All of You, Who Once Believed in 9/11 Truth, Share Your Experiences

I recommend you take a breath, slow down, and observe patterns some more until you can be more or less sure of what's going on here. You can't even understand a basic joke (due to perhaps some filter?) and are here saying the forum is like a cult.

There is soooome sort of truth to something like that, a prevailing ethos, and sometimes it gets thicker than I'd like, but hey, that's a forum. Getting in a tizzy isn't going to help you any. Productively sticking on topic will. :thumbsup:

Don't worry, I'm chilled. I may not understand the "in jokes" but, I can assure you I have observed here for a very long time. My observations are based upon years rather than days.

Interestingly, the "in jokes" are indicative of exclusivity rather than inclusivity. Another sign of cultism.

Actually you make a good point, we ALL should stay on topic.

I'll shut up now and enjoy reading the posts from the former "Truthers".
 
Last edited:
I am looking for written experiences from people who used to be on the truther side, but are not anymore. I know there are many on this board. What I'd especially like to know are follows:

a) How did you once become a truther? I am not looking for answers, like "watching Loose Change". If possible, I'd like you to write in a bit more detailed manner, like "I watched Loose Change, and started surfing the internet. All I could find were more truther sites, which further reinforced my truther status... etc" or something like that.

b) What convinced you back from truther to non-truther? Once again, I hope you do not respond something like "truthers are dumb", but a bit more specific.

c) What are your thoughts nowadays about your time as a truther? What mistakes you made back then? Were you 100% convinced, agressively promoting the truth? Whatever comes to your mind.


I can give examples from my own experiences.

a) Conspiracy theories were very remote to me before 9/11 truth. Of course, I had heard that there were some JFK conspiracy theories, but had never gone through any of the claims in detail. Then all of a sudden, I was exposed to some truther propaganda. I went surfing the internet and found only more and more stuff reinforcing the conspiracy point of view. I guess it was the lack of any previous exposure to any conspiracy theories, combined with the massive amounts of conspiracy material so easily found in the internet, that made me a truther for a short while. I had no experience dealing with this kind of false claims. I thought at least most of the stuff had to be for real.

b) I started debating my (conspiracy) point of view, but every time I came out disappointed. I always thought I had a weaker case. But still, I could support my case pretty cleverly, if I only distorted some evidence a little bit, ignored some other evidence, etc. Until I reached the point, when I was so frustrated with it all, I knew I had no case. I knew very well the points each side was making. It was a non-contest. I became a debunker overnight. But it took me a couple of months of trutherism and defending my weak points, before I fully realized I was wrong.

c) I am somewhat embarrassed, that I was lured into the conspiracy world so easily. I had always thought I was critical of evidence. I had always thought I cannot be fooled. And there I was, claiming WTC demolition. But that time also taught me a lot. One has to be very careful with stuff that sounds exiting, but you have no previous experience with. Because once you take the first wrong step, it is very easy to convince yourself with further evidence supporting the wrong conclusion, while twisting in your mind the evidence that doesn't.


Share your thoughts, all people that once believed even some of the truther stuff. I might do some writing about this subject, if I get enough material.

As a former Truther I assume that you thought WTC7 looked like a controlled demolition. Do you still think it looked like a controlled demolition ?
 
Last edited:
... Another sign of cultism.
... I'll shut up now and enjoy reading the posts from the former "Truthers".
The best part is one day you will become a cult member of physics, math, and logical thinking. You will be posting here as an ex-truther. I thought I saw it in your posts, a ray of intelligence indicative of someone who will be able to break the shackles of delusions from other people and start thinking for yourself. It is a matter of time and all based on your finding your freedom to think on your own.

The cult of skepticism, critical thinking, throw in some physics, and a bit of logic; the only requirement to be in this cult is the ability to think for yourself. When will you take the responsibility to drop your delusions and join the reality cult?

You seem to have some potential, whereas BillSmith is doing her best to avoid reality or display a future potential to do so.
 
Last edited:
frightening.

alot people claimed I belive it simply because it is less scary than a bunch of Terrorists. Thats not the case, i find Terrorists alot less frightening than a Government turning against its own people.

Just wanted to second that sentiment. It got annoying hearing "normal people" explain how we were all comforted by the thought that our muderous government could kill us anytime they wanted to justify more wars, etc. I should think believing is external terrorists who will try to strike again, but the government's working on protecting us, is much more comforting. Not that I would ascribe "normal people" beliefs to such a simple emotional calculus.

On there other hand there is a certain satisfaction in feeling that you're at least aware of the evils closer to home. You imagine the others are more enslaved and vulnerable since they're still ignorant of the situation. Does the "normal people" side have any corollary smugness any one here has encountered?

As the others say, welcome back to more solid ground DC. Sorry it took so long.
 
Last edited:
I can assure you I tossed fruit at no one.

That was grenerd's first post on here, and his/her last from the looks of it!!!!

Given the subject that grenerd was posting on and the depth of personal analysis he/she was going into it hardly seems appropriate to start demanding evidence and throwing fruit at the poster. I would like to understand from Brainache exactly what the motivation was so, stop apologising for him and let's hear it.

I was using the Forum in-joke of a one word post "Evidence?" which was the trade mark of a poster here named Claus Larsen. (I'm not sure if he is still around so I'll use past tense) Claus prided himself on being the most skeptical skeptic in all of Skepticville. I was being facetious and demanding evidence which I knew could not be provided. As others have pointed out, it was a joke. The smilie should have given you the clue. I made a silly statement and then ducked to avoid the fruit I expected would be thrown my way.

The fact that you need this explained to you mystifies me.

Oh well, I hope this ends the derail.

Now back to more heart warming tales of people recovering from Conspiranoia...

ETA: Good to see DC back from the Dim side.
 
Last edited:
Bumped both for the anniversary and relevance!

This has been a most interesting and educating thread about CT-thinking. As more and more people is leaving and has left the truth-movement, all you ex-truthers please share your honest accounts. But please do read OP first, all of you.
 
I completely dismissed all of the 9/11 conspiracies till 2008. I had a friend who strongly believed in them, who I argued with for several months. I ended up reading Fetzer's book "The 911 conspiracy" and David Ray Griffin's "Debunking 911 debunking" which ended up convincing me of their claims. In the last couple months I've been browsing through posts here, and looking at other debunking websites and little by little I began to let go of certain claims. First I let go of the pentagon claims, then shanksville and just recently the collapse of the towers and building 7. I think I just had an extremely late start in this debate, so that's why it seemed to take me so long to find out the truth. I'm glad I did research the counter argument thoroughly,because I now understand the sociology behind it all. Not just 9/11 but JFK and any other conpiracy theory or pseudoscience. I apologize for the few posts I had on here as a conspiracy believer.
 
I completely dismissed all of the 9/11 conspiracies till 2008. I had a friend who strongly believed in them, who I argued with for several months. I ended up reading Fetzer's book "The 911 conspiracy" and David Ray Griffin's "Debunking 911 debunking" which ended up convincing me of their claims. In the last couple months I've been browsing through posts here, and looking at other debunking websites and little by little I began to let go of certain claims. First I let go of the pentagon claims, then shanksville and just recently the collapse of the towers and building 7. I think I just had an extremely late start in this debate, so that's why it seemed to take me so long to find out the truth. I'm glad I did research the counter argument thoroughly,because I now understand the sociology behind it all. Not just 9/11 but JFK and any other conpiracy theory or pseudoscience. I apologize for the few posts I had on here as a conspiracy believer.

Good for you for rationally sifting through the evidence (or lack of evidence on the truther side). And kudos for admitting your mistakes and making an apology. Well done all round. :)
 
Bumped both for the anniversary and relevance!

This has been a most interesting and educating thread about CT-thinking. As more and more people is leaving and has left the truth-movement, all you ex-truthers please share your honest accounts. But please do read OP first, all of you.

Welcome to the forum! What led you to first post in this thread and subforum in particular?

Kind regards,
Orph.
 
Thank you for the welcome! I'm a long time lurker in JREF forum (years), and as my first post I decided to bump this most educating thread for the anniversary and for great justice :)

Since I have never been a truther or a CT-believer, I don't have personal experiences to add in to this thread. The accounts posted here are very interesting to read and I hope this thread continues to grow with more win.


ETA: Very big thank you to all of you ex-truthers for your accounts. It takes a lot of courage to admid having been wrong. Hats off to you!
 
Last edited:
I also think this is the treath to make my introduction. Some of know me from other forums.

a) How did you once become a truther?
I saw Loose Change back in 2006, I was convinced by it for about a day. But when I really become a truther was spring of 2009 when I heard a radio-interview of Hannu Yli-Karjanmaa, the number one conspirasy theoretic here in Finland. I went and bought his book, that was when I was convinsed.

b) What convinced you back from truther to non-truther?

Well, it was what it was for you. I started debating my case, everytime these guys ref and spin0 defeated me. So after while there was nothing left but say "I was wrong".

c) What are your thoughts nowadays about your time as a truther?
I actually do think it was valuable experience for me. I had education and I though I had critical thinking in me, I had none. Through that experience of trutherism I have learned what critical thinking is!

Nowadays I have spend my time trying teach others have some critical thinking. ref once said to me it makes it all worth while if I have been able to get through just one person.
 
Welcome Epic, and thanks for your comments :) nice to see your development. Glad you found your way out of that funk.
 
Welcome Epic, and thanks for your comments :) nice to see your development. Glad you found your way out of that funk.

Thanks, haven`t seen you around for awhile guess you got tired of this. Can`t really blame you, I also have already become pretty frustrated with the truthers. In fack I have been thinking about making a site or a blog in finnish since there really isn`t one. I have a theory that truthers can be divided to three groups:

The silent truthers that are the biggest group, they have been exposed to truther propaganda but don`t spread the word anything. The number of these people can be up to hundreds of thousand here in Finland alone. These are the people that should be reached.

The deniers are ones that are making the fuss. These are the people that we are reaching in forums. But since they are deniers, debating them has absolutely no effect. The number of these people is small, here in Finland the number is about 50.

Finally the mentally ill. They are not as loud as the deniers since they also have other things to attend to, like chasing UFOs and wondering what are trails from aeroplanes. Hard to say what number of them is, but it don`t matter because they are beyond our help.

So I was thinking to put together a site that would be targetted to silent ones. Somewhat similar to your site, take all the most common claims and write just few sentences about them plus give links where to find more information. When silent ones go to google they are much more likely to read something that is short and is in their native language. I bet it would have much more impact than debating the deniers.
 
Thanks, haven`t seen you around for awhile guess you got tired of this. Can`t really blame you, I also have already become pretty frustrated with the truthers. In fack I have been thinking about making a site or a blog in finnish since there really isn`t one. I have a theory that truthers can be divided to three groups:

The silent truthers that are the biggest group, they have been exposed to truther propaganda but don`t spread the word anything. The number of these people can be up to hundreds of thousand here in Finland alone. These are the people that should be reached.

The deniers are ones that are making the fuss. These are the people that we are reaching in forums. But since they are deniers, debating them has absolutely no effect. The number of these people is small, here in Finland the number is about 50.

Finally the mentally ill. They are not as loud as the deniers since they also have other things to attend to, like chasing UFOs and wondering what are trails from aeroplanes. Hard to say what number of them is, but it don`t matter because they are beyond our help.

So I was thinking to put together a site that would be targetted to silent ones. Somewhat similar to your site, take all the most common claims and write just few sentences about them plus give links where to find more information. When silent ones go to google they are much more likely to read something that is short and is in their native language. I bet it would have much more impact than debating the deniers.
Welcome:

What makes you believe there is a large group of "silent truthers"? I'm a bit confused about this concept. Are you saying you have evidence a large group in Finland believe the "truther" talking points or just "distrust" American politics? If it's the latter, no ****.
 
Welcome:

What makes you believe there is a large group of "silent truthers"? I'm a bit confused about this concept. Are you saying you have evidence a large group in Finland believe the "truther" talking points or just "distrust" American politics? If it's the latter, no ****.
Thanks for the welcome.

The number in Finland is no bigger than in any other country. They really are not truthers, but they have been exposed to propaganda and not to debunking material and do think that something is not right with 9/11, they don`t really even known much about it. Number is estimate that I made up to give some ballpark, have no evidence to back it up. I have became to this conclusion mostly from polls around the world and every now then I hear someone saying something that can be interpret as trutherism.

ETA. There is 5,4 milj. people in Finland if let`s say 2% have some 9/11 conspiracy believes that would make 108000 people. So if 4,2% of Americans believe the Government "Made it happen" in Zogby poll. I think 2% in Finland is not far from the truth.

ETA2. In Sweden 7% didn`t believe al-Qaida was responsible for the attack. And that 7% is what would qualify as silent truthers.
 
Last edited:
Thanks, haven`t seen you around for awhile guess you got tired of this. Can`t really blame you, I also have already become pretty frustrated with the truthers. In fack I have been thinking about making a site or a blog in finnish since there really isn`t one.

There are many reasons, but yes I haven't been paying much attention to this topic for a while now.

Let me give you a little of my thoughts. I also thought about translating at least parts of my site to Finnish. I already started doing that a couple of years ago, but I gave it up pretty quickly and never thought of doing it again. There are a couple of important reasons I decided not to do it.

- It was a lot of work doing it in English, it's a lot of work all over again doing it in another language.
- Most of the people in Finland understand English very well.
- Most of Finnish truthers have become truthers by reading American truther sites or watching American truther documentaries or Youtube, which means they already know english, so there is no additional value for translating stuff into Finnish.
- Most truther points are originally made in english, so translating them into Finnish might lose some information in the process. The target audience might not think about the same thing as the person doing the translation. Something might become lost in translation.
- To most truthers it doesn't matter what the language, they don't care about any counterpoints to their beliefs, so it's mostly a lot of work for nothing.

So my advice would be, that it's not worth the effort to put much thought into putting up anything in Finnish. You can do it, but I think directing people into english sites would do the same trick to those who care.

Another advice is not debating the stubborn truthers anymore, once you already see they don't care. They make the same points no matter what, and nothing happens. It gets nobody nowhere. If someone new comes around, there might be reason to give them a chance, but to those who have made the same points for years, let them be who they are. They are not going to change. You can pretty quickly see who are maybe likely to change and give your words a thought, and who are not. You did it and I'm happy for that.
 
Last edited:
I know this is a pretty dead topic but I wanted to ask a related question about CT beliefs. Why is it that they seem to "snowball?" Believing in one CT seems to make you more vulnerable to believing in another, and another and another. Logically there should be a (very) finite number of possible "enormously complex conspiracies" in the world and yet the majority of CT with whom I have had interaction believe in dozens of them. Many of a contradictory and self-excluding nature (e.g. the government is actually run by both crypto-communists and by crypto-Muslims).
 
They all pretty much boil down to "teh illuminatiz"

Essentially each successive paranoid and silly theory goes a long way to proving the previous.

For instance, since the jooz were responsible for 9/11, it's pretty clear that they are also the masterminds behind the fake holocaust....

Or something like that.
 
I know this is a pretty dead topic but I wanted to ask a related question about CT beliefs. Why is it that they seem to "snowball?" Believing in one CT seems to make you more vulnerable to believing in another, and another and another. Logically there should be a (very) finite number of possible "enormously complex conspiracies" in the world and yet the majority of CT with whom I have had interaction believe in dozens of them. Many of a contradictory and self-excluding nature (e.g. the government is actually run by both crypto-communists and by crypto-Muslims).

A CT thrives on distrust for the government/ruling elite. Once a CT is proved the evilness of the government/ruling elite is reinforced, the distrust deepens, making it easier for the next CT to be accepted. And off it goes.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom