Aphelion: time to clarify the FDNY's role in WTC7

So now the FDNY does do demolitions? Regardless of who did it, how does one go about placing explosives, detonation cables, etc inside a burning, structurally unsound building you have admitted was likely to fall anyway?

Carefully.


Please email Jowenko and ask him. He is an expert.
 
The FDNY dont demolish buildings.

They feared a collapse so they created a zone around 7. This zone included the remains of the towers so while 7 stood, no rescue operations could take place on the pile. Now what would you do? Leave the building standing for days potentially, or get rid of it so you could go in and rescue the people?

So, does the FDNY demolish buildings or not?!?! Make up your mind!

BTW, contradictions =/= logic. Just so you know.
 
THE FIREFIGHTERS RESCUE EFFORTS WERE ON HOLD WHILE 7 STOOD. IF SEVEN HAD STOOD FOR 3 DAYS THEN THEY COULDNT GO ON THE PILE FOR 3 DAYS.

False, as Arus said, there are many ways to get to the WTC rubble.

WTC7 WAS LEANING TO THE SOUTH, AND THE PILE WAS TO THE SOUTH. ALL FIREFIGHTERS WITHDREW FROM THE PILE UNTIL 7 CAME DOWN. IT WAS VERY MUCH IN THEIR INTERESTS TO BRING IT DOWN SOONER. NOW TELL ME YOU UNDERSTAND OR I WILL NEVER DISCUSS THE FDNY AGAIN.

So they helped it go down? Even if that were possible, tell me how is that the smoking gun? How is that a conspiracy?
 
I would think official policy would be ignored when thousands of people lay under rubble, including 350 firefighters, wouldn't you?

It makes no sense to blow it up. Just block further access to it. The collapse of WTC7 had no impact on the rescue effort at WTC 1 & 2. By the time WTC7 collapsed there were thousands of first responders going through the rubble at ground zero. There was NO manpower shortage at 5:20 pm
 
I am going to say this one last time. If you deliberately act dense again then I will leave the thread.

THE FIREFIGHTERS RESCUE EFFORTS WERE ON HOLD WHILE 7 STOOD. IF SEVEN HAD STOOD FOR 3 DAYS THEN THEY COULDNT GO ON THE PILE FOR 3 DAYS. WTC7 WAS LEANING TO THE SOUTH, AND THE PILE WAS TO THE SOUTH. ALL FIREFIGHTERS WITHDREW FROM THE PILE UNTIL 7 CAME DOWN. IT WAS VERY MUCH IN THEIR INTERESTS TO BRING IT DOWN SOONER. NOW TELL ME YOU UNDERSTAND OR I WILL NEVER DISCUSS THE FDNY AGAIN.

So lets bring a huge burning building down on any possible survivors in the area.
 
Carefully.


Please email Jowenko and ask him. He is an expert.

Jowenko was not there that day, and he was shown a video of its collapse from one perspective and told by two conspiracy nuts that "secret" papers were housed in that building. He has never, been to New York nor has seen the construction details of that building. He places his belief (and he said so in his interview) taht the building was destroyed simply to cover up these "secret" documents.

He is not an expert, when it comes to that.
 
I would think official policy would be ignored when thousands of people lay under rubble, including 350 firefighters, wouldn't you?

I'm sorry, I'm still not clear on 3 things.

- why was WTC 7 a hindrance when they could've just let her burn.

- how a standing building is more of a hindrance than a one reduced to a pile of rubble.

- how forming a collapse zone adds manpower to the rescue operation.
 
I curious as to why the demolition was kept secret, and why the NIST insists that damage and fires were what brought the building down.

If there were such logical reasons to demolish the building, then why lie about it and risk be discovered? Wouldn't that make people suspicious, and insurance companies livid, even if the reason for the demolition was legitimate?

ETA, and if the collapse was so obviously CD this needless subterfuge was even more weird to me.
 
yelling doesn't prove what you say, so again

How was the rescue efforts of that day hindered by a burning building that they FDNY decided to let burn? That means they were free to do what they needed to do with the other two collapsed buildings that day.
[/size]


I will respond when you point out the specific bias in the CBC documentary.

For everyone else on this thread: If you continue to pretend not to know what I mean then I shall leave the thread and never answer questions about the FDNY again. I was courteous enough to join the thread and answer your questions.
 
So, they blowed WTC 7 up for respectable reasons with soundless explosives, sent a press release to the BBC in advance, and then started to cover it up!

Is that about it, Aphelion?
 
They feared a collapse so they created a zone around 7. This zone included the remains of the towers so while 7 stood, no rescue operations could take place on the pile. Now what would you do? Leave the building standing for days potentially, or get rid of it so you could go in and rescue the people?

You're saying that no rescue operations took place on the pile before 5:20pm? Wrong.
 
his whole "contention" that it hindered rescue efforts is baseless;

if it hindered the rescue efforts, then it would have been stated to everyone there that day, INCLUDING hte media with an explanation as to why the FDNY would want the building demolished.

None was given.
 
I'm sorry, I'm still not clear on 3 things.

- why was WTC 7 a hindrance when they could've just let her burn.

- how a standing building is more of a hindrance than a one reduced to a pile of rubble.

- how forming a collapse zone adds manpower to the rescue operation.


You are being deliberately stupid.

How could they rescue people on a pile that had a huge 47 storey building leaning towards it?
 
I shall now exit the thread. I will never post about the FDNY again. I would have happily answered your questions but you are pretending to be thick.
 
For everyone else on this thread: If you continue to pretend not to know what I mean

OK, let's calm down.

Respectfully, Aphelion, the problem is that we know exactly what you mean, and I suspect we know more than yourself.

If you really think this through, this makes no sense, none whatsoever.

It's OK to be wrong.
 
So now the FDNY does do demolitions? Regardless of who did it, how does one go about placing explosives, detonation cables, etc inside a burning, structurally unsound building you have admitted was likely to fall anyway?

Furthermore, since it was damaged, a careful time consuming analysis would have to be done in order make sure it would come down in a 'neat' pile, which it did not as the owners of 30 West Broadway can testify to.
 
I will respond when you point out the specific bias in the CBC documentary.

oh gee, cause I caught you in a logical knot, my questions aren't important? F

What happens if another poster repeats my questions to you? are you going to answer when its asked by another person?

I told , I wont watch the CBC video ,because it was already pointed out to you where the bias was. Im not going to repeat something that was already stated by another member.

For everyone else on this thread: If you continue to pretend not to know what I mean then I shall leave the thread and never answer questions about the FDNY again. I was courteous enough to join the thread and answer your questions.

and we are not pretending about not knowing what you mean. YOU are going through so much illogical loops, that your claims are being unravled by a simple quesiton

why demolish a burning building to help in rescue efforts?
 
You are being deliberately stupid.

How could they rescue people on a pile that had a huge 47 storey building leaning towards it?

For the THIRD time.....why cover up a demolition done for legit, noble reasons?

How can the FDNY be covering it up and yet NOT be involved in the conspiracy?

Feel free to concede defeat any time, Aphelion.
 
Then we found out, I guess around 3:00 [o'clock], that they thought 7 was going to collapse. So, of course, [we've] got guys all in this pile over here and the main concern was get everybody out, and I guess it took us over an hour and a half, two hours to get everybody out of there. (Q. Initially when you were there, you had said you heard a few Maydays?) Oh, yes. We had Maydays like crazy.... The heat must have been tremendous. There was so much [expletive] fire there. This whole pile was burning like crazy. Just the heat and the smoke from all the other buildings on fire, you [couldn't] see anything. So it took us a while and we ended up backing everybody out, and [that's] when 7 collapsed.... Basically, we fell back for 7 to collapse, and then we waited a while and it got a lot more organized, I would guess." - William Ryan
 
I shall now exit the thread. I will never post about the FDNY again. I would have happily answered your questions but you are pretending to be thick.


typical. when cornered all you can do is run away.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom