An alternative to social security: Let senior citizens work

TimCallahan

Philosopher
Joined
Mar 11, 2009
Messages
6,293
In response to conservative claims that the Social Security system is going bankrupt, being overburdened, etc., let me suggest that it would help everyone, including the Social Security syste,m for the government to enact policies that might keep older people in the workforce. Since enforcing prohibitions against ageism might well be a dicey affair, however, one alternative might be to give a tax break to those companies that institute programs to give older workers decent paying jobs. I'm curious to hear what others think of this form of stimulus.

I should add, in the interest of full disclosure, that my wife and I lost our good-paying jobs in the animation industry in 1999. As an older worker, suddenly out of work in my late fifties, I found that the only work I could get was that of substitute teacher. This was a hit and miss affair. There was very little work in September, when almost all the teachers were healthy. Work picked up in October and early November. However, it soon dropped off again with Thanksgiving and the Christmas holiday season. Work picked up again from January through May - with the exception of the spring break. June was a half-month in which teachers were unlikely to be absent. To work during the summer, I had to take lower paying jobs in childcare. I also supplemented low-demand school months with work in after-school programs.

Not only was this work uneven, the abuse I suffered at the hands of the brats I had to deal with (not all classes, only some) was often exceeded by the contempt doled out by the administration of the individual schools and of the districts - this despite the fact that there were teachers in both districts in which I worked who specifically asked for me as a substitute. I was thus happy when my pension and Social Security both kicked in and I could cease subbing.

Not only do we who have become senior citizens have a lot to contribute - most of which society seems to spurn these days - there are more of us in ratio to the population in general as time goes on, and more of us are healthy and will continue living longer. This presents a problem to society in general

So, what do the rest of you think of tax incentives for companies hiring the elderly to work in decent positions?
 
The biggest problem would be defining 'decent' positions. What does that mean?

What about seniors who aren't qualified for those decent positions?
 
The one positive of seniors retiring at 62 is that it opens jobs for younger people. If more seniors worked, the UI rate would go up. Wouldn't it be better to simply stop wasting so much money on the military, and tax the wealthy and corporations at a reasonable rate (unlike now) so that we can afford to take care of people who want to retire? After all, not everyone works in cushy animation jobs where the worst thing you deal with is a sore back and carpal tunnel. People in jobs like construction and manual labor simply can't work into their 70s, as a rule.
 
The biggest problem would be defining 'decent' positions. What does that mean?

By decent positions I mean something other than a macjob or working at Walmart.

What about seniors who aren't qualified for those decent positions?

I wouldn't penalize companies for not hiring unqualified workers. That's why I would opt for a tax break rather than punitive actions for not hiring seniors. Further, I would compensate companies for for the money they had to spend on training seniors.
 
The one positive of seniors retiring at 62 is that it opens jobs for younger people.

For most of the baby boomer generation, the retirement age to qualify for full Social Security benefits is 66, and for many workers the benefit is probably quite a bit less than 20 grand. If you start collecting at 62, your payments are cut by 25% (progressively less at ages 63, 64 or 65). People don't usually retire early by choice unless they have other resources in the form of pensions, 401Ks, other investments etc. And some legislators want to increase the qualifying age. But older workers are likely to face discrimination when they look for work, even for part-time jobs, for a variety of reasons.

I'm not sure it makes any sense to subsidize employers to hire older workers. Why do they deserve help more than any other group that needs a job? What might work is to provide training programs to help older workers update their practical skills, so they could show potential employers that they are as qualified as younger applicants. (I recently spoke with a retired naval officer who grumbled that new cars have too many electronic gadgets for him to figure out. I doubt that would go over well in an interview for a "decent" job almost anywhere.)
 
The one positive of seniors retiring at 62 is that it opens jobs for younger people. If more seniors worked, the UI rate would go up. Wouldn't it be better to simply stop wasting so much money on the military, and tax the wealthy and corporations at a reasonable rate (unlike now) so that we can afford to take care of people who want to retire? After all, not everyone works in cushy animation jobs where the worst thing you deal with is a sore back and carpal tunnel. People in jobs like construction and manual labor simply can't work into their 70s, as a rule.

Of course, I was essentially addressing the attack of Social Security. The people attacking it will probably rail against letting people retire at 62, which is pretty much what I did (actually a bit after that) when I could no longer stomach being crapped on by the school districts.

Unfortunately, those people who constantly rail at Social Security and Medicare costs probably view increasing corporate taxes and controlling military costs as heresy.
 
For most of the baby boomer generation, the retirement age to qualify for full Social Security benefits is 66, and for many workers the benefit is probably quite a bit less than 20 grand. If you start collecting at 62, your payments are cut by 25% (progressively less at ages 63, 64 or 65). People don't usually retire early by choice unless they have other resources in the form of pensions, 401Ks, other investments etc. And some legislators want to increase the qualifying age. But older workers are likely to face discrimination when they look for work, even for part-time jobs, for a variety of reasons.

I'm not sure it makes any sense to subsidize employers to hire older workers. Why do they deserve help more than any other group that needs a job? What might work is to provide training programs to help older workers update their practical skills, so they could show potential employers that they are as qualified as younger applicants. (I recently spoke with a retired naval officer who grumbled that new cars have too many electronic gadgets for him to figure out. I doubt that would go over well in an interview for a "decent" job almost anywhere.)

Concerning the hilited area: I'm thinking more in terms of practicality, rather than whether people deserve various breaks.
 
We do seem to have a surplus of jobs right now. But what about companies firing older workers because young people work cheaper.

I'm all for the authorities going after those who practice ageism. My main concern is that it's often hard to prove.
 
By decent positions I mean something other than a macjob or working at Walmart.
Still not much of a definition. Is there a minimum wage to be considered decent? A particular type of job?

I wouldn't penalize companies for not hiring unqualified workers. That's why I would opt for a tax break rather than punitive actions for not hiring seniors. Further, I would compensate companies for for the money they had to spend on training seniors.
Wouldn't a large portion of seniors who had to work be unskilled?

I'm not seeing a major benefit for you plan. It seems it would probably help some seniors but not the ones who would need it most.
 
Hang on, are you saying that the US is so backwards that you can actually be activity discriminated against because of your age? wow!
 
Still not much of a definition. Is there a minimum wage to be considered decent? A particular type of job?

You have a point. I'm just running this out as a general idea. How about this? Let's make the wage roughly equal to what they would otherwise be drawing from Social Security, or perhaps a bit more, to make working preferable to retiring and collecting Social Security.

I would imagine there are forms of clerical work most seniors could do.

Wouldn't a large portion of seniors who had to work be unskilled?

I'm assuming a situation in which the tax incentives given to companies hiring seniors would also include compensating them for what they have to spend on retraining.

I'm not seeing a major benefit for you plan. It seems it would probably help some seniors but not the ones who would need it most.

And the ones who need it most are who, precisely, in your view?
 
And what about us non-senior-citizens in the barely-above-crap jobs you're trying to convince companies to give to senior-citizens? Are you going to subsidize other companies to hire the workers displaced by the subsidies to the first companies?
 
Hang on, are you saying that the US is so backwards that you can actually be activity discriminated against because of your age? wow!
Very much so. Forty year olds are being replaced by fresh-out-of-college kids who will work for enough to pay off their student loans.

ETA: It's not "American" that's doing this, it's the "bottom line is the only concern" folks.
 
Last edited:
Very much so. Forty year olds are being replaced by fresh-out-of-college kids who will work for enough to pay off their student loans.

If they're paying enough to cover student loans, they'd be better off sticking with the seniors.
 
In response to conservative claims that the Social Security system is going bankrupt, being overburdened, etc., let me suggest that it would help everyone, including the Social Security syste,m for the government to enact policies that might keep older people in the workforce. Since enforcing prohibitions against ageism might well be a dicey affair, however, one alternative might be to give a tax break to those companies that institute programs to give older workers decent paying jobs. I'm curious to hear what others think of this form of stimulus.

I should add, in the interest of full disclosure, that my wife and I lost our good-paying jobs in the animation industry in 1999. As an older worker, suddenly out of work in my late fifties, I found that the only work I could get was that of substitute teacher. This was a hit and miss affair. There was very little work in September, when almost all the teachers were healthy. Work picked up in October and early November. However, it soon dropped off again with Thanksgiving and the Christmas holiday season. Work picked up again from January through May - with the exception of the spring break. June was a half-month in which teachers were unlikely to be absent. To work during the summer, I had to take lower paying jobs in childcare. I also supplemented low-demand school months with work in after-school programs.

Not only was this work uneven, the abuse I suffered at the hands of the brats I had to deal with (not all classes, only some) was often exceeded by the contempt doled out by the administration of the individual schools and of the districts - this despite the fact that there were teachers in both districts in which I worked who specifically asked for me as a substitute. I was thus happy when my pension and Social Security both kicked in and I could cease subbing.

Not only do we who have become senior citizens have a lot to contribute - most of which society seems to spurn these days - there are more of us in ratio to the population in general as time goes on, and more of us are healthy and will continue living longer. This presents a problem to society in general

So, what do the rest of you think of tax incentives for companies hiring the elderly to work in decent positions?

Just curious as we saw so many in that field here lose their's....Orlando? We were Siggraph members but only semi-active in teaching computer animation at the time....
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom