Any NYC dwellers feel like taking a ferry ride?

I think you need to be on the boat that docks here, to the right of Castle Clinton. The most important reference point is the top of the Athletic Building, which should show almost level with the Whitehall building. Those to the right, partly covered by the yellow sticky should be out of the frame.
FWIW, The Staten Island Ferry gives us a that view, a clear shot right up Church St. as it approaches the Manhattan-side dock.
 
A few of the pictures-

Hope it's what you needed...
 

Attachments

  • View from the line.jpg
    View from the line.jpg
    119.9 KB · Views: 3
  • ground.jpg
    ground.jpg
    129.7 KB · Views: 1
  • upper deck view.jpg
    upper deck view.jpg
    106.6 KB · Views: 1
  • ANOTHER VIEW-UPPER DECK.jpg
    ANOTHER VIEW-UPPER DECK.jpg
    121.9 KB · Views: 2
  • DSC07886.jpg
    DSC07886.jpg
    87.5 KB · Views: 5
And this is the view from the lower deck

I took pictures from the back of the deck, inside (through the glass) and from the bow...
 

Attachments

  • inside the lower deck.jpg
    inside the lower deck.jpg
    98 KB · Views: 0
  • again, through the windows of the deck.jpg
    again, through the windows of the deck.jpg
    126.2 KB · Views: 0
  • the bow.jpg
    the bow.jpg
    106.8 KB · Views: 0
  • the bow of the lower deck.jpg
    the bow of the lower deck.jpg
    61.1 KB · Views: 1
Thanks! Where was the last picture taken, precisely? That looks like the closest match. (Referring to the 5th pic in your first post.)
 
Last edited:
And those are two more upper deck photos, second from when the ferry came back.
 

Attachments

  • the upper deck and castle clinton.jpg
    the upper deck and castle clinton.jpg
    88.9 KB · Views: 3
  • took this as the ferry landed.jpg
    took this as the ferry landed.jpg
    86.4 KB · Views: 2
Thanks! Where was the last picture taken, precisely? That looks like the closest match.

The one with the security tent seen at the bottom? That was taken from the lower deck's bow. The lower deck has a place to sit inside but has an open space at the bow and the rear.

BTW, the security tent was only installed after 9/11 and the opening of the Statue.

It was never there before the attacks...
 
Here are a few that might help out with the question of the trees-
 

Attachments

  • DSC07836.jpg
    DSC07836.jpg
    138.3 KB · Views: 0
  • DSC07834.jpg
    DSC07834.jpg
    118.1 KB · Views: 0
For what it's worth, here is a photo I took in 2002 when I tried to recreate the same view:

photoun5.jpg


It's not quite right but it was close enough for me (I was trying to recreate several memorable views at the time).
 
Last edited:
Thank you! Domo arigato! Viel schoenen Dank!

A certain cretinous troll with the class of cynaobacteria and I went a few rounds about this a couple months ago.

Oooooh! Somebody got a surprise coming when his long-dead thread rises from the grave.
 
For what it's worth, here is a photo I took in 2002 when I tried to recreate the same view:

http://img85.imageshack.us/img85/5969/photoun5.jpg

It's not quite right but it was close enough for me (I was trying to recreate several memorable views at the time).


Wow thats very close. maybe about 20 or 30 feet to the west would be perfect. The western edge of the building in the background should align with the decorative gingerbread parapet eastern edge of the building in the foreground.
 
Good job, Eeney. Did you hang out at the statue or Ellis Island?
 
How apropos given the latest carousel of looney tunes in a couple of recent threads. Anyone wanna invite Mr. Charmichael in here?

Then again, do we really want to see his multicolor, ADD-inspired font formatting again? :stone023: Maybe I oughtta rethink that...
 
Thank you! Domo arigato! Viel schoenen Dank!

A certain cretinous troll with the class of cynaobacteria and I went a few rounds about this a couple months ago.

Oooooh! Somebody got a surprise coming when his long-dead thread rises from the grave.

You're welcome!

So, you're also online sparring partners with bsregistration? Or is it someone else?
 
Here's one that might be a little closer to the photo. Posting it for everyone to see.

EDIT: I looked again and found two more worth a look.
 

Attachments

  • the upper deck.jpg
    the upper deck.jpg
    121.2 KB · Views: 3
  • DSC07882.jpg
    DSC07882.jpg
    89.2 KB · Views: 3
  • DSC07899.jpg
    DSC07899.jpg
    94 KB · Views: 3
Last edited:
Follow up: No surprises here; "truthers" live in a place untouched by reason, and they guard the castle gate ferociously. Fred/bsregistration seems to have disappeared from the 911researchers.com blog where this started (which has become a near ghost town -- or is it ghostplane town -- after yet another "truther" soap opera/gang fight/disinfo-agent outing over the last few months), but Genghis, Zark, and Rick were on duty to reject any attempt at sensibility. ("Rick" is Richard Siegel, who shot the "Hoboken video" and produced the DVD 9/11 Eyewitness, and is the owner of the 911researchers.com site.)

It appears that EeneyMinnieMoe's ferry was not at the same dock as the Taylor/Hezarkhani ferry -- it was at the next dock to the left, i.e. the first dock from the north -- so the viewpoint is not exactly the same. (I'm sure EMM had no choice of docks.) So, even though Fred's ridiculous "tree theory" based on ignoring the view from the ferry has been soundly refuted, no-planers will of course find some other reason to hang on to their delusions, in this case the precise location of buildings.
Abject failure of JREF
Submitted by rick on Sun, 2007-10-28 22:03.

"Judging by the buildings, Taylor and Hezarkhani were both somewhat to the right of this position"

Damn William. You said you would get the exact spot. So now there is a huge problem. You, ultimately, even if you passed the buck to the JREF, were going to come with the picture. I was waiting as others. You now post a picture that does not clarify at all. In fact it adds more "judging by" and "somewhat to the right" putting the vision back in an imagination that you, or anyone, wants to create using the marvel of words rather than picture.
The project was to find the spot where the two films, or pictures, were taken. There is abject failure here and defending it, as work completed is want. You did not find the spot anymore than Fred did because you, as he, have to keep talking about imaginary spots spitting distance from where you are.

Excuses are just that. The picture was what we were all waiting for and you only delivered another version that is NOT right and further powers the theorists who want to prove it can't be taken.

Your people went out and failed to duplicate the shot or position. Either try again or bow out as gracefully as possible. But claiming victory is wrong. Face the reality.

I had hoped with all the care in research at JREF that they would have brought home the bacon. Instead it looks like crow pie they will be eating.

:rolleyes: http://www.911researchers.com/node/579

(ETA: I'm not posting this to suggest that anyone should waste time getting another photo. All that would accomplish would be to "prove" to the no-planers that the fake plane was inserted into real images.)
 
Last edited:
One more follow-up: It seems that EeneyMinnieMoe's last photo above is actually the closest to the viewpoint of the Taylor and Hezarkhani images. It's line-of-sight to the buildings is actually between the two -- perhaps closer to Hezarkhani's -- but it's from a slightly lower elevation. Below are Hezarkhani's and Taylor's widest shots:

wtc2-3s.jpg


These do from a parallel-view stereographic pair, like the ones above, but the severe "hypering" (caused by the 20-foot or so separation) makes the close trees very difficult to "fuse." Nonetheless, the same trees can be identified in both: for example, the notch in the tree line immediately at the base of WTC2 in the right photo (Taylor's) is seen displaced well to the right in Hezarkhani's. This same notch is about in the middle of EMM's last photo above.

Two sources of difference in elevation have already been identified above: to get the "exact spot" that Rick claims is so vital to "truther research" you would need to get on the same ferry or type of ferry, if they are different heights, and you would need for the tide to cooperate by being the same height. A third source would be that you would need to be the same distance from the boat's railing as Taylor and Hezarkhani. An apparent difference in elevation, if judged only by the trees, would also be affected by six years of growth.

Very clearly, the claim that the images must be fake because there's no way to get the same viewpoint is totally bogus. So, I'm calling this one a wrap. Good job, Eeney!
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom