Are taxes lower under Obama than Bush?

Tax rates are basically unchanged since 2003 , who claims income taxes are higher now. That is why the current rates are called the Bush cuts
 
Last edited:
You're welcome. I find that digging out the real data on something is not as hard as it looks, and that the deceptions a lot of people attempt are predicated on nobody being arsed to go check on the data themselves.
I know. I dug up the data when someone claimed the economy under Bush grew an average of 3.5%. In truth the average was .75%.The average was never higher than 1.6. The DJIA was no better.
 
Given Obama's effectiveness at the podium, I am frequently taken aback by how poorly this administration has been at communicating such a basic message.
 
Given Obama's effectiveness at the podium, I am frequently taken aback by how poorly this administration has been at communicating such a basic message.

A major point in President Obama's campaign was no taxes on anyone below 250,000
 
On inflation, $40,000 in 1980 dollars is approximately $109,000 now.

The tax on that, $7,332.50 would be approximately $20,000 now

I estimate current tax on $109,000 to be $18,500.

Still down from St. Ronald Reagan.

OH! I should have used 1988!

$40,000 in 1988 is around $76,300 today.
Equivalent tax is around $14,000.

2010 tax on $76,300 is $11,444 from the tables.

Constant year dollars calculated using; http://146.142.4.24/cgi-bin/cpicalc.pl
Thanks for the update. I just wanted to make sure we were working with accurate numbers. Obama cut taxes on taking office but his election somehow spawned the Taxed Enough Already party. That can't be repeated often enough.

Daredelvis
 
What did Bush have to do with tax rates in 2001?
Bush proposed and signed the Economic Growth and Tax Relief Reconciliation Act of 2001.

The Economic Growth and Tax Relief Reconciliation Act of 2001 (Pub.L. 107-16, 115 Stat. 38, June 7, 2001), was a sweeping piece of tax legislation in the United States by President George W. Bush. It is commonly known by its abbreviation EGTRRA, often pronounced "egg-tra" or "egg-terra", and sometimes also known simply as the 2001 act (especially where the context of a discussion is clearly about taxes), but is more commonly referred to as one of the two "Bush tax cuts".

I've yet to find when the tax cuts started. WildCat doesn't ask silly questions the way I do so I suppose this is not a naive question. I'll be back.
 
Last edited:
H.R. 1836

The reductions in individual income tax rates and the increase in the child tax credit would begin in 2001 and phase in over time. The creation of a new income tax bracket with a tax rate of 10 percent would also begin in 2001, and would include an advance refund mechanism to provide taxpayers with most of the benefit for tax year 2001 before fiscal year 2001 ends. Other provisions would start in later years. Provisions in the act generally sunset at the end of calendar year 2010.
So that would seem to be the answer. Bush proposed and enacted H.R. 1836 (EGTRRA) and the new rates began in 2001. Right?
 
Last edited:
How many people who know what they are saying claim President Obama has raised income taxes?

Did you see the homemade signs at Glen Beck's rally? Those people thought they knew what they were saying and they were pretty sure Obama was crushing us with Communist level taxes. Then they went and elected Tea Partiers to congress with explicit mandate to lower taxes to more acceptable (which I guess to them is nothing) levels.
 
Did you see the homemade signs at Glen Beck's rally? Those people thought they knew what they were saying and they were pretty sure Obama was crushing us with Communist level taxes. Then they went and elected Tea Partiers to congress with explicit mandate to lower taxes to more acceptable (which I guess to them is nothing) levels.

Expect that lie to keep being repeated. I heard it on the radio just today.
 
Except for temporary blanket refunds, taxes under Obama are virtually identical to taxes under Bush, and neither side can claim an advantage and still pretend to have clue what they are talking about.

Of course, Obama can fairly claim not to have engaged in two seperate and very expensive wars while lowering revenue.
 
The point is that they are not higher in spite of the constant lies to the contrary.

Constant lies to the contrary? While I have heard people express fear that Obama will raise taxes (true, if he can), I have not heard anyone claim that he has actually done so. You are exaggerating.
 
Except for temporary blanket refunds, taxes under Obama are virtually identical to taxes under Bush, and neither side can claim an advantage and still pretend to have clue what they are talking about.

But there's no reason to ignore the Making Work Pay tax credit, is there? So taxes aren't identical; they're lower under Obama.
 
How many people who know what they are saying claim President Obama has raised income taxes.

Knowing what you're talking about is not a prerequisite to making political speech (like carrying signs at Tea Party rallies) or even for voting!

About a year and a half ago, this poll showed that about 1/4 of Americans think taxes have gone up during Obama's administration. Among just self-identified Tea Party supporters, 44% believed taxes have gone up.
 
Knowing what you're talking about is not a prerequisite to making political speech (like carrying signs at Tea Party rallies) or even for voting!

About a year and a half ago, this poll showed that about 1/4 of Americans think taxes have gone up during Obama's administration. Among just self-identified Tea Party supporters, 44% believed taxes have gone up.
Have you heard any politician claim President Obama raised taxes. Other than the health care mandate and increased Medicare
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom