Are taxes lower under Obama than Bush?

Have you heard any politician claim President Obama raised taxes. Other than the health care mandate and increased Medicare

What you quoted was a direct response to this:


How many people who know what they are saying claim President Obama has raised income taxes.
As I indicated, the poll was over a year old, but at that point anyway there were plenty of people who believed taxes were higher under Obama than Bush.

I believe the OP is an attempt to debunk that fairly widespread meme.

I surely hope no Washington politicians or any other politician in the national spotlight has repeated such misinformation. I think there's been plenty of fear-mongering, though--suggesting that raising our taxes is the only thing Obama wants to do.
 
Given Obama's effectiveness at the podium, I am frequently taken aback by how poorly this administration has been at communicating such a basic message.

The message must be communicated. But I can see some reasoning behind the White House's not taking the lead - it could backfire on Obama, because his credibility with the people who need to know these numbers isn't high.

I wonder if there's a nonpartisan tax education group, if some strategy could be brought to bear on the best way to disseminate this information in a cogent, rational way. David Stockman seems to have some credibility on this.
 
Last edited:
But there's no reason to ignore the Making Work Pay tax credit, is there? So taxes aren't identical; they're lower under Obama.

No, taxes are not lower under Obama. Bush provided the same temporary advanced tax refunds in a different form - and the Making Work Pay credit has expired. Taxes are the same under Obama as they were under Bush. That Obama has not raised taxes in spite of the spending orgy Bush engaged is endoursment enough - or at least it should be for thinking persons.
 
I think that since I am making much less because the economy is worse, I am being "taxed" more now.

Only if you severely redefine the verb "tax".

In fact, if you are making much less money now, you are almost certainly being taxed less, and possibly even at a lower rate.
 
No, taxes are not lower under Obama. Bush provided the same temporary advanced tax refunds in a different form - and the Making Work Pay credit has expired. Taxes are the same under Obama as they were under Bush.

So do you think the numbers BenBurch posted are wrong? If so, what is your source for that information, and what should the numbers be?

My point about the Making Work Pay tax credits is that there is no reason not to count them in making this assessment.
 
Last edited:
No, taxes are not lower under Obama. Bush provided the same temporary advanced tax refunds in a different form - and the Making Work Pay credit has expired. Taxes are the same under Obama as they were under Bush. That Obama has not raised taxes in spite of the spending orgy Bush engaged is endoursment enough - or at least it should be for thinking persons.

But you do still have the 2% reduction in payroll taxes.
 
So do you think the numbers BenBurch posted are wrong? If so, what is your source for that information, and what should the numbers be?

The numbers Ben posted include temporary reductions in nominal tax rates - and are easily offset by Bush's tax credits. In real dollars, US citizens are paying the same federal income taxes now as they were in 2008.

It is not necessary to distort the facts IOT demonstrate that taxes have not risen under Obama - although his (and Bush's) tax relief measures were deficit spending.

My point about the Making Work Pay tax credits is that there is no reason not to count them in making this assessment.

I did not discount them. I pointed out that Bush had similar measures that were discounted in Bens figures.

You are quibling - taxes under Obama remain functionally identical to taxes under Bush.
 
But you do still have the 2% reduction in payroll taxes.


We don't actually. The marginal tax rates have remained unchanged since at least 2006. That the 5 marginal rates are spread over very slightly different brackets doesn't actually change anything.

ETA: Are you talking about the 2% temporary (now expired) reduction in employee social security contributions?
 
Last edited:
We don't actually. The marginal tax rates have remained unchanged since at least 2006. That the 5 marginal rates are spread over very slightly different brackets doesn't actually change anything.

ETA: Are you talking about the 2% temporary (now expired) reduction in employee social security contributions?

Yes, the 2% percent temporary reduction. Although it does not expire until the end of 2011.

I agree 100% that tax brackets should be exactly the same as 2003 since they have only been indexed for inflation since then.

Middle class people with rental property losses have seen inflation incroach on their allowed deductions because certain thresholds for that have not been adjusted.
 
The numbers Ben posted include temporary reductions in nominal tax rates - and are easily offset by Bush's tax credits. In real dollars, US citizens are paying the same federal income taxes now as they were in 2008.
So you think his numbers were wrong? That he included these temporary cuts for 2010 but not for 2008 and 2001*?

*ETA: And as pointed out the tax cuts passed in 2001 would not have applied to that year.
 
Last edited:
So you think his numbers were wrong? That he included these temporary cuts for 2010 but not for 2008 and 2001*?

*ETA: And as pointed out the tax cuts passed in 2001 would not have applied to that year.

I'm at a loss as to which part you don't understand?

The marginal tax rates are unchanged. They are identical. There are five of them. The income thresholds for these brackets have changed - and that change has nothing at all to do with the identity of the President. Taxes are the same now as they were under Bush.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom