Moderated A letter of thanks to Richard Gage

...

from: Mark Roberts
to: Richard Gage
date: Mon, Feb 16, 2009
subject: Thanks!


Dear Richard,

I note with interest your promotion of Anders Bjorkman as Architects and Engineers for 9/11 Truth's "Petitioner of the Month" for February. I wholeheartedly agree that he's a fitting addition to your pantheon of "professional" petitioners. Take care that he doesn't steal your limelight though: his "3.5 m tower (95 boxes) with an 0.5 m pizza impactor" has had an ecstatic reception from bedazzled four-year-olds at ChuckE.Cheese's restaurants nationwide.

From my website:

We've seen the staggeringly ignorant and outright bizarre nonsense spewed by Gage and the "experts" whose opinions he promotes. Is Björkman's promotion by AE911Truth another fallacious appeal to authority, or has he done some sensible analysis of the events of 9/11? Bjorkman posts as "Heiwa" on the JREF forum:​


I note also that in addition to still not correcting your online slide presentation's avalanche of major errors about the events of 9/11, you continue to claim that your organization has a full-time staff of a dozen people. You'll recall that this was the first thing I corrected you about during our Hardfire shows. I'm very curious to know how you justify to yourself this blatant lie when appealing for money.

Sincerely,
Mark Roberts
He is perfect for Gage and his pantheon of 911Truth delusions.
 
Last edited:
Bonavada, do you have a link to that post?

Hi bell, it was me that posted the quote.

Here is the question.

Originally Posted by Heiwa
The small fires we see on photos are negligible. Just to roast a chicken on! So I assume most heat had escaped with the smoke, the temperature had fallen as fresh air was sucked in.


Why did people jump from the building if the fires weren't hot?

And where did all that smoke come from?


http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2783488&postcount=130

Here is the answer

If you have read the 9/11 Commission report about all events that took place on 9/11 prior impacts as I assume you have, do you believe everything in it? I do not (and millions others). It is too much fiction and fantasy in the report.
But my main interest is the analysis of structural damages after impacts, i.e. the results of forensic examinations ... or the lack of them.

WTC2 was the first tower that collapsed. I assume the people trapped in the section above thought they were safe and that the tower would not collapse as the fire slowly went out. But then WCT2 suddenly collapsed ... and NIST is coming up with some suggestions why that we are discussing. Controlled demolition is evidently not investigated by NIST.

The people trapped in the WCT1 must have been horrified when WTC2 collapsed. I assume they concluded their tower would also collapse ... and some desperate persons decided to jump before that, etc. Terrible.

I see no harm in discussing WTC2 and what happened to its structure after impact and prior to the global collapse that ensued.

NIST alleges that the east wall suddenly buckled and that there was load redistribution which caused the collapse. But it is not certain. Very little is certain.

NIST says that the intact section above tilted 7-8° to east prior collapse, but then the west part of the tower could not really be damaged as it was. And where did the intact section land?

With all respect to NIST they should have spent less ink/paper on the design, construction, maintenance and fire protection of the tower and descriptions of fires after impact and prior collapse. Much more efforts should have been spent on the structural conditions of the tower after impact and prior collapse and forensic examinations of the rubble that could explain the collapse.

I have bolded the answer.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2785187&postcount=149

Taken from this thread.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=87437&page=4

As you may gather from the tone of my posts in this thread I was very annoyed at it, hence the reason I remember it so well.

Regards.
 
Last edited:
Naw, just crap typing skills. :)

But, seriously, if there's one thing that really gets on my wick it's incompetence in the profession. This man is a fool, and disgraces us all.

You might want to define "gets on my wick" for our benighted American readers, who will surely find such idiom baffling. A typo here and there they can accomodate, English slang perhaps not so much.

"This man is a fool" - that's solid bedrock. After reading his posts there's no discussion or arguing about that.
 
Stateofgrace, thanks! Heh, I just noticed Heiwa was a member here back in 2007. Must not have made much of an impression on me, as I don't remember him from back then. And seeing that he is in the camp of "dying fires" and "fires not that hot" bull****, he'll not make any impression on me ever, since I'll be putting him on ignore.
 
Stateofgrace, thanks! Heh, I just noticed Heiwa was a member here back in 2007. Must not have made much of an impression on me, as I don't remember him from back then. And seeing that he is in the camp of "dying fires" and "fires not that hot" bull****, he'll not make any impression on me ever, since I'll be putting him on ignore.

This is the best place for him. :)
 
I had wanted to post this to the existing thread, but it was closed due to off-topic posts.


from: Mark Roberts
to: Richard Gage
date: Mon, Feb 16, 2009
subject: Thanks!


Dear Richard,

I note with interest your promotion of Anders Bjorkman as Architects and Engineers for 9/11 Truth's "Petitioner of the Month" for February. I wholeheartedly agree that he's a fitting addition to your pantheon of "professional" petitioners. Take care that he doesn't steal your limelight though: his "3.5 m tower (95 boxes) with an 0.5 m pizza impactor" has had an ecstatic reception from bedazzled four-year-olds at ChuckE.Cheese's restaurants nationwide.

From my website:

We've seen the staggeringly ignorant and outright bizarre nonsense spewed by Gage and the "experts" whose opinions he promotes. Is Björkman's promotion by AE911Truth another fallacious appeal to authority, or has he done some sensible analysis of the events of 9/11? Bjorkman posts as "Heiwa" on the JREF forum:
​

I note also that in addition to still not correcting your online slide presentation's avalanche of major errors about the events of 9/11, you continue to claim that your organization has a full-time staff of a dozen people. You'll recall that this was the first thing I corrected you about during our Hardfire shows. I'm very curious to know how you justify to yourself this blatant lie when appealing for money.

Sincerely,
Mark Roberts

My, my - what big effort to write this letter to Richard. Just for the records - my (Anders Björkman's) observations, findings, calculations and conclusions about WTC 1 and WTC 7 you find at my web site http://heiwaco.tripod.com .
Structural damage analysis of steel structures is explained in clear and simple language from my personal point of view. The content has been reviewed by 10 000's of visitors and 99.9% seem very happy. Of course I get comments that point out areas that can be better described, etc., so I do that. Nobody has pointed out anything wrong, actually! As expected!

Re the Heiwa posts you link to above (big effort to collect those!) you should know they are adapted for the average JREF participants in the discussions (age <10, IQ <80) - that can visualize pizza boxes, sponges, lemons, etc.

I like the feed back except all these rude, stupid, disgusting comments of a personal nature that are OT. What is the real purpose with your trash, sorry, letter? Jealousy? Malice?

Anders Björkman
 
Setting this thread to moderated status, as per warning in post 39.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: chillzero
 
Nobody has pointed out anything wrong, actually! As expected!
False. Read the threads I linked to.

Re the Heiwa posts you link to above (big effort to collect those!)
False. It took very little effort. I just searched for Heiwa+Stundie. Forum members provided links to several remarkable claims of yours that I'd missed.
 
Structural damage analysis of steel structures is explained in clear and simple language from my personal point of view. The content has been reviewed by 10 000's of visitors and 99.9% seem very happy. Of course I get comments that point out areas that can be better described, etc., so I do that. Nobody has pointed out anything wrong, actually! As expected!

I'm sorry, but that's plainly wrong. You have failed to post any competent and meanginful structural calculations of the type we would expect in the design or analysis of a building, including failure thereof.
 
Nobody has pointed out anything wrong, actually!

Aren't you conveniently forgetting that I pointed out recently that (a) your calculation of the stored spring energy is wrong, and that (b) you've ignored half the potential energy released in the initial drop with no justification? I think it would be more accurate that nobody has pointed out anything that you're prepared to admit is wrong.

Dave
 
Aren't you conveniently forgetting that I pointed out recently that (a) your calculation of the stored spring energy is wrong, and that (b) you've ignored half the potential energy released in the initial drop with no justification? I think it would be more accurate that nobody has pointed out anything that you're prepared to admit is wrong.

Dave

No! Just send an e-mail and copy/paste text of my article that you consider wrong + corrections and I will look at it. It is very easy. You have never done it.
 
I'm sorry, but that's plainly wrong. You have failed to post any competent and meanginful structural calculations of the type we would expect in the design or analysis of a building, including failure thereof.

No! Just send an e-mail and copy/paste text of my article that you consider wrong or incomplete + corrections and I will look at it. It is very easy. You have never done it. All calculations are in the articles. No need to copy those in posts.

Who are we?
 
No! Just send an e-mail and copy/paste text of my article that you consider wrong + corrections and I will look at it. It is very easy. You have never done it.

Ah, I see. So when you say "Nobody has pointed out anything wrong, actually!", you really mean "Nobody has used an arbitrary process I have specified to point out anything that I have subsequently admitted to be wrong". I have pointed out things wrong with your article, and you have replied to my comments (although incorrectly). So, you knew things had been pointed out as wrong, yet you claimed that this hadn't happened. You really do tell a lot of lies for someone claiming to expose the truth.

Dave
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom