AE911 Truth plans their own model

Look what I found in my inbox:

http://us1.campaign-archive1.com/?u=d03bf3ffcac549c7dc7888ef5&id=340cf2655f&e=[UNIQID

Richard Gage said:
A New Wave of WTC Research

Dear Fellow 9/11 Advocates,

Thank you for making the first week of our 2015 Membership Drive a great success!

Today, I would like to tell you about some of the most important initiatives we have planned for 2015. Please read on – or visit our 2015 Membership Drive page to learn more.

Modeling WTC 7

https://gallery.mailchimp.com/d03bf...ages/cc566843-65b3-41ba-897d-1f13ae5d6921.png

One of our highest priorities for 2015 is to conduct a “finite element analysis” of WTC 7.

Working with a structural engineering professor from a major university and a committee of peer reviewers composed of renowned leaders in the engineering field, the goal of our computer modeling will be to demonstrate conclusively that NIST’s collapse initiation mechanism for WTC 7 could never have occurred, and, secondly, that the destruction we actually saw can be more easily and accurately replicated by simulating a controlled demolition.

Once completed, this team of researchers will seek to publish their findings in top engineering journals, thus widely disseminating this critical information to a key community that continues, inexplicably, to be mostly unaware of WTC 7’s destruction.

If successful, this study will awaken the entire engineering community to the truth about WTC 7 in a short period of time, and serve as the foundation to finally undermine NIST’s fraudulent reports in eyes of the world.
 
I find it strange that people think that the buildings came down due to CD. Comparing 911 videos with actual demolitions easily shows that there are major differences. I guess Oystein's link is nothing more than a fantasy.
 
But is there any reason why a computer model couldn't do such a thing in this context?
The computer they program will produce whatever result they want. Since they have already decided what conclusion they want, why bother with the work associated with creating a model when they could keep on claiming they are right?

Ranb
 
scammers said:
Working with a structural engineering professor from a major university and a committee of peer reviewers composed of renowned leaders in the engineering field, the goal of our computer modeling will be to demonstrate conclusively that NIST’s collapse initiation mechanism for WTC 7 could never have occurred, and, secondly, that the destruction we actually saw can be more easily and accurately replicated by simulating a controlled demolition.

It's odd how they don't actually name these professionals. Could it be they don't actually live up to the billing? Or are these the same names the engineering worlds has been ignoring all along?

Dick Gage wouldn't lie...............right? :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Is there some reason, in principle, why their stated goal could not be achieved? That goal is to "Conduct sophisticated computer modeling of World Trade Center Building 7 to demonstrate, first, the impossibility of the collapse initiation mechanism put forth by the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) and, second, that a controlled demolition more readily replicates the observed destruction." They are explicit about using computer modeling to demonstrate what they "already assume to be true." But is there any reason why a computer model couldn't do such a thing in this context?

Just thinking about this point in detail, it seems to me that (a) yes, in principle it's possible, (b) it's a fundamentally flawed approach, and (c) the fundamental flaw lies in the clause "more readily replicates the observed destruction". Let's look at those one by one.

Firstly, yes, in principle, it's possible that the NIST collapse initiation model is inaccurate. Given the limited amount that it is actually possible to know about the fine details of the collapse, it's an appeal to perfection to require NIST to have come up with a collapse scenario that precisely duplicates every observed feature of the collapse. The classic example I can call to mind at the moment is the Tay Bridge collapse, where, although it's completely uncontroversial that the collapse was caused by a combination of inadequate design, poor workmanship and extreme weather, there are still three completely separate theories as to how the collapse initiated, none of which has satisfactorily been proven. It's enough, for the purposes of debunking 9/11 CTs, for NIST to have come up with a class of plausible mechanisms (although, of course, the primary purpose of the NIST investigation was never anything to do with such trivia). And, of course, since the collapse proceeded as a sequence of failures of structural components, it's trivially simple to explain it as a controlled demolition, by simply invoking the presence of an appropriate explosive charge at the location and time of every failure that must have occurred, then simply handwaving away how and why such an absurdly complex demolition scheme was used. It's the equivalent of an appeal to God.

Secondly, it's fundamentally flawed because it's a false dilemma fallacy. All it can ever prove, even if it succeeds, is that one carefully constructed explosive demolition scenario is more likely than one specific fire initiated scenario. It doesn't address the possibility that the actual collapse was due to a slightly different fire initiated scenario.

And finally, it's flawed because I'm quite certain AE911T will cherry-pick the evidence, present the small subset - in this case, the precise visual appearance of the collapse - that appears to support their argument, while ignoring all the audible, testimonial and inferential evidence that comprehensively refutes it. If they do address the absence of a deafeningly loud series of bangs, or the logistical impossibility of placing the charges without being observed, for example, that's where the tortured logic, misrepresentation and outright lying will start. But they probably won't bother, because they know they'll look stupid at that point.

Bottom line is, however much of a step forward it may be in terms of actually doing something, it's still classic conspiracist thinking - focus on irrelevant details, ignore the overall body of evidence, and demand an impossible standard of proof for your opponents.

Dave
 
Since two identical (?) towers came down due to the same (apparent) cause the best way to test what happened is to build a full-sized replica of one of the towers, fill it with office furniture, papers and such, fly an airliner into it and watch. It's a fair bet it will come down like the other two if that's what happened first time round. I suggest the Nevada desert.
 
Last edited:
Since two identical (?) towers came down due to the same (apparent) cause the best way to test what happened is to build a full-sized replica of one of the towers, fill it with office furniture, papers and such, fly an airliner into it and watch. It's a fair bet it will come down like the other two if that's what happened first time round. I suggest the Nevada desert.



Completely aside from the question of who would actually pay for this, there's also the problem that even this wouldn't shut up the vast majority of truthers. Consider the Birthers as a test case. After years of demanding they see a copy of Obama's birth certificate, when they were finally shown exactly what they wanted, they simply turned around, and came up with a whole new class of nit-picks that allowed them to keep on claiming the same crap they were claiming all along.

So, let's say we do this massive reenactment. Will it look exactly like the collapse of the first two towers? Of course it won't, because the collapses of the original two didn't look exactly the same. Any trivial differences will be held out as "proof" that the original towers' collapses weren't caused by the same thing as the rebuilt tower.

But let's imagine we are able to produce an exact copy of one of the collapses. What then? Well, obviously, THEY rigged it to collapse in the same manner, because the truthers "know" that such a collapse is impossible. All they'll do is expand the circle of who is "in on it" to include the people doing this test.

The only way to win is not to play.
 
It's odd how they don't actually name these professionals. Could it be they don't actually live up to the billing? Or are these the same names the engineering worlds has been ignoring all along?

Dick Gage wouldn't lie...............right? :rolleyes:

Those professionals are in the same box as "sue NIST" and "contact Europeans".
 
I am sure there are some loose canons with professional standing or in Universities who will attempt this. They already have a few in their ranks.. Ron Avery to name one. A license does not make one sensible, or even competent.

But in the end they will not be able to prove the buildings did not come down "naturally" and only could do with placed devices.
 
See here.

Under "New Research Initiatives":
• Conduct sophisticated computer modeling of World Trade Center Building 7 to demonstrate, first, the impossibility of the collapse initiation mechanism put forth by the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) and, second, that a controlled demolition more readily replicates the observed destruction.

​


More MSFirePaint then.............​
 
Being a layman myself, how do they expect to carry out this work without having access to any of the steel from the towers or 7. Will they be using any of the documentation from NIST ? Which they claim is fraudulent.
 
Is there some reason, in principle, why their stated goal could not be achieved?

There is absolutely no reason why their stated goal cannot be achieved. In fact, I'm almost certain that if they manage to actually conduct the modeling, it will achieve their stated goal with flying colors. That's because their stated goals are, on their faces, illogical and unscientific.

"Sophisticated computer modeling," by which I have to assume they mean a finite-element analysis in the structure and thermodynamics domains, is an investigative tool. It's not a magic oracle that gives you the final answer at the bottom of the printout. It's no different than a magnifying glass. It only helps you understand the world if (a) you point it in the right direction, and (b) you know what the heck you're looking at.

As an objective tool -- albeit one that requires considerable skill to operate -- the magnifying glass does not simply produce the answer. It enables a person to collect additional information, one way or another, that lets him be more confident that the conclusion he draws is more informed that it would be otherwise. Therefore when Gage announces that his use of this tool will produce his predetermined results, that's patently unscientific. To purport your intent to collect more data, but to announce what that additional data will show, is effectively to announce that you really don't need the additional data.

So what has to be the purpose instead? I believe it's to convince the general public (not the relevant professional communities) that some magic oracle has confirmed Gage's suspicions all along. So you can bet the farm that the analysis will surely come out the way they announced it will. This Magic Oracle (i.e., the computer) has been invoked many times in conspiracism overall. People in a couple decades ago were told that a computerized analysis of Kennedy autopsy photos "proved" they had been doctored -- a method with no scientific merit but which fooled the gullible public. A decade ago, computerized photographic analysis "proved" such things as a thigh bone on Mars, vast alien structures on the Moon, and that what hit the Twin Towers could not possibly be Boeing airliners.

Conversely, in the appropriate, widely-consulted, peer-reviewed journal pertaining to such analysis, NIST posited to the relevant body of experts worldwide that they (a) pointed their magnifying glass in the right direction, and (b) properly interpreted what they were looking at. This rebuts Gage's disagreement; he accuses NIST of merely cobbling up a known-broken computer model and reading the "correct" results off the bottom of the printout -- in effect of attempting to deploy their own Magic Oracle. Not only is it refuted by evidence, it's contradicted by NIST's proper treatment of computer techniques within their overall investigative approach.

There is absolutely no reason a computer model of this type can't be made to do what the authors say it will. This type of analysis offers countless ways to load the dice in a way that the general public won't see or appreciate. Even in the best and most forthright of circumstances, the construction of the model entails estimating the values of so many unknowns as to make it a somewhat foggy magnifying glass.

That's obviously why NIST submitted their assumptions, estimates, and overall method to the candid professional judgment of people most qualified to determine whether the method was sound. There really is no body of experts in the world more qualified to make that judgment -- certainly not Tony Szamboti by himself. The sixty-four dollar question is whether Gage will validate his method to the same rigor and by the same method. If he will not, then he can expect little attention from the experts of the world.

Now on to the logical failures.

You can't prove something is impossible. You can only prove it isn't possible by any of the ways you tried. You can't prove there are no other ways. In terms of FEA, appearing to prove it's impossible for the model to evaluate to a certain outcome is simply a matter of cherry-picking the initial conditions and over-constraining the method not to produce the results you wish to avoid. Subsequently the exercise is in convincing your reader that your method was thorough enough that it would have discovered the smoking gun if there had been one.

This is easy to do because the initial conditions and unknowns typically exist across a range of potential values that combine in unforeseeable ways. The combinations require you to adopt a multidimensional approach to analysis that quickly burgeons beyond the practical limitations of evaluating the model. That's a fancy way of saying computer time for this costs you literally thousands of dollars a day. Conversely you must also beware a non-linear response in the model to linear distributions of values for single inputs. Hence there is a legitimate art in mediating among small trial runs and more faithful full-scale runs. Justifying that legitimate art to the layman reader can easily mask intentional shenanigans.

There are qualitative factors as well. The software techniques commonly employed do not automatically and straightforwardly simulate all the physical context. The additional techniques developed to simulate the effects of, say, joint failures for various causes, and the criteria by which elements are considered "failed" was a big part of NIST's exposition in the engineering literature. Any duplication of that effort would have to produce similar qualitative enhancements. And that's another mire in which someone can conceal from the layman the means by which a certain undesirable outcome is carefully avoided or precluded.

So it will be quite easy for Gage to simply shoot all his FEM bullets haphazardly in the general vicinity of the target, but not really intend to hit it, and then pronounce the target unhittable.

To propose a model showing that "controlled demolition more readily replicates the observed destruction," in addition to being wantonly presumptive, is further based on the fallacy of the affirmed consequent, and additionally on the same loaded-dice approach we examine above.

As we pointed out in the other thread where this was discussed, you could facetiously simulate the effects of explosions that disabled the structural elements the conventional model suggests were weaked by thermal and mechanical effects. Then the resulting effect would resemble the actual observations. But it would go nowhere toward proving that was the cause of those individual failures.

In many incarnations of this type of analysis, realizing the "failure" of an element is a matter of setting its "strength" to zero programmatically. The decision of when to consider an element failed, and thus when to remove it from consideration in structural behavior computations, is a key part of the model, and yet another item NIST belabored in its peer-reviewed work.

Hypothetically any criteria can be used to consider an element "failed," whether based on a constitutive relationship or not. If not, the computer does not enforce the physical validity of that criteria. It only implements what was programmed, which may be physically invalid or entirely arbitrary. For example, an item can be considered "failed" at a certain point on the basis of an assumption that a demolition charge severed it there. That effect is implemented by algorithmically "disconnecting" adjacent structural primitives along the purported cut. It simulates only the effect of the purported cause. It doesn't validate that the cause imagined in the programmer's thinking was what actually occurred.

In fact, as I mentioned, with the model simply being told to adopt the effect of some purported cause, you could apply reductio ad absurdum and show that this method would not only wrongly validate a controlled-demolition theory, it would also validate Judy Wood's space beams theory, and also a completely made-up one that says hostile aliens magically teleported away key elements of WTC 7. As a further absurd example, I could simply program the model at a certain instant to "fail" any structural element whose part-number digits add up to an odd number. It would be a completely arbitrary, completely non-physical way of defining "failure," but the model has no concept of that type of enforcement. It's told to fail certain elements, so it does. Any subsequent attempt to attribute the observed outcome to the programmed causes would be purely speculative.

Technical implementations aside, the central fallacy here is that if some purported antecedent displays the desired consequent, it is not necessarily the only antecedent that has the potential to do so. If we continue with the bullet-shooting analogy, this would be the Texas Sharpshooter's fallacy.
 
Last edited:
Since two identical (?) towers came down due to the same (apparent) cause the best way to test what happened is to build a full-sized replica of one of the towers, fill it with office furniture, papers and such, fly an airliner into it and watch. It's a fair bet it will come down like the other two if that's what happened first time round. I suggest the Nevada desert.

No doubt the 911 kooks will volunteer to populate the building with some leaping from the heights and the others crushed as the building falls?
After all we'd want it to be realistic ?
 
No doubt the 911 kooks will volunteer to populate the building with some leaping from the heights and the others crushed as the building falls?
After all we'd want it to be realistic ?

I had in mind propping up dead pigs at the desks to reproduce any effect of burning bodies. I am persuaded, on reflection, that my idea would not refute enough (or any) conspiracy ideas to be worth the investment.
 
See here.

Under "New Research Initiatives":
• Conduct sophisticated computer modeling of World Trade Center Building 7 to demonstrate, first, the impossibility of the collapse initiation mechanism put forth by the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) and, second, that a controlled demolition more readily replicates the observed destruction.

• Research, write, and publish monthly technical briefs.

• Publish and market a book based on psychologist Frances Shure’s groundbreaking series, “Why Do Good People Become Silent—Or Worse—About 9/11?”​

I take it that this would contribute to attempting to satisfy a perennial demand of debunkers, that AE911 produce its own research?

Sure.

But it won't actually happen.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom