Merged All things Trump + Russia

Status
Not open for further replies.
This is Brennan full quote on it, "I encountered and am aware of information and intelligence that revealed contacts and interactions between Russian officials and U.S. persons involved in the Trump campaign that I was concerned about because of known Russian efforts to suborn such individuals, and it raised questions in my mind about, again, whether or not the Russians were able to gain the cooperation of those individuals."

Highlight mine. How is that not explicitly saying they were in contact with the Trump team?

That is a more comprehensive quote than the source I had found. That does indicate contact between some individuals associate with Trump's campaign.

That still doesn't translate to publicly saying that "Trump team and Russians were in communication". While I think it is clear that a connection exists, I think it's premature to assume that Trump's Team, as a whole, had intentional and meaningful contact with Russia.... which is what your framing would appear to indicate. That might ultimately end up being the case, certainly. Could also be that Brennan was referencing stuff done by one individual that other people on the team, including Trump, were unaware of.
 
We're not talking about the same nature of connections at all. Your post is disingenuous.

Frankly put, you're looking for excuses to ignore the evidence we do have.
Enlighten me about the nature of the connections included in the volume to which you refer. You claim that my various examples of connections aren't the same nature as the connections being discussed. On what information are you basing that claim - do you know the nature of the connections, aside from the content of one phone call made by Flynn? What do you know about the other connections?

Before you accuse me of being disingenuous, how about providing the supporting evidence for your claim that they aren't of the same nature? I'm claiming that we do not yet know the nature of the connections; you have claimed that we 'know' it's not any of the sorts I mentioned as possible. Support your claim or retract your accusation of dishonest engagement.

If you don't want to be accused of dishonesty perhaps discussing honestly would be a good start for you.

But nice dodge. No one's demanding that you just take their word for it. The have been MONTHS of discussion and evidence and you're still acting as if there's nothing to see there. It's not your critics who are dishonest.
And once again you fall back on an accusation of dishonesty rather than actually supporting your argument and your belief.

If I am so clearly being dishonest, it should be trivial for you to find and provide proof of the nefarious nature of the connections in question. It should be trivial for you to find incontestable and verifiable support for your position.

Otherwise, I will contend that you are simply attempting to poison the well.
 
That still doesn't translate to publicly saying that "Trump team and Russians were in communication". While I think it is clear that a connection exists, I think it's premature to assume that Trump's Team, as a whole, had intentional and meaningful contact with Russia.... which is what your framing would appear to indicate. That might ultimately end up being the case, certainly. Could also be that Brennan was referencing stuff done by one individual that other people on the team, including Trump, were unaware of.

Flynn's (post-election) calls to the Russian ambassador?
 
Yes, but to rephrase slightly;

At some point in the (not too distant?) future, Flynn may find himself confronted with a choice between spilling everything he knows in an effort to get the best deal possible for himself (One which would hopefully, from his POV, not involve the prospect of decades in a Federal prison that isn't Club Fed.), and keeping mum, trusting in the reciprocal loyalty and gratitude of his conservative Republican buddies to insulate him from significant retribution.

Flynn may be a lying, self-serving, ethically bankrupt traitor to his country for cash, but is he stupid enough to trust in the loyalty and gratitude of conservative Republicans?

After all, he is quite familiar with their track record with regard to those character traits. Can't make him feel to confident.

Will he look in the mirror and ask himself what he would do in their shoes?

That wouldn't be very reassuring, either.

Rather reminiscent of Scooter Libby, isn't it. He was loyal enough to Dick Cheney to get convicted but when the judge imposed a harsh prison term, things went south and Bush had to commute his sentence to buy his silence.

Now add in that Bush understands that loyalty is a two-way street, and hasn't shown the recent... absentmindedness about keeping sensitive information secret, and you have an even more interesting problem for Flynn...
 
Enlighten me about the nature of the connections included in the volume to which you refer. You claim that my various examples of connections aren't the same nature as the connections being discussed.

Has anyone in your family had dinner with Vladimir Putin, dealt with banks known for laundering Russian dirty money, or have received medals from Putin personally before being nominated to Secretary of State, a government arm that Putin would absolutely love to see neutered?

Don't make me laugh.

Before you accuse me of being disingenuous, how about providing the supporting evidence for your claim that they aren't of the same nature?

This is ridiculous. You're pretending to have lived under a rock for the past 6 months. When the evidence is presented you ignore it, and then ask for it again. So yeah, I will call you disingenuous.

And once again you fall back on an accusation of dishonesty

You leave me no choice. Every attempt to educate you that relied on the assumption that you were being honest has failed. You've run out of benefit of the doubt.

If I am so clearly being dishonest, it should be trivial for you to find and provide proof of the nefarious nature of the connections in question.

None so blind as they who will not see.
 
The have been MONTHS of discussion and evidence and you're still acting as if there's nothing to see there.

Not to be confused with apologetics, of course.

:rolleyes:

*Sigh*

The length of discussion is irrelevant to the quality of information presented. The fact that this has gone on for months neither strengthens nor weakens either side. Arguments about Obama's citizenship went on for a long time. As did arguments about that whole Knox/whoever thing. The amount of time involved doesn't mean anything other than that it's interesting to at least some people.

I will again reiterate that we have little evidence.

Many in this thread appear to be accepting the volume of news reports as evidence. Speculation and allegation have been accepted as evidence. Incomplete information that can be interpreted as wrongdoing has been accepted as evidence. The fact that "there are some connections" has been accepted as evidence of collusion, with very little knowledge of what those connections are. Unnamed sources with unverifiable claims have been accepted as evidence.

I have not concluded innocence on the part of Trump. I have withheld a conclusion of guilt until more solid information is presented.

My failure to jump on board the conclusion train has been cast as "apologetics". A narrative has been created in which challenging the opinion and belief put forth with insufficient evidence is viewed as opposition. A false dichotomy has been the basis of attempts to poison the well with baseless accusations and with the application of labels intended to shame.

Honestly, quadraginta, I'd think you would be wholeheartedly against labeling of any sort.
 
What would you require as proof of guilt?

By its very nature, we are going to have to rely on a mountain of circumstantial evidence.

I know that you are an actuary, so you must be good with probabilities.

What are the probabilities that all the independent pieces of evidence point to an innocent explanation?

Add in that Trump has demonstrated absolutely no respect for the truth, unlike the Washington Post, and NYT, where being accurate is highly important to their reputation and thus brand and bottom line, and you have an overwhelming mountain of circumstantial evidence against Trump.
 
That is a more comprehensive quote than the source I had found. That does indicate contact between some individuals associate with Trump's campaign.

That still doesn't translate to publicly saying that "Trump team and Russians were in communication". While I think it is clear that a connection exists, I think it's premature to assume that Trump's Team, as a whole, had intentional and meaningful contact with Russia.... which is what your framing would appear to indicate. That might ultimately end up being the case, certainly. Could also be that Brennan was referencing stuff done by one individual that other people on the team, including Trump, were unaware of.

Why would you believe Brennan. He has shown you no evidence.:rolleyes:
 
It's "actual" fact that Flynn, Manafort, Page, Kushner, and Sessions were in contact with high level Russian officials / operatives. And they lied about it. You ignore these facts, and point to a particular reference where names aren't named. Highly unimpressive.

I have seen evidence that Flynn had contact with Russian officials after Trump was elected and before he took office. I have seen evidence that Flynn spoke in Russia for a Russian News Agency and was paid to do so. It strongly appears that he did not properly disclose that speaking engagement during his security review.

I have seen accusations against Manafort, Page, etc. What specific evidence am I ignoring? What specific contacts with high-level Russian officials have been shown to have occurred?

Not accepting allegation and accusation as evidence is not ignoring evidence. Suspicious? Yes. Worthy of investigation? Definitely. Sufficient to conclude wrongdoing and/or collusion? Not even close at this point in time.
 
Has anyone in your family had dinner with Vladimir Putin
Very possibly
, dealt with banks known for laundering Russian dirty money
Not unlikley. Also probably dealt with banks known for laundering US dirty money.
, or have received medals from Putin personally before being nominated to Secretary of State, a government arm that Putin would absolutely love to see neutered?
Not that I'm aware of. Who received medals from Putin?


This is ridiculous. You're pretending to have lived under a rock for the past 6 months. When the evidence is presented you ignore it, and then ask for it again. So yeah, I will call you disingenuous.
This is not the case. I have asked for evidence, I have done a lot of research on my own. With very few exceptions, mostly related to Flynn, I have not found evidence. I have found speculation, accusation, and allegation. None of which actually constitute evidence. If there is evidence that I am missing and cannot find, please feel free to provide me a link or search terms, or even the context of such evidence and I will go dig around.

What you've provided, however, is insult and accusations of dishonesty because I haven't accepted the evidence that you haven't provided. Simply accusing a person of something is not proof of the thing you've accused them of.


You leave me no choice. Every attempt to educate you that relied on the assumption that you were being honest has failed. You've run out of benefit of the doubt.
Baloney. You pull this crap all the time. You fail to support your argument, you fail to provide evidence, then you fall back on accusing your opponent of being dishonest because your bluster has failed to convince them of the rightness of your opinion.
 
I have seen accusations against Manafort, Page, etc. What specific evidence am I ignoring? What specific contacts with high-level Russian officials have been shown to have occurred?

Not accepting allegation and accusation as evidence is not ignoring evidence. Suspicious? Yes. Worthy of investigation? Definitely. Sufficient to conclude wrongdoing and/or collusion? Not even close at this point in time.

I assume you are aware of Manafort's mortgage being paid through a company of a rich Ukrainian?

http://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/feds-subpoena-records-3-5m-mortgage-manaforts-home-n759866
 
Has anyone in your family had dinner with Vladimir Putin


You know that that "dinner" was an event with hundreds of guests, celebrating the tenth anniverary of RT, right? Live broadcasted. There's nothing to "disclose" about this and the fact that Flynn sat right beside Putin is likely pure coincidence. At the same table were Jill Stein, the filmmaker Emir Kusturica and his wife, a former Czech and a former German politician, and Putin spokesperson Peskov plus Putin intimus Ivanov. We know from the former German politician that Putin's attendance to that event was both a surprise and shortlived, so likely the latter two people were the reason why he took that table. But keep obsessing.
 
What would you require as proof of guilt?

Generally speaking, I want unbiased objective information presented without speculation, supposition, and inference. I want a body of information that CANNOT be equally explained by a competing theory.

That's kind of the linchpin for me right now: This is a conspiracy theory. Now, not all conspiracy theories are false - some are true, conspiracies do sometimes occur in reality. But for a conspiracy to be effective, it needs to be well-hidden, executable, plausible, and simply put can't contain too many people.

At present, there is a conspiracy theory that Trump and his campaign team actively and purposefully colluded with Russia to manipulate the American public into electing Trump as president. The current theory includes a very large number of actors - many people have been accused. The current theory includes fairly transparent activities - many people are alleged to have had very easily discoverable interactions with very high-level Russian operatives, and Russian government agents are speculated to have hacked the DNC servers and released documents to WikiLeaks in a highly publicized and easily traceable way.

Is it plausible? Sure. It could be done. But if it was a conspiracy, it's an incredibly inept one. One has to wonder... if the conspiracy were so blatantly obvious to have been in the limelight for nearly a year now, where are our intelligence agencies in all this? Why did they not take action beforehand? Did they not see this coming, given that it was so easily discovered after the fact?

Does this then, suggest that in addition to this conspiracy of many people acting very transparently in easily discoverable ways, we also must have an inept intelligence community in the US?

An alternative theory could feasibly be presented as such: That a large number of people are very unhappy with Trump's win, and are perfectly willing to seek any opportunity to accuse him and his staff of gross misconduct in whatever form they think will stick. The claim of collusion draws attention and is easy to keep bubbling along, because it's trivial to make allegations as long as they align at the surface level with observable events. This theory doesn't even require a conspiracy - it can be effectively implemented by a host of independent actors who are not in communication with each other. They need merely piggy-back on the allegations and accusations made by any other actor of similar sentiment. Additionally, this theory isn't even required to produce verifiable evidence - it can be quite effective at damaging reputations and reducing the credibility of Trump and his staff simply by repeating an accusation enough times.

If you think that this alternative theory is infeasible, consider the treatment that Obama received. How many people claimed that he was ineligible for the office of President because he wasn't a US Citizen? How long did that go on?
 
Last edited:
Why would you believe Brennan. He has shown you no evidence.:rolleyes:

It is a direct quote from him, in an area where he has legitimate authority and knowledge, presented in a way that is unbiased, professional, and objective. He has also demonstrated an ability to be circumspect in what he says, as well as how he says it. He refused to divulge information that is still uncertain, he did not claim knowledge or conclusions that are outside his area of expertise. He did not engage in speculation, nor did he infer what any element of information might imply. He gave legitimate testimony to a body with the authority to seek restitution for perjury.

There seems no plausible reason to question his veracity.
 
Last edited:
There appears to be contact. What evidence do you have of collusion?

I have an email from a Russian official pretending to be a truther where Alex thanks him for his help in spreading the 9/11 Thermite theory. Helping him build Infowars, in the early days.
If I can still find it after all these years.
 
Top Russian Officials Discussed How to Influence Trump Aides Last Summer

American spies collected information last summer revealing that senior Russian intelligence and political officials were discussing how to exert influence over Donald J. Trump through his advisers, according to three current and former American officials familiar with the intelligence.

The conversations focused on Paul Manafort, the Trump campaign chairman at the time, and Michael T. Flynn, a retired general who was advising Mr. Trump, the officials said. Both men had indirect ties to Russian officials, who appeared confident that each could be used to help shape Mr. Trump’s opinions on Russia.

Some Russians boasted about how well they knew Mr. Flynn. Others discussed leveraging their ties to Viktor F. Yanukovych, the deposed president of Ukraine living in exile in Russia, who at one time had worked closely with Mr. Manafort.

The intelligence was among the clues — which also included information about direct communications between Mr. Trump’s advisers and Russian officials — that American officials received last year as they began investigating Russian attempts to disrupt the election and whether any of Mr. Trump’s associates were assisting Moscow in the effort. Details of the conversations, some of which have not been previously reported, add to an increasing understanding of the alarm inside the American government last year about the Russian disruption campaign.
 
That is a more comprehensive quote than the source I had found. That does indicate contact between some individuals associate with Trump's campaign.

That still doesn't translate to publicly saying that "Trump team and Russians were in communication". While I think it is clear that a connection exists, I think it's premature to assume that Trump's Team, as a whole, had intentional and meaningful contact with Russia.... which is what your framing would appear to indicate. That might ultimately end up being the case, certainly. Could also be that Brennan was referencing stuff done by one individual that other people on the team, including Trump, were unaware of.
No not associated with, but in the Trump campaign. The two things are quite different.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom