrelevant except for mjd's own words.

He said that a thread, and therefore everyone involved with it, agreed with him:
The thread concludes that a new PH was propitious to policy

This is so hilariously not true that it is deserving of a Stundy nomination. But the fun didn't stop there because not only was it so obviously false, he had previously complained that there were too many people in the thread who disagreed with him:
Now, let's look at a couple of simple barometers. My CF thread, which would ordinarily be the perfect rallying ground for CTers, since it makes monkeys out of OTers, has seen visits from 3 CTers that I can think of- me, SwingDangler, and Rev91. It has had well over 40 OTers, maybe up to 50. So on that thread, a highly propitious thread for Cters to frequent, it is 94% OTers.

This means it doesn't even matter if the nominated statement is true. Even if he had conclusively won the argument and we are all just closed-minded government sheeple, he claims that everyone agrees with him in a thread which he had previously complained didn't have enough people agreeing with him. This is what is known in the business as "horribly ironic".

The fact that his statement is so brilliantly oblivious to the real world is just icing on the cake. The fact that the statistics given in the management thread show that if any bias exists it is actually in favour of the ctists is just a load of sprinkles and chocolate flakes with a few of those weird crunchy silvery ball thingies on the cake.

The fact is, everyone did not agree with him. Dismissing everyone who doesn't agree with them is a standard woo tactic which itself got a nomination of mjd. Claiming that everyone who doesn't agree with you actually does agree with you is even more deserving. Doing so when you have previously complained that there are too many people who don't agree with you is even better.
 
You seem to have utterly missed the point. It is irrelevant whether ctists are reported or carded more often. It is irrelevant whether there really is a bias. Aboslutely everything is irrelevant except for mjd's own words.

He said that a thread, and therefore everyone involved with it, agreed with him:


This is so hilariously not true that it is deserving of a Stundy nomination. But the fun didn't stop there because not only was it so obviously false, he had previously complained that there were too many people in the thread who disagreed with him:


This means it doesn't even matter if the nominated statement is true. Even if he had conclusively won the argument and we are all just closed-minded government sheeple, he claims that everyone agrees with him in a thread which he had previously complained didn't have enough people agreeing with him. This is what is known in the business as "horribly ironic".

The fact that his statement is so brilliantly oblivious to the real world is just icing on the cake. The fact that the statistics given in the management thread show that if any bias exists it is actually in favour of the ctists is just a load of sprinkles and chocolate flakes with a few of those weird crunchy silvery ball thingies on the cake.

The fact is, everyone did not agree with him. Dismissing everyone who doesn't agree with them is a standard woo tactic which itself got a nomination of mjd. Claiming that everyone who doesn't agree with you actually does agree with you is even more deserving. Doing so when you have previously complained that there are too many people who don't agree with you is even better.
Maybe we ought to apply the comedy standards to Stundies:
If you have to explain the joke, it ain't funny, and go on...
 
he said he wasn't a "supporter", he never said he didn't believe the obvious controlled demolitions.

Galileo was talking about statement from Dr. Quintiere

"Although Dr. Quintiere was strongly critical of NIST’s conclusions and its investigatory process, he made it clear he was not a supporter of theories that the Twin Towers were brought down by pre-planted explosives. “If you go to World Trade Center One, nine minutes before its collapse, there was a line of smoke that puffed out. This is one of the basis of the ‘conspiracy theories’ that says the smoke puffing out all around the building is due to somebody setting off an explosive charge. Well, I think, more likely, it’s one of the floors falling down.”

Check it out here
 
Galileo was talking about statement from Dr. Quintiere

"Although Dr. Quintiere was strongly critical of NIST’s conclusions and its investigatory process, he made it clear he was not a supporter of theories that the Twin Towers were brought down by pre-planted explosives. “If you go to World Trade Center One, nine minutes before its collapse, there was a line of smoke that puffed out. This is one of the basis of the ‘conspiracy theories’ that says the smoke puffing out all around the building is due to somebody setting off an explosive charge. Well, I think, more likely, it’s one of the floors falling down.”

Check it out here


I predict this one will win easily (take that, Sylvia Browne :p ). And remember, you heard it here first. :D
 
Well August isn't quite over yet.

Can I nominate Alex Jones for comparing himself to Galileo (the real one), in that History Channel CT doco? I haven't watched it yet, but it was reported* that Jones thinks Galileo was persecuted for saying that the Earth is round.



*It's good enough for Prison Planet.
 
How about this line from OldSchool describing the wonderful world of LCF?

<snip>

If you're looking for actual discussion of the professionals who do support the Truth Movement, I would suggest The Loose Change Forum. As they are the most moderate forum I've discovered relating to 911, you'll find the discussion there doesn't include personal attacks. The focus at the Loose Change forum is to discuss professionals who disagree with the government censored account of 911.

<snip>
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom