All of You, Who Once Believed in 9/11 Truth, Share Your Experiences

You just tossed fruit at the guy. Note how he already ducked. This is a sign of fun and merriment. Please observe. also for me: :duck:

I can assure you I tossed fruit at no one.

That was grenerd's first post on here, and his/her last from the looks of it!!!!

Given the subject that grenerd was posting on and the depth of personal analysis he/she was going into it hardly seems appropriate to start demanding evidence and throwing fruit at the poster. I would like to understand from Brainache exactly what the motivation was so, stop apologising for him and let's hear it.
 
I can assure you I tossed fruit at no one.

That was grenerd's first post on here, and his/her last from the looks of it!!!!

Given the subject that grenerd was posting on and the depth of personal analysis he/she was going into it hardly seems appropriate to start demanding evidence and throwing fruit at the poster. I would like to understand from Brainache exactly what the motivation was so, stop apologising for him and let's hear it.

He's not apologizing. He's patiently explaining the very simple meaning of a very simple post.

Future derail attempts will be reported.
 
Thanks to all the new contibutors, fascinating read!

I enjoyed it as well, some very open posts.

I do worry however, that some of the posters have substituted one cult for another and will just get drawn into another set of fundamentalist beliefs.
 
I enjoyed it as well, some very open posts.

I do worry however, that some of the posters have substituted one cult for another and will just get drawn into another set of fundamentalist beliefs.

Are you saying skepticism = fundamentalism?

Prop that one up with reasoning, if you would be so kind.

We keep seeing this "one cult for another" argument over and over again, and I'm not sure if it's just 'sour grapes' or that kind of understated derision cigarette smokers have for people who've just quit successfully.

Do you expect us to believe your agenda actually entails concern for the well-being of other people? I thought it was about getting "THE TRUTH" out there - as soon as you all can agree on what "THE TRUTH" actually consists of.

Collaborative efforts become more difficult when you look around you and realize that your movement is shrinking. It was already irrelevant, now it's circling the drain of extinction.

Neener neener.

How's about you direct your activism towards problems in this world that actually exist rather than trying to push a fabrication that doesn't?
 
Last edited:
I enjoyed it as well, some very open posts.

I do worry however, that some of the posters have substituted one cult for another and will just get drawn into another set of fundamentalist beliefs.

If you mean fundamentalist beliefs like demanding evidence grounded in mathematics, physics and reality before making wild claims, then that's a fundamentalist belief system I wish everyone had.
 
I enjoyed it as well, some very open posts.

I do worry however, that some of the posters have substituted one cult for another and will just get drawn into another set of fundamentalist beliefs.

I would not see how one could compare skepticism and 9/11 truth as opposed (or even simply separate) cults. 9/11 truth, christianity, anti-vaccination all IMO qualify as cults because amongst other traits, they have 2 very important ones: conclusion and delusion. Their foundation is a conclusion (vaccines cause autism, 9/11 was an inside job, etc) which is protected by delusion which prevents the cult members from critically considering evidence to the contrary of their founding conclusion. Skepticism however is not at all a conclusion, but rather a process, and furthermore this process relies heavily on the critical consideration of all the evidence. It would make one lousy cult.
 
...Skepticism however is not at all a conclusion, but rather a process, and furthermore this process relies heavily on the critical consideration of all the evidence...

Exactly the point. Absolutes will breed cults and, judging by some of the behaviour patterns on here it already has.
 
Exactly the point. Absolutes will breed cults and, judging by some of the behaviour patterns on here it already has.

How did you get that out of what he said?

The skeptical process almost never supports the absolute conclusion.

The 9/11 Truth Movement was never about a process. They had the answer already figured out, and then just worked backwards trying to prop up a flimsy conclusion with even flimsier scientific conclusions.

Your reading comprehension skills betray you.
 
How did you get that out of what he said?

The skeptical process almost never supports the absolute conclusion.

The 9/11 Truth Movement was never about a process. They had the answer already figured out, and then just worked backwards trying to prop up a flimsy conclusion with even flimsier scientific conclusions.

Your reading comprehension skills betray you.

Yeah, I guessed you were about making cheap points rather than being open and honest. After some of the great posts in here you have thrown it all back in their faces posting this nonsense.

Welcome to my ignore list.
 
Please don't mangle the basic concept laid out in my post. There is no absolute conclusion in skepticism.
 
Trying to save us from being wrong about 911; kind of naive to think you had ultimate knowledge. But thanks for the warning, it takes guts to say what you believe while being told otherwise. Thanks for taking the time to try and inform others about what you believed was true.

As for warning us about 911 using delusions from other people without checking them out is not so great.

I have found, I believe and have seen, people like you who have figured out a lesson the hard way, worked your way up, are the best leaders and experts in the field. You did the hard work, got dirty in the pit of ignorance and built your own means of escape while others fell back in, or are hiding their original failure.

I learned things about the WTC while posting to your old 911 nonsense. I figured you had the ability to understand 911 issues. You could correct minor errors in some of the smallest details but still insisted on the delusions being true. To move from the world of delusions to reality is a greater step than I have made warning you 911 truth was a lie.

thanks :)

but hey, when we get hit on 2012 by Planet X, dont blame me for not warning you, ok? :D j/k
 
releaseeabode said:
Yeah, I guessed you were about making cheap points rather than being open and honest. After some of the great posts in here you have thrown it all back in their faces posting this nonsense.

Welcome to my ignore list.

If you bothered to look around, you'd see that I'm one of the posters here who is sympathetic towards discourse with 9/11 truthers. The problem is, I don't feel the need to wear baby gloves when I do it. You started this off with an insulting and baseless crack at the forum community here, which like it or not, you're a part of as well. You come in with that kind of attitude, and someone is going to call you on it.

If you're going to ignore everyone that tells you that your conclusions are scientifically incorrect and your attitude sucks; then I'm going to be in good company.

I sincerely hope one day you look at yourself and your beliefs with the kind of objectivity and courage that Temecula has shown.
 
Last edited:
I can assure you I tossed fruit at no one.

That was grenerd's first post on here, and his/her last from the looks of it!!!!

Given the subject that grenerd was posting on and the depth of personal analysis he/she was going into it hardly seems appropriate to start demanding evidence and throwing fruit at the poster. I would like to understand from Brainache exactly what the motivation was so, stop apologising for him and let's hear it.

Lol. Sorry, internet humor so often fails, mate. It was a "bad joke" to simply ask for "evidence" of someone's experience, especially when it's detailed and earnest. Historically, bad jokes have been met with rotten fruit. A "comedian" will sometimes follow a "bad joke" with a pantomime duck, to avoid the fruit (often tomatoes). No one usually throws stuff anymore, but the gag persists. The smilie thus was to clarify that "evidence?' was a joke. A good-natured ribbing to the newbie.

I hope now that will clarify the situation.

disclaimer: I only presume that's what Brainache meant, and cannot be construed as speaking for him in any capacity.

Or was it more sinister? We'll never know for sure...
 
Please don't mangle the basic concept laid out in my post. There is no absolute conclusion in skepticism.

It's funny how two people can be agreeing on a basic concept and one of those people still believes that they are not.

I am saying that absolutes breed fundamentalism, or am I imagining that I posted that?
 
Lol. Sorry, internet humor so often fails, mate. It was a "bad joke" to simply ask for "evidence" of someone's experience, especially when it's detailed and earnest. Historically, bad jokes have been met with rotten fruit. A "comedian" will sometimes follow a "bad joke" with a pantomime duck, to avoid the fruit (often tomatoes). No one usually throws stuff anymore, but the gag persists. The smilie thus was to clarify that "evidence?' was a joke. A good-natured ribbing to the newbie.

I hope now that will clarify the situation.

disclaimer: I only presume that's what Brainache meant, and cannot be construed as speaking for him in any capacity.

Or was it more sinister? We'll never know for sure...

OK, I get it. If that's what Brainache was doing then I withdraw my criticism except to say it was a bit hard on a newbie to throw that kind of humour out on a first post. It certainly went over my head.

Hopefully, Brainache can clarify when he gets the chance.

Thanks for taking the time to offer some clarification.
 
Last edited:
I am saying that absolutes breed fundamentalism, or am I imagining that I posted that?

You did post it. As a non-sequitur.

Temecula posted "Skepticism is a process."

You quoted that phrase and added on "Absolutes breed fundamentalism."

Where's the connecting reasoning between the two? If you are alleging that the members of this forum who do not believe that the events of 9/11 were orchestrated by the Bush Administration or some shadowy elite cabal are somehow jingoistic torch-brandishing fundamentalists in the same vein as suicide bombers and the Westboro Baptist Church, you'd better connect the two with some kind of statement or show yourself to be intellectually dishonest.

Let me say right now that if I'm misrepresenting anything you've said, point it out and I'll retract it if it's in error. Too many stupid arguments start over communication problems. If I've got you pegged wrong, I'd rather know that sooner than later.
 
OK, I get it. If that's what Brainache was doing then I withdraw my criticism except to say it was a bit hard on a newbie to throw that kind of humour out on a first post. It certainly went over my head.

Hopefully, Brainache can clarify when he gets the chance.

Thanks for taking the time to offer some clarification.

I recommend you take a breath, slow down, and observe patterns some more until you can be more or less sure of what's going on here. You can't even understand a basic joke (due to perhaps some filter?) and are here saying the forum is like a cult.

There is soooome sort of truth to something like that, a prevailing ethos, and sometimes it gets thicker than I'd like, but hey, that's a forum. Getting in a tizzy isn't going to help you any. Productively sticking on topic will. :thumbsup:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom