A Hot Knife Through Bullcrap

Skeptics seem to jump at the opportunity to design testing protocols and I had this idea for a test while reading this thread...

This is sort of a meta test. The goal is to design a test protocol to prove to your self that you have some ability to effect the real world. This ability does not have to be paranormal.

But there is a catch. You are sealed in a room and your only communications is via text messaging to an assistant on the outside. You can request that this assistant perform any task and request a report on any observation.

A successful test protocol will allow you to determine if the assistant is accurately reporting results or just making things up.

And just one more thing, the assistant knows everything that you know either through close association or perhaps is able to read your mind.
 
Hmm, interesting!

And just one more thing, the assistant knows everything that you know either through close association or perhaps is able to read your mind.

I wonder why you wrote that in an almost invisible color?

As loosely specified as your problem is, it is solvable. The protocol would have to include some information that is not known to you but can be verified afterwards. For example, you could ask the assistant to use a computer to solve a difficult mathematical problem and then spend years verifying it manually. If the answer turns out to be correct, you know he has used a computer. ;) Or, you could ask him to measure some physical constant which you don't remember exactly, then verify it yourself. If his answer is correct, you know he didn't make it up.

These solutions rely on assumptions that you didn't explicitly forbid (that your assistant is human, or that the outside world is governed by the same physical laws as your room). If you meant to say that no assumptions can be made about the outside world or about the nature of the assistant, then no such protocol exists. It can be shown as follows:

Scenario 1: Your assistant happens to be a computer simulating a small universe with a tiny simulated assistant. This computer exists in a different universe governed by different laws, but it tunnels your communication unchanged to the simulated assistant, who honestly makes experiments in his simulated universe and answers questions truthfully.

Scenario 2: The outside universe is the small universe, as simulated by the computer from scenario 1, and you are actually talking to the tiny assistant.

The exchanged communication will be identical in both cases - if it isn't, then the computer from scenario 1 is not properly simulating the small universe. If a protocol exists that decides about the assistant's honesty based only on the exchanged communication, then it must give the same answer in both scenarios and the answer is therefore necessarily wrong in one of the scenarios.

However, I don't think that this means that no protocol can be designed to prove to yourself that you can affect the real world. Scientific protocols make a whole lot of implicit assumptions (such as that the observer's memory is not changed immediately after he makes an observation, and many others). Unfalsifiable hypotheses (e.g., what if we all live in a Matrix?) belong to the realm of philosophy, they are not part of the scientific method.
 
I wonder why you wrote that in an almost invisible color?
I added that because I didn't want to be accused of changing the problem when I add some clarification after everyone has had a chance to think about this for a while.
 
Those two are tossing pies and I don't even have to duck. :confused:

I tried to keep it simple so it wouldn't go too far over anyones head. :duck:

Let the box represent the conscious self and the assistant represent perceptions and physical responses. Now try your self test for paranormal powers with the assumption that the assistant could have been programmed through the individuals strong belief in their power to help prove that the power exists.
 
I tried to keep it simple so it wouldn't go too far over anyones head. :duck:
;)

Now try your self test for paranormal powers with the assumption that the assistant could have been programmed through the individuals strong belief in their power to help prove that the power exists.
I don't know, there must be some missing punctuation or misplaced pronouns or something, because I can't parse this sentence.
Who are "the individuals" and to whom does "their" refer?
 
;) I don't know, there must be some missing punctuation or misplaced pronouns or something, because I can't parse this sentence.

I'll try again...

Now, try your "self test for paranormal powers" with the assumption that the assistant (aka, the test subject's own perception) could have been programmed through the individual (test subject)'s strong belief in their (refering to a property of the test subject) [percieved paramonmal] power [in order] to help prove [to themself (the test subject)] that the [(test subject's) percieved paramonmal] power exists.
 
Now, try your "self test for paranormal powers" with the assumption that the assistant (aka, the test subject's own perception) could have been programmed through the individual (test subject)'s strong belief in their (refering to a property of the test subject) [percieved paramonmal] power [in order] to help prove [to themself (the test subject)] that the [(test subject's) percieved paramonmal] power exists.
Ah....
Is this an accurate translation of your last three posts?....


The goal is to design a test protocol to prove to yourself that you have some ability to effect the real world.

You are inside a sealed room and your only communications are via text messaging to an assistant outside the sealed room. The assistant knows everything that you know. The room represents your conscious self, and the assistant outside the room represents your perceptions and physical responses. You can request this assistant to report on any observation (which is how he represents your perceptions). And you can request that this assistant perform any task (which is how he represents your physical responses).

In order to help prove to yourself that your ability exists, perform your "self test for (paranormal) ability" with the assumption that your assistant could have been programmed through your strong belief in your ability.

A successful test protocol will allow you to determine if the assistant is accurately reporting results or just making things up.


How's that sound?
 
It's getting close. The ultimate goal is to design a self test for a paranormal ability. However, it is difficult to separate the observance of the paranormal from an error in perception so I introduced a metaphor shift to isolate the perceptions and remove the paranormal in developing this part of the protocol. A successful protocol for the sealed room scenario would be a building block for a paranormal self test.
 
Though they are somewhat tricky to self administer.

Sometimes yes, sometimes no. That depends very much on the claim.

Some claims are trivial to test in a double-blinded fashion, such as predictions, prophecies, event-outcome-forcing etc. With many other claims - dowsing, ESP, remote viewing, etc. - it is less trivial, but one can still self-administer a double-blinded test if one can hide the objects in visually and mechanically indistinguishable containers and randomly shuffle them; if the containers are small and sturdy, one can easily use a big opaque bag or a tumble-dryer for this purpose.

Claims that are inherently subject to interpretation - astrology, communication with spirits, etc. - would be very difficult to self-test while remaining double-blinded. I can't really think of a way how that could be done. And finally, claims such as psychic surgery or telepathy are impossible to self-test altogether, due to the nature of the claim.

Considering the inherent diversity of claims and their respective tests, I really doubt that any generic design for self-tests can be suggested, other than "keep it double-blinded". Can you propose any?
 
Sometimes yes, sometimes no. That depends very much on the claim.

It depends more on who is making the claim.

In most any paranormal claim, we have a subject that is stating a personal observation that reality as we know it is flawed. This subject is the one that would be administering the test. We cannot blindly assume that they will be a reliable observer.
 
A successful protocol for the sealed room scenario would be a building block for a paranormal self test.
Yes, I see.

The ultimate goal is to design a self test for a paranormal ability. However, it is difficult to separate the observance of the paranormal from an error in perception so I introduced a metaphor shift to isolate the perceptions and remove the paranormal in developing this part of the protocol.
But I'm wondering what form the "assistant" would take in such a "self-test".

In JM's case, the "assistant" would constitute a device for (1) receiving JM's choice of "heads" or "tails", (2) tossing the coin, (3) informing JM when the toss is completed (so he can stop concentrating on the outcome), and (4) informing JM of the outcome of the coin toss.
Sounds pretty complex for a simple self-test to see if it is worth going public (by applying for the MDC).
 
In JM's case, the subject in the box and the assistant are all part of JM and cannot be separated. A protocol needs to be constructed so that JM's conscious self (the subject inside the box) will know the real outcome of the test despite the best efforts of JM's perceptions (the assistant) trying to fake a paranormal power.

Just flipping a coin doesn't work because JM can simply "see" the coin land heads or tails in whatever pattern best supports his theory of his power. We need to at least separate the observation of the test from the performance of the test.

One possibility is to use a video camera to record the trials and a computer to tally the results:
  • Flip a coin or roll a die in a box without looking at the result (possibly wear a blindfold)
  • Verbally call out the predicted or forced result before each toss
  • Do enough trials that you cannot memorize the whole sequence of results
  • Rewind the tape and replay with the sound off and record the results in the first column of a spreadsheet
  • Lock and hide the first column of the spreadsheet
  • Rewind the tape and listening only to the sound, record the called result
  • Lock the second column
  • In the third column, compute the match between the first two columns
  • Compute the percentage of matching results.

This isn't perfect because JM would need to still correctly perceive the final percentage. But at least he is not consciously trying to use his power to change the numbers on the screen.
 
Well, why didn't you say so right from the start.

All we need is for JM to call out his choice (loudly and clearly) and then flip the coin into a box. Use a box with sufficiently high walls and positioned sufficiently far away from JM's chair that he cannot possibly see the bottom of the box.
Have a video camera (which also records sound) positioned so that it takes in the whole view of the bottom of the box.

What do you think JM?
 
Well I don't want to be unnecessarily negative, but I must say that I find this suggested modification of the protocol entirely pointless. It completely fails to achieve its promised goal of eliminating or even reducing the effects of skewed perception of reality.

Just flipping a coin doesn't work because JM can simply "see" the coin land heads or tails in whatever pattern best supports his theory of his power.

If you assume that the experimenter might be seeing heads where tails are (i.e. be hallucinating), then every single point of the suggested protocol can be challenged by the same assumption:

Flip a coin or roll a die in a box without looking at the result (possibly wear a blindfold)
The experimenter may, without being conciously aware of it (through his pre-programmed assistant), indicate the called outcome to the camera with a finger gesture when picking up the coin. Later when transcribing the video track into the first column, he may use this information to rewrite the actual result into the called result (his pre-programmed assistant will prevent him from realizing he is doing that). Even if all other points are adhered to, this invalidates the protocol.
Verbally call out the predicted or forced result before each toss
The experimenter may, without being conciously aware of it, shift his blindfold so that he can see the result when picking up the coin and mumble the result. Later when transcribing the audio track into the second column, he may use this information to rewrite the called result into the actual result (his pre-programmed assistant will prevent him from realizing he is doing that). Even if all other points are adhered to, this invalidates the protocol.
Do enough trials that you cannot memorize the whole sequence of results
The experimenter may, without being conciously aware of it, use an easily memorable pattern of calls. His pre-programmed assistant may then use this to override the results he sees when watching the video track. Even if all other points are adhered to, this invalidates the protocol.
Rewind the tape and replay with the sound off and record the results in the first column of a spreadsheet
The experimenter may believe he turned the sound off, but actually leave it on (his pre-programmed assistant will prevent him from realizing he has done that). Even if all other points are adhered to, this invalidates the protocol.
Lock and hide the first column of the spreadsheet
The experimenter may believe he locked and hid the first column of the spreadsheet, but not actually do it (pre-programmed assistant covers up). Even if all other points are adhered to, this invalidates the protocol.
Rewind the tape and listening only to the sound, record the called result
The experimenter may believe he turned the screen off or not be looking at it, but actually watch it (pre-programmed assistant covers up). Even if all other points are adhered to, this invalidates the protocol.
Lock the second column
The experimenter may believe he locked the second column, but instead of doing that, use the spreadsheet program to copy the results from the first column (pre-programmed assistant covers up). Even if all other points are adhered to, this invalidates the protocol.
In the third column, compute the match between the first two columns
The experimenter may believe he used a spreadsheet function to compute the match between the first two column, but actually use a spreadsheet function that will fill the third column with positive matches (pre-programmed assistant covers up). Even if all other points are adhered to, this invalidates the protocol.
Compute the percentage of matching results.
Finally, the experimenter may believe he used a spreadsheet function to compute the percentage of matching results, but actually use a different function to compute some other number (pre-programmed assistant covers up). Even if all other points are adhered to, this invalidates the protocol.

To sum up, this complicated protocol, requiring the use of a video-camera and a spreadsheet, accomplishes precisely nothing in proving to the experimenter that he is not deluding himself.

Most importantly though, it is a distraction, because it does not address the actual point that prevents Jim Mich from applying to the challenge, and that is the fact that he is flipping the coin himself. The possibility that Jim Mich might be hallucinating when observing the results (and I have no reason to suspect that) is irrelevant to taking the challenge.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom