Moderated A letter of thanks to Richard Gage

Ah, I see. So when you say "Nobody has pointed out anything wrong, actually!", you really mean "Nobody has used an arbitrary process I have specified to point out anything that I have subsequently admitted to be wrong". I have pointed out things wrong with your article, and you have replied to my comments (although incorrectly). So, you knew things had been pointed out as wrong, yet you claimed that this hadn't happened. You really do tell a lot of lies for someone claiming to expose the truth.

Dave

No, everyone that has commented on my article via e-mail support the basic conclusion re WTC1 that the top would be arrested up top. Re WTC7 I have not received so many comments. But silence is a good sign.

Re your comments on e.g. this forum I cannot guarantee that I read all posts so if you point out something here, well, there is no guarantee. Pls, follow the recommended procedure (so I know who you are). Re your point how much energy is involved in an alleged contact/impact; it is of course part of the article. I assume one value (0.6 GJ ?) but it just an example. In reality there is no impact!

Do you really believe there is an IMPACT, when the WTC1 top drops. Sorry - no evidence for that on any video. You put yourself in the 'no planes' group by making such absurd suggestions.
 
Heiwa, this thread is about the credibility of Richard Gage's organization. I used your posts here as examples of why Gage's "experts" list amounts to a fallacious argument to authority.

This is not about what some people did not email to you. Your arguments here speak for themselves. If you choose to renounce those arguments now, I'll gladly send an email to Gage to that effect.
 
So, you hear back from Gage yet? :D

No, so I sent him another email today:

Dear Richard,

Members of the JREF forum have pointed out that I missed some of the bizarre 9/11 claims that Anders Bjorkman has made. A few of those:

Björkman claims that if 30 stories of one of the Twin Towers was dropped on the lower 80 stories from a height of two miles, it would bounce off without damaging the lower portion.

Bjorkman claims no plane crashed in a field near Shanksville, which makes him a quadruple no-planer.

Björkman insists that a bathroom scale will register the same weight whether you stand on it or jump on it.

Bjorkman claims that the Twin Towers collapses were comparable a bicycle running into a wall and a child jumping on a bed.

Bjorkman claims that the structures of the Twin Towers, and their collapses, were comparable to a tower of lemons.

In light of all this information, please state your position about the credibility of Anders Bjorkman as a 9/11 researcher.

I would also like to know AE911truth's position on the credibility of the statements made by the engineers on its roster that are quoted here: http://wtc7lies.googlepages.com/theyoughtaknowbetter:critiquesoftheinept

I also welcome your comments on my refutations of your claims on that page.

Thank you,

Mark Roberts

As well as an mail via ae911truth's contact page:

Hello.

A few days ago I sent an email to Richard Gage which summarized the 9/11 claims of Anders Bjorkman, a "no-planer" who believes all evidence that doesn't agree with him is fake and who ranks with Judy Wood in his inability to grasp even the simplest physics concepts.

Please read that summary here: http://wtc7lies.googlepages.com

Mr. Gage hasn't replied to me. In light of the information I've provided, I'd like to know AE911truth's position on the credibility of Mr. Bjorkman as a 9/11 researcher.

I would also like to know AE911truth's position on the credibility of the statements made by the engineers on its roster that are quoted here: http://wtc7lies.googlepages.com/theyoughtaknowbetter:critiquesoftheinept

Thank you,
Mark Roberts

Obviously they're not going to change anything: they haven't deleted all the crackpot statements from their other engineers. But at least now they can't say they didn't know about Bjorkman's views.
 
Heiwa, this thread is about the credibility of Richard Gage's organization. I used your posts here as examples of why Gage's "experts" list amounts to a fallacious argument to authority.

This is not about what some people did not email to you. Your arguments here speak for themselves. If you choose to renounce those arguments now, I'll gladly send an email to Gage to that effect.

In my view your letter is a malicious attack on A&E911truth using me as an example with odd, out-of-context quotes. The matter is quite clear. The three WTC buildings were not brought down by gravity alone initiated by some local structural failures due to heat and fire. It is, in my view, quite easy to prove as Richard Gage and A&E911truth do their way and I my way. My method to debunk the NIST reports and the Bazant opus I, II and III is to compare with structural damage analysis of steel ship collisions (or pizza box collisions) where much bigger (and smaller) energies are involved and then in clear and simple language explain the errors of NIST and Bazant.

An interesting side effect is plenty of hate mail from anonymous supporters of the NIST theory without any technical basis.
 
In my view your letter is a malicious attack on A&E911truth using me as an example with odd, out-of-context quotes. The matter is quite clear. The three WTC buildings were not brought down by gravity alone initiated by some local structural failures due to heat and fire. It is, in my view, quite easy to prove as Richard Gage and A&E911truth do their way and I my way. My method to debunk the NIST reports and the Bazant opus I, II and III is to compare with structural damage analysis of steel ship collisions (or pizza box collisions) where much bigger (and smaller) energies are involved and then in clear and simple language explain the errors of NIST and Bazant.

An interesting side effect is plenty of hate mail from anonymous supporters of the NIST theory without any technical basis.

It doesn't look like you and Gage are getting anywhere with your new theory of physics and structural engineering.

What's your next step, Heiwa?
 
False. Read the threads I linked to.

False. It took very little effort. I just searched for Heiwa+Stundie. Forum members provided links to several remarkable claims of yours that I'd missed.

Regarding your allegation that

"Björkman claims that airliners would have "bounced off" the Twin Towers."

you completely missed the point that Heiwa was pointing out logical inconsistencies in different viewpoints of the buildings. Apparently, you don't know what a physicist means when they refer to a rod, e.g., as "rigid". (From context, you can usually infer if they mean "perfectly rigid".) If you had bothered to read not just Heiwa's post 9, but also his post 19 in the same thread, where he says,

Well, if you have a nuke in your wardrobe and want to destroy a rigid structure with it, have a try. The rigid structure is indestructible (by definition) and thus remains intact. That's why NIST, Bazant, Seffen & Co assume WTC1/2 upper parts are rigid in their various (NWO) theories of the collapses of the structure below.
(emphasis mine)

then you could have figured this out, even without knowing it previously.

Now, I have to say that Heiwa's English is not the best, so it's not always easy to get his meaning. But before you go and make a list "exposing" him, shouldn't you have made a good-faith effort understand what the heck he meant?

I don't accept a lot of what Heiwa writes, but in this particular case, if you have any integrity, you will immediately revise your list to either remove this particular "find", or else make a semi-legitimate complaint that plane would not literally "bounce" off of a rigid structure, but rather break into many pieces. I say "semi-legitimate" because nobody, including Heiwa, believes that a thin - skinned metallic structure zipping along at 400 + mph will bounce like a rubber ball, on impact. Well, at least I hope so!

Speaking of rigid vs. non-rigid, I have posted Goldsmith's graphs of purely elastic, longitudinal collisions of rods. Hopefully I will follow up with graphs of the stress wave resulting from a rigid impactor on a fixed elastic rod in about 1.5 weeks. See here and here. Note that the sanity check was eventually OK (roughly, anyway), after I corrected errors in the quantities I was comparing, so pay no attention to the title.

I'm sure that if and when the Bazant Zhou paper is completely and rigorously deconstructed, and shown to be not just illogical, but fundamentally aphysical, that you will be happy to write the Journal that it was published in and demand it's retraction. Correct? Somehow, I think not, but "thankful" is not the word to describe how I feel about the herd mentality exhibited by NIST and debunkers in failing to see obvious faults, either in technical papers or in interpretations of posts that you and they so gleefully find fault in, but can be understood by simply reading a few posts further down in the same thread. "Sad" is more like it, and it doesn't just affect the pathetic level of research into 911, but areas of mainstream physics, also.

This should be the topic of another thread, but I will just say, for now, that society really needs critical, long-term thinking about civilization threatening events and tendencies. JREF could play a part in making society more rational, but not by confusing snark with sincere criticism, nor by hypocritically applying different standards towards claims that you don't like, and another towards ones you do. And it's really, really a bad idea to not examine the critiques we already have (such as Not Even Wrong and The Trouble with Physics) which point clearly to "tribalistic" behavior being antithetical to scientific truth-seeking, and yet way too common.
 
I'm sure that if and when the Bazant Zhou paper is completely and rigorously deconstructed, and shown to be not just illogical, but fundamentally aphysical, that you will be happy to write the Journal that it was published in and demand it's retraction. Correct?

Well-poisoning, and ignorant of the fact that Bazant's papers have already withstood peer review, formal published responses, seven years of endless belly-aching from the Truth Movement, and multiple refinements from the good Doctor and his colleagues. It won't happen. Existential Fallacy as well.

This line of attack is ridiculous. The fact, indisputable, is that Heiwa has made a stunning number of absolutely impossible statements, while cloaking himself in the authority of an "engineer." That you would write it off as a language barrier, or try to focus on some imagined future time when he is exonerated and all legitimate science downcast as in the excerpt above, is truly pathetic to behold.
 
None of what you say changes the fact that I suspect you are ideologically biased, Metamars. An ideologue is a poor investigator, whether he be far to the right or far to the left. I'll leave it at that.
 
Regarding your allegation that

"Björkman claims that airliners would have "bounced off" the Twin Towers."

you completely missed the point that Heiwa was pointing out logical inconsistencies in different viewpoints of the buildings.
Fair enough. While that statement is entirely consistent with Bjorkman's ideas about the physical world, I've removed it and replaced it with this one.

Björkman says a Tower wouldn't be destroyed if a 60-million-pound block of ice were dropped on it.

My, how his credibility is restored!

Since this thread is about the credibility of Richard Gage's organization, please state if you think Bjorkman was a good choice for "Petitioner of the Month," and whether you agree with the statements by AE911truth's other featured engineers, linked above.
 
Fair enough. While that statement is entirely consistent with Bjorkman's ideas about the physical world, I've removed it and replaced it with this one.

Björkman says a Tower wouldn't be destroyed if a 60-million-pound block of ice were dropped on it.

My, how his credibility is restored!

Since this thread is about the credibility of Richard Gage's organization, please state if you think Bjorkman was a good choice for "Petitioner of the Month," and whether you agree with the statements by AE911truth's other featured engineers, linked above.

I clicked on the link and could not find any 60-million-pound block of ice.

There is mention of 30 000 ton of water being poured on WTC 1 with no effect other than people getting wet in the plaza. And maybe Heiwa suggested 30 000 ton of ice cubes to be put in a G&T at 5 pm? You have to quote correctly, Gravy. That's rule number 1. Don't invent things.

Re Bjorkman - just quote what he says in his articles and if you find anything wrong just send him (me) an e-mail. You'll get an answer.
 
Fair enough. While that statement is entirely consistent with Bjorkman's ideas about the physical world, I've removed it and replaced it with this one.

Björkman says a Tower wouldn't be destroyed if a 60-million-pound block of ice were dropped on it.

My, how his credibility is restored!

Since this thread is about the credibility of Richard Gage's organization, please state if you think Bjorkman was a good choice for "Petitioner of the Month," and whether you agree with the statements by AE911truth's other featured engineers, linked above.

The only things I have to say about ae911truth, at this time, are these two:

Gage's first claim about collapse "through the path of greatest resistance" is bogus. He's not thinking about the details, enough, which strikes me as a little strange for an architect. The resistance to collapse is essentially via the columns, which only occupy about 2% of the area of any floor. If you get what I call a "disconnecting collapse" going, a vertical path of greatly diminished resistance is only about 1 foot away from "the path of greatest resistance".

Secondly, I quit ae911truth recently, in part because of what Gage said about Gregory Urich. While Greg could have been a little less strident, I fully sympathize with his frustration in getting both stj911 and ae911truth to act more scientifically. "Science thrives on controversy" - Lee Smolin.

Good on you for dropping the mistaken criticism of Björkman's statement involving a rigid building.
 
I clicked on the link and could not find any 60-million-pound block of ice.

There is mention of 30 000 ton of water being poured on WTC 1 with no effect other than people getting wet in the plaza. And maybe Heiwa suggested 30 000 ton of ice cubes to be put in a G&T at 5 pm? You have to quote correctly, Gravy. That's rule number 1. Don't invent things.

Re Bjorkman - just quote what he says in his articles and if you find anything wrong just send him (me) an e-mail. You'll get an answer.

From the linked post (bolding mine):

Heiwa said:
2. Drop an ice block of 30 000 tons (same amount of PE) on WTC1 and the steel columns of WTC1 will break the ice and the PE ends up as small ice blocks in the streets of NYC. Agree? Ice is slightly more solid than water but not rigid! Don't you break ice and put it in your G&T at 5 pm?

30,000 tons * 2000 lbs/ton = 60,000,000 lbs, just as Gravy said.
 
Secondly, I quit ae911truth recently, in part because of what Gage said about Gregory Urich. While Greg could have been a little less strident, I fully sympathize with his frustration in getting both stj911 and ae911truth to act more scientifically. "Science thrives on controversy" - Lee Smolin.

Good on you for dropping the mistaken criticism of Björkman's statement involving a rigid building.

Good for you! Just out of curiosity, Has you name been removed from the site yet?
 
I clicked on the link and could not find any 60-million-pound block of ice.

There is mention of 30 000 ton of water being poured on WTC 1 with no effect other than people getting wet in the plaza. And maybe Heiwa suggested 30 000 ton of ice cubes to be put in a G&T at 5 pm? You have to quote correctly, Gravy. That's rule number 1. Don't invent things.
Sheer lunacy.

You said "ice block of 30 000 tons." Are you the only engineer in the world who cannot figure out how to do basic unit conversions?

2. Drop an ice block of 30 000 tons (same amount of PE) on WTC1 and the steel columns of WTC1 will break the ice and the PE ends up as small ice blocks in the streets of NYC. Agree? Ice is slightly more solid than water but not rigid! Don't you break ice and put it in your G&T at 5 pm?

3. Drop the top part of 30 000 tons of WTC1 on the WTC1 structure below and the top part breaks up and pieces of it falls down on the plaza below while some remain up top - actually bounces on the structure below. Reason? Top part was not rigid. No collapse will ensue due to PE>SE.

4. Drop anything A on anything B and see Newton's third law at work. A cannot free fall through B (even if NIST suggest that that is the case with WTC7).

My, how your credibility is restored!
 
The only things I have to say about ae911truth, at this time, are these two:

Gage's first claim about collapse "through the path of greatest resistance" is bogus. He's not thinking about the details, enough, which strikes me as a little strange for an architect. The resistance to collapse is essentially via the columns, which only occupy about 2% of the area of any floor. If you get what I call a "disconnecting collapse" going, a vertical path of greatly diminished resistance is only about 1 foot away from "the path of greatest resistance".

Secondly, I quit ae911truth recently, in part because of what Gage said about Gregory Urich. While Greg could have been a little less strident, I fully sympathize with his frustration in getting both stj911 and ae911truth to act more scientifically. "Science thrives on controversy" - Lee Smolin.

Good on you for dropping the mistaken criticism of Björkman's statement involving a rigid building.
Good for you, but what's so difficult about my simple questions?

Do you think Anders Bjorkman was a wise choice for an organization that's trying to establish its credibility in the field of structural engineering?

Do you think the quotes I've posted by its other engineers are an accurate representation of reality?
 
No, so I sent him another email today:

As well as an mail via ae911truth's contact page:

Obviously they're not going to change anything: they haven't deleted all the crackpot statements from their other engineers. But at least now they can't say they didn't know about Bjorkman's views.

I understand your frustration Gravy, but I would be very surprised if Mr. Gage responds, considering your rather hostile tone. He hasn't even responded to my "Open Letter" which was much more "friendly" in approach.

Here is an interesting exchange between Richard Gage and I, which started with my resignation from Scholars for 9/11 Truth and Justice:

Dear Steering Committee of Scholars for 9/11 Truth and Justice,

(Please forward to the other members.)

I hereby resign my membership with Scholars for 9/11 Truth and Justice and respectfully demand that all information on the public web site regarding my membership status be updated to reflect this or be removed. My reasons for this decision are that the organization does not live up to its charter regarding “evidence based scientific inquiry” or democratic principles...

Guys – I wouldn’t even dignify him with a response. He did the same thing over here at AE911Truth.

Richard

Mr. Gage,

Since you didn't dignify well reasoned criticism from a member of your organization with a response either, I am not surprized at your attitude.

Your blatant disregard for the scientific method and your dishonesty will catch up with you sooner or later.

/Gregory

Gregory – everyone knows your intentions and they are not scientific nor honorable. We have very important work to accomplish at AE911Truth which you are blind to - having your own ulterior motive. Please don’t waste our time. Post over at the JREF forum with your good friends who will surely give you the attention you crave.

Richard Gage

Interesting that both Gage and some hardcore JREFers have reached the same conclusion regarding my having an "ulterior motive". The only difference is that the imagined motives are diametrically opposed. And the attention I crave? Has this man ever looked in a mirror? :jaw-dropp

Mr. Gage has important work to do Gravy. Why are you wasting his time?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom