That is what I am trying to get atheists to come to, concurrence...
Let me ask this question of both "sides."
What criteria to you use to determine somethings' existence or non-existence? If there is no agreement on this point, there is no common ground for discussion.
I have already said that we must theists and atheists agree that we exist objectively, and start from that point to discuss whether God exists or does not exist.
But atheists as many observers have noticed do not really want to discuss constructively and productively to arrive at more points of concurrence on the way to a determination whether God exists or does not exist.
If you don't believe me, then read the messages of atheists here, and imagine that you are writing a report to your professor of journalism on how atheists write in this thread and in every thread where they are supposed to discuss about the question of God's existence or non-existence.
And read the writings of atheists in atheists' websites and forums.
An example of refusal to come to concurring concepts is already their conspicuous phobia to not accept what learned theists in particular Christian theistic thinkers understand quintessentially the concept of God as the:
Existent entity independent of man's mind, creator of heaven and earth and everything.
Another example of their refusal to come to concurring concepts is their to the present willful silence on what is empirical testing or evidence, when they are the ones to have waved furiously the flag of empirical testing.
I ask them to mention what organs of man are into experience by which experience man can empirically test the reality of entities outside man's mind.
Just You read all the messages here and see for yourself how they keep dilly-dallying, but will never come up with a serious presentation of what they know to be the quintessential concept of God from learned theists, and also now their own elucidation on what is empirical testing or evidence, starting with the enumeration of the organs of experience which are the indispensable access and process means to empirical testing and evidence of reality outside man's mind.
Anyway, let us now wait for them to come up with a decent presentation of their concept of what learned theists understand by God, and also how they explain empirical testing or evidence ( and they are the ones who are insisting on empirical evidence all the time ).
To atheists: suppose you discuss among yourselves first and come to a concurring concept of what you know to be the concept of God harbored in the minds of learned theists.
Then you discuss among yourselves to come to a concurring concept among yourselves what is empirical evidence and test, starting with organs of experience and how such organs are access and process means for the arrival by man at knowledge of things outside man's mind.
Tell you what, about empirical evidence, do it this way, bring up examples of things proven to be objectively existing on the basis of empirical evidence, and show how an organ of man or several organs can and do make man experience the objective existence of these things.
------------------
Back to the request of Ordover...
Addressing atheists here:
I give you the first crack at bringing up criteria to ascertain that we exist or anything at all exists outside man's mind.
Next, then you can proceed to work on a common concept of God as propounded by learned theists.
Afterward. expound rationally and intelligently and using only the most plain language but still viable, what is empirical evidence, employing examples of things proven to exist objectively on the basis of empirical evidence, indicating what organs are involved.
By the way, someone reading my threads here asked me how I can put up with all these obviously evasive maneuverings of atheists, and I told him that I am doing it for a mental exercise of rational intelligent thinking in analyzing atheists' mind and heart.
The man is of the conviction that atheists don't want to discuss, they just want to tire you out and make you go away so that they can continue to rest in self-absorbed but shallow assurance of there being no God.
My next thread will be on the title: "No atheists in a vacuum."
No, not foxhole, but vacuum, meaning atheists are into atheism for the pursuit of advantages they themselves should know if they do honest to goodness self-introspection, whatever protestations they put up that they are only after the truth.
And for atheists who complain that I am repeating messages here like putting at the top of my posts a repeated preamble about my concept of God and my request for atheists to come up with man's organs of experience
in re empirical evidence or testing, that is necessary because they keep asking the same question about what is my concept of God and that I should produce empirical evidence.
Come to think of it, perhaps and almost certainly that is exactly their strategy to weary me out.
So, to atheists whom I notice to be into tergiversative gambits, for your information I will not read further as soon as I sense that you are into playing dummy, and I also won't even get started on your messages if you have already established a habit of writing evasively and wasting people's time here and the forum's bandwidth.
Yrreg