A Hot Knife Through Bullcrap

There could of course be a problem using a box. The uncertainty principle in physics states that it is impossible to know both the position and state of an object. If this principle also applies to psychics, it would be impossible for JM to control both the side on which the coin lands and getting the coin to land in the box.

On a more serious note: Taping the trials without other controls is only sufficient for a self test so there is no point in asking JM to post such video as proof of his ability. For remote testing I have another protocol (though it might require a slightly different paranormal ability).

At an appointed time, each person with an interest in the results would think up a 10 digit number. A commitment to these numbers would be posted so the numbers cannot be changed. The numbers from each participant will later be added without carry to produce the target number. Each applicant would record what they believe the target number will be and post a commitment to their answer. Finally, all the numbers would be posted so each participant can verify the commitments and the applicants results.
 
Well I don't want to be unnecessarily negative, but I must say that I find this suggested modification of the protocol entirely pointless. It completely fails to achieve its promised goal of eliminating or even reducing the effects of skewed perception of reality.

I already said it wasn't perfect. In fact, no self test can be perfect because the subject could hallucinate the entire test. The goal of using the video tape was (as I had previously stated) to separate the events of performing the trials where Jim would be putting himself into a state of mind where he believes his paranormal powers are changing the outcome and the process of scoring the test. The video tape alone may be sufficient for this task but I thought there would be a significant risk of Jim falling into the same state during playback when he is anticipating the results. By splitting the visual and audio playback, the scoring of the trials becomes a purely mechanical task where there is no feedback of being right or wrong until the final score is relieved.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom