An alternative to social security: Let senior citizens work

Very much so. Forty year olds are being replaced by fresh-out-of-college kids who will work for enough to pay off their student loans.

ETA: It's not "American" that's doing this, it's the "bottom line is the only concern" folks.

I am really surprised by this as I thought that the US was actually a little more progressive, I guess not.

Here is our Law.

21 Prohibited grounds of discrimination


(1) For the purposes of this Act, the prohibited grounds of discrimination are—

(a) sex, which includes pregnancy and childbirth:

(b) marital status, which means being—
(i) single; or
(ii) married, in a civil union, or in a de facto relationship; or
(iii) the surviving spouse of a marriage or the surviving partner of a civil union or de facto relationship; or
(iv) separated from a spouse or civil union partner; or
(v) a party to a marriage or civil union that is now dissolved, or to a de facto relationship that is now ended:

(c) religious belief:

(d) ethical belief, which means the lack of a religious belief, whether in respect of a particular religion or religions or all religions:

(e) colour:

(f) race:

(g) ethnic or national origins, which includes nationality or citizenship:

(h) disability, which means—
(i) physical disability or impairment:
(ii) physical illness:
(iii) psychiatric illness:
(iv) intellectual or psychological disability or impairment:
(v) any other loss or abnormality of psychological, physiological, or anatomical structure or function:
(vi) reliance on a guide dog, wheelchair, or other remedial means:
(vii) the presence in the body of organisms capable of causing illness:

(i) age, which means,—
(i) for the purposes of sections 22 to 41 and section 70 and in relation to any different treatment based on age that occurs in the period beginning with 1 February 1994 and ending with the close of 31 January 1999, any age commencing with the age of 16 years and ending with the date on which persons of the age of the person whose age is in issue qualify for national superannuation under section 7 of the New Zealand Superannuation and Retirement Income Act 2001 (irrespective of whether or not the particular person qualifies for national superannuation at that age or any other age):
(ii) for the purposes of sections 22 to 41 and section 70 and in relation to any different treatment based on age that occurs on or after 1 February 1999, any age commencing with the age of 16 years:
(iii) for the purposes of any other provision of Part 2, any age commencing with the age of 16 years:

(j) political opinion, which includes the lack of a particular political opinion or any political opinion:
(k) employment status, which means—
(i) being unemployed; or
(ii) being a recipient of a benefit under the Social Security Act 1964 or an entitlement under the Accident Compensation Act 2001:

(l) family status, which means—
(i) having the responsibility for part-time care or full-time care of children or other dependants; or
(ii) having no responsibility for the care of children or other dependants; or
(iii) being married to, or being in a civil union or de facto relationship with, a particular person; or
(iv) being a relative of a particular person:

(m) sexual orientation, which means a heterosexual, homosexual, lesbian, or bisexual orientation.

(2) Each of the grounds specified in subsection (1) is a prohibited ground of discrimination, for the purposes of this Act, if—
(a) it pertains to a person or to a relative or associate of a person; and

(b) it either—
(i) currently exists or has in the past existed; or
(ii) is suspected or assumed or believed to exist or to have existed by the person alleged to have discriminated.

22 Employment

(1) Where an applicant for employment or an employee is qualified for work of any description, it shall be unlawful for an employer, or any person acting or purporting to act on behalf of an employer,—

(a) to refuse or omit to employ the applicant on work of that description which is available; or

(b) to offer or afford the applicant or the employee less favourable terms of employment, conditions of work, superannuation or other fringe benefits, and opportunities for training, promotion, and transfer than are made available to applicants or employees of the same or substantially similar capabilities employed in the same or substantially similar circumstances on work of that description; or

(c) to terminate the employment of the employee, or subject the employee to any detriment, in circumstances in which the employment of other employees employed on work of that description would not be terminated, or in which other employees employed on work of that description would not be subjected to such detriment; or

(d) to retire the employee, or to require or cause the employee to retire or resign,—

by reason of any of the prohibited grounds of discrimination.

(2) It shall be unlawful for any person concerned with procuring employment for other persons or procuring employees for any employer to treat any person seeking employment differently from other persons in the same or substantially similar circumstances by reason of any of the prohibited grounds of discrimination.

As you can see, since the 1st of Jan 2000, it is illegal to refuse to hire someone, force someone to retire, or fire them because of their age.
 
I am really surprised by this as I thought that the US was actually a little more progressive, I guess not.
...
As you can see, since the 1st of Jan 2000, it is illegal to refuse to hire someone, force someone to retire, or fire them because of their age.

Wow, the year 2000, here's ours from 1967...

PROHIBITION OF AGE DISCRIMINATION

SEC. 623. [Section 4]

(a) Employer practices

It shall be unlawful for an employer-


(1) to fail or refuse to hire or to discharge any individual or otherwise discriminate against any individual with respect to his compensation, terms, conditions, or privileges of employment, because of such individual’s age;

(2) to limit, segregate, or classify his employees in any way which would deprive or tend to deprive any individual of employment opportunities or otherwise adversely affect his status as an employee, because of such individual’s age; or

(3) to reduce the wage rate of any employee in order to comply with this chapter.

(b) It shall be unlawful for an employment agency to fail or refuse to refer for employment, or other*wise to discriminate against, any individual because of such individual’s age, or to classify or refer for employment any individual on the basis of such individual’s age.
http://www.eeoc.gov/laws/statutes/adea.cfm
 
Don't forget that there is a pretty stiff penalty for working once you start drawing down Social Security benefits:

We will deduct $1 in benefits for every $2 earned above $15,120.

That's effectively a 50% tax rate, and does not include regular income taxes, so your actual tax bite on a "good-paying" job could be north of 80%.
 
I don't suppose I'm atypical.... I'm 67. Been in police work for a very long time. Working in campus policing now is not as demanding as the "mean streets", but I won't be able to keep it up forever....
I'm currently drawing SS. Since I applied at the proper age, I get no "hit"; I can make as much money as I like.
However, we have no savings, no retirement fund, no pension. For many years we lived paycheck to paycheck after bankruptcy and getting caught up in the housing collapse and all that.
So...I cannot "retire". I must keep working in some capacity, as our combined social security is not sufficient for even a very limited lifestyle. Of course, I can't continue in police work.
I imagine this is the case with many; although age discrimination is a problem, many senior workers simply cannot do a variety of jobs due to increased infirmity and such.
( I plan to move into dispatching; an area i which I have some experience)
 
You have a point. I'm just running this out as a general idea. How about this? Let's make the wage roughly equal to what they would otherwise be drawing from Social Security, or perhaps a bit more, to make working preferable to retiring and collecting Social Security.
Okay, that's not bad.

I would imagine there are forms of clerical work most seniors could do.
I don't think there is that much clerical work to be had.

I'm assuming a situation in which the tax incentives given to companies hiring seniors would also include compensating them for what they have to spend on retraining.
Unfortunately most companies don't have the wherewithal and/or desire to retrain people. Tax incentives would have to be pretty big to change that.

And the ones who need it most are who, precisely, in your view?
Those who earned very little during their working years and do not have much if anything to supplement Social Security.

Then of course these jobs have to be taken from someone else. This does not create any new jobs. So they are going to displace younger workers, so do we then need a program for younger workers.

Before you misinterpret me, I am sympathetic to your idea. I think seniors are too easily discounted from job opportunities simply because of age. The excuse, "Well they aren't going to be here that long." is what one hears a lot. But then the same place goes and hires younger workers who definitely aren't going to be there that long either.
 
You have a point. I'm just running this out as a general idea. How about this? Let's make the wage roughly equal to what they would otherwise be drawing from Social Security, or perhaps a bit more, to make working preferable to retiring and collecting Social Security.
...

Why would working be preferable to not working for the same money? How much more than your SS benefits would it take to make working worthwhile? At a minimum, you'd have to cover work-related expenses, and even then you'd only break even. What would be the point? It might make more sense to stop reducing SS benefits by $1 for every $2 earned (above around $14 grand) if you starting collecting early; that would create an incentive for seniors to accept lower-paid or part-time jobs by letting them keep everything they earn. Or maybe SS benefits should be exempt from income tax, whether the recipient is working or not, so your income tax rate would be based only on your work income.
 
Last edited:
Why would working be preferable to not working for the same money? How much more than your SS benefits would it take to make working worthwhile? At a minimum, you'd have to cover work-related expenses, and even then you'd only break even. What would be the point? It might make more sense to stop reducing SS benefits by $1 for every $2 earned (above around $14 grand); that would create an incentive for seniors to accept lower-paid or part-time jobs by letting them keep everything they earn.

The penalty only applies to those retiring early. After the month of reaching full retirement age there is no penalty. The penalty discourages early retirement. A part time job might not even get you into the penalty, unless it is very high paying, at which point, why did you retire early?
 
The penalty only applies to those retiring early. After the month of reaching full retirement age there is no penalty. The penalty discourages early retirement. A part time job might not even get you into the penalty, unless it is very high paying, at which point, why did you retire early?

Sorry. I fixed my post about the early retirement penalty just before you posted. But I could imagine a well-paid professional choosing to take early retirement and still do some work (part-time hours, independent consulting, tutoring) getting into the penalty pretty quickly. My thinking is that if you have earned SS from a lifetime of working, AND you accept the substantially lower benefits that you get if you retire early, you shouldn't have to pay an additional penalty for continuing to do some work.
 
Last edited:
Sorry. I fixed my post about the early retirement penalty just before you posted. But I could imagine a well-paid professional choosing to take early retirement and still do some work (part-time hours, independent consulting, tutoring) getting into the penalty pretty quickly. My thinking is that if you have earned SS from a lifetime of working, AND you accept the substantially lower benefits that you get if you retire early, you shouldn't have to pay an additional penalty for continuing to do some work.

Hilite added by me. The point is to allow partial early retirement but to discourage "early retirement" for those still earning a decent living. It is a very small hole and am not sure if it is actually hurting someone's ability to make a living.

I actually know someone in a similar position. Retired professional, does consultations. Doesn't collect social security yet because of the penalties. His goal is to work to about the level of his deductible medical costs.
 
I am really surprised by this as I thought that the US was actually a little more progressive, I guess not.

Here is our Law.





As you can see, since the 1st of Jan 2000, it is illegal to refuse to hire someone, force someone to retire, or fire them because of their age.

Except if they are unlucky enough to work for state governments. Note that this article from the Baltimore Sun is from January 2000. In any case, making it illegal and proving that it's being done are two different things.

In the animation industry the ageism was more or less de facto: As the directors and department heads were increasingly in their 20s and 30s and tended to hire people they knew, those of us over 50 had a harder and harder time getting work. At one of the union Christmas parties a bit after 1999, a younger friend of mine, with whom I had worked, gave me a tip. The studio he was working for needed background designers, and, since he admired my work, he said they could really use my talent. I called the studio and was told to call back later to set up a time for dropping off my portfolio for review. I called back the same person, only got her answering machine and left a message, asking when I could get my portfolio seen. When she didn't return my call, I called again, a number of times. My calls were never returned, and I could never get my portfolio seen. So, if it turns out that my age is why they wouldn't so much as look at my work, how would I prove that?
 
Last edited:
. . . (snip) . . .
Those who earned very little during their working years and do not have much if anything to supplement Social Security.
Then of course these jobs have to be taken from someone else. This does not create any new jobs. So they are going to displace younger workers, so do we then need a program for younger workers.

Before you misinterpret me, I am sympathetic to your idea. I think seniors are too easily discounted from job opportunities simply because of age. The excuse, "Well they aren't going to be here that long." is what one hears a lot. But then the same place goes and hires younger workers who definitely aren't going to be there that long either.

Concerning the first hilited area: Yes, I agree. These people desperately need both their Social Security and Medicare - what the Teabaggers want to cut back - along with cutting back food stamps for the poor.

Concerning the second hilited area: In fact, a lot of seniors aren't that interested in moving up the ladder and would probably stay in a position without hope or expectation of advancement for as long as they could work. So, if a company hires 60 year-old workers whose willing to work until they're 70, the ten years they put in will probably be more time and service given by any of the twenty-somethings.
 
Wow, the year 2000, here's ours from 1967...

Well to be fair ours started out much earlier, but the then conservative Government who in power in 1994 thought everything the US was doing was wonderful, and hence destroyed a lot of the more liberal laws, decided to toss out age discrimination and it wasn't until we got a more liberal Government back in 1999 that they fixed it.
 
Concerning the first hilited area: Yes, I agree. These people desperately need both their Social Security and Medicare - what the Teabaggers want to cut back - along with cutting back food stamps for the poor.

The crazy thing is it's not the government's money. Well, I should say the government isn't supposed to touch our savings. Reagan fixed that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom