Aphelion: time to clarify the FDNY's role in WTC7

CHF restart the thread but just you and I. If you pretend to not know what I am talking about though, I will leave it.
We all know exactly what you're talking about. You're desperately trying to claim the FDNY was in on it, while at the same time denying it. Why don't you just admit you're wrong and move on?
 
one on one? CHf destroyed your claims aphelion.

All CHF has to ask is why destroy a burning building just to aid rescue efforts? that would be illogical.
 
If you want to go one on one wth CHF, fine, but do so in this thread, there are enough threads about the same things as it is.
 
CHF asking me to tell you exactly what happened between which people is ridiculous. I can't possibly know. You are using one of Russells disinfo tactics, namely "Demanding complete solutions".

I could also play that game. Please tell me exactly what happened on the planes before they crashed.
 
I will debate you on this tomorrow CHF. Lets see how you fare without your group of distractors to help you.

I look forward to it. Have a good evening.
 
no he isn't asking for complete solutions. the fact that you can't see the fallacy in your own claims is telling.
 
I will debate you on this tomorrow CHF. Lets see how you fare without your group of distractors to help you.

I look forward to it. Have a good evening.


translation : I can't explain myself, or why i think the WTC 7 was demolished and the FDNY fully knew that it would be demolisehd, but they decided to cover up the whole thing, yet they are not in on the conspiracy.
 
I could also play that game. Please tell me exactly what happened on the planes before they crashed.

Start another thread if you want to talk about hijackers. But if you must know, fully-licensed amateur pilots hijacked the airplanes and pointed the nose at their targets.....
 
OK...just you and me, kid.

Everyone else: Ssssshhhhhhhhhh! Please don't disturb Aphelion's intense concentration.

OK, now that we're alone...

WTC7 was demolished for noble reasons, yes?

OK. Let's assume that's true.

1) why would the FDNY (or anyone else) lie about it? Why cover up a demolition done for....:rolleyes:....rescue op reasons?

2) if someone lies about an incident by, say, misrepresenting the reason for a building collapse (as you're claiming the FDNY is), then how can that not make them complicit in the cover-up of the demolition?

Take your time, Aphelion.

And feel free to admit anytime that your logic makes no sense. Everyone here already knows. You can at least take comfort in the fact that the great Jason Bermas didn't fair any better at tackling the FDNY problem than you have.
 
Last edited:
CHF,

I won't partake in this thread, as per your wishes. However I did just want to say something. Aphelion, as you may recall, it was originally me that raised this issue.

While you act like a child and insult people, you are clearly demonstrating that YOU don't understand what I was saying.

The collapse of WTC7 due to structural damage and fire is part of the OFFICIAL ACCOUNT of the September 11 terrorist attacks. This version is currently based primarily on the mountain of testimony from dozens upon dozens of FDNY personnel. Their statements are unequivocal. WTC7 had suffered massive structural damage, was a raging inferno, and WAS going to collapse. The area around it was evacuated BY ORDER OF THE FDNY because of this imminent collapse.

Now, pay attention.

If your account is true - that WTC7 was brought down by controlled demolition - there is absolutely no way whatsoever this could happen WITHOUT FDNY KNOWING ABOUT IT.

That means all of their testimony, all of their statements, are LIES. They are fabrications. They are deceit, created to cover up the demolition.

That makes FDNY complicit in a cover-up of the September 11 Terrorist Attacks.

I will not discuss this matter any further as you have demonstrated a total and utter failure to grasp a hold of this very basic fact. Continue living in ignorance if you wish. But know, that to the rational world, by claiming CD of WTC7, you are implicating the FDNY in a conspiracy to conceal what really happened on 9/11. That is a fact. It is undeniable, and it will not change just because you blindly refuse to accept it.

-Gumboot
 
CHF asking me to tell you exactly what happened between which people is ridiculous. I can't possibly know.
And yet you claim the the FDNY or someone else demolished the building.

Any you think we are being thick.

Here's a hint and when you grow up it will become 2nd nature.

When you don't know STFU. Don't accuse people of destorying things without a shred of evidence.
 
I will not discuss this matter any further as you have demonstrated a total and utter failure to grasp a hold of this very basic fact.

Actually Gumboot, I think he fully grasps it. He just doesn't want to admit that the logical conclusion of his theory is that the FDNY was involved.

Twoofers try to avoid making that statement at all costs; it's in poor taste, what with 350 FDNY being killed that day - not to mention pretty stupid.

But because they tend to not think before opening their mouths they often find themselves claiming or implying just that, and then desperately try to weasle their way out of it when someone points out where their logic leads.
 
They feared a collapse so they created a zone around 7. This zone included the remains of the towers so while 7 stood, no rescue operations could take place on the pile. Now what would you do? Leave the building standing for days potentially, or get rid of it so you could go in and rescue the people?
But wait!

The FDNY dont demolish buildings.
 
I haven't made any such claims. If wtc7 was demolished, it was done to allow rescue operations to continue on the pile. Noone died in wtc7. The FDNY would be complicit in nothing more than furthering their own rescue efforts.

Ok as well as the problems that other people have pointed out to you with this statement I have a couple of questions and maybe you would be courteous enough to answer.

If as you say the building was brought down to aid rescue operations then:

When was it rigged with explosives ?

Clearly for your scenario to hold any weight it must have been rigged with explosives after the attacks had started. Somebody, not the FDNY of course because as you have said they do not demolish building, had to go into a building that had been damaged and on fire and rig explosives. Somebody had to make the decision that the building was an hindrance to the rescue operations and have the building rigged for demolition. If you believe this then :

How did they rig a badly damaged, burning 47 story building for CD in the short space of 6 hours ?

If this is not the case then the building was purposefully rigged prior to the attacks and it was the clear intention to destroy this building. In this case your scenario of the building being destroyed to aid rescue efforts does not stand up.

So which was it ? When was this 47 story building rigged for demolition ?
 
Last edited:
It seems you cannot clear the thread CHF. Such a shame.

In the hardfire debate, it was Jason and Dylan against Roberts and Wieck. They chose the numbers for fairness. Why on eartgh should I debate 20 people at once? You are just trying to distract from the real issue and several people in this thread were feigning ignorance of the point I was making.

I will answer your question CHF. I do not believe the firefighter heroes were in any way complicit in a 911 inside job plot. I think that a decision was made between the heads of FDNY, the demolition people on the scene and the OEM that the building needed to go to help rescue efforts. It fits all the evidence, including the erroneous report to the BBC and the video of people saying "its about to come down". Now, if people within the FDNY knew of this and are covering it up then a) I cant give you the reason but i've pointed out there are possibilities. and b) They are simply covering up the destruction of an empty building so they could rescue their men, NOT murder.

You are desperate for me to disrespect firefighters and I won't. They did something i'm sure I couldn't do when they climbed those towers.

IF they were part of any decision to demolish 7 then they did the right thing, top rescue their men.
 
It seems you cannot clear the thread CHF. Such a shame.

In the hardfire debate, it was Jason and Dylan against Roberts and Wieck. They chose the numbers for fairness. Why on eartgh should I debate 20 people at once? You are just trying to distract from the real issue and several people in this thread were feigning ignorance of the point I was making.

I will answer your question CHF. I do not believe the firefighter heroes were in any way complicit in a 911 inside job plot. I think that a decision was made between the heads of FDNY, the demolition people on the scene and the OEM that the building needed to go to help rescue efforts. It fits all the evidence, including the erroneous report to the BBC and the video of people saying "its about to come down". Now, if people within the FDNY knew of this and are covering it up then a) I cant give you the reason but i've pointed out there are possibilities. and b) They are simply covering up the destruction of an empty building so they could rescue their men, NOT murder.

You are desperate for me to disrespect firefighters and I won't. They did something i'm sure I couldn't do when they climbed those towers.

IF they were part of any decision to demolish 7 then they did the right thing, top rescue their men.

Got any facts on this one. Your idea pretty much destroys a CT. And you are quickly debunked by events of 9/11.

Got any more ideas. You still have about as many facts as pdoh. Are you sure you are not pdoh?

Your logic may sound okay to you; which leads me to think you are just like pdoh or 28th Kingdom trying real hard not to go super nova dumb.

Where to you find the time to think up stories that make no sense? How can you believe such junk? Sorry for thinking you could be as bad on research as pdoh and 28th; but your post are evidence enough.
 
Last edited:
CHF I tried but your buddies have no respect, even for your request to clear the thread.
 
The building was stopping men working on the pile where hundreds of dead and injured firemen lay. It would make sense to get rid of the empty building so that rescue operations can continue. What part of that are you having difficulty understanding?

Oh just the bit where the FDNY (which "doesn't do demolitions") somehow manages to carry out a controlled demolition of a building which was severely damaged and on fire and posed a threat to the on-going rescue operations by very quickly installing a new type of demolition charge which contrary to every other example of CD of a multistorey steel frame structure exhibited no sequential flashes or sounds of explosions but still brought down the building in such a clean manner that every 'truther' sees it and believes it to be cd, though no one from the FDNY has come forward to confirm that this is how they brought the building down.

Just little details such as that.

Oh, and, of course, the potential insurance fruad.

Oh, and the fact that they stopped rescue operations in order to create the collapse zone.

Oh and the fact that 99% of the 'truth' movement don't even believe wtc7 was damaged, so there was no need to bring it down to facilitate the wtc tower clean up

Oh and the fact that testimony from firefighters suggests that the building WAS severely damaged, to the point where it was dangerous to enter, thus making the setting of the cd rather difficult

Oh and the fact that the building's owner stated in an interview that he was advised by the fire department that the building was too badly damaged and on fire that to attempt to fight thes fires would put further personel at risk so they had decided to pull any attempt to salvage the building and let it burn, therefore leading to its collapse due to good ol' gravity.
 
I will answer your question CHF. I do not believe the firefighter heroes were in any way complicit in a 911 inside job plot. I think that a decision was made between the heads of FDNY, the demolition people on the scene and the OEM that the building needed to go to help rescue efforts.
If you believe this, the firemen are in on it. No way around it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom