“Alex was doing what he loved to do”

Your perspective seems to be slipping. Dude was a daredevil. Remember. The whole purpose of his occupation was doing dangerous things that most sane people would not do. That is the reason people paid to watch him. It was thrilling to others because it was dangerous. He went out of his way to engage in an activity that put his life in danger.

An acceptable level of risk for parents is a level that gives them the best opportunity to stick around at least until their children are young adults. This does not preclude every day activities such as driving where the main risk/danger to a reasonably cautious driver is an outside agent (other driver more reckless than themselves). Every day events such as commuter driving are not considered to be thrilling and dangerous enough for people to go out of their way do watch others engage in the activity. Don’t know what an SAR Tech is, and it likely does not matter. It would not include race car driving. It would include pickle jar opening. It would not include jumping a motorcycle over long distances.

It's absolutely more dangerous than doing many things for a living, but I don't know how much more or that it's actually as dangerous as presented. Stage magicians appear to be doing something incredibly dangerous as well, but we know that's not true. Daredevilry may be more safe than we realize.
 
It's absolutely more dangerous than doing many things for a living, but I don't know how much more or that it's actually as dangerous as presented. Stage magicians appear to be doing something incredibly dangerous as well, but we know that's not true. Daredevilry may be more safe than we realize.

Well the dude the thread is about actually managed to kill himself. Doesn’t really get any more dangerous than that. The key word with stage magicians is “appear”. The dead daredevil was not creating illusions.
 
As long as they don't endanger other people, if some idiot want to risk his life that is his business. Consider it Darwinism in action.
And not really much we can do about it, unless you want to give the state total power over your life.
 
As long as they don't endanger other people, if some idiot want to risk his life that is his business. Consider it Darwinism in action.
And not really much we can do about it, unless you want to give the state total power over your life.

I agree. Idiots are as welcome to make their own choices as anyone else. As I said upthread, he had already produced offspring so no Darwin Award for him.
 
Your perspective seems to be slipping. Dude was a daredevil. Remember. The whole purpose of his occupation was doing dangerous things that most sane people would not do. That is the reason people paid to watch him. It was thrilling to others because it was dangerous. He went out of his way to engage in an activity that put his life in danger.

An acceptable level of risk for parents is a level that gives them the best opportunity to stick around at least until their children are young adults. This does not preclude every day activities such as driving where the main risk/danger to a reasonably cautious driver is an outside agent (other driver more reckless than themselves). Every day events such as commuter driving are not considered to be thrilling and dangerous enough for people to go out of their way do watch others engage in the activity. Don’t know what an SAR Tech is, and it likely does not matter. It would not include race car driving. It would include pickle jar opening. It would not include jumping a motorcycle over long distances.

The whole purpose of "dudes" occupation, much like everyone else's, is to make money. A SAR Tech is a search and rescue tech. The SAR Tech I mentioned is responsible for rescuing people in marine environments.

Your "For The Children's Sake, Don't Do It" discounts a lot of everyday things and doesn't align with a reasonable person's beliefs.
 
Well the dude the thread is about actually managed to kill himself. Doesn’t really get any more dangerous than that. The key word with stage magicians is “appear”. The dead daredevil was not creating illusions.

I understand that. Stage magicians have also died performing in the past. There's danger inherent in both professions. It's possible there is some illusion in daredevilry in that it appears more dangerous than it is as well.
 
The whole purpose of "dudes" occupation, much like everyone else's, is to make money. A SAR Tech is a search and rescue tech. The SAR Tech I mentioned is responsible for rescuing people in marine environments.

Your "For The Children's Sake, Don't Do It" discounts a lot of everyday things and doesn't align with a reasonable person's beliefs.

No. At least part of the dude’s motivation for his occupation was that he loved it. He died “doing what he loved”, not doing “what earned him money”.

Seems that an SAR Tech’s profession is a reasonable and necessary one. A certain amount of danger inherent in the job is traded off against the necessity of helping people in serious trouble. There is no way I can see to equate the necessary work of an SAR Tech with jumping a motorcycle lover things.

You may notice that nowhere have I said “don’t do it”. A person’s choice to make a stupid and selfish decision inconsiderate of their own children’s welfare is their own to make.
 
No. At least part of the dude’s motivation for his occupation was that he loved it. He died “doing what he loved”, not doing “what earned him money”.

Not mutually exclusive for a whole lot of people.

Seems that an SAR Tech’s profession is a reasonable and necessary one. A certain amount of danger inherent in the job is traded off against the necessity of helping people in serious trouble. There is no way I can see to equate the necessary work of an SAR Tech with jumping a motorcycle lover things.

But he doesn't have to do it. Some single dude could do that job.

You may notice that nowhere have I said “don’t do it”. A person’s choice to make a stupid and selfish decision inconsiderate of their own children’s welfare is their own to make.

But it isn't really theirs to make because you are going to heap in plenty of righteous indignation. That seems to be your whole argument, your righteous indignation trumping the informed decisions of adults.
 
Not mutually exclusive for a whole lot of people.

Didn't say it was. It is however the main point of the op. “Alex was doing what he loved to do”, not "Alex was doing what he had to to make money".

But he doesn't have to do it. Some single dude could do that job.

True. But it is a job that needs to be done. People's lives and safety are at stake. Jumping a motor cycle over things, on the other hand... You are stretching this feeble attempt at equivalence well past the breaking point.


But it isn't really theirs to make because you are going to heap in plenty of righteous indignation. That seems to be your whole argument, your righteous indignation trumping the informed decisions of adults.

Of course it is their decision. My opinion has zero impact and trumps nothing. And you know it. A choice by some thrill-seeker to engage in a stupidly pointless activity is rarely if ever influenced by some internet stranger's opinion. Strangely, I do not feel this righteous indignation that you ascribe to me. Nor any other kind of indignation for that matter. What I do feel is some sympathy for the family now deprived of their father and husband for no good reason.

But hey, I get your point and you are welcome to it. The dude died doing what he loved. Everything and everybody else is really rather insignificant and peripheral to that.
 
Well the dude the thread is about actually managed to kill himself. Doesn’t really get any more dangerous than that. The key word with stage magicians is “appear”. The dead daredevil was not creating illusions.

That doesn't follow at all. I knew a girl who died taking a shower. That doesn't show that the risk of taking showers is inordinately high. Yes, he died doing a stunt, but what is the rate of death for such stunts?
 
I do agree with Steve that having children should enter into one's decision making process about risk. Last year I was climbing mountains in Tibet with a friend of mine. We got to a point on the mountain that I found pretty precarious, and I talked to my friend about turning around. He was a little more sure footed than me and seemed pretty okay but after talking for a while I said to him, "Man, if Matt (a mutual friend) were here he'd remind you that you have kids." He laughed, but we turned around at that point.

Two days later we actually went over more challenging terrain without turning back, but knowing that we'd made the right decision earlier gave me a little more confidence to assess the risk correctly going forward.

But how much risk should one reasonable take? I think it's a pretty subjective judgement that each person has to make themselves. And certainly the reward ought to be factored in to one's assessment. Steve points out that the OP daredevil's reward for his activities seems to be mostly his own enjoyment of what he's doing. Other's say that he's also making a living from it, and that ought to be factored in. I agree with that, but would like to point out that while it may not seem particularly noble, his enjoyment is a meaningful benefit of taking that risk. And while his obligations to his children ought to be factored in, that doesn't mean that they completely supersede the idea of taking some risks whose reward is no more noble than just enjoying life.
 
Huh. For millennia, males have been expendable. Hunting, warfare, seafaring, construction, mining, blood sports, and even farming all took their barely lamented toll.

What's changed recently, that makes us so much more desirable to keep around?
 
What's changed recently, that makes us so much more desirable to keep around?

If you ask my wife, her reasoning is that I'm still a net profit to the household. Life insurance would get her by for a few years, but I still make enough to be valuable. I'm 40, so give me a bit and that might change.
 
If you ask my wife, her reasoning is that I'm still a net profit to the household. Life insurance would get her by for a few years, but I still make enough to be valuable. I'm 40, so give me a bit and that might change.

You might want to watch a classic film noir called "Double Idemnity".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom