Are Jones' Energy Release Observations Significant?

JamesB

Master Poster
Joined
May 27, 2006
Messages
2,152
Now I don't have much of a science background, but I do have a basic understanding of statistics, and I was wondering if those of you with a better understanding could tell me if I was doing this right.

I was reading Jones new thermite paper and I noticed the graph on page 21 regarding the energy release of their samples, where they argue:

http://www.bentham-open.org/pages/content.php?TOCPJ/2009/00000002/00000001/7TOCPJ.SGM

It is striking that some of the red/gray chips release more energy in kJ/g than does ordinary thermite, as shown in the blue bar graphs above. The theoretical maximum for thermite is 3.9 kJ/g [27]. We suggest that the organic material in evidence in the red/gray chips is also highly energetic, most likely producing gas to provide explosive pressure. Again, conventional thermite is regarded as an incendiary whereas super-thermite, which may include organic ingredients for rapid gas generation, is considered a pyrotechnic or explosive [6, 24]. As this test was done in air it is possible that some of the enhancement of energy output may have come from air oxidation of the organic component.

But as they mention, only 2 of the 4 samples released energy above that of thermite. Looking at their bar chart (I don't see anywhere they give the exact number, so this is an estimate) one comes up with the following (plugged into Excel):

Sample Kj/g
1 1.2
2 2.5
3 7.2
4 5.8
Avg 4.175
StdDev 2.795681193

There is a huge variance and therfore a huge standard deviation. The thermite they are comparing it to has an energy release of 3.9 Kj/g. So when I had Excel do a z-test using 3.9 as the total population, it returned a .42, which if I recall correctly indicated there is a 42% chance that the population they are sampling actually has a lower energy release than thermite.

Now this type of sampling is normally used for things like marketing surveys, but isn't this well below the typical 2 standard deviations, 95%, normally used to determine statistical significance?

Note, this is also leaving aside the question as to whether having a higher energy release than thermite would actually mean anything to begin with.
 
Last edited:
They're significant in that they prove the stuff isn't thermite.

Nano- or not, if the stuff really is thermite, it should come in pretty close to 4 kJ/g, or if some bizarre alternate metal formulation was found, maybe more, maybe double that. But for darn sure if it is some precision-engineered compound, it would perform pretty much the same regardless of sample.

It doesn't. The measurements are all over the map. Imagine having to use an explosive that varied up to six times in its potential, with no way to predict it.

On the other hand, flakes of paint, all damaged by heat to varying degrees, containing different amounts of rust flakes from the steel columns from whence they came, give you exactly this kind of behavior and exactly this rough order of magnitude of energy.
 
They're significant in that they prove the stuff isn't thermite.

Nano- or not, if the stuff really is thermite, it should come in pretty close to 4 kJ/g, or if some bizarre alternate metal formulation was found, maybe more, maybe double that. But for darn sure if it is some precision-engineered compound, it would perform pretty much the same regardless of sample.

It doesn't. The measurements are all over the map. Imagine having to use an explosive that varied up to six times in its potential, with no way to predict it.

On the other hand, flakes of paint, all damaged by heat to varying degrees, containing different amounts of rust flakes from the steel columns from whence they came, give you exactly this kind of behavior and exactly this rough order of magnitude of energy.

I like how he just invents new terms when he doesn't find what he wants.

Tech: Sir, this sample cannot be thermite.

Jones: must be nanothermite.

Tech: How will we test for nanothermite?

Jones: Tests!! We don't need no stinkin' tests!!! (cue gunfire)
 
I like how he just invents new terms when he doesn't find what he wants.

Tech: Sir, this sample cannot be thermite.

Jones: must be nanothermite.

Tech: How will we test for nanothermite?

Jones: Tests!! We don't need no stinkin' tests!!! (cue gunfire)

This makes no sense. Nano-thermite is thermite, just in smaller particles.

The lead auther was not Jones, either. He wasn't even the second author. I think you have Jones fixation.
 
This makes no sense. Nano-thermite is thermite, just in smaller particles.

The lead auther was not Jones, either. He wasn't even the second author. I think you have Jones fixation.

You are right, it doesn't make sense, now get Jones to explain why his theories don't make any sense.

Yes, Jones is technically not the lead author, but he has been the main proponent of derivations of this theory for years, so he pretty much owns it.
 
You are right, it doesn't make sense, now get Jones to explain why his theories don't make any sense.

Yes, Jones is technically not the lead author, but he has been the main proponent of derivations of this theory for years, so he pretty much owns it.

Jones' scientific thesis has been confirmed in a peer reviewed scientific journal.

Furthermore, unlike most scientific journals, Bentham is not a vanity journal.

Most journals sell their papers vanity-style to any scientist who will pay for it.

Not Bentham. They do not require you to buy their journal, they post it for free on the Internet, they are not a pay-for-play operation.

The future of science is with the Bentham marketing model.
 
Jones' scientific thesis has been confirmed in a peer reviewed scientific journal.

Wrong. It was published in the "journal" not confirmed.

Furthermore, unlike most scientific journals, Bentham is not a vanity journal.

Wrong. Not only is it a Vanity Journal, but it is a particularly dubious one at that. Sending out mass viral emails to obtain members for its editorial board, whether they are qualified or not.

Most journals sell their papers vanity-style to any scientist who will pay for it.
Not Bentham. They do not require you to buy their journal, they post it for free on the Internet, they are not a pay-for-play operation.

Have you lost your mind completely?

The whole point of an Open Access Journal, is to allow people to have the content for free. That is why they charge the AUTHORS to publish. You obviously have no idea what a "Vanity" journal is.

The future of science is with the Bentham marketing model.

Part of the future in science and research will likely be in the "Open Access" model, but the real scientific community will hardly buy, pay for, or put up with the likes of Bentham.

TAM:)
 
Most journals sell their papers vanity-style to any scientist who will pay for it.

Not Bentham. They do not require you to buy their journal, they post it for free on the Internet, they are not a pay-for-play operation.

I'm going to have a go at explaining this rather than simply nominating it for a Stundie. Galileo, the normal process of publishing involves charging the reader for access to the material, and is predicated on the assumption that the material published is of suffucient quality for customers to be prepared to pay for that access. Vanity publishing involves charging the originator for the publication of the material, and in general involves material of poorer quality (whatever the appropriate definition of the word "quality" may be in context), because originators of content for which there is significant demand will take the cheaper (for them) route of normal publishing. In other words, pay-to-publish is for material that nobody particularly wants to read. It may be that this is simply because the customer base isn't aware of the material, in which case it may then progress from vanity to conventional publishing routes; or it may simply be that nobody but the author believes the material is worthy of dissemination.

Bentham is no less a pay-for-play operation than any conventional journal; the difference is, simply, who pays. A conventional journal relies on its reputation for producing high quality material to induce readers to pay to read it. It competes with other similar journals most effectively by offering higher standards of quality of content. Bentham, on the other hand, must rely on the willingness of authors to submit material to it, and the commercial pressures on it are to accept more material, and impose poorer quality standards, in order to compete with any other similar publications. Regardless of whether the Bentham journals have responded to these pressures so far, in the long run it will inevitably be an issue for open journals in general that commercial pressure is opposed to high standards of content quality.

Dave
 
This makes no sense. Nano-thermite is thermite, just in smaller particles.
the theoretical maximum enthalpy for thermite is about 3.9 Kj/g, so anything above that cant be thermite

also, IIRC thermite is the most exothermic reaction known, so they have either discovered a hitherto completely unknown chemical reaction, or (much more likely) have tainted results
 
the theoretical maximum enthalpy for thermite is about 3.9 Kj/g, so anything above that cant be thermite

also, IIRC thermite is the most exothermic reaction known, so they have either discovered a hitherto completely unknown chemical reaction, or (much more likely) have tainted results

Wrong. It can't be thermite in stoichiometric proportions. It should be possible to find out if a fuel-rich thermite that weighs half as much as a stoichiometrically proportioned version can still burn quickly enough that it explodes. What is your opinion on this matter? Can there be such a thing as thermite manufactured in non-stoichiometrically correct proportions, or is this impossible? If it's possible, can the thermite still be explosive?

While I haven't done chemistry calculations in decades, I believe that if they burn various chips, of known weight, in containers containing a variable amount of oxygen, they can determine the fuel/oxygen ratio within their samples.

Unfortunately, the chips will not have constant proportions between their red and gray layers - as can be inferred by looking at this one.

You might be interested to know that Dr. G. has remarked, regarding this paper ( Nanostructured Energetic Materials with Sol-gel Methods )on aerogel and xerogel composites of sol-gel iron (III) oxide and ultra fine grained aluminum (UFG Al)

One material is fine-grained aluminum/sol-gel iron oxide "nanothermite" amazingly similar to the red/gray chips found in WTC dust as recently reported by by Harrit, Jones et al.


I'm not sure why he's saying this, as iron containing particles in Harrit, et. al. Figure 9 don't look connected into some sort of gel network. However it's conceivable (to this laymen) that Fe2O3 particles are also embedded in a more tenuous Fe2O3 framework (such as can be seen in Figure 5 of Nanostructured Energetic Materials with Sol-gel Methods, at 5 nm scale ) which doesn't show up in a picture at 1 μm scale. In such a scenario, I would guess that the primary function of the gel is not energetic - i.e., to partake of the Al/Fe2O3 thermite reaction. Rather, it's primary function would be to keep the larger Al/Si platelets and Fe2O3 particles "suspended" close to each other:


The nanostructuring of the composite performs two unique functions relative to simple mixing of nanopowders. First, it provides very intimate mixing of the phases as the sol-gel phase is formed in situ, in a colloid of the added particulate phase, and it grows around the suspended particles.
This methodology promotes very intimate mixing of oxidizer and fuel. Second, it provides a three-dimensional nanostructure where the two phases are interlocked and will resist separation upon manipulation and have different properties relative to mixtures of nanopowders.

(emphasis mine)

In the red gray chips, Fe2O3 in gel form would be "interlocked" with both Fe2O3 particles, and Al/Si platelets, thus "interlocking" the Fe2O3 particles and Al/Si platelets, with each other.
 
Food for thought...

Sample Kj/g
1 1.2
2 2.5
3 7.2
4 5.8
Avg 4.175
StdDev 2.795681193

There is a huge variance and therfore a huge standard deviation. The thermite they are comparing it to has an energy release of 3.9 Kj/g. So when I had Excel do a z-test using 3.9 as the total population, it returned a .42, which if I recall correctly indicated there is a 42% chance that the population they are sampling actually has a lower energy release than thermite.

I think Jones' "energy release" and claims of this "energetic compound" is just an attempt to fool people who have no idea how such energies compare to other substances.

Right now I'm actually EATING a substance which has more energy per gram than thermite. It actually has about 25 kJ/Gram....that's over 6 times as much energy per gram as jones' super duper nano thermite chips. (And mighty tastier too)

Yes...I'm eating peanut butter.

Check my work:

24 servings * 200 Cal Each = 4800 Calories/jar
4800 Calories per jar / 793.8 Grams per jar = 6 Cals/Gram
1 Calorie = 4.184 KJ
6 Cals * 4.184 Kj = 25.104 Kj/Gram

Peanut Butter = 6 Cal/Gram
Jones' "thermite chips" = Approx 1.6 Cal/Gram
Potato Chips = Approx 5.4 Cal/Gram
 
I think Jones' "energy release" and claims of this "energetic compound" is just an attempt to fool people who have no idea how such energies compare to other substances.

Right now I'm actually EATING a substance which has more energy per gram than thermite. It actually has about 25 kJ/Gram....that's over 6 times as much energy per gram as jones' super duper nano thermite chips. (And mighty tastier too)

Yes...I'm eating peanut butter.

Check my work:

24 servings * 200 Cal Each = 4800 Calories/jar
4800 Calories per jar / 793.8 Grams per jar = 6 Cals/Gram
1 Calorie = 4.184 KJ
6 Cals * 4.184 Kj = 25.104 Kj/Gram

Peanut Butter = 6 Cal/Gram
Jones' "thermite chips" = Approx 1.6 Cal/Gram
Potato Chips = Approx 5.4 Cal/Gram

That's wonderful, but the point that thermite is not as energy dense as, e.g., paper was made quite a while ago. This is an example of a nitpick that I'm sure most scientists (say Ph.D. level materials scientists, or physical chemists) that you can take the Harrit paper to, would not make.

If your peanut butter could be used to, say, make jet fuel turn into a fireball in 1/3 second, by all means make your case. Also, after you ignite your peanut butter, let us know if you find any microspheres, won't you?
 
Last edited:
Wrong. It can't be thermite in stoichiometric proportions. It should be possible to find out if a fuel-rich thermite that weighs half as much as a stoichiometrically proportioned version can still burn quickly enough that it explodes. What is your opinion on this matter? Can there be such a thing as thermite manufactured in non-stoichiometrically correct proportions, or is this impossible? If it's possible, can the thermite still be explosive?

What in God's name is this supposed to mean? How would an excess of one reactant change the enthalpy to the point where it exceeds that of normal thermite? Did you even read the comment you're replying to?

the theoretical maximum enthalpy for thermite is about 3.9 Kj/g, so anything above that cant be thermite.

If you have 'X' amount of thermite releasing 3.9KJ/g, having .9X, .5X, or .1X should reduce your enthalpy per unit of mass. It does so because only the stoichiometric amounts of each reactant will participate in the reaction. What's left over is just deadweight. If your energy density increases, you've effectively demonstrated that the reaction in question is not what you thought it was.

Thought experiment - This is a stoichiometrically correct thermite reaction: Fe2O3 + 2Al = 2Fe + Al2O3

Mass per reactant:
Fe2O3: 159.6882 g/mole
2Al: 2 x 26.982 g/mole, so 53.964 grams for this reaction

Mass per product:
2Fe: 2 x 55.845g/mole, so 111.69 grams in this reaction
Al2O3: 101.9613 g/mole.

Add the reactants: 2Fe + Al2O3 = 111.69 g + 101.9613 g = 213.6513 g

You would end up with 213.65 grams of iron and aluminum oxide in a pile and an enthalpy measurement of -3.98 kilojoules/gram (negative because it is an exothermic reaction).

Now, recalculate with an obvious excess of one or the other reactant:

20Fe2O3 + 2Al = 2Fe + Al2O3 +18Fe

Mass per reactant:
20 Fe2O3: 20 x 159.6882g = 3,193.764 grams total
Al: 2 x 26.982g = 53.964 g

Mass per product:
2 Fe: 2 x 55.845 = 111.69g
Al2O3 = 101.9613 18 Fe2O3: 18 x 159.6882 = 2874.3876 You'd still have 213.65 grams of reacted product, but it's in a mass of over 3 kilograms of junk left at the end: 213-some grams of the thermite product, and the leftover 18 moles (which is ~ 2.87 kilograms) of iron oxide. You're dividing the heat released by the now bigger amount of material left over. This in no way should lead to a larger figure for energy release per gram. You can recalculate this with an excess of aluminum: Fe2O3 + 20Al = 2Fe + Al2O3 + 18Al Mass per reactant: Fe2O3: 159.6882 g/mole 20 Al: 20 x 26.982 g/mole = 539.64g Mass per product: 2Fe: 2 x 55.845 = 111.69g Al2O3 = 101.9613 18Al: 18 x 26.982 = 485.676 g. You'd end up with the same 213.65 grams of reactant plus 485.68g of leftover aluminum, for a total of 699.33 grams of iron, aluminum oxide, and plain aluminum sitting in a pile. But again, you've only reacted the 213.65 grams, so you only have the 850-some kilojoules of heat released, but now you're dividing that over 699.33 grams, not just 213.65 grams. Once again, you end up with less joules per gram. The bottom line here is that providing a non-correct ratio of one reactant to another should not result in an increase in heat released per gram. Plug in any numbers you want, but the result demonstrates the same trend. This is exactly why any argument that supposed "nano" properties of thermite fail: There is an absolute limit to the enthalpy of an iron oxide - aluminum redox reaction, and nothing anyone does can increase that. You can refine the particles for a more complete real-world release, but the maximum remains the same regardless. So demonstrating an energy density higher than the maximum possible for thermite is de facto admitting that you weren't looking at thermite to begin with. That's just basic, 100-level chemical thermodynamics. ------ Others with chemistry backgrounds: Please correct anything I may have gotten wrong. I haven't touched a chem textbook since the early 90's, so regardless of how basic this concept is, I'm really struggling to remember if I'm doing things right or not. And yes, I'm being careless with significant digits, I'm presuming reactions to 100% completion, yadda yadda... I realize that. This is just a back-of-the-envelope calc I'm doing, after all, so I definitely could've borked something up.
 
Last edited:
What in God's name is this supposed to mean? How would an excess of one reactant change the enthalpy to the point where it exceeds that of normal thermite? Did you even read the comment you're replying to?
The WTC buildings weren't attacked in an oxygen free environment, and the DSC experiments in the Harrit paper weren't done in an oxygen free environment, either. Indeed, that has been a criticism of the paper by Sunstealer.

Certainly, you get the concept of drawing oxygen from both Fe2O3 and the gaseous environment, don't you?

Al can burn with no solid oxidizer present, at all.

Aluminum powder is a light, silvery-white to gray, odourless powder. It is a REACTIVE FLAMMABLE MATERIAL. Moist aluminum powder may ignite in air, with the formation of flammable hydrogen gas. It is also a COMBUSTIBLE DUST. When aluminum powder comes in contact with water, strong acids, strong bases or alcohols, it releases flammable hydrogen gas. It can react violently or explosively with many inorganic and organic chemicals. Aluminum powder is essentially non- toxic following short-term exposure.
(emphasis mine)

BTW, the Grainier thesis has many graphs of DSC's of aluminum nanoparticles and O2 gas.
 
Last edited:
The WTC buildings weren't attacked in an oxygen free environment, and the DSC experiments in the Harrit paper weren't done in an oxygen free environment, either. Indeed, that has been a criticism of the paper by Sunstealer.

Certainly, you get the concept of drawing oxygen from both Fe2O3 and the gaseous environment, don't you?

Al can burn with no solid oxidizer present, at all.

And this changes things how? Now you yourself are trying to say that there was no iron-oxide/aluminum redox, but rather aluminum burning in air. Either way, you're coming back to the argument that this wasn't thermite.
 
The bottom line here is that providing a non-correct ratio of one reactant to another should not result in an increase in heat released per gram. Plug in any numbers you want, but the result demonstrates the same trend.
From physicsforums.com:

2 Al + 3/2 O2 --> Al2O3 delta H = -1672 kJ

so, the reaction is exothermic.

This is exactly why any argument that supposed "nano" properties of thermite fail: There is an absolute limit to the enthalpy of an iron oxide - aluminum redox reaction, and nothing anyone does can increase that.

Well, what do you have to say, now?
 
From physicsforums.com:

2 Al + 3/2 O2 --> Al2O3 delta H = -1672 kJ

so, the reaction is exothermic.



Well, what do you have to say, now?

The same thing I've been saying this whole time, and that you don't appear to be understanding: The enthalpy of a thermite reaction is 3.9 kj/mole. If you're now invoking a straight Aluminum oxidation with elemental oxygen, you're no longer talking about a thermite reaction.

Really, how hard is that to understand? You're saying that the thermite ingredients were present, but they failed to react with each other? Because if you're saying the elemental aluminum reacted with the oxygen in the air, that's exactly what you're getting at. At that point, why the hell apply thermite to begin with? Why not just plant aluminum and set that on fire?

My point is made. You are making it for me. You are discussing a different reaction than a thermite redox now.
 
Others with chemistry backgrounds: Please correct anything I may have gotten wrong.

I think I understand what Metamars is trying to claim, and what is the basis for that claim. Let's go from the beginning. Metamars googled "nanothermite" + "fuel rich" and found an abstract from the University of Missouri-Columbia which doesn't itself mention different fuel mixtures. He hasn't read the paper because it's a pay-to-download journal, but the small excerpt provided by the Google search page also includes the text, "Nanothermite composites containing metallic fuel and inorganic oxidizer are gaining importance ... defined asbetween 0.6 (fuel lean) and 1.8 (fuel rich). ...".

At this point, we depart from reference and embark on speculation. Metamars has speculated that, if 1.8 is a viable ratio for a thermite reaction, and this reaction results in complete combustion of the excess aluminium with ambient air making up the required balance of oxidiser, then the energy density of such a mixture is just high enough that it could account for the highest energy density reported by Jones and co-workers, assuming that the sample giving this energy density had no grey layer present (because the presence of the grey layer would require that part of the sample be inert, hence the energy density of the reacting portion would be even higher).

Now, apart from the fact that this is based on an interpretation of a brief excerpt of the paper taken completely out of context (Does anyone here have a subscription to Applied Physics Letters? I don't, but it's a prestigious enough journal that I would expect anyone in a university physics department could lay their hands on a copy; Appl. Phys. Lett. 91, 243109 (2007) if anyone can find it), the important point is this. The paper claims proof that the material found in the dust samples is unreacted thermite. Metamars is trying to retreat to the position that the material cannot be proven not to be unreacted thermite. Since the collapse mechanism of the Twin Towers has been described in several peer-reviewed papers, the authority claimed by Jones for this paper requires that its proof be absolute and irrefutable; otherwise, the appeal to the authority of Bazant's series of peer-reviewed papers overturns the appeal to the authority of Jones's single paper that has been through a somewhat suspect peer-review process. Therefore, lack of disproof is not good enough.

Of course, had Jones and co-workers carried out their DSC measurements in an inert atmosphere - dry nitrogen would have done nicely, and is usually available in a well-found laboratory - the situation would be much clearer. Unfortunately, their experiments were done in a way almost certain to yield false positive results.

Dave
 
And this changes things how? Now you yourself are trying to say that there was no iron-oxide/aluminum redox, but rather aluminum burning in air. Either way, you're coming back to the argument that this wasn't thermite.

If you define thermite as Al and Fe2O3, in exact, stoichiometric proportions, then saying that the red/gray chips aren't thermite, based on the DSC data, would have some significance.

However, if you talk about thermite more loosely, then you have no point, at all. (Well, right now. If we can narrow down the samples as to content more precisely, then this may, indeed, be a significant point. Or, what if Harrit does future DSC tests in a vaccuum or inert gas, and comes to find that they're still getting 8kJ/g? Then, you would have a point. The point that has validity right now is Sunstealer's, whereby they have introduced ambiguity into their data by doing the tests with O2 present.)

Do tell us, won't you, how much Fe2O3 we can remove from an ideal thermite mix before we have to declare it to be something else. 01% ? .1% ? 1% ? 10% ?

Whatever you decide is the correct answer, do tell what we should call it if we add 1 grain of Fe2O3 back, and the batch combusts with atmospheric 02, also, in spite of your definition. To help clarify the point further, it should help by considering a substance you call "thermite" as distinct from a "thermite reaction".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom