Any NYC dwellers feel like taking a ferry ride?

WilliamSeger

Philosopher
Joined
Nov 28, 2006
Messages
5,092
Carmen Taylor says she was on a ferry still docked at the Battery Park pier when she took her famous photo of Flight 175 barreling toward the WTC south tower. Apparently, very near her, Michael Hezarkhani was taking a video of the same scene, which was bought by CNN and included on their 9/11 DVD.

As I have posted here before, the two cameras were close enough together that it's possible to make a stereographic pair of images by finding the frame in Hezarkhani's video taken at approximately the same time that Taylor's photo was snapped. (Below is a "left-right-left" sequence; the left and center photos can be "parallel" viewed together to see the 3D effect, i.e. by diverging your eyes as if looking at something in the distance until the two images overlap and merge, or the center and right ones can be viewed "cross-eyed," as if looking at something close until the images merge.)

175s4LRLs.jpg


(Larger image: http://opendb.com/images/175s4LRL.jpg)

The relative parallax of the two images implies that Hezarkhani was about 20 feet or so to Taylor's left, and if Taylor was on the ferry, then so was Hezarkhani. However, Hezarkhani's location has recently become a "big mystery" since Truther/Crank-Yanker-wannabe Jeff King (a.k.a. PlaguePuppy) somehow got Hezarkhani's phone number and called to ask him where he was when he shot the video. Like many of King's cold-call victims, Hezarkhani blew him off and refused to answer any questions, which of course made great Truther Theater for those who claim the video was faked.

I presume this line of "inquiry" was suggested when, several months ago, a certain producer of exceptionally poor 9/11 "truth" videos -- Fred of 911researchers.com, a.k.a. bsregistration -- claimed that the Hezarkhani video had to be fake because Fred hadn't been able to find the precise location in Battery Park where the video was shot. One of his videos taken from the pier sidewalk showed the buildings and trees at a lower angle than the Taylor and Hezarkhani images, and another video shot from the top deck of a ferry while out in the water showed a higher angle. Common sense would imply that a shot from the ferry still at the pier (where Taylor says she was) would fall somewhere between those two viewpoints, but common sense apparently isn't Fred's strong suit -- he wants proof.

I was scheduled to attend a conference in NYC the last week of September, so I intended to take a ferry ride and provide that proof, but unfortunately I had to cancel because of a crunch to finish a project on schedule.

So, here's my offer: I'll pay for two ferry tickets (payable by PayPal or check) to anyone who can get some photos (or videos, but photos would be easier to deal with) of the above buildings from the Statue of Liberty/Ellis Island Ferry while still at the pier. (I can provide more precise info on the most probable location by P.M.)

Anyone interested?
 
I think you may be mistaking Jeff from Canada, who records telephone calls, with Jeff King, AKA plaguepuppy.

I posted a photo here a while back that I took from a similar angle but farther out in the water. It's no longer in this thread, but check ktesibios' graphic. Yes, it seems quite probable that the video was taken from the ferry.

I'm on the Staten Island Ferry all the time, but I only wait in line at the SOL/Ellis Island ferry when it's absolutely necessary. This is not one of those times. :D

Also, there's no guarantee that the ferry will take the same route or pull into the same spot. They use several boats. I do recommend going to Ellis Island. It's one of the few places in NYC that I suggest going to when it's crowded.
 
Did you say two free tickets to the Statue of Liberty and Ellis Island? Count me in!

I think it would be difficult to duplicate, though and, I mean, even if you knew what camera the person used and how far they zoomed in and where they were standing, I think you'd just get a photo of the sky at the level of 110 stories.
 
I think you need to be on the boat that docks here, to the right of Castle Clinton. The most important reference point is the top of the Athletic Building, which should show almost level with the Whitehall building. Those to the right, partly covered by the yellow sticky should be out of the frame.
 

Attachments

  • JREF locator.jpg
    JREF locator.jpg
    100.4 KB · Views: 6
Yes, this is Canada Jeff, not PlaguePuppy. Jeff King has a degree from MIT; Canada Jeff couldn't spell MIT.
 
Here's my best guess on Hezarkhani's line-of-sight, which appears to be the second dock from the north:

BatteryParkDock.jpg


I believe Hezarkhani and Taylor were probably on the upper deck, but it would be good to get a photo from the next lower deck, too.

Eeney, I found that I can order the tickets online and have them mailed to you, if you can be sure of the date you could do it (they are issued for a particular day). That would also save you from having to wait in line to buy them. Otherwise, if you have a PayPal account, I can send you the money now and you can go any time. P.M. me.
 
Here's my best guess on Hezarkhani's line-of-sight, which appears to be the second dock from the north:

[qimg]http://opendb.com/images/BatteryParkDock.jpg[/qimg]

I believe Hezarkhani and Taylor were probably on the upper deck, but it would be good to get a photo from the next lower deck, too.

Eeney, I found that I can order the tickets online and have them mailed to you, if you can be sure of the date you could do it (they are issued for a particular day). That would also save you from having to wait in line to buy them. Otherwise, if you have a PayPal account, I can send you the money now and you can go any time. P.M. me.

Chris Deburgh always says don't pay the ferry man 'till he gets you to the other side.

What? Don't look at me like that! Someone had to take that one! :D
 
While cruising through YouTube, I found a thumbnail of a person standing on one of the ferries obviously already moored, with trees of about the right height in the background, but no view of the towers. Structure around the edges suggested a lower deck of the ferry. Something about it suggested that it might be additional Hezarkhani footage.

Unfortunately, the video had been tagged as having been removed for administrative reasons of some kind.
 
The Staten Island Ferry is Free. You do not pay to ride it any more. You use to pay on the manhatten side, but that was done away with a few years back.

I Am He
 
No Planer-Hugger??
No-planer-huggers, a comical reference, not to you, but to people who spend time debunking the claims of people who don't think planes hit the Twin Towers (no-planers). It's a riff on a phrase by a no-planer, Nico Haupt, who calls people who do believe that planes hit the Twin Towers "plane-huggers."
 
Yes. The ferry in question is the Statue of Liberty/Ellis Island ferry.

See what confusion you no-planer-huggers cause? :p
But they're soft and furry, and are fun to play with!

Good boy! Go pick on an old man! Make believe you're a real investigator!

What a good boy!
 
I had not seen the stereoscopic pair before--That is a remarkable shot. Obviously, the NWO has its fingers deep into this; how else could two separate cameras, with two separate chains of custody, possibly have every pixel of the animated plane fit so perfectly with one another?
 
<Snip>

I'm on the Staten Island Ferry all the time, but I only wait in line at the SOL/Ellis Island ferry when it's absolutely necessary. This is not one of those times. :D

<Snip>

I am going to have to agree with Gravy on this. I have only been to the Statue of Liberty once because of how long the line can get.
 
I think it would be difficult to duplicate, though and, I mean, even if you knew what camera the person used and how far they zoomed in and where they were standing, I think you'd just get a photo of the sky at the level of 110 stories.

For the purpose of debunking bsregistration, it's only necessary to approximate the position, not necessarily duplicate the shot, and the points of main interest are the tops of the Whitehall and the Athletic Club buildings and the tops of the trees in the park. (You can't see the trees in this stereograph because Hezarkhani was zoomed in for this frame and I cropped the Taylor photo to match, but bsregistration's "proof of fakery" is actually the tree line: In his video from the pier sidewalk, the trees appear to be too tall relative to the buildings. So, the intent is to show that from the ferry, the tops of the trees relative to the buildings matches what's seen in other frames from the video and in the full Taylor photo.)
 
Don't be suprised if you can't get an exact match, the trees have had 6 years to grow...
 
For the purpose of debunking bsregistration, it's only necessary to approximate the position, not necessarily duplicate the shot, and the points of main interest are the tops of the Whitehall and the Athletic Club buildings and the tops of the trees in the park. (You can't see the trees in this stereograph because Hezarkhani was zoomed in for this frame and I cropped the Taylor photo to match, but bsregistration's "proof of fakery" is actually the tree line: In his video from the pier sidewalk, the trees appear to be too tall relative to the buildings. So, the intent is to show that from the ferry, the tops of the trees relative to the buildings matches what's seen in other frames from the video and in the full Taylor photo.)
And you have to be on the right ferry (they are different heights), and you have to account for six years of tree growth. Sorry, but there are so many reasons why a person would be better off doing almost anything than debating a no-planer. You speak of debunking bsregistration, but no-planers are prebunked. There will never be an end to what they believe to be anomalies. Even if you were doing this as an exercise to sharpen your analytical skills, the bottom line is that you're giving them the attention and the motivation they require to keep their moonbat clinic going. Just my two bits.

Edit: I see phunk has covered the growth issue. Welcome to the forums, phunk!
 
Last edited:
Justr thought of another thing we would have to factor in. The tide has to be the same height as at the time of impact. I don't know what they are like in NYC, but in an enclosed bay, they can run about ten to fifteen feet a day.
 
Sorry, but there are so many reasons why a person would be better off doing almost anything than debating a no-planer.

It's certainly true that debating bsregistration and the other no-planers is largely a waste of time except as a minor intellectual exercise, but bsregistration deleted two of my comments on his LiveVideo.com blog where I pointed out that Hezarkhani must have been very near Taylor and that Taylor says she was on the ferry, not in the park where bsregistration shot his video. That kind of blatant intellectual dishonesty is even more irritating than the no-planer "logic." Then, when he posted my stereo images from DU on his 911researchers.com blog (suggesting that there was something ridiculous about them but not quite able to say why), I gave him a pretty hard time about being so incredibly stupid as to use his own inability to figure things out as "proof" of anything. Since I was planning on being in NYC and wanted to go the Statue of Liberty anyway, I posted that I would get some photos that I fully expected to show the same angle as the images. So, I feel obligated to come up with some evidence now, even though a sane person shouldn't need any. At least it will be one more demonstration that the no-planer "evidence" comes from people who simply don't know what they are talking about.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom