A policy I agree with Romney about.

Health insurance is really bankruptcy insurance. It's easy to run up a bill that would demolish most nest eggs. So you pay premiums to avoid the risk.

A lot of old people could afford a premium closer to market rates - means testing doesn't seem horrible.
 
Whle the Democrats would try to eliminate ANY contributions by THOSE people and try to make everyone else pay for it regardless of what the economy was doing.
Dude, if you are disabled and unemployed, making you pay an insurance premium is kind of a blood-from-turnips trick. The idea of Medicare was that we would all be paying for it in taxes, so even the dimmy who has worked his butt off making some entrepreneur rich has kicked into it. The entrepreneur has paid into it, and it is available to him so that he doesn't wind up in the street if he gets cancer.

If we are not all in on it, rich or poor, the rich might well just get the idea that they should not be paying into it, and will buy enough congress crittters to get them out of it.
 
Even if I were as wealthy as Croesus I'd rather have an insurance card so if I showed up in an emergency room at 3am sunday morn with chest pains I'd get admitted and treated asap.
Emergency rooms are required to treat you regardless of your ability to pay or insurance coverage. Show me a case where they prioritize a potential heart attack patient based on ability to pay, and I'll show you a lawsuit waiting to happen.
 
You have to be admitted before you get treated; an insurance card gets you admitted asap.

Perhaps a tardy admission would also be grounds for a lawsuit from your survivors; I'd rather no one in my family ever finds out.

As to means testing, "How often?" is my first question; monthly? yearly? other? As previously mentioned I'd like to see a cost/benefit workup, and who pays for that?
 
Last edited:
As an FYI, means testing is already part of the system. Any significant increase year to year of taxable Adjusted Gross Income will result in a large increase in next years Medicare premiums that are deducted from social security for joint filers both get hit, and the year this happened to us resulted in medicare premiums exceeding premiums for supplemental Major Medical.

AGI includes capital gains, if any; that was what our trigger was, and the lower taxrate for cap. gain does not fully offset the attendant increased Medicare premiums.
 
http://www.npr.org/blogs/health/2012/03/12/148471674/romney-says-no-thanks-to-medicare?ft=1&f=1001

Medicare SHOULD be means tested. The bar should be set fairly high, but it should be means tested.

Unfortunately, Romney's position on Medicare is actually extremely vague:

Romney’s Positions Increasingly Impossible To Nail Down

Democrats and Republicans alike have tried to portray Mitt Romney as a “flip-flopper” who changes his positions on crucial issues over time. But in 2012, Romney’s inoculated himself against these charges with a more nuanced tactic: taking positions that are so vague as to be adaptable to any situation.

The most recent example is Medicare, where the Romney campaign released a heavily misleading memo on Monday that, in addition to other odd claims, simultaneously called out the White House for not reducing Medicare spending then attacked them for doing exactly that in the very same paragraph.

In fact, Romney has been attacking President Obama from both sides on Medicare funding for months. And while it’s a clear contradiction, there’s no decisive way to evaluate just which side of the issue he’s on thanks to a vague proposal that withholds key details. Romney has suggested replacing Medicare with a voucher system in which seniors are allowed to choose between private insurance and a competing public plan and then receive federal help to pay for the coverage. But unlike the House GOP’s budget — the so-called Ryan Plan — Romney has declined to offer any specifics on how big those subsidies would be.

The Many Misleading Claims In Mitt’s Monday Medicare Memo

Romney’s own Medicare framework is fairly vague. But he has articulated support for the more detailed plan in the GOP’s budget, written by Rep. Paul Ryan. That model would provide future seniors federal subsidies to buy private insurance, and allow the existing Medicare program to phase itself out as current seniors pass away, or opt into the private system. A different version of this same program, (the so-called Wyden-Ryan plan, which Romney also supports) would provide future seniors more generous subsidies, and allow them to buy into the existing Medicare program as a public option. The unifying feature of these plans is that they end the Medicare benefit guarantee, and replace it with a subsidy (or defined contribution).

President Obama, by contrast, has made cutting waste on the provider side a key goal. His 2010 health care law includes myriad new policies and pilot programs aimed at bringing costs down by eliminating waste and introducing new efficiencies into Medicare. He also enacted the Independent Payment Advisory Board — the health care law’s cost-cutting panel, whose expert members will, in the years ahead, be tasked with reducing provider payments in order to keep Medicare spending growth at or below GDP growth plus 1 percent. Crucially, the plan is designed to preserve the basic structure of the existing program for all seniors, current and future.

A new Romney camp memo elides all of this. First it ignores the fact that Obama’s health law and the Romney-backed Wyden-Ryan plan hold Medicare cost growth at the same level. Instead, it asks, “Why is President Obama ending Medicare as we know it by allowing it to go bankrupt in less than 15 years?” There are reasons to doubt Medicare will go bankrupt in the next 15 years, but if Obama’s cost-growth plan leads to bankruptcy, then either Romney’s does too, or else he’ll have to lay out how much he plans to cut future seniors’ vouchers to keep his plan sustainable for a longer period of time.

Romney’s staff refers to the plan outlined on the campaign website, which notes “Mitt continues to work on refining the details of his plan, and he is exploring different options for ensuring that future seniors receive the premium support they need while also ensuring that competitive pressures encourage providers to improve quality and control cost.”

The memo goes on to attack Obama for “ending Medicare as we know it,” by cutting $500 billion from Medicare spending in the health care law. This line frustrates some conservatives who say it exposes Romney’s unwillingness, in the face of political pressure, to truly roll back Medicare — the GOP vilified the health care law’s Medicare cuts to great effect, making them politically toxic even for those who claim to support cutting Medicare spending.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom