Are Jones' Energy Release Observations Significant?

Do tell us, won't you, how much Fe2O3 we can remove from an ideal thermite mix before we have to declare it to be something else. 01% ? .1% ? 1% ? 10% ?

Most likely there isn't a hard-and-fast definition, but I think a rational definition would be a mixture capable of a self-sustaining thermite reaction. What the limits are on that, we don't know for certain, as the Google blurb for the Missouri paper doesn't contain enough information. It's even more complicated than that, though, because Jones and co-workers point out that only part of their sample is reacting to give off the heat spike, and the presence of the inert grey layer means that the energy density of the part that's reacting is at least twice that of a stoichimetric thermite mixture. Without some idea of the relative masses of reactive and inert sections of the sample, we can't say anything more than that the substance cannot be near-stoichimetric thermite, and that the lower limit of its energy density barely overlaps what we think is the upper limit of energy density for non-stoichimetric thermite.

Ideally, they'd have done measurements both in air and in an inert ambient, and quantised the ratio of reactive material to inert grey layer, then we'd know for certain what proportion of the energy was released due to which oxidiser. At the moment there's still an outside chance that the heat is evolved from a thermite reaction, but really it's no more than that. It falls dismally short of the level of proof Jones would like to think he's achieved.

Dave
 
Metamars is trying to retreat to the position that the material cannot be proven not to be unreacted thermite.

Wrong. metamars is refuting the specific claim (or refutation) that 8 kJ/g DSC reading for what is claimed to be a Al/Fe2O3 nanothermite, done in a container containing oxygen, does not, ipso facto, mean that the substance cannot be identified as thermite.

metamars never claimed that the substance in the Harrit, Jones, et. al. paper is nanothermite. Rather, Harrit, Jones, et. al., have made this claim. You are conflating me with them.

I've made it clear that I am not convinced by the Harrit paper, and neither am I convinced by Sunstealer (who has probably made the best points against the paper). My position hasn't changed. What also hasn't changed is my observation that all manner of BS arguments get thrown against the Harrit paper by "debunkers".

Once again, I would encourage 911 truthers to take the paper to domain experts who can properly evaluate it. It seems like a huge mistake to me to focus on debunkers, media, or government. Having said that, I have to admit that Harrit appearing on Danish television will probably help direct the attention of domain experts to his paper. Even if most Danish scientists don't watch TV, their kids probably do.

However, if the paper turns out to be mistaken in its conclusions, that's not going to turn out very well for the 911 truth movement, that certainly has more complaints about the "investigations" into 911 events, besides the buildings collapsing.
 
I think I understand what Metamars is trying to claim, and what is the basis for that claim. Let's go from the beginning. Metamars googled "nanothermite" + "fuel rich" and found an abstract from the University of Missouri-Columbia which doesn't itself mention different fuel mixtures. He hasn't read the paper because it's a pay-to-download journal, but the small excerpt provided by the Google search page also includes the text, "Nanothermite composites containing metallic fuel and inorganic oxidizer are gaining importance ... defined asbetween 0.6 (fuel lean) and 1.8 (fuel rich). ...".

At this point, we depart from reference and embark on speculation. Metamars has speculated that, if 1.8 is a viable ratio for a thermite reaction, and this reaction results in complete combustion of the excess aluminium with ambient air making up the required balance of oxidiser, then the energy density of such a mixture is just high enough that it could account for the highest energy density reported by Jones and co-workers, assuming that the sample giving this energy density had no grey layer present (because the presence of the grey layer would require that part of the sample be inert, hence the energy density of the reacting portion would be even higher).

Now, apart from the fact that this is based on an interpretation of a brief excerpt of the paper taken completely out of context (Does anyone here have a subscription to Applied Physics Letters? I don't, but it's a prestigious enough journal that I would expect anyone in a university physics department could lay their hands on a copy; Appl. Phys. Lett. 91, 243109 (2007) if anyone can find it), the important point is this. The paper claims proof that the material found in the dust samples is unreacted thermite. Metamars is trying to retreat to the position that the material cannot be proven not to be unreacted thermite. Since the collapse mechanism of the Twin Towers has been described in several peer-reviewed papers, the authority claimed by Jones for this paper requires that its proof be absolute and irrefutable; otherwise, the appeal to the authority of Bazant's series of peer-reviewed papers overturns the appeal to the authority of Jones's single paper that has been through a somewhat suspect peer-review process. Therefore, lack of disproof is not good enough.

Of course, had Jones and co-workers carried out their DSC measurements in an inert atmosphere - dry nitrogen would have done nicely, and is usually available in a well-found laboratory - the situation would be much clearer. Unfortunately, their experiments were done in a way almost certain to yield false positive results.

Dave

So if this is indeed the case, and if the actual speculation is that there was a thermite redox to completion plus a burning of the remaining Al with O2, then we can account for the energy density?

All right. That argument works as an excuse. Problem is, it also illuminates the failure of the paper itself: The authors only cite the total energy release, and handwave some explanation that the additional energy could have come from "air oxidation". They do no work to differentiate between the thermite redox energy or energy from an elemental aluminum/elemental oxygen reaction. Of course they couldn't, because the reactions as a practical matter cannot be separated. But that right there is the whole problem: Because the reactions cannot be separated, where do they get the thesis that part of the heat was provided by a thermite reaction? How is it that they can say the end result was 'X' KJ/g, some of that came from thermite, some came from another oxidation, therefore this supports the thermite conclusion? It is entirely possible (and let's be blunt: Probable) that a thermite redox contributed zilch to that overall energy output, and if the other material in the chip - or the aluminum, to use Metamars's argument - was what was oxidizing, then that could account for the amount of energy seen. What's my point? My point is that they do not establish that any of the energy produced is from a thermite redox. They merely presume it.

Metamars has come up with a reasonable excuse for why the energy difference exists, but it very clearly demonstrates that the experiment (as well as lines of argument extending from it) is flawed because it highlights the fact that they did no work to prove that a thermite reaction actually occurred to contribute to the heat observed.

And above all that, this whole argument we're indulging in is being generous at presuming that what everyone else has thought was the result of reasonable, rational consideration. To be blunt, I doubt that. I've yet to see any of these truthers actually make the argument that the excess energy release is actually due to a non-thermite reaction. The only ones who've stated it were the authors of the paper, and if we're correct, Metamars here himself. The crux of everyone else's posts defending the energy-release-proves-thermite proposal is that the energy release is high, that means explosives/incendiaries/thermite, full stop. And that's an unsupported leap, especially given the disclaimer the paper's authors gave.

So we're still back at the beginning: To get the additional energy that was observed, we have to posit a different reaction than the thermite redox. And to do so, we would need to presume that the thermite reaction only contributed part of the heat. If we do that, how can this be taken as evidence supporting thermite? Given that we have to presume it's presence to make the argument work? And also given that we could end up with the same energy release in the absence of thermite?

Dave, of course, you would have figured this or something similar out already. I work my thoughts out so laboriously not for your benefit - you hardly need my two cents to figure stuff out - but rather for the benefit of other readers. But I think the overall point is clear: The measurement of energy density contributes nothing in support of the thesis that they found thermite. It's ridiculous to cite it as evidence that they have.
 
I'm going to have a go at explaining this rather than simply nominating it for a Stundie. Galileo, the normal process of publishing involves charging the reader for access to the material, and is predicated on the assumption that the material published is of suffucient quality for customers to be prepared to pay for that access. Vanity publishing involves charging the originator for the publication of the material, and in general involves material of poorer quality (whatever the appropriate definition of the word "quality" may be in context), because originators of content for which there is significant demand will take the cheaper (for them) route of normal publishing. In other words, pay-to-publish is for material that nobody particularly wants to read. It may be that this is simply because the customer base isn't aware of the material, in which case it may then progress from vanity to conventional publishing routes; or it may simply be that nobody but the author believes the material is worthy of dissemination.

Bentham is no less a pay-for-play operation than any conventional journal; the difference is, simply, who pays. A conventional journal relies on its reputation for producing high quality material to induce readers to pay to read it. It competes with other similar journals most effectively by offering higher standards of quality of content. Bentham, on the other hand, must rely on the willingness of authors to submit material to it, and the commercial pressures on it are to accept more material, and impose poorer quality standards, in order to compete with any other similar publications. Regardless of whether the Bentham journals have responded to these pressures so far, in the long run it will inevitably be an issue for open journals in general that commercial pressure is opposed to high standards of content quality.

Dave


Sort of like trusting the biographical information in the average "Who's Who" compared to a reference encyclopedia.
 
The same thing I've been saying this whole time, and that you don't appear to be understanding: The enthalpy of a thermite reaction is 3.9 kj/mole. If you're now invoking a straight Aluminum oxidation with elemental oxygen, you're no longer talking about a thermite reaction.

Really, how hard is that to understand? You're saying that the thermite ingredients were present, but they failed to react with each other? Because if you're saying the elemental aluminum reacted with the oxygen in the air, that's exactly what you're getting at. At that point, why the hell apply thermite to begin with? Why not just plant aluminum and set that on fire?

My point is made. You are making it for me. You are discussing a different reaction than a thermite redox now.

Sigh.

Your thinking is fallacious, because you are constraining it in this question via a dichotomizing characterization. My questions were specifically worded so as to help you break out of that mental straight-jacket. You know, the ones you ducked about .01%, etc? If you enjoy your mental prison, fine, but don't ask me to enter it with you.

BTW, I thank you for not admitting defeat too quickly. I looked more closely at the enthalpies involved.

2 Al + 3/2 O2 --> Al2O3 ΔH = -1672 kJ

thermite reaction:
Fe2O3 + 2Al --> 2Fe + Al2O3 ΔH = -768.75 kJ

In my 'mama pajama' calculation, I hadn't really thought about this. (Well, looks like I unconsciously assumed it would be the same for both reactions.) However, it's obvious that since ΔH for the thermite reaction is so much lower (in magnitude) than for the Al + O2 gas reaction, you don't need to cut the Fe2O3 by 2 thirds in order to double the theoretical maximum density of stoichiometric thermite. It's probably closer to cutting it by half of that amount, or to 2/3 of the stoichiometric Fe2O3 component.

As for your question of why not just use no solid oxidizer at all, I think the answer depends on the specific use that a nanothermite is intended for. But basically, I think the key parameter that needs to be considered is speed of reaction. I find it hard to believe that the speed of reaction of a fuel rich nanothermite will be as fast as a stoichiometric one. There is probably data on this in the reference I cited, that talks about fuel rich thermites.

And speed matters, does it not? Otherwise, one could demolish buildings with peanut butter and paper. Also, the Allies would have made a mistake in WW2 by adding thermite to incendiary bombs, when plain old waste paper would have done the job.
 
Ah. Discussion occurred while I was composing.

If you define thermite as Al and Fe2O3, in exact, stoichiometric proportions, then saying that the red/gray chips aren't thermite, based on the DSC data, would have some significance.

However, if you talk about thermite more loosely, then you have no point, at all. (Well, right now. If we can narrow down the samples as to content more precisely, then this may, indeed, be a significant point. Or, what if Harrit does future DSC tests in a vaccuum or inert gas, and comes to find that they're still getting 8kJ/g? Then, you would have a point. The point that has validity right now is Sunstealer's, whereby they have introduced ambiguity into their data by doing the tests with O2 present.)

Do tell us, won't you, how much Fe2O3 we can remove from an ideal thermite mix before we have to declare it to be something else. 01% ? .1% ? 1% ? 10% ?

Whatever you decide is the correct answer, do tell what we should call it if we add 1 grain of Fe2O3 back, and the batch combusts with atmospheric 02, also, in spite of your definition. To help clarify the point further, it should help by considering a substance you call "thermite" as distinct from a "thermite reaction".

Metamars, my point was that simply citing the energy release in and of itself is actually proof against the material being thermite. Of course that presumes that the person defending that portion of the authors' experiment didn't realize that the energy release was in excess of a pure thermite reaction. If you're making the argument that aluminum and oxygen burning provided the rest of the energy, then you have certainly highlighted a possibility. This goes nowhere to proving thermodynamically that the chips were indeed thermite, but that does explain where the energy comes from. My point is limited to demonstrating that if we presume a pure thermite reaction in the absence of all else, the limit of energy density is the established 3.9 KJ/g, and anything above and beyond that cannot be handwaved as some "nano" property. The presence of another reaction can be used as an excuse for the energy, but the original point still stands: Nothing anyone does can elevate the energy density of a pure thermite reaction above 3.9KJ/g. That enthalpy is set, period. So arguing that a material is "energetic" in and of itself does zero to establish that the material is thermite, and arguing a figure above that 3.9KJ/b contradicts it. Presuming there is no other reaction.

The next logical step would be to establish that a thermite reaction did occur to contribute heat. Or, to ditch that line of argument altogether. Why? Again, as I said above, the entire energy output can be explained by an "alternate" reaction. So either thermite contributed some to it, or nothing at all, and if thermite contributed nothing at all, then the whole energy density experiment is nothing but noise, and should not be mentioned as doing anything more than establishing 1. The presence of organic compounds (something already established in the X-EDS data), or 2. The presence of Aluminum (if we presume that is what oxidized and lead towards the readings. And this too is already established in the X-EDS data). Otherwise, adding it does nothing but hurt the argument.

Most likely there isn't a hard-and-fast definition, but I think a rational definition would be a mixture capable of a self-sustaining thermite reaction. What the limits are on that, we don't know for certain, as the Google blurb for the Missouri paper doesn't contain enough information. It's even more complicated than that, though, because Jones and co-workers point out that only part of their sample is reacting to give off the heat spike, and the presence of the inert grey layer means that the energy density of the part that's reacting is at least twice that of a stoichimetric thermite mixture. Without some idea of the relative masses of reactive and inert sections of the sample, we can't say anything more than that the substance cannot be near-stoichimetric thermite, and that the lower limit of its energy density barely overlaps what we think is the upper limit of energy density for non-stoichimetric thermite.

Ideally, they'd have done measurements both in air and in an inert ambient, and quantised the ratio of reactive material to inert grey layer, then we'd know for certain what proportion of the energy was released due to which oxidiser. At the moment there's still an outside chance that the heat is evolved from a thermite reaction, but really it's no more than that. It falls dismally short of the level of proof Jones would like to think he's achieved.

Dave

I'm afraid that Metamars latched onto my point about stoichiometry as trying to narrowly define what thermite is. No, that wasn't why I brought it up. Again, the point I was making was that reactions can only achieve stoichiometric proportions and go no further, and that any excess of one reactant would reduce the heat release per gram of the material observed. Not increase it. Of course, that presumes no other reaction at all, and it turns out that Metamars might have been leaning towards that argument from the beginning (that another reaction was where the "extra" energy came from). If so, my point is still correct, but I'll admit it wasn't what Metamars was driving at.

Regarding your statement: Yes, I agree. It would have been nice to see some attempt at differentation between the thermite and the "organic" material oxidation. Given that that whole section went on about the energy release of thermite, you'd think they would have actually attempt to quantify what energy release was actually provided by thermite. But they didn't. So we're stuck. All in all, this goes to highlight that the authors were sloppy.

Wrong. metamars is refuting the specific claim (or refutation) that 8 kJ/g DSC reading for what is claimed to be a Al/Fe2O3 nanothermite, done in a container containing oxygen, does not, ipso facto, mean that the substance cannot be identified as thermite.

metamars never claimed that the substance in the Harrit, Jones, et. al. paper is nanothermite. Rather, Harrit, Jones, et. al., have made this claim. You are conflating me with them.

I've made it clear that I am not convinced by the Harrit paper, and neither am I convinced by Sunstealer (who has probably made the best points against the paper). My position hasn't changed. What also hasn't changed is my observation that all manner of BS arguments get thrown against the Harrit paper by "debunkers".

Once again, I would encourage 911 truthers to take the paper to domain experts who can properly evaluate it. It seems like a huge mistake to me to focus on debunkers, media, or government. Having said that, I have to admit that Harrit appearing on Danish television will probably help direct the attention of domain experts to his paper. Even if most Danish scientists don't watch TV, their kids probably do.

However, if the paper turns out to be mistaken in its conclusions, that's not going to turn out very well for the 911 truth movement, that certainly has more complaints about the "investigations" into 911 events, besides the buildings collapsing.

Fine. I now think I understand where you're coming from. And if you have decent criticisms of the paper yourself, good. But beware of stating "BS arguments"; it's one thing to write it off because we don't like Jones. It's a whole other to write off any of the points we've made that don't involve like or dislike. Regardless of what you were saying about the energy release, I've already seen others try to claim that it indeed demonstrates that thermite was used; I only clearly remember Bill Smith using the "nanoproperties" excuse, but I've seen it tossed around here. That's what my post above was addressing: The fallacy of thinking that higher and higher energy densities proved thermite. They don't. There's a limit. But given that you're proposing an alternate oxidation, I think it's safe to say that you're the only non-"debunker" here who's managed to realize that.
 
Sigh.

Your thinking is fallacious, because you are constraining it in this question via a dichotomizing characterization. My questions were specifically worded so as to help you break out of that mental straight-jacket. You know, the ones you ducked about .01%, etc? If you enjoy your mental prison, fine, but don't ask me to enter it with you.

BTW, I thank you for not admitting defeat too quickly. I looked more closely at the enthalpies involved.

2 Al + 3/2 O2 --> Al2O3 ΔH = -1672 kJ

thermite reaction:
Fe2O3 + 2Al --> 2Fe + Al2O3 ΔH = -768.75 kJ

In my 'mama pajama' calculation, I hadn't really thought about this. (Well, looks like I unconsciously assumed it would be the same for both reactions.) However, it's obvious that since ΔH for the thermite reaction is so much lower (in magnitude) than for the Al + O2 gas reaction, you don't need to cut the Fe2O3 by 2 thirds in order to double the theoretical maximum density of stoichiometric thermite. It's probably closer to cutting it by half of that amount, or to 2/3 of the stoichiometric Fe2O3 component.

As for your question of why not just use no solid oxidizer at all, I think the answer depends on the specific use that a nanothermite is intended for. But basically, I think the key parameter that needs to be considered is speed of reaction. I find it hard to believe that the speed of reaction of a fuel rich nanothermite will be as fast as a stoichiometric one. There is probably data on this in the reference I cited, that talks about fuel rich thermites.

And speed matters, does it not? Otherwise, one could demolish buildings with peanut butter and paper. Also, the Allies would have made a mistake in WW2 by adding thermite to incendiary bombs, when plain old waste paper would have done the job.

Read my points above. Your criticism of my "mental prison" are unwarranted.

On top of all of that, nothing you've said actually establishes that thermite provided even a portion of the energy observed. Again, that's merely presumed in the paper and in these arguments. None of that information in the paper actually establishes that thermite, whether in stoichiometric proportions or not, was actually present, let alone contributed to the heat given off. They burned material, they determined the enthalpy of that reaction, it doesn't match thermite, the "additional" must be due to another reaction. That's the thought process. Problem is, whether thermite contributed in part to that is never established.

My point is made. Arguments that do not presume the additional reactions, but merely say that the excess energy released is a result of some mysterious "nanoproperty" are vacuous. Energy being present due to some other reaction is not only possible, but practically certain; however that does nothing to establish thermite. Either way, that whole part of the paper is a waste.
 
Wrong. It can't be thermite in stoichiometric proportions. It should be possible to find out if a fuel-rich thermite that weighs half as much as a stoichiometrically proportioned version can still burn quickly enough that it explodes. What is your opinion on this matter? Can there be such a thing as thermite manufactured in non-stoichiometrically correct proportions, or is this impossible? If it's possible, can the thermite still be explosive?

While I haven't done chemistry calculations in decades, I believe that if they burn various chips, of known weight, in containers containing a variable amount of oxygen, they can determine the fuel/oxygen ratio within their samples.

Unfortunately, the chips will not have constant proportions between their red and gray layers - as can be inferred by looking at this one.

You might be interested to know that Dr. G. has remarked, regarding this paper ( Nanostructured Energetic Materials with Sol-gel Methods )on aerogel and xerogel composites of sol-gel iron (III) oxide and ultra fine grained aluminum (UFG Al)




I'm not sure why he's saying this, as iron containing particles in Harrit, et. al. Figure 9 don't look connected into some sort of gel network. However it's conceivable (to this laymen) that Fe2O3 particles are also embedded in a more tenuous Fe2O3 framework (such as can be seen in Figure 5 of Nanostructured Energetic Materials with Sol-gel Methods, at 5 nm scale ) which doesn't show up in a picture at 1 μm scale. In such a scenario, I would guess that the primary function of the gel is not energetic - i.e., to partake of the Al/Fe2O3 thermite reaction. Rather, it's primary function would be to keep the larger Al/Si platelets and Fe2O3 particles "suspended" close to each other:




(emphasis mine)

In the red gray chips, Fe2O3 in gel form would be "interlocked" with both Fe2O3 particles, and Al/Si platelets, thus "interlocking" the Fe2O3 particles and Al/Si platelets, with each other.

Nanothermite just reacts faster that thermite. The amount of energy stays the same it is just released at a faster rate.

http://www.answers.com/topic/thermite
http://www.answers.com/topic/super-thermites
 
My point is limited to demonstrating that if we presume a pure thermite reaction in the absence of all else, the limit of energy density is the established 3.9 KJ/g, and anything above and beyond that cannot be handwaved as some "nano" property. The presence of another reaction can be used as an excuse for the energy, but the original point still stands: Nothing anyone does can elevate the energy density of a pure thermite reaction above 3.9KJ/g. That enthalpy is set, period.
So arguing that a material is "energetic" in and of itself does zero to establish that the material is thermite, and arguing a figure above that 3.9KJ/b contradicts it. Presuming there is no other reaction.
Well, I certainly agree with this much.

Regardless of what you were saying about the energy release, I've already seen others try to claim that it indeed demonstrates that thermite was used;

I never said that 911 truthers weren't also throwing around BS arguments, probably based on their misunderstanding of the issues involved (plus their confirmation bias). :D Yet another reason to take the paper to domain experts, especially those who have little bias, one way or the other, or who can control what bias they do have through exercize of their intellects.

BTW, I tend to think that the greater energy released from an Al + O2 oxygen reaction should have made the researchers more cautious, since it would have made the DSC burning process more uncertain. Not sure about that, but in any case, I do wonder about why they didn't nail this down, better.
 
Last edited:
BTW, I tend to think that the greater energy released from an Al + O2 oxygen reaction should have made the researchers more cautious, since it would have made the DSC burning process more uncertain. Not sure about that, but in any case, I do wonder about why they didn't nail this down, better.

I can agree with that. Should've been a red flag.

If I were to be generous, I guess I could say that perhaps amounts of material present were too limited to really conduct many good tests on. But that leads to Sunstealer's argument: If the authors were truly serious about determining the composition, why dance around with a spectroscopic method that only reveals elements? And add to that yours and my contentions about the heat release figures: Why bother doing something that requires a roundabout argument? I don't know.

Look, I know that no experiment is ever truly ideal. And we see a ton of very non-ideal research coming from fields where uncertainty rules; look at how painfully medical knowledge advances. What you eventually get is very solid, but there's a helluva lot of pain separating noise from signal before you get there. But despite that, I too wish there were more rigor in the work. Forget it's venue of publishing, forget what the conspiratorial aspect of the paper is, why are some things left to argumentation - like this specific measurement - and not "nailed down"? I should be fair and allow that it could be a simple limitation like the one I mentioned above, but the cynic in me is hard to suppress in this case.
 
Last edited:
The WTC buildings weren't attacked in an oxygen free environment, and the DSC experiments in the Harrit paper weren't done in an oxygen free environment, either. Indeed, that has been a criticism of the paper by Sunstealer.

Certainly, you get the concept of drawing oxygen from both Fe2O3 and the gaseous environment, don't you?
Yes, we get it but if you wanted to show evidence of a reaction that occurs without air, such as the thermite one, then you do it in an inert atmosphere.

However, regardless of this, the thermite reaction cannot produce more energy than it's deltaHr, if it is doing so, then it isn't thermite or something else must be causing the increase over the ideal maximum.

Bearing in mind the chips were observed in a SEM and a carbon rich matrix is seen, it's obvious that what we are seeing is the ignition of that unknown matrix (most likely a binder for paint). In view of seeing that they didn't just have particles of Aluminosilicate and Fe2O3 they should understand that this matrix is likely to be flammable and therefore if they wish to test for a thermite reaction they must do it in an inert atmosphere.

If you define thermite as Al and Fe2O3, in exact, stoichiometric proportions, then saying that the red/gray chips aren't thermite, based on the DSC data, would have some significance.

However, if you talk about thermite more loosely, then you have no point, at all.
We are not talking about different types of thermite, because the Harrit et al paper specifically talks about Al + Fe2O3. Their own SEM data shows Fe2O3 crystals approximately 0.2µm in size in the red layer.

There are only two other constituents that they identify, one an aluminosilicate (which has the correct morphology and EDS spectrum that matches Kaolinite closely) 1µm and greater in size and a carbon rich matrix. Talk of anything else is pointless. You can speculate all you like about nano-this and nano-that, but we don't observe any particles that small and we don't observe any particles of Al. Talk of alligator breeding is just as far away as talk of nano-thermite in respect of this paper.

Wrong. metamars is refuting the specific claim (or refutation) that 8 kJ/g DSC reading for what is claimed to be a Al/Fe2O3 nanothermite, done in a container containing oxygen, does not, ipso facto, mean that the substance cannot be identified as thermite.

metamars never claimed that the substance in the Harrit, Jones, et. al. paper is nanothermite. Rather, Harrit, Jones, et. al., have made this claim. You are conflating me with them.

I've made it clear that I am not convinced by the Harrit paper, and neither am I convinced by Sunstealer (who has probably made the best points against the paper). My position hasn't changed. What also hasn't changed is my observation that all manner of BS arguments get thrown against the Harrit paper by "debunkers".
So why are you desperately googling for any any term with nano-thermite in and throwing it into the mix? I've seen absolutely zero work from you regarding what I am saying, although in your defence no other truther has bothered to try and they are letting the official moderated thread die - it's no surprise they won't tackle it head on because they don't even know where to start from.

Why are you spending all of your time on the thermite side and not looking to see whether conclusions, based on available data, are correct?

It makes you look like a truther. It looks to everyone like you are trying to defend the paper. If not then where is the balance? Why are you not also spending time looking for things that explain the paper without reference to thermite and then weigh your own evidence?

As ElMonndoHummus points out in post #25, the experiment is flawed and no conclusion of a thermite reaction can be claimed. So why are you not acknowledging this massive failure and see it as a black mark against the paper? If they failed in such a basic matter why doesn't that make you suspicious of their other claims? Could they also be failing in other basic areas?

<snip snide remarks>

2 Al + 3/2 O2 --> Al2O3 ΔH = -1672 kJ

thermite reaction:
Fe2O3 + 2Al --> 2Fe + Al2O3 ΔH = -768.75 kJ

In my 'mama pajama' calculation, I hadn't really thought about this. (Well, looks like I unconsciously assumed it would be the same for both reactions.) However, it's obvious that since ΔH for the thermite reaction is so much lower (in magnitude) than for the Al + O2 gas reaction, you don't need to cut the Fe2O3 by 2 thirds in order to double the theoretical maximum density of stoichiometric thermite. It's probably closer to cutting it by half of that amount, or to 2/3 of the stoichiometric Fe2O3 component.
You go on and on about the Al. You continue to make claims based on reactions that contain Al. For this to happen you NEED particles of Al, whereby Al is the dominant element with only O present as would be expected. Where is this Al? Show me the Al? Show me the particles? Point to them in this photo!

picture.php


I see no aluminium particles. Does anyone else?

Why do we see massive amounts of Si, O and C let alone Na, Fe and K in these platelets if we require particles of commercially pure Aluminium >99% which is available off the shelf by the thousands of tons for either the thermite reaction or reaction with O2 from air? If there's no Al particles there is no thermite reaction or with air.

picture.php


Why do you continue with ideas about Al when there is no particle in the sample that matches what you are speculating with? You can keep on and on and on, but you are not describing anything that is actually in the samples! Therefore your theories about what constitutes thermite of whatever variety in whatever proportion of reactants is utterly, utterly useless. Might as well talk about zombies, they have as much relevance.

There are no particles with a high enough concentration (99%) of Aluminium in the red or gray layers in samples a) to d) whether they are available for oxidation with air or for a thermite reaction or just taking pretty pictures. If they are then I want someone to point them out to me.

N.B. IMPORTANT - Do not quote the MEK chip EDS data - it is a different material (which has been proven) to samples a,b,c,d that were used for the DSC.
 
I never said that 911 truthers weren't also throwing around BS arguments, probably based on their misunderstanding of the issues involved (plus their confirmation bias). :D Yet another reason to take the paper to domain experts, especially those who have little bias, one way or the other, or who can control what bias they do have through exercize of their intellects.
I did something similar today.

I took out all of the text, no reference to anything just the pure data, no photographs like Figs 2 & 3, I married up the SEM pics and the EDS data and printed it out onto 2 sides of A4 only for samples a,b,c,d. When I had time I asked 3 people who have 30+ years experience each what they thought it was - Figs 4 and 5 were last. No prompting just that question. What do you think this is? I did get a couple of funny looks especially from Malcolm who said, Come on Sunstealer, you know what that is! when referring to Fig 6. It's rust!

All of them said it was rusted steel with a layer of paint attached. Each one of them wanted to know what this was about and I just said, "I'll tell you some day". I daren't ask Bob (researches high temperature experimental alloys) who spends 2 days in the office, because he'd just look at me bizarrely and say, "Good god man, it's paint! What on earth do you want to know that for?", and then I'd have to educate the poor old sod about the internets at which point he'd shake his head and say, "haven't you got anything better to do?". Then he'd have an even stranger view of me.
 
I will make an overall comment, then reply to specific points. Overall comment is that you seem awfully interested in me, as opposed to my arguments. You thus reveal a bias of your own which in no way makes you a better candidate as a rational critic of the Harrit paper.

We are not talking about different types of thermite, because the Harrit et al paper specifically talks about Al + Fe2O3. Their own SEM data shows Fe2O3 crystals approximately 0.2µm in size in the red layer.
Can you show me where they claim that Al and Fe2O3 is present in stoichiometrically correct proportions? Didn't think so.
There are only two other constituents that they identify, one an aluminosilicate (which has the correct morphology and EDS spectrum that matches Kaolinite closely) 1µm
And a DSC that doesn't match that of raw kaolinite. You dismissed this as "chalk and cheese", but didn't bother explaining. Also, I've made an effort to understand the differences in readings generated by the micron level DSC vs. a regular DSC. Have you? Excuse me if my confidence in your kaolininte theory is less than complete. Since you are so fixated on Harrit, et. al., not having dotted every i and crossed every t, I'm sure that you'll eventually dot all of your i's and cross all of your t's. Correct? Actually, I doubt that you will dot every i and cross every t, which is why I hope to get a hold of somebody who will answer these basic questions. Posting in the Science forum didn't help, either. I am, frankly, beginning to doubt if the poll that showed that 48% of respondents were qualified scientists has any significance.

and greater in size and a carbon rich matrix. Talk of anything else is pointless. You can speculate all you like about nano-this and nano-that, but we don't observe any particles that small and we don't observe any particles of Al.
You may well be correct on this point. Too bad you haven't proven it, yet. (Which is not to say that Harrit, et. al. have proven that the platelets are rich in elemental Al).

So why are you desperately googling for any any term with nano-thermite in and throwing it into the mix?
Desperately? Compulsively, maybe, (it's not like I don't have real work that I should be doing), but I am not "desperate" as regards the final disposition of what the red/grey chips are, one way or the other. So, why would I "desperately" google for nano-thermite to "throw it in the mix"?

This is yet an example of where you are making a personal argument.

You've also reminded me of a question I've now put to you twice. Here goes the third time. Are you, or are you not, going to write a coherent, ad hominem free report on the Harrit paper which we could print out and show to domain experts, along with the Harrit paper? There is no need for you to "desperately" do this - if you took, say 3 weeks, that would be no skin off of anybody's back. See, no need for me to frame you as a "desperate" debunker, although your numerous ad hominems don't cast you in a favorable light.

I've seen absolutely zero work from you regarding what I am saying, although in your defence no other truther has bothered to try and they are letting the official moderated thread die - it's no surprise they won't tackle it head on because they don't even know where to start from.
It took a long time to find the references I did. Some ended up only here at JREF, some went to Harrit, et. al. - where, in the case of the LIBS method, Jones expressed warm appreciation.
Why are you spending all of your time on the thermite side and not looking to see whether conclusions, based on available data, are correct?

It makes you look like a truther.

Too bad. And by the way, I am a "truther", which doesn't mean that I buy all of the arguments embraced by various individuals in the truth movement, or I have some sort of pathological need for red/gray chips to turn out to be nanothermite, as opposed to paint chips, or anything else.

It looks to everyone like you are trying to defend the paper.
Again, with the personal stuff. As for "defending the paper", was I defending it when I posted

Speaking for myself, I am particularly interested in what scientists with relevant domain expertise have to say about the use of XEDS in the thermitic paper, as well as some detailed suggestions for other methods (hopefully not too costly) which would yield more definitive results. If there is insufficient elemental Al in the Jones chips, then they are not thermite.

Was I "defending the paper" when I emailed Harrit, et. al., a verbatim copy of Dr. Greening's most significant (as far as I could tell) criticism?

If not then where is the balance? Why are you not also spending time looking for things that explain the paper without reference to thermite and then weigh your own evidence?
Again with the personal stuff. It's really none of your business how I prioritize my time. (And to be perfectly honest, I often question myself as to why I spend all the time I do on this stuff. No good answer, yet! )

As ElMonndoHummus points out in post #25, the experiment is flawed and no conclusion of a thermite reaction can be claimed. So why are you not acknowledging this massive failure and see it as a black mark against the paper?
Sometimes it pays to read a thread carefully, before you post something that is contradictory to what you're claiming, only a few posts back. I do this, myself, so I'm not going to beat you over the head for this. However, I again will point out that you are asking a personal question.

E.g., I haven't asked you why you didn't bother to look up kaolinite DSC's, and why you didn't bother to see if silicon platelets can be manufactured. Also, why you didn't bother to debunk the nonsense put forth by other debunkers, such as thermite being 70% titanium*, or nano-thermite being just like classic thermite, just faster reacting, or, as you can see in this very thread, the total energy released from nanothermite is the same as from non-nanothermite?

Too busy writing your coherent paper, which truthers and debunkers could take to domain experts, along with the Harrit paper, to try and quickly identify problems with both their paper and your counter-arguments? I like to think that's true, but as you've avoided answering my question about your wonderful rebuttal, I assume that you ain't gonna bother. Funny, that.

If they failed in such a basic matter why doesn't that make you suspicious of their other claims?
Yes, it does.
Could they also be failing in other basic areas?
Absolutely! And that, once again, is a reason to take their paper to domain experts, who will more readily see failures and defects that I can.

You go on and on about the Al. You continue to make claims based on reactions that contain Al. For this to happen you NEED particles of Al, whereby Al is the dominant element with only O present as would be expected. Where is this Al? Show me the Al? Show me the particles? Point to them in this photo!

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=181&pictureid=916[/qimg]

I see no aluminium particles. Does anyone else?
If there's elemental Al in their sample, you know where it is. And by the way, speaking of platelets, you claimed that the Harrit paper's platelets showed a hexagon morphology. Perhaps you'd be good enough to to a highlighting of the edges that appear in the Harrit pictures, and point these hexagons out. Anything hexagonal looks few and far between.

Why do we see massive amounts of Si, O and C let alone Na, Fe and K in these platelets if we require particles of commercially pure Aluminium >99% which is available off the shelf by the thousands of tons for either the thermite reaction or reaction with O2 from air?
As you know better than I, you can't do a simple translation of peaks in the XEDS sprectra to quantitative ratios. Correct? If I'm wrong, feel free to correct me, and tell me what the ratio is of Si to Al.

Si is used to help make a eutectic with Al, at about 11%, IIRC. If it's 50%, then I'd start to wonder. Is it?

One reason I have trouble with your statement is because of another statement of yours, viz.,

EDS/EDX/XEDS basically will tell you what elements are present - and that's about it really.

So, you cast doubt on the Harrit claims of elemental Al, because they are using a line of evidence that can't be relied on to give you proportions, but somehow we can use XEDS to determine that there is "massive amounts of Si...".

So, which is it? Can we use Harrit's data to claim equal parts Al to Si (an example of a "massive" amount of Si, I trust), 11% Si, or neither, because "XEDS basically will tell you what elements are present - and that's about it really".

As for the rest of those "massive amounts", do us a favor and tell us what those "massive amounts" are, quantitatively, also. If you can't do that, you should be eager for more rigorous tests, to conclusively confirm or contradict the claims of Harrit, et. al. At least, that's what I would have expected of a real scientist, who is looking at this objectively, as best he can.
If there's no Al particles there is no thermite reaction or with air.
Yup. And this is what I posted at 911blogger, for all the world, and 911 truth community, to see. Nothing new about that.
 
The WTC buildings weren't attacked in an oxygen free environment, and the DSC experiments in the Harrit paper weren't done in an oxygen free environment, either. Indeed, that has been a criticism of the paper by Sunstealer.

Certainly, you get the concept of drawing oxygen from both Fe2O3 and the gaseous environment, don't you?
yes, but that invalidates the Kj/g stated in the paper, we dont know how many grams of reactant participated in the reaction, since an unmeasured amount of free oxygen was consumed
 
yes, but that invalidates the Kj/g stated in the paper, we dont know how many grams of reactant participated in the reaction, since an unmeasured amount of free oxygen was consumed

Yes, it makes it impossible to interpret, unambiguously. However, it's not inconsistent with a high fuel ratio nanothermite.

I think you'll find my next post interesting.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom