My first reaction: "Oh J.R. 'Bob' Dobbs on a popsicle stick, not
that whacko hatefreak again".
Y'see, I spent a bit of time looking into Mr. Errortheory's claims a couple of years ago, when they were the subject of considerable scorn on some of the blogs I hang out on. And you know what? This is a good topic for the Conspiracy Theories sub-forum, although not in the way some of our posters seem to think.
What I mean is that Mr. Errortheory's screed has some elements which the conoisseur of paranoid conspiracism will find familiar:
1. The use of
ad hoc methods of analysis, coupled with unwarranted claims of precision
and data fudging:
Mr. Errortheory takes a screen capture of an artist's conception from a pdf (do I really need to point out that this is a very far cry from an engineering document, which would quantify dimensions and orientations?), pastes it into Windows Paint, and plays "count the pixels". Ironically for someone who names his blog "Error Theory", he makes no attempt whatsoever to quantify the errors, either systematic or random, in his "measurement" methods. He arbitrarily selects different criteria for finding the two endpoints of the "crescent" so as to get the data to yield the conclusion he wants. He then relies on a freaking
Web site to do his math for him, despite the fact that the formulae for finding a great circle course between two points are easily found so that you can do the math for yourself.
And in spite of all that, the best he can come up with is a
sorta-kinda match.
I am unavoidably reminded of troofers peering at Youtube videos trying to "prove" that the plane that hit WTC 2 was really a CGI effect, or that the fall of WTC 1,2, & 7 were controlled demolitions, or jpeg images of crash debris to "prove" that what hit the Towers or the Pentagon wasn't a hijacked airliner- or Jack White using made-up photo analysis methods to "prove" that Apollo photographs were faked.
2. Reading great wads of meaning into tiny bits of language:
It's unfortunate that the architect used the term "Crescent of Embrace" in describing what visually is more of an arc. We don't know why he used that word; it could simply be that it seemed more high-falutin'.
But to the paranoid conspiracist, there is never any ambiguity in language, nor simply unfortunate choices of vocabulary. He
knows exactly what is meant by every stray word, and that meaning always supports the CT.
"Crescent of Embrace"... "decided to pull"...
3. Making @#$% up.
Mr. Errortheory finds that if you stand in just the right place and face just the right point on the arc, you'll be facing towards Mecca. From that, he concludes that the memorial is, believe it or not, a clandestine
mosque dedicated to the hijackers. In doing this, he demonstrates an ignorance of Muslim religious architecture that could be remedied by a simple visit to Wikipedia. A mosque will have a niche in one wall, called the
mihrab, which indicates the direction the worshippers should face. The congregation doesn't try to stand
in the mihrab; if one were made large enough for this those standing in it would lose their orientation. In Mr. Errortheory's conception, the memorial he insists is a mosque would be
all mihrab and no prayer hall. But his uninformed conception of how a mosque is designed trumps easily-available real-world information and real-world examples, since those examples don't provide support for the CT.
The rocks must have been made in a radiation oven. The DNA and airplane parts must have been planted. It must have been a controlled demolition because it sorta looks like one. It must be a mosque. The four glass blocks must be to honor the hijackers.
4. Mind-reading:
Having so cleverly deduced that the memorial design is really a clandestine mosque, Mr. Errortheory proceeds directly into the mind of its designer and finds that
he is a covert Islamofascist. He therefore went to the trouble of working out and submitting a design to a competitive process for the purpose of striking a blow for
jihad, or to sap and impurify our precious bodily fluids, or something really eevil.
Once the CTer has discovered the Evil Other in the guise of an ordinary human being, everything about their plans and motivations becomes blindingly clear. The evil plan proves the motive; the motive proves the evil plan, and everything the Evil Other does or says fits into the model.
The astronauts won't swear on a bible because they're guilty about their role in the hoax. Bush did 9/11 to provide a pretext for war with Iraq; the war is the proof of motive and the motive is the proof of guilt. The architect designed the memorial as a mosque because he is an Islamofascist.
5. Occam's anti-razor:
All explanations of the data which fail to support the CT are summarily rejected in favor of constructions of much greater, and unnecessary complexity. The possibility that the design was influenced by constraints of terrain and accessibility, or that the location of the break in the "crescent" was determined by the flight path of UA93 is rejected. So is the possibility that any similarities to Islamic religious architecture which can be tortured out of a brochure are the result of coincidence rather than evil intent.
Instead, the CTer insists on an elaborate construction in which the Evil Ones go to great lengths to execute a conspiracy in ways that often don't make sense in the light of the putative purpose of the conspiracy.
NASA had to murder the Apollo 1 crew and Christa McAuliffe because they might have exposed elements of the hoax, so they did it in the way most guaranteed to precipitate major investigations. The Towers werre clandestinely pre-planted with explosives to destroy them but airplanes were crashed into them anyway; the evil neo-cons planned 9/11 to justify the Iraq war but none of the planted evidence provided a direct link to their target. The Islamofascists have taken the trouble to infiltrate the planning of the memorial and make it a secret mosque; since there were over a thousand entries in the design competition, the commision which made the selection- including bereaved family members- must also have been part of the conspiracy, but how a design which only the CTer can interpret correctly inflicts harm commensurate with the effort involved is left unexplained.
I could go on, but those are some of the main points of similarity.
Many here are rightfully peeved to think of a Killtown harassing Val McClatchy or a Lyte Trip accusing a cabbie who was fortunate not to become another victim of the Pentagon attack of being an accomplice in a cover up.
I have to wonder how much hate mail and harassment the architects and planners of the memorial have had to endure at the hands of Mr. Errortheory's little clacque of hatefreaks and authoritarian followers. Thinking of that makes it hard for me to maintain the detachment needed to analyze a classic example of a paranoid conspiracy theory.