9/11 CTs in general

I was talking about the JREFers opinion of "Truthers". I am not a "Truther" but I do see a few JREFers who apparently think I am...
 
Do you believe the USG was involved in the planning of the 9/11 attacks, and in carrying them out? Yes, No, Not sure but I suspect so, which??

In case you missed it (it was the last post on the previous page)

TAM:)
 
TAM:

I think it is absurd to believe that the USG as a whole was behind the 9/11 attacks, but I do not preclude the possibility of covert deals by rogue agents. Try reading "Dollars for Terror" by Richard Labeviere, "The War Against America" by Laurie Mylroie and "Triple Cross" by Peter Lance for information on how the USG has aided and abetted violent Muslim movements over the past 25 years.
 
TAM:

I think it is absurd to believe that the USG as a whole was behind the 9/11 attacks, but I do not preclude the possibility of covert deals by rogue agents. Try reading "Dollars for Terror" by Richard Labeviere, "The War Against America" by Laurie Mylroie and "Triple Cross" by Peter Lance for information on how the USG has aided and abetted violent Muslim movements over the past 25 years.

I can accept the above, as it is fairly vague, and does not disagree with how I see the world, but could you be more specific...for instance...

Do you think there were elements of the USG (rogue or otherwise) who actually conspired, knowingly, to assist in the 9/11 attacks?

TAM:)
 
What I don't get is why questioning issues like 9/11, Waco, JFK, etc, etc, generates so much ANGER and HATE from the hard-core JREFERs!

You know, Fundamentalist Christians produce and peddle literature that claims that the world is going to end as in The Book of Revelations. Now I think this is a crazy notion, but I am not particularly concerned that some folks believe this. Creationists dispute Darwin's Theory of Evolution... well, good for them!

So if someone believes the US government was involved in some way in 9/11, why go off the deep end about it? And to claim that saying the USG was involved in 9/11 shows disrespect for the victims, their families and friends is nonsense any more than if I claim that Edward VIII and Prescott Bush were Nazi sympathizers shows disrespect for WWII victims.

If the "Truthers" are wrong... time and history will prove them to be wrong. To say they are dangerous or pernicious is absurd, as long as they promote their ideas non-violently. If they are "snake-oil salesmen" then I just put them in there with Jimmy Swaggart, Benny Hinn, Jim Bakker et al.

But you cannot FORCE someone to give up an idea by abusing them, by calling them idiots and liars. Try that on a Fundamentalist Christian and see how far you get!



Frankly, I'd like you to provide some evidence that any regular "debunker" poster in this forum feels hate for any conspiracy theorists. Quite the contrary, perhaps you should be asking yourself why it is that our differences of opinions generate so much antagonism, hate, anger, and even violence from Conspiracy Theorists. I've yet to see anyone here threaten to kill or injure a Conspiracy Theorist. Yet Conspiracy Theorists threaten to injure or kill "debunkers" on a regular basis, and the hate towards the JREF at sites like the Loose Change Forums is nothing short of pathological. You need to get your rose-tinted glasses checked Apollo20.

-Gumboot
 
ref: It is probably likely that they saw a plane but I am convinced that there is nobody in New York who actually saw a plane crash into the World Trade Center.Call it ridiculous...

It is ridiculous. It's an event with thousands of eye-witnesses. To claim that they are all mistaken is an absurdity.

But it's always open to an investigator to go and talk to some of them. Something the doubters never, never do.

But considering the fact that there are hundreds of people with cellphones, video cameras and all that equipment in New York, why are there so few authentic(ated) videos? And why did most of them appear after years?

Is it really that strange that only a small number of people would have their cameras pointed straight up in the air while a plane flew over at high speed? I find it amazing that so many videos exist.

Why should they all emerge at once? There is no central record of personally held videos. There's no requirement for anyone to hand such videos over.

If anything, this is quite obvious to me.

That is quite worrying.
 
Creationists dispute Darwin's Theory of Evolution... well, good for them!

So you don't believe in education then? Do you think it is perfectly OK to teach lies in school? Or is it just possible that responsible people would want education to actually teach people about the world and how to deal with it rather than about magical sky fairies?

If the "Truthers" are wrong... time and history will prove them to be wrong.

How exactly will this happen? Are "history" and "time" going to write books? Or take jobs as teachers? Nothing happens all by itself. If you want to show that something is wrong then you have to show it is wrong. You can't just stand around hoping people will suddenly realise it one day.
 
phew. I didn't expect that much feedback. It still took me a while to read it all.

I am still missing the replies on why Bush and Cheney didn't 'need to be' under oath and why no transcript was handed out by the 9/11 commission.

I also read the 'debunking' thingy on 'september clues'. That's one big problem with conspiracy theorists... They try to make a point but fail miserably, because they tune their story to fit entirely. That Theresa Renauld, or whatever the hell her name was, said, doesn't seem interesting to me in any way... If she lied, so f..ing what? I don't care about some fake interview. What I do care about is that the videos simply don't fit.

The color of the plane, the audio blips on the TV stations... There are so many things to mention.

And one thing in general... The Zeitgeist Movie and the points they make in this film... Why is everybody so concerned about 'debunking' everything? The movie has a really good intention. RFID chips and world government are things nobody on this planet needs. I don't care about some redneck opinion who needs to be taken care of. I want to be in charge of my own life without being bullsh...ed by the system.

Even if there is only one tiny thing that is true about this movie, it still makes some good points everybody should be concerned about. And being a sceptic also means being sceptic towards a government and similar institutions.

And still... I read this too many times by now. I am not calling anybody a liar. But I am convinced, that people, under certain circumstances, are willing to see what seems convenient to them.

How many people do we know, that claim that they saw Jesus? How many people claim, that they were obducted by aliens or some similar crap? Nobody calls these people liars. Though nobody believes them.

This matter made so many people 'eye-witness' something that is, from my point of view, still not proven. From a moral perspective, many people will call that ignorant or ridiculous. But after watching my own home videos (VHS), showing the same weird details, such as something wandering across the screen which has obviously been covered up, this makes me feel really skeptic about wether this actually happened or if I was just duped.

I am still waiting for things to happen, as soon as the first part of this breaks apart.

Thanks for the replies, especially the ones which were actually arguing and not just unnecessary cynicism.

So what about this matter of Bush and Cheney refusing to be under oath? Any clues on that? Anything reasonable?
 
Andreas, my advice to you, continue to pursue the evidence that the buildings were brought down by controlled demolition. The fact that they were is quite obvious. Only a well financed and well connected organization could have had the means to infiltrate security at the WTC complex and planted the explosives. That shows that the 9/11 attacks were carried out by sophisticated conspiracy with some kind of state support (though not necessarily that of the US government.)

As for your ideas regarding the planes, I hope you drop that nonsense as soon as possible. Overwhelming evidence shows that all four planes ended up where the official story says they did.

This coming from the same guy who tried to use the boeing website to support one of his claims by saying the nose gear doors were an avenue of escape. Not knowing of course that they were just that, the nose gear doors, and not a route of escape.
 
sts60: Good point. But I think it would have cost lives of the people involved, considering that you can not remote control a plane like that for a hit like that. I am not too sure about that, but I considering the concept of ILS and plane navigation, it would be really hard to develop something that could actually FAIL-SAFE crash that plane into their remotely. Far too risky. What if you miss? But as I said, not sure about that.

FatesWebb: The human eye is capable of much more than just 10 frames a second. Imagine your images stuttering like that. The truth is a little more complex. Your brain fills in the gaps of what you are supposed to see and gathers additional information from the nervs to complete the image. You can't break that down to actual frames per second.

However, having something run with 24 frames per second, the human eye (and brain) can't tell that this is just a series of images. It appears to be real motion.

So. Still about the question, what the point of slowing videos down is... You don't need a high-speed camera for that. If you take a look at each frame (1/30 second), that will give you a really close look on the video.

There is also a very interesting thing about the second plane hit and the framerate the plane appears to be moving in. I don't know if the plane appears to be skipping across the screen in slow motion (yes, that's the point of slowing it down) due to framerate conversions inbetween PAL/SECAM/NTSC. PAL has something like 25 fps, NTSC has 29.97 or 23,96, depending on some factors I don't know ;)

That might be a reason for the plane appearing to skip across the screen (4th or 5th video of september clues), but that's hard to say because there's not really much in motion except for the plane. So it's really not easy to figure out if it is the entire video that is dropping frames or if it is just the (possibly inserted?) plane.

Take a look and tell me what you think.
 
Andreaz:

with regards to 9/11 CT films in general, I personally debunk them because I do not want innocent people, gullible people to stumble upon them, watch them, and then think they are the truth, because there is no rebuttal to them. Providing a rebuttal to the films (a debunking) allows someone to see ALL the evidence.

TAM:)
 
Last edited:
Andreas, tens of thousand people watching the first tower burning saw live (not on tv) the second plane hit. And you have a converted video that looks strange as proof that something is wrong?
Edited by chillzero: 

Edited for civility
 
Last edited by a moderator:
T.A.M.: Well. But not all of it can be 'debunked'. I think, one big problem of conspiracy theorists is, that they fix some (unnecessary) glitches in their sources to make their point.

Such as cutting out the part of the interview with the girl in chelsea. Or the nonsense about WW2 in the Zeitgeist movies.

Regardless of what you think of the movie and the contents, they _do_ make some good points. I am not talking about that star wars laser weapon crap and similar 'ideas'. I tend to focus on those who actually make a political point and come up with a reasonable theory.

The idea of terror in general is presented very well in the Zeitgeist movie. Men were not meant to live in peace. You can tell by every country, every dialect, every sector. 'neighbors' are most likely in a competition or at their own personal war. For instance, we germans, who live close to the dutch border are sick of the dutch. We hate their language, the way they drive a car, the kinds of food they have, and so on. It's just natural, not personal at all.

But this kind of competition and 'war' in a metaphorical sense is not sufficient to keep a society under full control and obedience. So what happened after 9/11 was the introduction of the patriot act and the war in afghanistan and iraq. People would never go for that without being properly motivated.

Real terrorism, for instance, doesn't occur very often. In germany we had the RAF, don't know if you heard of it. In short: Back in the 1970s, these people tried to make a point by planting explosives, assassinating 'capitalists', robbing banks (irony?) to protest against US-like imperialism and capitalism in general.

This was real. The founders of this group killed themself in 1976 and 1977. They were both in prison at the time. Some people doubt the suicide, but that's not too important. The point is that this actually happened. As a result, after years of terror, an anti-terror law was passed in germany. But nothing even close to the patriot act. Many people died, millions of german Marks (german currency at that time) were stolen, buildings destroyed and people had to live in fear of terror.

Germany made this experience and it is proven to be sufficient to allow the government to control this one tiny part of your personal life. Keep track of which country you're traveling to and where you're living. Social security, taxes, ... There are so many things that let you keep track of people. And from a US government perspective, it is still not enough. I don't want to be chipped, like my dog. There is absolutely no need to have a dark vision of the future, where I can be held responsible for everything I do that might be considered out of line.

It's not of anyones business, where I am, who's with me in the same room, same place, whatever. And no 'act' should have the power to change that. Did anyone of you READ the patriot act? The bottomline is pretty obvious... But americans don't seem to be bothered about it. Anything like this in germany and we'd have a civil war.

The law that was passed in germany was introduced to identify people who actually come out of our own families, groups, etc. What's the point of the patriot act?

Despite all the laws we have got, all the police, border control, and so on, yesterday the italian mafia killed 6 people, less than a mile away from the place where I live. In this area, something like that didn't happen in over 40 years. And still they managed to smuggle automatic weapons from italy into germany , slaughter the people that they were assigned to and disappear.

You have got to see, that this is exceptional. This doesn't happen in everyday life. History has shown, that events like these make people call for justice. And that's, imho, exactly, what is being exploited by governments like the current US administration.
 
Last edited:
Andreas, tens of thousand people watching the first tower burning saw live (not on tv) the second plane hit. And you have a converted video that looks strange as proof that something is wrong?
Edited by chillzero: 

Edited for civility

I didn't say that. I said that I don't know (you know... NOT KNOWING and stuff), if this is the entire video that looks like this, as a natural effect of framerate conversion, OR if there is a glitch in a POSSIBLE forgery.

Read. Think. Reply. How about that?
 
Enormous amounts of eyewitnesses saw the second plane live with their eyes - not on tv! How can there be any question about the existence of it?
 
Enormous amounts of people saw Jesus Christ... So what?

Do you honestly believe, that what flies by in less than five seconds and explodes, as it hits the WTC, will be what people actually saw or what everybody tells them it was?

I don't care about the eye-witnesses. There are also hundreds of claims of people who saw a missile. So what? People don't give a damn about what an eye-witness saw, unless he's got it on tape. Millions saw it on TV, 'witnessed' it. What do you think people care about?

And now take a bunch of rednecks who don't know anything but the damn TV... What do you think, counts to them? And unfortunately, what do you think, these guys opinions are worth?

You'll find the worth of their voice in the previous two presidential elections.
 
I know I am not american, so my opinion may not count for much, but I am getting real tired of all the BITCHING and WHINING about the Patriot Act. Please, anyone, name one person who they personally know who has been effected in a significant and deleterious way by the Patriot Act since its inception?

TAM:)
 
Enormous amounts of people saw Jesus Christ... So what?

Do you honestly believe, that what flies by in less than five seconds and explodes, as it hits the WTC, will be what people actually saw or what everybody tells them it was?

I don't care about the eye-witnesses. There are also hundreds of claims of people who saw a missile. So what? People don't give a damn about what an eye-witness saw, unless he's got it on tape. Millions saw it on TV, 'witnessed' it. What do you think people care about?

And now take a bunch of rednecks who don't know anything but the damn TV... What do you think, counts to them? And unfortunately, what do you think, these guys opinions are worth?

You'll find the worth of their voice in the previous two presidential elections.

This sounds suspiciously like somebody trying to rationalize their summary dismissal of any evidence that doesn't support their conclusion, right down to the gratuitous off-topic political barb at the end.

Is there anybody in the truth movement not motivated by ideology or politics?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom