Oystein
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Dec 9, 2009
- Messages
- 18,948
Picking up what Jay Utah wrote - how a simulated CD scenario, where you programmatically "fail" members at will by setting their strength to zero or removing them from the model:
NIST justified each failure. They first ran a variety of fire szenarios, trying to make them match the observed progression over time.
Then they computed resulting heat within members, looking for areas with significant activity. The fire floors around columns 79 and 80 were obvious targets for such searches because
(a) Their failure was obviously the proximate reason for the first sign of rapid collapse - the kink down the center of the east penthouse
(b) 79 was surrounded by the longest floor trusses - a circumstance that already had been fatal for the twins.
They found a scenario where a certain girder-to-column connection failed due to the girder being pushed laterally off its seat. They defined a semi-arbitrary condition for this walk-off: The seat had a width of 11", and they assumed it would fail once the girder was pushed 5.5". Now it turned out that apparently the seat was a little wider, so instead of 5.5" the semi-arbitrary distance should have been 6.25" or some such value.
I think NIST stopped simulationg the beam expansion once the 5.5" threshold was reached - we don't know if 6.26" wouldd have been reached a bit later anyway to trigger the exact same collapse sequence. But actually it is quite possible that 5.5" was too conservative to start with, that 4.5" would have sufficed.
Such are the uncertainties of modelling.
In any case, NIST ran a detailed fire szenario and computed temperatures throughout the fire floors over time, and used that information to estimate effects on steel, concrete and windows.
When/If AE911T runs a simulation with CD charges in locations of their choice, I expect them to do the very same: Do their own fire sims (or adopt NIST's), and apply the resulting temperature development to the charges. Conventional explosives and especially their detonators ignite (burn or explode) at 320 °C max; their beloved "nano-thermite" ignites, according to their delusions, around 420 °C, and any equipment used to trigger those charges (cables or wireless units) likewise are sensitive to high temperatures.
They would thus have to show that their assumed charged would survive the actual fires and remain controllable.
Furthermore I'd expect them to use specialized tools to simulate
(a) the effect of explosives and/or incendiaries on steel members, to validate the minimum required charge size and
(b) the other effects of such charges, especially sound propagation of explosives, to allow for a comparison of predicted sound levels with observed sound levels.
NIST did both of these, with four different blast scenarios, and concluded that the minimum required charge size to bring down the critical col 79 would have left an unmistakeable imprint on the environment, with windows shattered and high sound volumes far away.
NIST justified each failure. They first ran a variety of fire szenarios, trying to make them match the observed progression over time.
Then they computed resulting heat within members, looking for areas with significant activity. The fire floors around columns 79 and 80 were obvious targets for such searches because
(a) Their failure was obviously the proximate reason for the first sign of rapid collapse - the kink down the center of the east penthouse
(b) 79 was surrounded by the longest floor trusses - a circumstance that already had been fatal for the twins.
They found a scenario where a certain girder-to-column connection failed due to the girder being pushed laterally off its seat. They defined a semi-arbitrary condition for this walk-off: The seat had a width of 11", and they assumed it would fail once the girder was pushed 5.5". Now it turned out that apparently the seat was a little wider, so instead of 5.5" the semi-arbitrary distance should have been 6.25" or some such value.
I think NIST stopped simulationg the beam expansion once the 5.5" threshold was reached - we don't know if 6.26" wouldd have been reached a bit later anyway to trigger the exact same collapse sequence. But actually it is quite possible that 5.5" was too conservative to start with, that 4.5" would have sufficed.
Such are the uncertainties of modelling.
In any case, NIST ran a detailed fire szenario and computed temperatures throughout the fire floors over time, and used that information to estimate effects on steel, concrete and windows.
When/If AE911T runs a simulation with CD charges in locations of their choice, I expect them to do the very same: Do their own fire sims (or adopt NIST's), and apply the resulting temperature development to the charges. Conventional explosives and especially their detonators ignite (burn or explode) at 320 °C max; their beloved "nano-thermite" ignites, according to their delusions, around 420 °C, and any equipment used to trigger those charges (cables or wireless units) likewise are sensitive to high temperatures.
They would thus have to show that their assumed charged would survive the actual fires and remain controllable.
Furthermore I'd expect them to use specialized tools to simulate
(a) the effect of explosives and/or incendiaries on steel members, to validate the minimum required charge size and
(b) the other effects of such charges, especially sound propagation of explosives, to allow for a comparison of predicted sound levels with observed sound levels.
NIST did both of these, with four different blast scenarios, and concluded that the minimum required charge size to bring down the critical col 79 would have left an unmistakeable imprint on the environment, with windows shattered and high sound volumes far away.