Archeologly proves the Bible?

But the temple itself probably existed. We have quite a few references about it in Jewish culture.

I don't think anybody is arguing that the Bible got everything wrong. In fact, some books of the old testament such as the two books of the Kings seem based on relatively factual historical chronicles. There are some interpretation and more than a little propaganda, but it inspires a relative level of confidence.

Other books are pure fiction. The Old Testament, one should keep in mind, is an accidental reunion of unrelated books by different authors, from various time periods and with a variety of motives.
 
"All these places are mentioned in the Harry Potter books, therefore if we keep looking we'll eventually find Hogwarts!"

Of course it's there. I should know; I fly in and out of the airstrip on the property in my DH Twin Otter many times ---- On my Microsoft Flight Simulator 2004. There is an addon for Hogsmere, near Loch Ness. The graphic detail is excellent. One can drive a car around all the roads, past the quiddich ground, up to the castle. I have landed a float plane on the lake as well.


That's pretty sweet. Next they should do a broom-stick add on for FS.
 
"That's pretty sweet. Next they should do a broom-stick add on for FS. "

I have the Coyote's Acme Rocket from the Road Runner Show.

Simon, Do you have FS?
 
"That's pretty sweet. Next they should do a broom-stick add on for FS. "

I have the Coyote's Acme Rocket from the Road Runner Show.

Simon, Do you have FS?


Nope; I murked around an old version back in the day but not in many years.
 
I beg to differ. I recommend the book "Christ in Egypt" The Jesus-Horus Connection" D.M. Murdock (2009). You will find that all Christianity is based on myths. I also recommend studying the history of the First Council of Nicea. I recommend ex.minister.org. As a bedraggled refugee from the "Holy" Roman Catholic Church, now free to learn the truth, I can attest to the accuracy of all these sources.

em hotep

heard the Jesus-Horus claims before, bit narrow minded imho to claim that the antics of Jesus are based on just one pagan God and on the whole most of the similarities only work if you twist them a little and ignore a lot of evidence
:)
 
Did you try ex.minister.org? I cannot provide the URL. I have not got my number of posts to 50 yet. At The Council of Nicea, the Church Fathers at the request of Constantine I voted on the new god to be a combination of Hesus Krishna which, when the letter "J' was added to the alphabet became Jesus Christ.

em hotep
 
Have you been to Kings cross station? (it exists) Have you seen platform 9 3/4 (it exists) Have you seen Downing Street? (it exists).

All these places are mentioned in the Harry Potter books, therefore if we keep looking we'll eventually find Hogwarts!
__________________

[/quote]

Well, the way I look at it is this: it's in my computer. I've written more words about it than J.K. Rowling has, so I figure I've got proprietary rights to it too. True, the copyright holders may not agree. However, all I have to do is to conceal what I've written more cunningly than she has (I've got some really, really cunning plans, you see), and then 100,000 years from now, when aliens come down to study the lost civilizations of earth, my fanfic versions of what really happened at Hogwarts will be the only ones in existence. Come on-- it worked for the books that got into the Bible, so it should work for me! :p
 
I beg to differ. I recommend the book "Christ in Egypt" The Jesus-Horus Connection" D.M. Murdock (2009). You will find that all Christianity is based on myths. I also recommend studying the history of the First Council of Nicea. I recommend ex.minister.org. As a bedraggled refugee from the "Holy" Roman Catholic Church, now free to learn the truth, I can attest to the accuracy of all these sources.

em hotep

Dorothy Murdock's self-published works have been specifically addressed and debunked by people far more interested in pursuing her specifically than I am. I actually gave Dorothy the offer of discussing it personally, to which she responded with personal insults. In the meantime, another self-published author friend of hers, Jan Irvin, decided to come at me on his own website with personal insult and angry epithets, and there are at least one or two people other than myself who post in this forum who can attest to it (his forum is member-view-only, though I have copies of the discussion). Since I know for a fact that Dorothy relies on the writings of Gerald Massey (who repeated mistakes Budge originally made and backward-interpreted vignettes), direct mistaken interpretations (early on she made the "Isis-Ra-El" mistake, but dropped that in favor of the "meri-Mary," "Anup," and other mistranslations), and for someone who claims to know so many languages she fails to produce any primary sources and instead relies on mistaken Greek interpretations of Egyptian society, as well as taking some European 20th century scholars out of context.

In other words, if you're attesting to Dorothy's sources, that doesn't speak very well to your own credibility.

I would like to make this observation. It is my opinion only. I seem to have a feeling that Israeli Archaeologists have a biased approach to their work. They want to find evidence for the factual nature of their Torah. It is amazing how many artifacts dug up or appearing in private collections have been proved to be forgeries. The Ossurary of James is the best example. I am not saying that Solomon did not exist and that there was not a Temple, but until irrefutable evidence is found by unbiased Archeologists the Temple has to be regarded as only possible

Interestingly, a fellow poster here (rmackey) came up with what he called the Inflationary Model of Conspiracy Theories (and corrolary), to which you've just provided an inflated excuse to support your conspiracy theory. Mr. Mackey's model goes as follows:
RMackey said:
The Inflationary Limit of Conspiracy Theories is reached when it requires those questioning the conspiracy theory to be a part of the conspiracy. This final excuse occurs because any alternate hypothesis, no matter how well it fits the known facts, is viewed as a threat to the conspiracy hypothesis. No further inflation is possible because, when this point is reached, any criticism is considered suspect -- thus encompassing the entire world outside the conspiracy hypothesis.

Conversely, reaching the Inflationary Limit logically implies that any alternate hypothesis is superior to the conspiracy hypothesis.

Therefore, a conspiracy theory that reaches the Inflationary Limit is by definition the worst of all possible hypotheses.

So, how far does this conspiracy you suggest go, eccles? How many groups are supposedly in on it? I can guarantee you that I can go pound-for-pound on the evidence, and if you like we can take a look at the primary sources together and I can show you how to translate them and see for yourself how hokey the claims are. The fact is that "Horus" isn't even a single figure in Egyptian mythology, and is instead a number of aspects of divinity representing the union of Upper and Lower Egypt. This is, in fact, why so many pharaohs (though not all) were considered divine in and of themselves-- they were the human embodiment of Horus on Earth.

As for the Temple in Israel, what you suggest is preposterous. What the general reputable scholarly position tends toward is a Temple (and, incidentally, a kingdom of Israel) that was historically much smaller than claimed in the religious story. No need to make excuses for it, because the plain and reasonable assessment of the stories of the Temple (and the kingdom) is that the religious fervor inflated the descriptions in much the same manner as the proverbial "well, my daddy is so strong he can lift a car!" types of narrative.
 
Did you try ex.minister.org? I cannot provide the URL. I have not got my number of posts to 50 yet. At The Council of Nicea, the Church Fathers at the request of Constantine I voted on the new god to be a combination of Hesus Krishna which, when the letter "J' was added to the alphabet became Jesus Christ.

em hotep

That sounds like some good, old-fashioned Madame Blavatsky level syncretism right there (along with being completely unsupported by any primary source)
 
Nothing personal here. How many of you bible-believers are locked into blind faith and no reason and logic?


em hotep
 
Nothing personal here. How many of you bible-believers are locked into blind faith and no reason and logic?


em hotep

Instead of offering insults, how about trying evidence?

As I keep having to explain to you conspiracy theorists, I'm not a Christian (or anything else). Suggesting I'm in on it simply inflates the excuses for the conspiracy theory. Is everyone who finds your claims preposterous in on it?
 
Did you try ex.minister.org? I cannot provide the URL. I have not got my number of posts to 50 yet. At The Council of Nicea, the Church Fathers at the request of Constantine I voted on the new god to be a combination of Hesus Krishna which, when the letter "J' was added to the alphabet became Jesus Christ.

em hotep

I'm sorry, but that is preposterous. Please provide evidence for this extraordinary claim.

Here are my reasons for suspecting that you will not be able to provide anything even close to proof for this bald assertion (preferably a primary source document, but anything that doesn't come from a 19th or 20th century pseudo-historian would be welcome): 1. Why would the Church Fathers be voting on the name of God in the first place, and then chose two names completely outside their own religious tradition? The idea is absurd. 2. Why, among all the names available to them, would they chose the combination of a Hindu goddess's name, a deity from a region scarcely known to the inhabitants of the 4th Century Roman Empire, and the name of an obscure minor Celtic god of only marginal significance to the Romans? 3. The origin of the names Ἰησοῦς (Latininzed to Iesus) and Χριστός (latinized to Christus) are well known. "Krishna" only superficially resembles "Christos", and the letter "J" is merely an alteration of the letter I, and under no circumstances would it replace H or the Greek letter Eta.
 
Last edited:
Nothing personal here. How many of you bible-believers are locked into blind faith and no reason and logic?

em hotep
Nothing personal here, but did you ever learn to use reason, or critical thinking?

Might want to do so at some point.

DR
 
Nothing personal here. How many of you bible-believers are locked into blind faith and no reason and logic?
I'm a bible-believer who is locked into blind faith and no reason and logic!!

Did I win anything?
 
Nothing personal here. How many of you bible-believers are locked into blind faith and no reason and logic?

Unlike some here, I DO get personal...

Excuse me, but do you have any blanking idea where you're posting? Really? Most of the people here are anything but "Bible-believers." We have several discussion threads going on right now where atheists are directly challenging the literalism of the handful of Christian morons who dwell here to spread their lies and annoy anyone with half a brain. Believe me the last thing many of care about is the Damn Bible!

However, what we do care about are the facts. If we're going to give the Fundies the lambasting they so rightly deserve, we're going to need facts (e.g. historical, scientific, literary) to combat their BS, not more BS. We do care about reason and logic, which is why we roll our eyes at this Zeitgeist malarkey.
 
Last edited:
Ok, Guys, I might have gone too far with the 'blind faith" comment. I don't want to be "Scourged" yet. I shall stick only to the topic from now on.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom