Merged All things Trump + Russia

Status
Not open for further replies.
At no point does Brennan attribute those "contacts and interactions" to anyone on Trump's team. Read the article again, he's very circumspect in his wording, and at no point does he indicate any specific person, nor does he indicate any affiliation with Trump or any other public figure.

The connection is an inference that you (and probably a lot of other readers) are making, because it's what the author of the article is subtly suggesting.

It doesn't look good though that there appears to be collusion between the Russians, Flynn, and Alex Jones, Infowars,-RTv,- and off Gardian.
And Trump just gave Agent Alex a White House press pass.
 
No, he hasn't.

Not all interference with an investigation is obstruction of justice, just as not all lies told under oath are perjury.

As much as I would like to see Donald Trump removed from office, there needs to be a legitimate reason to do so. What is publicly known so far isn't good enough. I would hate to see today's Democrats sink to the level of the 1998 Republicans, pressing forward a case that never even should have been voted on, and would not have been had it not been for the Republican leadership parliamentary maneuvering to stop alternatives. The result was a huge embarrassment for the United States that I would not like to see repeated.

So, let the muckraking continue. There are some hints that there may be something impeachment-worthy, so I'm all for investigations, but so far, it just isn't there.

I'd say the combination of Trump's words to Lester Holt, to the Russians, what he wrote in Comey's termination letter and his actions makes it clear that Trump violated 18 USC 1512 (b)
 
No, he hasn't.

Not all interference with an investigation is obstruction of justice, just as not all lies told under oath are perjury.

As much as I would like to see Donald Trump removed from office, there needs to be a legitimate reason to do so. What is publicly known so far isn't good enough. I would hate to see today's Democrats sink to the level of the 1998 Republicans, pressing forward a case that never even should have been voted on, and would not have been had it not been for the Republican leadership parliamentary maneuvering to stop alternatives. The result was a huge embarrassment for the United States that I would not like to see repeated.

So, let the muckraking continue. There are some hints that there may be something impeachment-worthy, so I'm all for investigations, but so far, it just isn't there.

Judging by their uninterrupted stream of lies and frantic, panicked reactions, Team Trump seems to think there's plenty there. On that, at least, I believe them.
 
Last edited:
Is my reasoning sound?

During the campaign:
Trump&Co. has business connections with Russia and might stand to gain financially from Russia's help.
Trump publicly stated that "Putin not so bad", "sanctions could be loosened", etc., indicating in public that he would be softer on Russia than Obama or Hillary.
Trump publicly suggested, "Russia, hack her e-mails".
Thus, Russia would prefer that Trump be president because Hillary was clearly worse for them, and they had a clear indication of what they could do to help, all based on public statements involving no private meetings whatsoever.

During the campaign, ANY contact between Russian statesmen/agents and Trump campaign persons (of which there are several known) could have been used to confirm this public impression in very few words. ("we'll help you if you help us, capisce? Capisce.")

Any contact between Russia and and Trump&Co AFTER the election can be written off/explained away as normal transition procedure for the new administration (depending on the exact content of the conversation of course).

In order to confirm illegal collusion, someone must reveal the content of verbal exchanges between Russian agents and Trump campaign staff during the campaign, no matter how brief these interactions may be. This would seem difficult to achieve.

Am I thinking clearly?

Your reasoning isn't unsound, exactly, but there's a lot of selective information in there. It is possible to frame many of the events in a different way, and be just as reasoned. In this case, it's not a matter of applied reasoning, so much as it's a matter of selective framing and pre-existing assumptions (not necessarily yours, but I think pretty much all of us in some fashion or other). That's part of what makes this topic so tangled. Even when the factual elements are being referenced, the framing can be substantially different.

Trump said "Russia hack her emails". Well, no. Not really. It's incredibly difficult to parse his rambling oratory... but here's the pertinent section, a follow-up to a question that isn't noted in the transcript:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-fix/wp/2016/07/27/donald-trumps-falsehood-laden-press-conference-annotated/?utm_term=.4c5ba4738cae
It's just a total deflection, this whole thing with Russia. In fact, I saw her campaign manager I don't know his title, Mook. I saw him on television and they asked him about Russia and the hacking.


By the way, they hacked -- they probably have her 33,000 e-mails. I hope they do. They probably have her 33,000 e-mails that she lost and deleted because you'd see some beauties there. So let's see.

But I watched this guy Mook and he talked about we think it was Russia that hacked. Now, first of all was what was said on those that's so bad but he said I watched it. I think he was live. But he said we think it was Russia that hacked.

And then he said -- and this is in person sitting and watching television as I've been doing -- and then he said could be Trump, yeah, yeah. Trump, Trump, oh yeah, Trump. He reminded me of John Lovitz for "Saturday Night Live" in the liar (ph) where he'd go yes, yes, I went to Harvard, Harvard, yes, yes. This is the guy, you have to see it. Yes, it could be Trump, yes, yes. So it is so farfetched. It's so ridiculous. Honestly I wish I had that power. I'd love to have that power but Russia has no respect for our country.

And that's why -- if it is Russia, nobody even knows this, it's probably China, or it could be somebody sitting in his bed.


Effectively, what he actually said was that they probably have her emails, and he hopes they do. He doesn't ask them to hack it, he doesn't even suggest they should release them. But if one were inclined to see it that way, one could make that case. One could easily interpret his statement to mean that he was requesting Russia's assistance to illegally obtain and distribute private content from his competitor. Alternatively, one could interpret his statement as an off-the-cuff jab at Clinton made while deriding the entire situation.

Many of the press agencies presented the event with negative framing:
The New York Times: Donald Trump Calls on Russia to Find Hillary Clinton’s Missing Emails
Politico: Trump urges Russia to hack Clinton's email
Chicago Tribune:
Trump challenges Russia to hack Clinton's emails
Time: Donald Trump Calls on Russia to Hack Hillary Clinton's Emails
Business Insider: Trump invites Russian hackers to find Clinton's missing emails

A couple of them presented it in a bit more objective fashion, but still not entirely accurate:
USA Today: Trump says he hopes Russia can find 'missing' Clinton emails
CNDC: Trump: I hope Russia finds 'the 30,000 emails that are missing'

Both interpretations of Trump's intent are reasonable. Neither is necessarily bad logic. But neither is definitively correct either.
 
Last edited:
Why?

It is a perfectly serviceable word with a clear and unambiguous meaning which is being quite appropriately applied here.
What is wrong with that? Does it cut too close to the bone?

Because it's not being appropriately applied here. It's being used to poison the well and dismiss any counter argument, or even any challenge to the speculations being accepted as fact. I haven't defended Trump. Challenging poor logic, speculation, negative framing, and spin is not equivalent to defending Trump.

Just because I disagree with your "reasoning" doesn't mean I agree with the "other side" of a false dichotomy.
 
Last edited:
Until there are actual facts rather than speculation.

You know there's a middle ground between "proven 100% fact" and "sheer speculation", right? In this case "informed conclusion" works too. It's hard for me to imagine that the sheer number of connections between Trump's people and Russia are all coincidence.

But your characterisation of all this as "speculation", added to the one saying that others accuse "people of being apologists if they don't swallow what they're told without question" doesn't sound very genuine. It sounds like manipulating words to make things appear moreuncertain, or to make people appear more dishonest.
 
You know there's a middle ground between "proven 100% fact" and "sheer speculation", right? In this case "informed conclusion" works too. It's hard for me to imagine that the sheer number of connections between Trump's people and Russia are all coincidence.
We're up to what, a dozen or so now?

Do you know what that connection entails? Depending on how you want to parse it, I have 3 connections to Russia all by myself. Of course, they're all friends or coworkers who are immigrants from Russia, but hey, it's a connection.

My dad has dozens of connections with Russia. He was stationed in Berlin when Germany was divided, and interfaced regularly with Russian personnel during that time. He has stayed in contact with several people through the years.

My Brother in Law has extensive connections with Russia. As a secret service agent employed through the last 3 presidents (Bill Clinton, W. Bush, and Obama), he has worked closely with Russian military and protection services innumerate times.

My friend has a pen-pal who lives in Russia, they've been exchanging letters (now emails) on a regular basis since she was a kid, some 25 years or so.

Without some reasonable indication of what the "connection" is, and what is included in the content of those connections, it's pretty much impossible to come to an informed conclusion. You can conclude that some connections exist. You can conclude that those connections are being investigated to determine whether they constitute a risk or a breach of protocol. We can definitely conclude that Flynn's contact constituted a breach of protocol. Flynn's contact very probably constitutes a severe and actionable breach of protocol, but may or may not indicate collusion.

To go from "There are several connections" to "That's evidence of collusion" is absolutely speculative and a winning leap of faith that might get you in the record books..

But your characterisation of all this as "speculation", added to the one saying that others accuse "people of being apologists if they don't swallow what they're told without question" doesn't sound very genuine. It sounds like manipulating words to make things appear moreuncertain, or to make people appear more dishonest.

I'm not the one in the habit of accusing people of dishonesty on a regular basis, my friend.

I'm also not making things appear more uncertain than they are. I'm insisting on actual facts and information rather than framing, interpretation, and opinion. As a fellow skeptic and intelligent person, I would think you would want to put aside your preconceptions and evaluate the evidence as objectively as possible. When you go read the articles written, the framing, the suggestion, the implied meaning is extremely obvious. The various bloggers and new outlets aren't being subtle. The degree of interpretation being rubbed on all things Trump isn't hard to see unless you're refusing to look.

I strongly dislike Trump. I don't like his methods, I don't like his demeanor, and I don't like his blustering, bombastic, bullying approach to everything. But my dislike of him doesn't mean I sacrifice the skeptical approach and the ideal of objectivity in an effort to get him canned.
 
At no point does Brennan attribute those "contacts and interactions" to anyone on Trump's team. Read the article again, he's very circumspect in his wording, and at no point does he indicate any specific person, nor does he indicate any affiliation with Trump or any other public figure.

The connection is an inference that you (and probably a lot of other readers) are making, because it's what the author of the article is subtly suggesting.

This is Brennan full quote on it, "I encountered and am aware of information and intelligence that revealed contacts and interactions between Russian officials and U.S. persons involved in the Trump campaign that I was concerned about because of known Russian efforts to suborn such individuals, and it raised questions in my mind about, again, whether or not the Russians were able to gain the cooperation of those individuals."

Highlight mine. How is that not explicitly saying they were in contact with the Trump team?
 
Until there are actual facts rather than speculation.
The pretense there aren't "actual" facts defies credulity. As you've been repeatedly shown, there's an extensive body of actually factual, not speculative, circumstantial* evidence.

* In the sense of proving collusion. There's direct evidence of Flynn's criminality in the public domain.
 
Effectively, what he actually said was that they probably have her emails, and he hopes they do. He doesn't ask them to hack it, he doesn't even suggest they should release them. But if one were inclined to see it that way, one could make that case. One could easily interpret his statement to mean that he was requesting Russia's assistance to illegally obtain and distribute private content from his competitor. Alternatively, one could interpret his statement as an off-the-cuff jab at Clinton made while deriding the entire situation.

I watched what he said when he said it.
Why is it you who gets to interpret what he actually said?

One could easily interpret both of your scenarios happening at the same time.
He asked for Russia's assistance to obtain (you added the word illegally) and distribute
private content from his competitor (that is cute, but no, it is a national election, not
a swim meet) and an off the cuff jab at Clinton by bringing up the word emails.

"While deriding the entire situation?" What "situation" was Trump deriding?

Trump has shown himself to be incapable of any insight, and clueless about the basics
of our form of government.

He thinks he is boss, and all his underlings (FBI, CIA, NSA, etc.) will do what he asks
if he keeps his inside voice. Trump is surprised when someone says "no".

This level of denial is shameful. The United States of America is being shamed around
the world by this clown and his enablers.

Lucky for us, the idiot keeps doing what he does best, tripping over his own.....
tie.

There are rumors that he is getting an attorney. The attorney that represented him
for Trump University scam.
:o
Awesome!
 
We're up to what, a dozen or so now?

Do you know what that connection entails? Depending on how you want to parse it, I have 3 connections to Russia all by myself. Of course, they're all friends or coworkers who are immigrants from Russia, but hey, it's a connection.

We're not talking about the same nature of connections at all. Your post is disingenuous.

Frankly put, you're looking for excuses to ignore the evidence we do have.

I'm not the one in the habit of accusing people of dishonesty on a regular basis, my friend.

If you don't want to be accused of dishonesty perhaps discussing honestly would be a good start for you.

But nice dodge. No one's demanding that you just take their word for it. The have been MONTHS of discussion and evidence and you're still acting as if there's nothing to see there. It's not your critics who are dishonest.
 
We're not talking about the same nature of connections at all. Your post is disingenuous.

Frankly put, you're looking for excuses to ignore the evidence we do have.


Not to be confused with apologetics, of course.

:rolleyes:

If you don't want to be accused of dishonesty perhaps discussing honestly would be a good start for you.

But nice dodge. No one's demanding that you just take their word for it. The have been MONTHS of discussion and evidence and you're still acting as if there's nothing to see there. It's not your critics who are dishonest.


Not to be confused with apologetics, of course.

:rolleyes:
 
We're up to what, a dozen or so now?

Do you know what that connection entails? Depending on how you want to parse it, I have 3 connections to Russia all by myself. Of course, they're all friends or coworkers who are immigrants from Russia, but hey, it's a connection.
It's "actual" fact that Flynn, Manafort, Page, Kushner, and Sessions were in contact with high level Russian officials / operatives. And they lied about it. You ignore these facts, and point to a particular reference where names aren't named. Highly unimpressive.

Friends and co-workers?
 
Last edited:
This is Brennan full quote on it, "I encountered and am aware of information and intelligence that revealed contacts and interactions between Russian officials and U.S. persons involved in the Trump campaign that I was concerned about because of known Russian efforts to suborn such individuals, and it raised questions in my mind about, again, whether or not the Russians were able to gain the cooperation of those individuals."

Highlight mine. How is that not explicitly saying they were in contact with the Trump team?

Known Russian efforts to suborn such individuals.

varwoche said:

The pretense there aren't "actual" facts defies credulity. As you've been repeatedly shown, there's an extensive body of actually factual, not speculative, circumstantial* evidence.

* In the sense of proving collusion. There's direct evidence of Flynn's criminality in the public domain.

Thank you both for putting it more succinctly than I did.

I just moved to southern Georgia. My representative is a Republican who
said (I think on Sunday) that Trump is moving the country in the right direction. Then asked the people at the Community Health Center opening
to pray for him (Trump).

AAAARRRRGGGGHHHH!
:blush:

He is up for re-election in 2018. Time for a change.
 
Yes, but to rephrase slightly;

At some point in the (not too distant?) future, Flynn may find himself confronted with a choice between spilling everything he knows in an effort to get the best deal possible for himself (One which would hopefully, from his POV, not involve the prospect of decades in a Federal prison that isn't Club Fed.), and keeping mum, trusting in the reciprocal loyalty and gratitude of his conservative Republican buddies to insulate him from significant retribution.

Flynn may be a lying, self-serving, ethically bankrupt traitor to his country for cash, but is he stupid enough to trust in the loyalty and gratitude of conservative Republicans?

After all, he is quite familiar with their track record with regard to those character traits. Can't make him feel to confident.

Will he look in the mirror and ask himself what he would do in their shoes?

That wouldn't be very reassuring, either.

Rather reminiscent of Scooter Libby, isn't it. He was loyal enough to Dick Cheney to get convicted but when the judge imposed a harsh prison term, things went south and Bush had to commute his sentence to buy his silence.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom