Apollo 11 Moon Landing Revisited: Hoax ~vs~ Debunk

Are you saying that polyester base photographic film isn’t a thing?

Because despite your ignorance of how it might work, polyester backed photographic film is in fact a thing, that has been around for a long time, that has some advantages over acetate film that was previously used (it’s more chemically stable for example, not prone to vinegar syndrome).

This is something you can simply look up on Google, or in your local library or in magazine articles. Did you even bother to Google how polyester film is made or works before asking questions like this?

Are you going to go full conspiracy theorist and deny the existence of polyester based photographic film?
Okay, so are you saying the film Ektachrome developed specifically for Apollo11 was definitely polyester backed, with no gelatine?
 
Okay, so are you saying the film Ektachrome developed specifically for Apollo11 was definitely polyester backed, with no gelatine?
There you go again.

You've already been told, multiple times, that the film used was selected, from available options, for the mission, not specially developed.
 
Silver bromide is used because it is highly light-sensitive. Its crystals are used in a gelatine backing because on exposure to light (which happens when you click the knob, opening the shutter on the lens) it creates a negative image which only becomes apparent on development of the film ALWAYS. Just as surely as common table salt dissolves in water. Gelatine is used because the silver bromide crystals are cube-shaped, which fit well together when formatted on a gelatine base. I am rather sceptical of JayUtah's claim they didnt use (the organic) gelatine on the Moon (given it would have been destroyed by ionizing radiation [the same reason hello?!!! for the space suit protection {yes, and these rays do penetrate camera frames}]) but used polyester instead.
Ok, youre confused about what film base is and what emulsion is. You can Google these things to find out what they are and fix your confusion.

They didn’t use polyester “instead” of gelatin. Polyester was the film base, gelatin is the emulsion for the film. It makes no sense to talk about using polyester “instead” of gelatin. What are you talking about?

Can you quote Jay’s post where he claimed that gelatin wan’t used, but polyester was used “instead” of gelatin?
 
We were talking about the word 'invariably'. X-rays (and also alpha- and gamma- rays) invariably ruin camera film.

Except when they don't. Again, specifics and quantities are important. You can't just jump from a general observation of tendency to a quantitative conclusion about a likely result in a specific circumstance. For that, you would need to use your numbers acumen and physics education.

Alpha particles can be blocked by a sheet of paper, so they aren't likely to pose a threat to film inside a solidly-built camera.

Alpha is also the only species you mention that would be significantly attenuated by the small volume of air inside a pressurized compartment (though, again, this would have been redundant for film inside a solidly-built camera). Gamma and x-rays not so much. If these latter two were sufficient to ruin the film used on the Apollo missions, then they should also have ruined the film used on the Lunar Orbiter missions. They didn't, because you're wrong.



Silver bromide is used because it is highly light-sensitive. Its crystals are used in a gelatine backing because on exposure to light (which happens when you click the knob, opening the shutter on the lens) it creates a negative image which only becomes apparent on development of the film ALWAYS. Just as surely as common table salt dissolves in water. Gelatine is used because the silver bromide crystals are cube-shaped, which fit well together when formatted on a gelatine base. I am rather sceptical of JayUtah's claim they didnt use (the organic) gelatine on the Moon (given it would have been destroyed by ionizing radiation [the same reason hello?!!! for the space suit protection {yes, and these rays do penetrate camera frames}]) but used polyester instead.

Gelatin is for the emulsion. Polyester is for the film base (i.e. the structural backbone of the film). The material polyester replaced was cellulose acetate, not gelatin. I myself have learned this over the course of this thread. You, for all your claims about your high intelligence and keen grasp of concepts, apparently still have not.

I await to hear with interest how silver bromide crystals sit on polyester.

View attachment 78091

No one said they did. That's a figment of your incomprehension.
 
Last edited:
I am rather sceptical of JayUtah's claim they didnt use (the organic) gelatine on the Moon (given it would have been destroyed by ionizing radiation ...
I made no such claim.

They used a different film base, but one that was commercially available at the time. The "gelatin" is the medium for the emulsion. You insist on using the wrong words for everything. The emulsion was the same emulsion as the commercially available Ektachome. That's what makes it Ektachrome.

Neither cellulose acetate nor polyester is especially sensitive to radiation. However, polyester has far better mechanical performance in temperature extremes. Hence it is better for use in space.

The medium of the emulsion is also relatively inert to radiation and relatively unaffected by changes in temperature.

The silver salt crystals held in place on the base by the "gelatin" are of course sensitive to radiation. That's their job. They are specifically sensitive to visible light. They would be sensitive to soft x-rays were those x-rays capable of penetrating the film magazine or the lens. Since soft x-rays are fully absorbed by far less than a millimeter of aluminum, there was no danger. Higher energy particles (not photons) can penetrate the film magazine and may be absorbed by the silver crystals, but the flux of these particles is far too low to matter. And in fact a microscopic examination of the film shows that a few of these particles did in fact leave traces in the film.

When you find time to stop putting words in my mouth, perhaps you'd like to answer my questions.

Was Trevor Weaver lying when he said the TETR satellites were capable of carrying television signals? Was Marcus Allen lying when he claimed stars should be incidentally visible in the Apollo photos?
 
Last edited:
Once the film is changed, you know? Once it comes to the end. The Apollo11 astronauts had to remove and replace the film casing with their hands still wearing thick gloves.
In what way do you think there would be additional exposure to radiation when the film magazines were changed? Have you ever seen seen a film back on a medium format camera?
 
In what way do you think there would be additional exposure to radiation when the film magazines were changed? Have you ever seen seen a film back on a medium format camera?
Don't you realise that changing a magazine invariably ruins the film? It lets all the radiation in!

If you ever see something that's claimed to be a photograph, it's a hoax. Cameras actually contain very small demons with paintbrushes. I've read about them in a book.
 
In what way do you think there would be additional exposure to radiation when the film magazines were changed? Have you ever seen seen a film back on a medium format camera?
Prior to changing magazines, the astronauts took several sacrificial exposures to wind the important exposures deep within the magazine. The primary radiation exposure to film still near the gate was from visible light.
 
Vixen continues to wallow in her abject ignorance of all things related to photography.
It gets her ten more pages.

Her latest stunt appears to be misattributing something to me so that she'll be sure to get at least one post out of me correcting her.
 
Last edited:
We were talking about the word 'invariably'. X-rays (and also alpha- and gamma- rays) invariably ruin camera film.
No, they don't. You were ignorant before, but you're just knowingly lying now. You've been shown photographs of the remains of Reactor 4 under Chernobyl, emitting orders of magnitude more particle radiation than anyone would encounter during the entire duration of an Apollo mission. Pretending you can't see that doesn't make it go away for the rest of us. Radiation, even the types actually encountered in cislunar space, don't invariably ruin film any more than heat invariably kills people.

Silver bromide is used because it is highly light-sensitive. Its crystals are used in a gelatine backing because on exposure to light (which happens when you click the knob, opening the shutter on the lens) it creates a negative image which only becomes apparent on development of the film ALWAYS. Just as surely as common table salt dissolves in water. Gelatine is used because the silver bromide crystals are cube-shaped, which fit well together when formatted on a gelatine base. I am rather sceptical of JayUtah's claim they didnt use (the organic) gelatine on the Moon (given it would have been destroyed by ionizing radiation [the same reason hello?!!! for the space suit protection {yes, and these rays do penetrate camera frames}]) but used polyester instead.

I await to hear with interest how silver bromide crystals sit on polyester.
You are confusing the emulsion with the film base. These are two different things. The earliest base was a glass plate, with the emulsion of silver halide coating it. Early photographic film used a celluloid base. Polyester base was a step forward from that.

So the answer to your question that you think can't be answered is that the silver halide emulsion coats the polyester like paint coats a car body. Once more, in an attempt to assert your superior knowledge of everything, you only manage to betray your ignorance and pretentiousness.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom