3 Year Old Shoots Parents . . . Both of Them.

I think the Rule of So applies.





When a sentence starts with "So..." the follow-on is never what the person said, or even meant to say, just a wild exaggeration, i.e., a strawman.

Yes, that's Belz...'s First Law of Non Sequiturs. :mad:
I note neither of you even attempted to answer the question, which is certainly a valid one which follows the claim that waiting periods are Constitutional.

When, if ever, does a waiting period become unconstitutional? A week? 30 days? 6 months? Please be specific and cite your reason.
 
my favorite part of the story:

The couple could face felony negligence charges. The child does not face criminal charges, Drobik said.

Thanks for clearing that up... :D
 
"A right delayed is a right denied" - Martin Luther King Jr.
Sorry, which Amendment is that, again?

There has to be a valid reason for delaying a right, and a period for "cooling off" can hardly be considered valid for someone who already owns firearms or has already gone through a lengthy licensing process.
Of course it can. What if you're out at the bar and someone disses your wife and all your guns are at home?
 
I needed something obvious to make sure I had tge basics down. Originally I was going to go with "So, Whitney Houston and her daughter were right?" but thought it might be too soon. :p

Never too soon for that!!!
 
Who has said that? Not me, and not the Heller court. It's the anti-gun people who say that half of it has no meaning at all, and that "the people" are not really "the people".

Well, yes you did. Tell me again why the first part of the second isn't relevant.

That you have a right to purchase a firearm is certainly implied by the 2nd Amendment

Ooh, implied, now ? This is fun. It sounds a little like when religious fundamentalists claims to believe in the bible literally, and then blurt out that some passage they don't like is a metaphor.
 
Well, yes you did. Tell me again why the first part of the second isn't relevant.



Ooh, implied, now ? This is fun. It sounds a little like when religious fundamentalists claims to believe in the bible literally, and then blurt out that some passage they don't like is a metaphor.

Some folks treat the Constitution like believers treat the Bible, as The Big Book of Multiple Choice. Take what you like, ignore the rest. :rolleyes:
 
Some folks treat the Constitution like believers treat the Bible, as The Big Book of Multiple Choice. Take what you like, ignore the rest. :rolleyes:
Alternatively, that it is the ultimate expression of literal truth and must be followed to the letter, no matter what ridiculous things it says.
 
Well, yes you did. Tell me again why the first part of the second isn't relevant.
It's only irrelevant to the second part in that it does not pose a limitation to the second part. I even quoted the Supreme Court opinion and everything until the mods here decided that court opinions are copyrighted and removed it just before Scalia would have heard about it and sued.

Ooh, implied, now ? This is fun. It sounds a little like when religious fundamentalists claims to believe in the bible literally, and then blurt out that some passage they don't like is a metaphor.
Lots of rights are implied, like abortion for example. Do you compare abortion rights activists to religious nutjobs?

eta: familiarize yourself with the standards for evaluating restrictions on rights, particularly rational basis vs. intermediate scrutiny vs. strict scrutiny and when it is appropriate to use which standard.
 
Last edited:
It's only irrelevant to the second part in that it does not pose a limitation to the second part. I even quoted the Supreme Court opinion

"Only irrelevant" in that it doesn't change anything about the second part of the sentence, then. Ergo, irrelevant. I know about the supreme court decision, WildCat. That's part of what I've been saying: it's a thing of beauty when you get to ignore half of an amendment because you don't like the wording.

Lots of rights are implied, like abortion for example.

Abortion is a right implied where, exactly ?
 
It's only irrelevant to the second part in that it does not pose a limitation to the second part. I even quoted the Supreme Court opinion and everything until the mods here decided that court opinions are copyrighted and removed it just before Scalia would have heard about it and sued.


does the supreme court make these rulings based on instruction or information from the writers of the constitution or are they using some other standard?
 
Photo from yesterday's open carry rally in Olympia, Washington.

2183154d7a3ca85c85.jpg


:eek:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom