A guy worse than Heiwa? Or Heiwa clone?

3.2 nukes destroyed the WTC? :eek:x1000

Add this to stundies ASAP!


hehe yes it should be added but just to be clear I didnt read that he said 3.2 nukes were used just that it would take that much energy to do so... lol
 
And... lunacy.

He assumes that there would need to be an equivalent of about 588:1 extra mass applied on the building in order for it to collapse. He then calculates the potential energy of this mass and calculates an equivalent number of atomic bombs.

I didn't bother continuing on past then to confirm the mathematical accuracy of his calculations, I only looked at his assumptions. He assumes the in-service live load is 5 times the dead load and that the maximum allowable is 20 times this. It's a pretty ridiculous assumption.

Alright, I have to keep going, this is so insanely hilarious. Skilling said (and I'm sure most of you remember this) that some of the perimeter columns could support 20 times the design live load. A guy on the 911 commission report team, Ronald Hamburger, SE, stated that the tower, before being damaged, could support 5 times it's own weight. So this lunatic decides to multiply the 5 and 20 together for ALL of the columns as a capacity. And then, for some even more ridiculous reason that I cannot fathom, he multiples this by the ratio of columns below the collapse front to those above.

This has got to be a spoof. Please tell me it's a spoof.



@NewtonsBit

He replied to you... wanna tell me what you think? ;)


He multiplies them because the 2000% was for the perimeter and the 5 times was for the core columns, he multiplies them by the ratio because only the bottom was there to support anything, it's pretty simple, I don't see how you don't get it...
And you can tell those idiots on your forum that the expression of 2.4 (not 3.2) nukes was only used to express the amount of energy needed to destroy the towers from the top.



This is the video if you want to respond personally.
 
He lost me at the disclaimer:

First, I'd like to explain something before we get started. I'm not trying to prove anything or provide the complete answer as to what happened on the horrible day of 9/11/2001. I'm merely trying to raise questions about the events and encourage people to demand further investigation of 9/11.
Riiiiiiiight.

Oh geez, a "707 at 600mph" would have more kinetic energy than both the planes on 9/11. Why do these guys have to lie so much?
 
First, I'd like to explain something before we get started. I'm not trying to prove anything or provide the complete answer as to what happened on the horrible day of 9/11/2001. I'm merely trying to raise questions about the events and encourage people to demand further investigation of 9/11.

What the hell is wrong with that?
 
Everything with a debunker is "probably". That's your problem.
The truther definitely got his physics wrong.

According to the screenshot in the original post, the truther is saying the energy required to demolish each WTC tower is the same as the energy required to raise 100 such towers the full height of the tower against the force of gravity.

In reality, the demolished state of the towers had less potential energy and greater entropy than the undemolished state. Thermodynamics was on the side of the terrorists.

Will
 
First, I'd like to explain something before we get started. I'm not trying to prove anything or provide the complete answer as to what happened on the horrible day of 9/11/2001. I'm merely trying to raise questions about the events and encourage people to demand further investigation of 9/11.
What the hell is wrong with that?
Well, to respond to a question with a question:
How are the answers already given incomplete and why should people demand further investigation into 9/11?

This guy claims to just be raising questions, but the problem is, most of his questions are based in fantasy rather than reality.

calebprime said:
Just Asking Questions has long been abused, probably disingenuous.
Everything with a debunker is "probably". That's your problem.
It isn’t a problem. Absolutes are for idiots, bigots and lunatics. Sane, rational people see most things in terms of degrees and probabilities.
 
Last edited:
@NewtonsBit

He replied to you... wanna tell me what you think? ;)


He multiplies them because the 2000% was for the perimeter and the 5 times was for the core columns, he multiplies them by the ratio because only the bottom was there to support anything, it's pretty simple, I don't see how you don't get it...
And you can tell those idiots on your forum that the expression of 2.4 (not 3.2) nukes was only used to express the amount of energy needed to destroy the towers from the top.



This is the video if you want to respond personally.

Sienna is as clueless as Mr. Boldwyn. His so-called calculations are idiotic in the extreme.:covereyes
 
@NewtonsBit

He replied to you... wanna tell me what you think? ;)


He multiplies them because the 2000% was for the perimeter and the 5 times was for the core columns, he multiplies them by the ratio because only the bottom was there to support anything, it's pretty simple, I don't see how you don't get it...
And you can tell those idiots on your forum that the expression of 2.4 (not 3.2) nukes was only used to express the amount of energy needed to destroy the towers from the top.



This is the video if you want to respond personally.

Hamburger states that the true demand-to-capacity ratio of the towers (implicitly the weakest set of columns) is 0.20. This means that increasing the mass evenly on all floors by a factor of 5 would cause a complete global collapse.

Skilling stated that the live load on a few of the columns could be increased by 2000%. I don't have the exact quote or the context that it is in, but I imagine that he is talking about the corner perimeter columns. Due to the nature of how the floors work these corner perimeter columns don't support a very large tributary area of floor. They are, however, one of the elements that prevent overturning forces due to wind. They are designed for this, not for live loads.

How one can possibly think that because a couple of corner columns have a LIVE-LOAD reserve capacity of 20, and that the entire building has a reserve capacity equal to 5 times the self-weight, that the entire building thus has a reserve capacity of 100 is beyond me. It's pure insanity.

In any event, it is the columns that prevent the building from collapsing, not the ratio of mass from the upper block and the lower block. If the columns fail, gravity will pull the whole structure down. This should be self-evident, but if you're a raving lunatic, maybe it's not.
 
boldwyn said:
This is translated into: One 94-Floor-Steel-Block can top-Load at least 588 16-Floor-Steel-Blocks before potential Total Collapse

Doesn't this translate into the 94th floor columns being able to carry 9408 floors? Or a factor of safety of 588? Does this guy realize how stupid he sounds? :eye-poppi:boggled::eye-poppi
 
Must be awfully small atomic bombs.

That's what I was thinking. The largest bomb ever actually detonated (larger ones were built, and even larger designed) was around 50 megatons. That's getting on for 50,000 times more powerful than Little Boy. So rather than taking "at least 3.2 atomic bombs", what it would actually take, according to his calculations, would be 0.000064 atomic bombs. I guess that doesn't sound quite so impressive.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom