A guy worse than Heiwa? Or Heiwa clone?

Edx

Philosopher
Joined
Feb 1, 2008
Messages
5,642
A truther on a youtube comment shootout pointed me to his sidebar and told me to read it.

Here is what he said...

If you look at the thrid link in the sources, it shows that 15 seconds is about the right timing for a controlled demolition.

....

I told you to go look at the third link in my sources, did you? because I believe it's explained there. I think we can agree that the whole structure of the building would have at least 2x the resistance of air but that isn't what is shown in the videos.

So I did and lets have a read...


I do suggest you take a look because its seriously funny. Now please do tell me if I am misinterpreting it but while my eyes glaze over when I see mathematics there are things that caught my eye.

911atombomblol.png




911120mileshighlol.png




edit:

1. 3.2 ATOM BOMBS???

2. 120 MILES UP?

:eye-poppi:eye-poppi:eye-poppi


:D:D:D:D
 
Last edited:
oooh, the entire mass was at the very top. And then it's multiplied by 100 for some reason.

And what exactly does the PE of the building mass have to do with anything other than that being the energy used in the destruction anyway?

EDIT:
but while my eyes glaze over when I see mathematics

I get the same effect, maybe I'm not seeing this right.
 
Last edited:
And he didn't take air resistance into account.

Post from 'twin towers at freefall speed' topic by 3bodyproblem
Just for fun, if anyone's interested:Terminal Velocity Calculator

The drag coefficient for a cube is 0.8.

The cross sectional area was 43264 ft^2

Mass? Use Greening's 30,000 tonnes.

What's that you say? The terminal velocity is 781.305 mph?
 
I dont know about that, I'm mainly shocked that he said it would take the energy of 3.2 ATOMIC BOMBS to destroy a WTC tower, and that for pancaking to destroy the towers in the way that it did the top part would have to be raised 120 MILES ABOVE IT and fall for 200 seconds. Puts Heiwa's "2 miles" above the lower block to shame, doesn't it?
 
Last edited:
His calculation say the wtc would only collapse under the weight of 100 wtcs... Yeah his Mathematics is bogus.
 
He's claiming that it would take a mass of something like 60,000 tons travelling at mach 6 (over 2 km/s) to demolish the lower part!!!!!!!!!!

Man, those towers were well built.
 
Last edited:
So if someone wanted to destroy Manhattan with atomic bombs, how many would they need?

It takes 3.2 A-bombs per WTC tower and they were the biggest buildings there, so lets be generous and estimate just one for every other skyscraper....

That's a lot of nukes.:wackyeek:
 
Cold War strategic nuclear attack ground zero,,, Manhattan.

So if someone wanted to destroy Manhattan with atomic bombs, how many would they need?

It takes 3.2 A-bombs per WTC tower and they were the biggest buildings there, so lets be generous and estimate just one for every other skyscraper....

That's a lot of nukes.:wackyeek:

So all our fears growing up during the cold war were unfounded? According to this guy, all the energy from a nuclear attack would be used up, Consumed during the destruction of all the skyscrapers in Manhattan while we could have safely watched from the piers at liberty park in NJ?
 
Last edited:
:boggled:

"Ze potential energeeez of ze upper sekshuns are eeeqwated to the amounts of bombz, zerfore, something"

He's basically saying all of the potential energy in the upper section was used to destroyed the lower section, which is 3.2 Lil' Boyz?

Very Heiwa'esque. Not so much the logic, but the graphics, they look similar to the stuff on tripod.

Where do these guys get these graphics? It's like they literally go back in time 10 years to get em'. It's like Paintshop from Windows 95'.
 
He's claiming that it would take a mass of over 60,000 tons travelling at mach 6 to demolish the lower part!!!!!!!!!!

Man, those towers were well built.

...and yet we have all seen a commercial airliner of considerably less mass and velocity punch right through the very same structures. Funny that.
 
It's weird because it only took one nuke to destroy the entire alien mothership in Independence Day.

. . . and Stargate.

. . . among others.
 
And... lunacy.

He assumes that there would need to be an equivalent of about 588:1 extra mass applied on the building in order for it to collapse. He then calculates the potential energy of this mass and calculates an equivalent number of atomic bombs.

I didn't bother continuing on past then to confirm the mathematical accuracy of his calculations, I only looked at his assumptions. He assumes the in-service live load is 5 times the dead load and that the maximum allowable is 20 times this. It's a pretty ridiculous assumption.

Alright, I have to keep going, this is so insanely hilarious. Skilling said (and I'm sure most of you remember this) that some of the perimeter columns could support 20 times the design live load. A guy on the 911 commission report team, Ronald Hamburger, SE, stated that the tower, before being damaged, could support 5 times it's own weight. So this lunatic decides to multiply the 5 and 20 together for ALL of the columns as a capacity. And then, for some even more ridiculous reason that I cannot fathom, he multiples this by the ratio of columns below the collapse front to those above.

This has got to be a spoof. Please tell me it's a spoof.
 
Last edited:
Ah.. Mr Boldwyn. I once had an "analysis" of him thrown at me by a Truther, that was supposed to show that the collapses where impossible. Number juggling it was. The resilience to collapse depended only on the weight of the bottom section. Yes.. its weight. Thinking their own argument through (hmm.. imagine I fill the lower section with molten lead) and wondering "where did I go wrong?" is not one of the Truthers' strong points.

Without blushing he multiplied safety factors (5 and 20). Yes, multiplied. One of these was a "safety factor" (20) for which I could not find a source other than DRG. Changes are that this is the root of this bizarre factor of 100.

I didn't bother to go to youtube, but the writing style in the OP looks familiar. This man is a peevish crackpot. From googling his name I got the impression that he tried to propel himself as a new rising star of Truther Science.

Ah.. memories.. Memories.. when debunking Truther nonsense was fun.
 
Last edited:
I once ran across another Heiwa'esque truther, who keeps a rather elaborated site on a forray of truthernoia, with the attempt of engineering the 'facts' in the expected fashion:
http://www.takeourworldback.com/wtcdemolition.htm
Excerpt:
The molten structural steel would total 14.06 ins^2 * 12 * 36 * 240 = 1,457,741 ins^3 = 23.89 m^3. After multiplying this volume by the density of steel at 7,860 kg/m^3, we obtain 187.8 tonnes or 207 tons of molten structural steel. That is just for one three-story section of exterior columns per building. Although there were only 47 core columns, the larger cross-sections - that of the steel, and the hollow area for the thermate - would concentrate the molten metal and allow it to remain molten for longer. As we shall see, the molten metal from the basement core columns was not only dispersed amongst fewer columns, but totalled more than the 464 tonnes of molten metal resulting from thermate applied to 240 thirty-six feet sections of perimeter column.

:p
 
I dont know about that, I'm mainly shocked that he said it would take the energy of 3.2 ATOMIC BOMBS to destroy a WTC tower, and that for pancaking to destroy the towers in the way that it did the top part would have to be raised 120 MILES ABOVE IT and fall for 200 seconds. Puts Heiwa's "2 miles" above the lower block to shame, doesn't it?

Must be awfully small atomic bombs. 10 kilotons was the smallest I saw.
 
Man, that made my head spin - and I only made it through the first 2 pages! I remember seeing this a few years (?) ago. Hopefully someone set this poor guy straight somewhere along the line.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom