WilliamSeger
Philosopher
- Joined
- Nov 28, 2006
- Messages
- 5,092
Carmen Taylor says she was on a ferry still docked at the Battery Park pier when she took her famous photo of Flight 175 barreling toward the WTC south tower. Apparently, very near her, Michael Hezarkhani was taking a video of the same scene, which was bought by CNN and included on their 9/11 DVD.
As I have posted here before, the two cameras were close enough together that it's possible to make a stereographic pair of images by finding the frame in Hezarkhani's video taken at approximately the same time that Taylor's photo was snapped. (Below is a "left-right-left" sequence; the left and center photos can be "parallel" viewed together to see the 3D effect, i.e. by diverging your eyes as if looking at something in the distance until the two images overlap and merge, or the center and right ones can be viewed "cross-eyed," as if looking at something close until the images merge.)
(Larger image: http://opendb.com/images/175s4LRL.jpg)
The relative parallax of the two images implies that Hezarkhani was about 20 feet or so to Taylor's left, and if Taylor was on the ferry, then so was Hezarkhani. However, Hezarkhani's location has recently become a "big mystery" since Truther/Crank-Yanker-wannabe Jeff King (a.k.a. PlaguePuppy) somehow got Hezarkhani's phone number and called to ask him where he was when he shot the video. Like many of King's cold-call victims, Hezarkhani blew him off and refused to answer any questions, which of course made great Truther Theater for those who claim the video was faked.
I presume this line of "inquiry" was suggested when, several months ago, a certain producer of exceptionally poor 9/11 "truth" videos -- Fred of 911researchers.com, a.k.a. bsregistration -- claimed that the Hezarkhani video had to be fake because Fred hadn't been able to find the precise location in Battery Park where the video was shot. One of his videos taken from the pier sidewalk showed the buildings and trees at a lower angle than the Taylor and Hezarkhani images, and another video shot from the top deck of a ferry while out in the water showed a higher angle. Common sense would imply that a shot from the ferry still at the pier (where Taylor says she was) would fall somewhere between those two viewpoints, but common sense apparently isn't Fred's strong suit -- he wants proof.
I was scheduled to attend a conference in NYC the last week of September, so I intended to take a ferry ride and provide that proof, but unfortunately I had to cancel because of a crunch to finish a project on schedule.
So, here's my offer: I'll pay for two ferry tickets (payable by PayPal or check) to anyone who can get some photos (or videos, but photos would be easier to deal with) of the above buildings from the Statue of Liberty/Ellis Island Ferry while still at the pier. (I can provide more precise info on the most probable location by P.M.)
Anyone interested?
As I have posted here before, the two cameras were close enough together that it's possible to make a stereographic pair of images by finding the frame in Hezarkhani's video taken at approximately the same time that Taylor's photo was snapped. (Below is a "left-right-left" sequence; the left and center photos can be "parallel" viewed together to see the 3D effect, i.e. by diverging your eyes as if looking at something in the distance until the two images overlap and merge, or the center and right ones can be viewed "cross-eyed," as if looking at something close until the images merge.)
(Larger image: http://opendb.com/images/175s4LRL.jpg)
The relative parallax of the two images implies that Hezarkhani was about 20 feet or so to Taylor's left, and if Taylor was on the ferry, then so was Hezarkhani. However, Hezarkhani's location has recently become a "big mystery" since Truther/Crank-Yanker-wannabe Jeff King (a.k.a. PlaguePuppy) somehow got Hezarkhani's phone number and called to ask him where he was when he shot the video. Like many of King's cold-call victims, Hezarkhani blew him off and refused to answer any questions, which of course made great Truther Theater for those who claim the video was faked.
I presume this line of "inquiry" was suggested when, several months ago, a certain producer of exceptionally poor 9/11 "truth" videos -- Fred of 911researchers.com, a.k.a. bsregistration -- claimed that the Hezarkhani video had to be fake because Fred hadn't been able to find the precise location in Battery Park where the video was shot. One of his videos taken from the pier sidewalk showed the buildings and trees at a lower angle than the Taylor and Hezarkhani images, and another video shot from the top deck of a ferry while out in the water showed a higher angle. Common sense would imply that a shot from the ferry still at the pier (where Taylor says she was) would fall somewhere between those two viewpoints, but common sense apparently isn't Fred's strong suit -- he wants proof.
I was scheduled to attend a conference in NYC the last week of September, so I intended to take a ferry ride and provide that proof, but unfortunately I had to cancel because of a crunch to finish a project on schedule.
So, here's my offer: I'll pay for two ferry tickets (payable by PayPal or check) to anyone who can get some photos (or videos, but photos would be easier to deal with) of the above buildings from the Statue of Liberty/Ellis Island Ferry while still at the pier. (I can provide more precise info on the most probable location by P.M.)
Anyone interested?