Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?

Why? That's like asking someone who doesn't collect stamps to show off their stamp collection... We don't even acknowledge that such a concept is valid in any way shape or form.

I say this is about a 2.3 on the troll scale?

is this a one to ten scale with "trolliest" being 1?
 
[ This is a repeated preamble. ]​

Before anything else, in case you care to be up-to-date, I have already said time and again that my concept of God is the following:

God is an existent entity independent of man's mind, the creator of heaven and earth and everything.​


And I am now into the examination of what is empirical testing by which atheists can be convinced that God does exist.

So if you have nothing to contribute about empirical testing for the God as described above, please dispense yourself from writing anything here, for the present.​


I last posted the message below at 09:53 AM, It is now 11:32 AM, both local time.

When I left last time I was asking you guys, atheists who are masters of empirical evidence or testing, empirical means man's experience...

I wanted you to enlighten me on what organs are into experiences of man, to get to the entities outside man's mind and also inside man's mind, all kinds of entities at all.

That should include the whole of existence of whatever kinds and manners and degrees, including God if He does exist, and He does according to theists.

But no atheist has come up with a list of the organs whereby man can encounter experiences, by which he knows entities to exist outside his mind but also inside his mind.



Please, no more talk about all kinds of gods, just concentrate on the most current God from learned theists, in particular I suggest the One believed in by learned Christians.

If you continue to dwell on many many many gods, you are into the non-thinking way of atheists' talk, No. 8 in the list below, see quoted text from myself below.


You say that I am making God more and more current to our knowledge in science and in philosophy and in technology and in arts.

Precisely correct, and you are into the hoary gods Zeus and Odin, so better grow up and get updated.


I will leave the forum now and maybe return later in the evening, but I make one request to you, atheists, as masters of empirical evidence or testing, please work your brain to bring up the organs of experience by which man gets to know entities outside his mind and also inside his mind.

Why work on empirical testing? Because that is what you are always demanding from theists, empirical evidence or testing; that is why we should get first to a mutually agreed on concept of empirical evidence or testing, if we are to have any exchange with our feet firmly set on common and solid ground.



If you still want to talk about innumerable gods, please dispense yourselves from writing further in this thread, to save yourselves time and trouble.


Also for atheists who will not for a provisional at least provisional concept of God on their part provisional that is, namely, as articulated in the statement already repeated several times here ( see text on top or text in the quoted message below ), for the sake of getting on with a hopefully constructive exchange of ideas on God or no God, please similarly excuse yourselves from writing in this thread, to save people's time here and the forum's bandwidth.







Thanks to all atheists who are sincerely interested in exchange of ideas no matter they promise themselves to never give up on their identity as atheists, come hell and high water.

At least with such a kind of atheists, communication with them is not impossible, and can even be mutually enjoyable, as an exercise in the mental hobby of genuine thinking and clear exposition.




Yrreg
Xtian god is not the most recent - and limiting your discussion to that particular delusion tends to imply you have a personal preference for one delusion over any alternative delusion or the lack of such delusion. You still have no evidence that any of those supposed creators of everything actually exists or that such a creator thing is even possible.
 
is this a one to ten scale with "trolliest" being 1?
No, the other way around. It works like the Richter scale. A T3 is twice as trolly as a T2, which is twice as trolly as T1. Most of yrreg's threads seem to hover around T2.3 - T2.5. DOC is usually around T3, JEROME DA GNOME topped the charts at T4.1 on his best days.
 
I've lived in California so I can well relate to the Richter scale. It all makes sense to me now.
 
[ This is a repeated preamble. ]​

Before anything else, in case you care to be up-to-date, I have already said time and again that my concept of God is the following:

God is an existent entity independent of man's mind, the creator of heaven and earth and everything.​
Good, at least you've owned up to him. Now will you please curb your God? I'll have you know that in most municipalities there's at least a $300 fine for God waste.

And I am now into the examination of what is empirical testing by which atheists can be convinced that God does exist.
Well, as I've repeatedly said, I'll accept anything for which one can provide evidence that stands on its own. A good place to start might be to knock God out and take a picture of him. That would certainly constitute solid evidence. (But please don't do to God what you did to the last person you knocked out and took a picture of. You'll scar him for life.)

So if you have nothing to contribute about empirical testing for the God as described above, please dispense yourself from writing anything (I just felt this strange compulsion to write something here. --SK) for the present.
Sorry, I couldn't resist.

When I left last time I was asking you guys, atheists who are masters of empirical evidence or testing, empirical means man's experience...

I wanted you to enlighten me on what organs are into experiences of man, to get to the entities outside man's mind and also inside man's mind, all kinds of entities at all.
I thought certain organs scared you.

That should include the whole of existence of whatever kinds and manners and degrees, including God if He does exist, and He does according to theists.

But no atheist has come up with a list of the organs whereby man can encounter experiences, by which he knows entities to exist outside his mind but also inside his mind.
Again, I thought certain organs scared you. How do I know these won't as well?

Please, no more talk about all kinds of gods, just concentrate on the most current God from learned theists, in particular I suggest the One believed in by learned Christians.
You're right, we should in no way base our concept of God on something written 2,000 years ago or more, because that'd be one old and hoary deity indeed.

If you continue to dwell on many many many gods, you are into the non-thinking way of atheists' talk, No. 8 in the list below, see quoted text from myself below.
I've been known to make lists myself. Check it out. You might recognize yourself on there. ;)

You say that I am making God more and more current to our knowledge in science and in philosophy and in technology and in arts.

Precisely correct, and you are into the hoary gods Zeus and Odin, so better grow up and get updated.
I agree. We should completely and immediately forget about ancient religions and deities dating back to milennia ago so that... Wait, what were we talking about again?

I will leave the forum now and maybe return later in the evening, but I make one request to you, atheists, as masters of empirical evidence or testing, please work your brain to bring up the organs of experience by which man gets to know entities outside his mind and also inside his mind.
The pinneal gland and the temporal-parietal lobe come to mind. Oh yes, pun intended.

Why work on empirical testing? Because that is what you are always demanding from theists, empirical evidence or testing; that is why we should get first to a mutually agreed on concept of empirical evidence or testing, if we are to have any exchange with our feet firmly set on common and solid ground.
Unfortunately I get the feeling that your feet are facing in the opposite direction and making fast tracks off towards another thread. Though I can't imagine why you'd ever do that.

If you still want to talk about innumerable gods, please dispense yourselves from writing further in this thread, to save yourselves time and trouble.
Oh no, not at all. It looks like I'll still have plenty of time and trouble leftover for some routine guiltless masturbation, eudaimonia, and retrogressive tergiversation.

Also for atheists who will not for a provisional at least provisional concept of God on their part provisional that is, namely, as articulated in the statement already repeated several times here ( see text on top or text in the quoted message below ), for the sake of getting on with a hopefully constructive exchange of ideas on God or no God, please similarly excuse yourselves from writing in this thread, to save people's time here and the forum's bandwidth.

[ This is a repeated preamble. ]​

ME RIGHT, YOU WRONG, YOU CRAZY!
There you go, I fixed it for you.

Thanks to all atheists who are sincerely interested in exchange of ideas no matter they promise themselves to never give up on their identity as atheists, come hell and high water.
At the same time? Wouldn't that kind of put the fires out? What's the point in it then?

At least with such a kind of atheists, communication with them is not impossible, and can even be mutually enjoyable, as an exercise in the mental hobby of genuine thinking and clear exposition.
You're right, I'm enjoying this way more than I thought I would.
 
No, the other way around. It works like the Richter scale. A T3 is twice as trolly as a T2, which is twice as trolly as T1. Most of yrreg's threads seem to hover around T2.3 - T2.5. DOC is usually around T3, JEROME DA GNOME topped the charts at T4.1 on his best days.
I like your scale idea!! Where would you place tinny tim and moonie69 ?:)
 
Yrreg Simple answer from a simple man

A simple answer from a rural PC Repair man. I was brought up in a Jewish household and had a Bar Mitzvah. I had never believed in anything such as your god as soon as I found out the tooth fairy was my dear mother. Nonetheless, I agreed to the charade on the condition that after my Bar Mitzvah, I would no longer be forced to proceed in religious studies. On my death bed after I was hit by a truck in Los Angeles I did not repent for my non belief and only prayed there was a good doctor who could fix me up. My prayers were for science to help me. God is a tool for those who are afraid of mortality and those who are sheep, brainwashed innocents. I respect the rights of you to believe in what you wish, however your rude responses to those who sincerely want to answer your questions would not make you a welcome guest.
 
Yrreg -- to answer your comment about people coming to [America] to practice religion, that's utterly immaterial to the question of a god's existance. As I said in my post, I am interested in evidence of (a) god's existance, not merely evidence that people believe in god(s). People committed suicide in the Heaven's Gate cult because they believed a flying saucer following a comet would take their souls away (or something close to that). In Ancient Egypt, great temples and pyramids were built for the tombs of the Pharoahs, whom they believed were gods. That people will do things because of their beliefs in clearly evident.

But belief is not evidence that what is believed in, is true. There are certainly hundreds of thousands, perhaps millions, of homeopathic remedy users; most of them believe it helps or cures their condition(s). Yet there is not a scrap of evidence that homeopathy works.

This is quite similar to the situation with religion and god(s). Lots of believers claiming lots of things, and none of them demonstrably true.

And, for the record, I am probably better versed in Christianity than most people in America, having been raised a Protestant and studied to convert to Roman Catholicism before abandoning organized religion--and then all gods--as having no essential truth to them.

All successful religions teach certain virtues and offer certain comforts; if they didn't, they wouldn't have adherents. Their followers would die off, and they'd fade into obscurity. (Somebody help me, was it the Shakers who were against fornication, even in marriage?) But that they offer some social values has nothing to do with whether or not their essential tenets--the existance and nature of their god or gods--are true.

Finally, I must disagree entirely with your definition of "empirical". Empirical means based on facts and observations, not on theory. Philosophically, it also implies acceptance that the senses bring in real data--that is, that we do not just imagine have senses, they do exist and give us information about things outside our own minds. "Having to do with Man's experience" is a bit too vague, since it necessarily includes experiences occurring in the mind of people--even, within the mind of only one person. By that definition, all hallucinations count as "empirical evidence." I once saw giant spiders walking on my bedroom wall--103 degree fevers will do that to ya!--and I am absolutely sure that they were not real, no matter how "real" they seemed at that moment.

If we can amend your empirical definition to include shared experiences, maybe we can work with this. But, again, it needs to be evidence of "God himself", not evidence of belief in god(s).

Is that a little clearer?

Fondly, MK
 
I would just like to make some comment on these for my own satisfaction. I mean to try to understand what the charges are and make some reply

And here is my latest enlarged enumeration of the ways of non-thinking atheists should avoid, if they want to show mankind that they can engage in constructive exchange of ideas with people who are not atheists like themselves, i.e, atheists themselves who engage in non-thinking ways of writing and talking.

It seems to me that any constructive exchange must be based on the idea that both sides are trying to understand each other. You do not seem to believe that is happening, Yrreg, and you appear to be trying to demonstrate that people here are not honest in their attempts to engage with you. This is obviously not true and several people have been disappointed by your failure to reply to their sincere posts responding to the points you have made. For myself I am afraid I have become convinced that you are not interested in a real exchange of ideas but in case I am wrong I want to challenge your list.



1. Retrogressive non-thinking, for example, bringing up hoary gods like Zeus and Odin.

Your use of the phrase "retrogressive" is not particularly helpful, but I am taking this to mean that you do not see any value in discussing conceptions of god which have been superseded. As I said in an earlier post, the reason this is important is that the people who believed in those gods were just as sincere as you are in their belief. You may think that belief in those deities died out because mankind made progress towards a better understanding of the nature of god: and you have said as much, I think. It is therefore not unreasonable to ask you to tell us what new evidence/knowledge/logic led to the revision. Once you have done this and shown why those "hoary" gods are intrinsically different from your modern conception I am sure we will all be able to see that the rise and fall of deities is not a matter of fashion or force: but rather that there is good reason not to think about the earlier conceptions while addressing this topic. You see, you say this is non-thinking: but I have thought about it. I have not been able to see any good reason for the change: and this is what you will show me, if you are honest in saying you wish a constructive exchange. It is possible I am too stupid or uneducated to see this clear improvement which renders Zeus or Odin irrelevant; and that you can show me the difference: but you have not done so. I have shown you why I think they are relevant and the ball is now on your side of the net: that is how it works. If you try and I don't get it there are others here who will: for I am not alone in believing there is no difference at all between these deities and currently accepted gods: except for historical accident. This is a serious point and unless you address it it seems to me that you are the one who is not thinking

2. Flippant non-thinking, defining God as the Flying Spaghetti Monster or the Celestial teapot, it could make you appear smart but solid thinkers see you to be engaging in camouflage to hide from the issue.

It has already been explained to you why these analogies are drawn:you are correct they are sometimes used rather flippantly here: but that is because most of us know what the particular entities were invoked to demonstrate and they were all serious issues. For example FSM was created to challenge creationism being taught in schools, and it was a graphic way of showing that that idea is silly but dangerous. Far from showing that atheists are not thinking these examples show they are thinking very deeply: you need to be able to show why the ideas they illustrated are not correct: you are not thinking if you dismiss them as the equivalent of children's stories. So I will ask you to read the origins of these things, if you have not done so already, and think about what they tell us about the status of gods in mainstream religion. This is equivalent to your demand that we research the current thinking on god amongst respectable theists: and it is no less legitimate. Many here have good knowledge of what theists propose (and in more than one sect or religion let it be said): extend the same courtesy to us, please.

3. Genital and anal non-thinking or coital and fecal, ipsa res loquitur, in place of rising above these otherwise biological matters and functions.

You have not phrased this in a way it is easy for me to understand at all. In fact I cannot even guess what you mean. On the face of it you seem to say that people are talking about sex and defecation rather than something else: but the only person I have seen make an issue of sex is you: since you raised the topic, albeit in another thread, it is hardly surprising people talk about it: you made it a topic by suggesting that sexual freedom was a reason for atheism: and we took the trouble to explain at length that you were wrong. Yet you now say that discussing it is in some sense an avoidance of thought? I am not at all sure where defecation comes into this but your phrase "rising above" these matters is a little strange since you actually insisted on making sex central to one of your threads. I think you should apologise for this charge, actually.

4. Literalistic non-thinking, for example when you read a religious text saying that God can be found under stones and beneath barks of trees, you insist you only find worms.

Yes, I do accept that this happens and that it is a little flippant. You may wish to consider that people respond in this way through frustration, mainly. Is that not why you object to metaphorical (is that the right word) conceptions like the FSM and dismiss it? We are no different. It is true that a phrase such as "god is found under stones" or "a universe in a grain of sand" is telling us something of the religious mindset: and indeed of the possibilities of the human mind in the latter case: and that the literal response is dismissive: so when you stop dismissing the FSM as an illustration of a truth not to be taken literally then I will stop dismissing your illustration in the same way. That is fair is it not?

5. Name-calling non-thinking, for example instead of addressing the issue you call people fundies, trolls, Idiots.

When you stop ignoring all the honest and serious responses you have had I am sure people will stop calling you a troll: because you will have ceased to be one. When you show some willingness to try to understand what people are saying to you instead of having both sides of the conversation by yourself then I think people will stop calling you an idiot: because you will have ceased to be one. I do not think I have seen you called an fundie: I certainly could not give you that label because you have not done me the courtesy of telling me what it is you believe: you prefer to see yourself as a pedagogue, I think, and you talk to us as children you need to instruct. This is rude and it is wrong: but as to your position - I haven't a clue

6. Phobia of self-incrimination non-thinking, for example, unreasonable and unintelligent resistance against producing any definition of God for fear of implicating themselves as God-believers.

I do not think this is happening at all. Many have explained why you need to give us the definition because the claim is yours and there are many very different conceptions of God. That is a fact. It is neither unintelligent or unreasonable to refuse to produce a definition out of the many available: that is for theist to do. We are willing to discuss whatever definition you propose and, after much ducking and diving (fear of self incrimination perhaps?) you have given one: that god is independent of the human mind and is the creator of all things. Ok. I am not averse to discussing that particular conception of god: it is not the only one and it is not sufficient for most theists, but it yours: and as I said, now we have that definition to discuss what do you want to say about it? I say it does not exist. Now what?

7. Off on a tangent non-thinking, for example, bringing up a sports event when the topic is about God’s existence.

No idea what you are talking about here, so I cannot comment

8. Tsunami non-thinking, by bringing in so many gods when the most current God believed in by learned theists is enough and best to focus on.

Ok, so we are going to talk about Brahma? Do you see the problem ?
 
Last edited:
Let me ask this question of both "sides."

What criteria to you use to determine somethings' existence or non-existence? If there is no agreement on this point, there is no common ground for discussion.

Just Evidence.

Of various types.

Oh, there are some tools around so you can see more evidence, that which you cannot perhaps experience directly......you'll find these in the science section somewhere.

Simple really.

Using all the tools we have from the beginnings of scientific thought to nowdays, any god has been conspicuous by absence.

You'd have thought that a god would'nt be hard to find, given most definitions of the major players.

However instead of perhaps "everywhere" for the location absolute of any given deity, we find "nowhere" so far.

However you may be in luck, oh seeker of the truth, because brother/sister yrreg has gone on a holy mission to bring back evidence of some sort of god or another.

Not sure which god the "evidence " wiil be for though.

As this may take a little time lets sit here in a place of quite contemplation, while taking the sacred mickey out of the deceived one.

When yrreg returns at some point, there will either be evidence, or there will not. Simple.

Or no yrreg, that's a possible.:)
 
Last edited:
Things that exist tend to have features which are measurable on some level. We would need something that can distinguish a real god from a delusion.

It doesn't appear that any invisible conscious entities have any measurable qualities, so it's the exact same as them not existing. I shall treat them as not existing.

I'd rather not know something than imagine that some invisible entity someone believes in is the explanation. You see, if I can't know if such an entity exists... then how can they? And if I can't tell such an entity from a delusion of such an entity, I don't believe anyone else can either. I think all such entities are delusions.

All the things that I know of that exist-- are manifest. You can measure them in some way. You can test them.... refine your knowledge about them... there are instruments that can measure or record things about them.

All of the myths, delusions, superstitions, and fantasies I know of have the same non measurable qualities that gods have. So do all the ones I've never heard about.
 
I would just like to make some comment on these for my own satisfaction. I mean to try to understand what the charges are and make some reply



It seems to me that any constructive exchange must be based on the idea that both sides are trying to understand each other. You do not seem to believe that is happening, Yrreg, and you appear to be trying to demonstrate that people here are not honest in their attempts to engage with you. This is obviously not true and several people have been disappointed by your failure to reply to their sincere posts responding to the points you have made. For myself I am afraid I have become convinced that you are not interested in a real exchange of ideas but in case I am wrong I want to challenge your list.





Your use of the phrase "retrogressive" is not particularly helpful, but I am taking this to mean that you do not see any value in discussing conceptions of god which have been superseded. As I said in an earlier post, the reason this is important is that the people who believed in those gods were just as sincere as you are in their belief. You may think that belief in those deities died out because mankind made progress towards a better understanding of the nature of god: and you have said as much, I think. It is therefore not unreasonable to ask you to tell us what new evidence/knowledge/logic led to the revision. Once you have done this and shown why those "hoary" gods are intrinsically different from your modern conception I am sure we will all be able to see that the rise and fall of deities is not a matter of fashion or force: but rather that there is good reason not to think about the earlier conceptions while addressing this topic. You see, you say this is non-thinking: but I have thought about it. I have not been able to see any good reason for the change: and this is what you will show me, if you are honest in saying you wish a constructive exchange. It is possible I am too stupid or uneducated to see this clear improvement which renders Zeus or Odin irrelevant; and that you can show me the difference: but you have not done so. I have shown you why I think they are relevant and the ball is now on your side of the net: that is how it works. If you try and I don't get it there are others here who will: for I am not alone in believing there is no difference at all between these deities and currently accepted gods: except for historical accident. This is a serious point and unless you address it it seems to me that you are the one who is not thinking



It has already been explained to you why these analogies are drawn:you are correct they are sometimes used rather flippantly here: but that is because most of us know what the particular entities were invoked to demonstrate and they were all serious issues. For example FSM was created to challenge creationism being taught in schools, and it was a graphic way of showing that that idea is silly but dangerous. Far from showing that atheists are not thinking these examples show they are thinking very deeply: you need to be able to show why the ideas they illustrated are not correct: you are not thinking if you dismiss them as the equivalent of children's stories. So I will ask you to read the origins of these things, if you have not done so already, and think about what they tell us about the status of gods in mainstream religion. This is equivalent to your demand that we research the current thinking on god amongst respectable theists: and it is no less legitimate. Many here have good knowledge of what theists propose (and in more than one sect or religion let it be said): extend the same courtesy to us, please.



You have not phrased this in a way it is easy for me to understand at all. In fact I cannot even guess what you mean. On the face of it you seem to say that people are talking about sex and defecation rather than something else: but the only person I have seen make an issue of sex is you: since you raised the topic, albeit in another thread, it is hardly surprising people talk about it: you made it a topic by suggesting that sexual freedom was a reason for atheism: and we took the trouble to explain at length that you were wrong. Yet you now say that discussing it is in some sense an avoidance of thought? I am not at all sure where defecation comes into this but your phrase "rising above" these matters is a little strange since you actually insisted on making sex central to one of your threads. I think you should apologise for this charge, actually.



Yes, I do accept that this happens and that it is a little flippant. You may wish to consider that people respond in this way through frustration, mainly. Is that not why you object to metaphorical (is that the right word) conceptions like the FSM and dismiss it? We are no different. It is true that a phrase such as "god is found under stones" or "a universe in a grain of sand" is telling us something of the religious mindset: and indeed of the possibilities of the human mind in the latter case: and that the literal response is dismissive: so when you stop dismissing the FSM as an illustration of a truth not to be taken literally then I will stop dismissing your illustration in the same way. That is fair is it not?



When you stop ignoring all the honest and serious responses you have had I am sure people will stop calling you a troll: because you will have ceased to be one. When you show some willingness to try to understand what people are saying to you instead of having both sides of the conversation by yourself then I think people will stop calling you an idiot: because you will have ceased to be one. I do not think I have seen you called an fundie: I certainly could not give you that label because you have not done me the courtesy of telling me what it is you believe: you prefer to see yourself as a pedagogue, I think, and you talk to us as children you need to instruct. This is rude and it is wrong: but as to your position - I haven't a clue



I do not think this is happening at all. Many have explained why you need to give us the definition because the claim is yours and there are many very different conceptions of God. That is a fact. It is neither unintelligent or unreasonable to refuse to produce a definition out of the many available: that is for theist to do. We are willing to discuss whatever definition you propose and, after much ducking and diving (fear of self incrimination perhaps?) you have given one: that god is independent of the human mind and is the creator of all things. Ok. I am not averse to discussing that particular conception of god: it is not the only one and it is not sufficient for most theists, but it yours: and as I said, now we have that definition to discuss what do you want to say about it? I say it does not exist. Now what?



No idea what you are talking about here, so I cannot comment



Ok, so we are going to talk about Brahma? Do you see the problem ?

Very nice, Fiona. If only it had a hope of getting through to yrreg...
 
That is what I am trying to get atheists to come to, concurrence...

Let me ask this question of both "sides."

What criteria to you use to determine somethings' existence or non-existence? If there is no agreement on this point, there is no common ground for discussion.


I have already said that we must theists and atheists agree that we exist objectively, and start from that point to discuss whether God exists or does not exist.

But atheists as many observers have noticed do not really want to discuss constructively and productively to arrive at more points of concurrence on the way to a determination whether God exists or does not exist.

If you don't believe me, then read the messages of atheists here, and imagine that you are writing a report to your professor of journalism on how atheists write in this thread and in every thread where they are supposed to discuss about the question of God's existence or non-existence.

And read the writings of atheists in atheists' websites and forums.


An example of refusal to come to concurring concepts is already their conspicuous phobia to not accept what learned theists in particular Christian theistic thinkers understand quintessentially the concept of God as the:

Existent entity independent of man's mind, creator of heaven and earth and everything.​

Another example of their refusal to come to concurring concepts is their to the present willful silence on what is empirical testing or evidence, when they are the ones to have waved furiously the flag of empirical testing.

I ask them to mention what organs of man are into experience by which experience man can empirically test the reality of entities outside man's mind.



Just You read all the messages here and see for yourself how they keep dilly-dallying, but will never come up with a serious presentation of what they know to be the quintessential concept of God from learned theists, and also now their own elucidation on what is empirical testing or evidence, starting with the enumeration of the organs of experience which are the indispensable access and process means to empirical testing and evidence of reality outside man's mind.



Anyway, let us now wait for them to come up with a decent presentation of their concept of what learned theists understand by God, and also how they explain empirical testing or evidence ( and they are the ones who are insisting on empirical evidence all the time ).



To atheists: suppose you discuss among yourselves first and come to a concurring concept of what you know to be the concept of God harbored in the minds of learned theists.

Then you discuss among yourselves to come to a concurring concept among yourselves what is empirical evidence and test, starting with organs of experience and how such organs are access and process means for the arrival by man at knowledge of things outside man's mind.


Tell you what, about empirical evidence, do it this way, bring up examples of things proven to be objectively existing on the basis of empirical evidence, and show how an organ of man or several organs can and do make man experience the objective existence of these things.




------------------

Back to the request of Ordover...


Addressing atheists here:

I give you the first crack at bringing up criteria to ascertain that we exist or anything at all exists outside man's mind.


Next, then you can proceed to work on a common concept of God as propounded by learned theists.

Afterward. expound rationally and intelligently and using only the most plain language but still viable, what is empirical evidence, employing examples of things proven to exist objectively on the basis of empirical evidence, indicating what organs are involved.



By the way, someone reading my threads here asked me how I can put up with all these obviously evasive maneuverings of atheists, and I told him that I am doing it for a mental exercise of rational intelligent thinking in analyzing atheists' mind and heart.

The man is of the conviction that atheists don't want to discuss, they just want to tire you out and make you go away so that they can continue to rest in self-absorbed but shallow assurance of there being no God.




My next thread will be on the title: "No atheists in a vacuum."

No, not foxhole, but vacuum, meaning atheists are into atheism for the pursuit of advantages they themselves should know if they do honest to goodness self-introspection, whatever protestations they put up that they are only after the truth.



And for atheists who complain that I am repeating messages here like putting at the top of my posts a repeated preamble about my concept of God and my request for atheists to come up with man's organs of experience in re empirical evidence or testing, that is necessary because they keep asking the same question about what is my concept of God and that I should produce empirical evidence.


Come to think of it, perhaps and almost certainly that is exactly their strategy to weary me out.


So, to atheists whom I notice to be into tergiversative gambits, for your information I will not read further as soon as I sense that you are into playing dummy, and I also won't even get started on your messages if you have already established a habit of writing evasively and wasting people's time here and the forum's bandwidth.




Yrreg
 
He's baaaaack!

Lots of us have agreed that the god most people are talking about "exists" and is the creator of the universe. All things that we know of that exist, are measurable on some level. We can see them, hear them, weigh them, test them, and/or refine our knowledge about them. Even invisible things like music, mental illness, DNA, math, languages, etc.

We can define them. They are all distinguishable from their imaginary counterparts. My imagining a dog is different than an actual dog. What distinguishes the god you believe in from an imaginary god? How do you know this god exists but not those "hoary gods" of yesteryear? How can you know about something invisible and immeasurable and why should we believe your claims of what you know over the claims of Tom Cruise and his beliefs regarding Scientology?

Why do you think we should take you more seriously than someone who really truly believes that they saw a Chupacabra? Why should we take you more seriously than the claims of those who swear they can "astral project"? How do we know that you haven't fooled yourself into believing whatever you believe in" just like millions of believers in those "hoary gods" of years past had? Or the way the Heavens Gate crowd did? Or the way the hijackers did? Why should we expect any less evidence from you than you'd expect from them to accept their beliefs as truth--their gods as "existing"? Why do you imagine those folks could be so easily fooled, but that you've somehow been immune?

Why do you expect us to answer your loaded leading questions, when you never answer any of our much more honest questions?

Why aren't these questions worth answering? Did you ever, ever think that you could be wrong about this god you believe in?-- See, most atheists don't believe in your god or any other god because they came to that exact conclusion after examining all the evidence (and noticing a huge lack thereof). Or do you just need it to be true so badly that you are afraid to look at the alternative? Wishing and believing in things can't make it true, yrreg! It's not our fault that your god doesn't manifest for us in whatever way you've managed to learn about him/her/it/them.

Your mental shenanigans have worked in making you a believer, but it won't fly here. We don't see you how you see yourself, and we sure don't see atheists as you so desperately want to prove to yourself they are.

Our disbelief in your god is the same as your disbelief in reincarnation. It's the same as your disbelief in Scientology. It's the same as your disbelief in those "hoary" gods of yesteryear, in fact!

Why not get a more current god (or theism)-- Mormonism is relatively new. Their god isn't hoary at all... and Joseph Smith sits with him on judgment day. Scientology is much more recent--and you get reincarnated. And the Raelians are looking for recruits. No hoary gods there.
 
Last edited:
Which "learned theists"? Which "quintessential properties of god"?

I know a very learned theist who would tell you that the quintessential properties of god vary from god to god. He's a Hindu. Most of the learned "theists" I work with are Buddhists, and will say that there are no gods, just the great cycle of life. I also used to work with a Pagan, and he was of the opinion that the whole Universe was alive and aware.

I know the answer you want is an agreement with you that the Judeo-Christian view is the simplest (and best), and therefore is the one we should concentrate on, but you aren't going about it in the right way. If you simply said "Let's just take this definition of god, and see where it takes us." then there'd be none of this semantic messing about. But you insist on couching it in pseudo-intellectual burbling, and obscure words and phrases, and write interminably long rambling posts, most of which are repeating or reposting what you've already said. And on top of all that, you insist on continually insulting the very people with whom you claim to want a reasoned discourse.

No joking, if you worked in academia, and took this approach to your research, you'd rapidly find yourself unemployable.


As far as the empirical testing goes, you said that you would be introducing empirical tests for god, and then moved the goalposts by asking what we would consider empirical.
 
I have already said that we must theists and atheists agree that we exist objectively, and start from that point to discuss whether God exists or does not exist.

Ok most of us do agree that we exist. The next step is to consider how we came to that conclusion. How did you? If you can lay out the process by which you came to believe that you and I and all other people exist then we can perhaps use that kind of thinking to address your next point. For my own part, being no kind of a philosopher, I believe that other people exist because they have detectable effects on the world: they build buildings and step on my toes. And other people can see these effects and agree with my perception: this is not the case with hallucinations or dreams and so I can tell the difference. That is one way and it is quite simplistic: but it seems to work for me. Perhaps you do something much more sophisticated in arriving at the same conclusion? So tell us about it


An example of refusal to come to concurring concepts is already their conspicuous phobia to not accept what learned theists in particular Christian theistic thinkers understand quintessentially the concept of God as the:

Existent entity independent of man's mind, creator of heaven and earth and everything.​

That is at best a misrepresentation of what has been said Yrreg. You are trading on the ambiguity of the word "accept" and it is not very impressive. So let me make it clear: many here have "accepted" that the conception you give is one which is held by some theists: what they have not done is "accepted" it in the sense of taking it as a true statement of something in the real world. Ms Kitt has already laid this out very plainly indeed. It is hard to believe you are honest in continuing this conflation of meaning when the point has been made so clearly.

Another example of their refusal to come to concurring concepts is their to the present willful silence on what is empirical testing or evidence, when they are the ones to have waved furiously the flag of empirical testing.

That is a lie. You have been told by several people what counts as evidence: it is a demonstration that god has an effect on the world which is detectable in the same way as your effect is detectable: let him build a building or stand on my toes or do anything which would change the world as much as the smallest baby can when it sicks up its milk.

I ask them to mention what organs of man are into experience by which experience man can empirically test the reality of entities outside man's mind.

Just the same ones you use to come to the agreement mentioned in your first paragraph: nothing fancy. When you have outlined those you have answered your question

<snip repetition>


To atheists: suppose you discuss among yourselves first and come to a concurring concept of what you know to be the concept of God harbored in the minds of learned theists.

Happy to accept yours :)

Then you discuss among yourselves to come to a concurring concept among yourselves what is empirical evidence and test, starting with organs of experience and how such organs are access and process means for the arrival by man at knowledge of things outside man's mind.

Probably happy to accept yours with the caveat that I do not yet know what it is: but if it as an honest statement of you came to the conclusion that you and other people exist I will likely go with it.


Tell you what, about empirical evidence, do it this way, bring up examples of things proven to be objectively existing on the basis of empirical evidence, and show how an organ of man or several organs can and do make man experience the objective existence of these things.

No I think I am happy to let you do that, for reasons given




------------------

[Back to the request of Ordover...


Addressing atheists here:

I give you the first crack at bringing up criteria to ascertain that we exist or anything at all exists outside man's mind.

After you :)


Next, then you can proceed to work on a common concept of God as propounded by learned theists.

No need: we will take yours

Afterward. expound rationally and intelligently and using only the most plain language but still viable, what is empirical evidence, employing examples of things proven to exist objectively on the basis of empirical evidence, indicating what organs are involved.

Dealt with: though I commend the part I have bolded and strongly suggest you try that

<snip> irrelevant and somewhat desperate attempt to support the argument by appeal to invisible authority and further insult
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom