9/11 CTs in general

And now take a bunch of rednecks who don't know anything but the damn TV... What do you think, counts to them?

Your assertion here seems to suggest that many Germans have something in common with "rednecks:"

Back here in germany, I always get into arguments with people, who have never ever been to the united states, but know from TV, that americans are fat, stupid, and so on... As Michael Moore already pointed out... And they don't know anything about foreign countries or politics, geographics whatsoever.

Of course, you know, real everyday life is exactly as it is depicted on our television programs and movies and news shows that are viewed overseas. Seems like every day I'm dodging driveby shootings in my "hood" while trying to avoid the size-2 flawless skinned supermodel hookers who proposition me on my way to work.

News shows are sensationalist, just as fictional TV programs and movies are fictional. They need to be out of the ordinary or they wouldn't be entertaining, they would not sell. Watch one of those un-edited bits of video from the Loose Change Boys showing one of their trips to NY and you'll see exactly what I'm talking about.

And, while I'll certainly admit that there are some ignorant people about, the stereotype that Americans are fat & stupid is insulting. I don't know where they find these people who can't find Iraq on a map, or have no idea who the president of Mexico is, or any number of those questions you see published in the polls, but they're not anyone I know. I've lived on 3 continents and I speak 2 foreign languages (one fluently, one passably). I live in an area where I can walk to work every day, keep up with world news fairly well, and would take on anyone from any country in a geography contest. So don't paint us all with the same brush.

Also, I don't feel that it's as important to know as much about as many different countries here in the States, compared to a place like Germany, because we don't have so many different neighboring countries with people speaking different languages that we have to deal with on a daily basis. Even between our 2 bordering countries, one of them speaks (mostly) the same language as we do.

ETA: I know Andreasz was arguing against those types of arguments, so this isn't directed specifically at him, but the sort of statements he was relaying, like the nonsense Oliver posts sometimes, aggravate me to no end.
 
Last edited:
Real terrorism, for instance, doesn't occur very often. In germany we had the RAF, don't know if you heard of it. In short: Back in the 1970s, these people tried to make a point by planting explosives, assassinating 'capitalists', robbing banks (irony?) to protest against US-like imperialism and capitalism in general.

This was real. The founders of this group killed themself in 1976 and 1977. They were both in prison at the time. Some people doubt the suicide, but that's not too important. The point is that this actually happened. As a result, after years of terror, an anti-terror law was passed in germany. But nothing even close to the patriot act. Many people died, millions of german Marks (german currency at that time) were stolen, buildings destroyed and people had to live in fear of terror.

.

It was not real, it was all a plot by the West German government as an excuse to tighten their control over the country. The "terrorists" were in reality members of GSG9 who were ordered to carry out the attacks.
 
Is there anybody in the truth movement not motivated by ideology or politics?

If depends on how you define ideology.
A great many of them,as has been pointed out,seem to be people in the 15 to 20 year old age group going through a intense "F--k All Authority" stage. I have a feeling that if a Liberal Democrat would have been in office when 9/11 happened a lot of these would still buy into the Conspiracy crap simply because they would hate ANYBODY in a position of authority. If you define that as an real ideology,yeah,almost all CTers have a ideological basis.

The Twoofers are a mixed lot....some Hate Dubya so much they would beleive anything bad about him, some are the Hardcore Cters who will buy into any wack theory (the large crossover between 9/11 CTs and the Moonbats shows that), and some are just going through a "Hate All Authority and Fight The MAN" stage.
THe ones I really dislike are some on the extreme political Left who probably know what a bunch of crap the 9/11 Conspiracy Theories are but push them anyway. That I find reprehesible.
 
Alt-F4: You really don't get it, do you?

Why, do you think, do soooooo many people encrypt their mail with GPG/PGP? Why do people use services with client authentication SSL via certificates?

It's not about "Yeah ma, thanks, love you too..."

And the Bush administration is embarassing for the entire united states. Back here in germany, I always get into arguments with people, who have never ever been to the united states, but know from TV, that americans are fat, stupid, and so on... As Michael Moore already pointed out... And they don't know anything about foreign countries or politics, geographics whatsoever. And of course, they re-elected Bush...

This makes it really hard to tell people, that not all americans are as stupid as they may think.

But an "I don't give a damn" attitude will just prove their point.

Thinking that someone is fat and stupid from what they see on TV is, well stupid. As for Michael Moore I find it puzzling how some europeans fawn over him. To me I find it ironic that he has made himself very rich attacking the very system that has made him so.
 
You are assuming only a brute force attack. Try to think of other forms of attack, including how your private key may be compromised.

Name one. I can't think of any.

The key was generated by myself. So it is nothing but a random hash noone else has access to.

I don't use any crap like Windows and the key is in a protected environment. There is really no way for anybody to gain access to my e-mail.

Of course, I don't encrypt everything of it, because it requires the other party to offer a public key that I can use to encrypt the message to him/her. But the important messages I write are all encrypted.

I pay a lot of attention to the information I offer about myself and how I deal with it. There was a german law, after 9/11, that allows the government, on suspicion, to look into your private mail if you use a freemail provider. I don't do that, but if I did, I would certainly encrypt all of my messages.
 
Thinking that someone is fat and stupid from what they see on TV is, well stupid. As for Michael Moore I find it puzzling how some europeans fawn over him. To me I find it ironic that he has made himself very rich attacking the very system that has made him so.


Moore is just a populist. No better than Bush or anybody else. I got some smiles out of his two movies, but I don't take him seriously in any way.
 
It was not real, it was all a plot by the West German government as an excuse to tighten their control over the country. The "terrorists" were in reality members of GSG9 who were ordered to carry out the attacks.

...very funny ;)
 
Your assertion here seems to suggest that many Germans have something in common with "rednecks:"

That is most likely due to anti-USA-propaganda on german television a few years ago. Now they're pro-US again, god knows why... But I have to agree with you on that... There are many narrow minded people in germany, acting like rednecks from that perspective. But usually they achieve something in life anyway. German TV is different from the one in the US.

And, while I'll certainly admit that there are some ignorant people about, the stereotype that Americans are fat & stupid is insulting. I don't know where they find these people who can't find Iraq on a map, or have no idea who the president of Mexico is, or any number of those questions you see published in the polls, but they're not anyone I know. I've lived on 3 continents and I speak 2 foreign languages (one fluently, one passably). I live in an area where I can walk to work every day, keep up with world news fairly well, and would take on anyone from any country in a geography contest. So don't paint us all with the same brush.

I guess you find them on the streets in Virginia, Texas and so on ;) But seriously... You already made your point. 'Sensational'. They pick 3.000 people and you see the top20 most stupid on TV ;)


Also, I don't feel that it's as important to know as much about as many different countries here in the States, compared to a place like Germany, because we don't have so many different neighboring countries with people speaking different languages that we have to deal with on a daily basis. Even between our 2 bordering countries, one of them speaks (mostly) the same language as we do.

Yupp. That's exactly my point in discussions with ignorant germans. You get stuff like 'They don't even know where Austria is...'. My reply to that is most likely: 'Well... Do you know where Texas is?' - You can imagine the rest of the conversation. I always tell them that there's no need for an american to know where austria is, as long as a german doesn't know where giant TX is.

Anyway... double-standards, nothing new. In germany you also get along quite well with your own language only... Even the movies are dubbed here. Disgusting. But they have english at schools here. Unfortunately, most germans consider 'english' at school as a school subject and not as a language.
 
Germany made this experience and it is proven to be sufficient to allow the government to control this one tiny part of your personal life. Keep track of which country you're traveling to and where you're living. Social security, taxes, ... There are so many things that let you keep track of people. And from a US government perspective, it is still not enough. I don't want to be chipped, like my dog. There is absolutely no need to have a dark vision of the future, where I can be held responsible for everything I do that might be considered out of line.

It's not of anyones business, where I am, who's with me in the same room, same place, whatever. And no 'act' should have the power to change that. Did anyone of you READ the patriot act? The bottomline is pretty obvious... But americans don't seem to be bothered about it. Anything like this in germany and we'd have a civil war.

The law that was passed in germany was introduced to identify people who actually come out of our own families, groups, etc. What's the point of the patriot act?

Hate to break the news to you but I have to have my civil liberties trampled upon. You seem to have no problem with having to register with the local police when you move. That's one thing that is not in the Patriot Act. If the government tried that here every congressman in the country would have their phone line jammed with angry calls.

I'm not sure if you are playing devils advocate for fun or you really believe some of the non-sense you are peddling here. If it's the latter all I can say is put down the Jägermeister. Quite frankly I find it insulting that anyone with half a brain would believe the whole no plane theory.
 
That's exactly my point in discussions with ignorant germans. You get stuff like 'They don't even know where Austria is...'. My reply to that is most likely: 'Well... Do you know where Texas is?' - You can imagine the rest of the conversation. I always tell them that there's no need for an american to know where austria is, as long as a german doesn't know where giant TX is.

That's a pretty good point - I think a lot of people from Europe don't really understand the dynamic that exists here amongst the various states. It really is similar to a number of small countries all packed together - so in that way it's a lot like Europe, but the same language (for the most part) is spoken in each, so in that way it's quite different.

One thing I've noticed, which I think shows this difference between how people think of America and Europe, is that Americans, when asked, will tell you what state / metropolitan area they are from, whereas Europeans will almost always give you a country. When a European asks me where I'm from, they expect me to say "the U.S." and not "St. Louis" or "Missouri." But, giving an answer like that makes as much sense to us as someone from München telling you they are from "Europe". Even when they say, "I am from Germany" I suspect that the next question (at least in the minds) of most Americans would be, "Oh? What part?"*

In any event, we've drifted away from talking about conspiracies into talking about politics and social issues, and I apologize for the derail. <back on track> I think that conspiracy theorist culture does not reflect well on our society, and certainly helps to reinforce those stereotypes at which I take umbrage.


*(Unless they're a very small country - in my experience the smaller the country the funnier the response)
 
Name one. I can't think of any.

The key was generated by myself. So it is nothing but a random hash noone else has access to.

I don't use any crap like Windows and the key is in a protected environment. There is really no way for anybody to gain access to my e-mail.

Of course, I don't encrypt everything of it, because it requires the other party to offer a public key that I can use to encrypt the message to him/her. But the important messages I write are all encrypted.

I pay a lot of attention to the information I offer about myself and how I deal with it. There was a german law, after 9/11, that allows the government, on suspicion, to look into your private mail if you use a freemail provider. I don't do that, but if I did, I would certainly encrypt all of my messages.

You may want to research or think a little harder.

Brute force methods:
- Trial division
- Quadratic Sieve (QS)
- Multiple Polynomial Quadratic Sieve (MPQS)
- Double Large Prime Variation of the MPQS
- Number Field Sieve (NFS)
- Birthday Attack

Others:
Chosen Cipher Text Attack
Low Encryption Exponent Attack
Error Analysis Attack
Passphrase Length/Information Theory Attack
Keypress Snooping
Van Eck Radiation Snooping
Memory Space Snooping
Disk Cache Snooping
Packet Sniffing
Trojan Horse Attack
Reworked Code Attack

And these are just the PUBLICLY known forms of attack.
 
You may want to research or think a little harder.

Brute force methods:
- Trial division
- Quadratic Sieve (QS)
- Multiple Polynomial Quadratic Sieve (MPQS)
- Double Large Prime Variation of the MPQS
- Number Field Sieve (NFS)
- Birthday Attack

Check this one.
http://www.iusmentis.com/technology/encryption/pgp/pgpattackfaq/asymmetric/

Either you don't know what you are talking about or you are just 'testing' me. Brute forcing a 2048bit GPG key is really pointless. It's like using a pencil to tear down a steel door. Check the MIPS table for the time you would need to guess the key.

AND if you manage to guess it, you will still need to guess the passphrase. This is why this method is considered secure.

Others:
Chosen Cipher Text Attack
Low Encryption Exponent Attack
Error Analysis Attack
Passphrase Length/Information Theory Attack
Keypress Snooping
Van Eck Radiation Snooping
Memory Space Snooping
Disk Cache Snooping
Packet Sniffing
Trojan Horse Attack
Reworked Code Attack

And these are just the PUBLICLY known forms of attack.

Most of that stuff works for faulty windows software. On an OpenBSD system it's just as pointless to try 'hacking' as for the GPG key... there are no known remote holes in OpenBSD. You can check on openbsd.org, if you don't know this operating system.

Behind OpenBSD, you can have almost any kind of software, operating system or architecture. That's almost immune to any kind of attack.

'almost' just because I have worked with IT security my entire life. Most people would call this unbreakable. Windows users most likely don't even know this kind of security.
 
*arches a brow* andreas, I work in the intelligence community. I am VERY aware of the power of information. And as the majority of your posts seem to be against the current Patriot Act, from an admittedly cursory inspection, I will tell you this. If the government wants to read my personal email, they are welcome to, because I am one of those people who dislikes breaking the law and would never consider sending an email that, upon a cursory inspection, would seem to be intimating I intended harm, either physical or psychological to others.

The information I deal with on a semi-daily basis is orders of magnitude more important than the trivial details of my life, which the government knows all about anyway due to the exhaustive background investigation they conducted to give me my clearance.

That being said, if I simply stick to your example, I can see your point; I just don't agree with it. You seem to be intimating that I should encrypt all of my correspondence, regardless of how trivial, and I view that as the beginnings of acute paranoia. Quite simply, if I don't want information to be splattered all over the internet, I don't post it, either via email, blog, or forum. There are easier ways of safeguarding your information besides encrypting your entire life, the main one of which is simply don't say or do anything in a public manner you wouldn't want splashed everywhere. It's a matter of self control versus "protection of your information" that the majority of people I know do tend to practice instead of encrypting everything. I find my way of "protecting my information" infinitely less complicated than the way you are advocating, and as I have yet to have my identity stolen or to have anyone blackmail me, I would say it seems to be working. Should one or the other of those happen, I would take whatever steps I felt necessary to prevent it from happening again, but I rather doubt I would include encrypting all of my correspondence into it. Just my two cents.

That's exactly what I mean. I have a lot of email contact. For my company, to my employees, private mail... Lots of online-communication. I don't want to change the way I communicate with my people just because some law allows the government to spy on me. They can kiss my a** and give the decryption a shot ;)

It's a matter of principle to me. It's just a plugin for my mailclient, I don't even notice the encryption being done. I really like to piss of anybody trying to invade my privacy in any way.

That's why most of the stuff I consider important is from a software perspective bullet-proof.
 
You may want to research or think a little harder.
Van Eck Radiation Snooping

I had to look that one up. I know this is possible, but a TFT screen doesn't give away too much radiation, does it? And if so, I am still in a safe environment, way out of range for an attack like this.

Very unlikely. And for the record... I wouldn't know how the monitor radiation would expose anything of value to an attacker...? As far as I understood the attack, if successful, it gathers information on what was being displayed on the screen.

Since there is only the framebuffer being sent to the monitor, I don't see any vulnerability there.

Could you explain if I just misunderstand this attack?
 
Hate to break the news to you but I have to have my civil liberties trampled upon. .

Oooppss, I meant to say "Hate to break the news to you but I have yet to have my civil liberties trampled upon".
 
Check this one.
http://www.iusmentis.com/technology/encryption/pgp/pgpattackfaq/asymmetric/

Either you don't know what you are talking about or you are just 'testing' me.

No. Why would I want to test you? This is, as the name implies, an EDUCATIONAL forum. I said to think of something other than a brute force attack. You said you couldn't think of one. I gave you examples.

Brute forcing a 2048bit GPG key is really pointless. It's like using a pencil to tear down a steel door. Check the MIPS table for the time you would need to guess the key.

True, assuming you don't know about non-public factoring algorithms, or the computing power available to run them.

AND if you manage to guess it, you will still need to guess the passphrase. This is why this method is considered secure.

Most of that stuff works for faulty windows software. On an OpenBSD system it's just as pointless to try 'hacking' as for the GPG key... there are no known remote holes in OpenBSD. You can check on openbsd.org, if you don't know this operating system.

Known being the key word. Actually, the Windows OS has very little to do with other modes of attack. Many of the attacks I listed have nothing to do with the operating system.

Behind OpenBSD, you can have almost any kind of software, operating system or architecture. That's almost immune to any kind of attack.

'almost' just because I have worked with IT security my entire life. Most people would call this unbreakable. Windows users most likely don't even know this kind of security.

Agreed; 90% of Windows users don't know how to spell security. In addition you are correct regarding PGP - it is very good. OpenBSD may be good for IT security, but IT security has very little to do with cryptography and the methods to defeat it.

In general, good security is more of a process than any specific piece of software. PGP is pretty good; but so far NO single piece of software or operating system can guarantee that a secure communication cannot be broken.

My only point, as I mentioned, was to try to be educational when you said you could not think of anything other than a brute force attack. Or were you just testing me? :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom