3 Year Old Shoots Parents . . . Both of Them.

That's one of the silliest arguments I've ever seen for infringements on an enumerated right.

Actually, since pro-gun people are so fond of playing with the wording of the second, going so far as to deny that half of it has any meaning, and that you can't own a nuke because you can't "bear" it, it stands to reason that an argument that the amendment says nothing about the purchasing of weapons being uninfringed would be acceptable to you.
 
Actually, since pro-gun people are so fond of playing with the wording of the second, going so far as to deny that half of it has any meaning, and that you can't own a nuke because you can't "bear" it, it stands to reason that an argument that the amendment says nothing about the purchasing of weapons being uninfringed would be acceptable to you.

I've noted elsewhere that they would ignore the 2nd if it didn't favor them, albeit in an edited manner.
 
So according to you guys a 5 year wait ought to be constitutional.

How long a wait would you feel would NOT infringe?

And why do you support a wait? Methinks you want to infringe as much as possible.
 
Well if it isn't Belz...'s First Law of Non Sequiturs, there.

I think the Rule of So applies.

But they are letting you acquire it, they're just asking you to wait a short while.

So according to you guys a 5 year wait ought to be constitutional.

When a sentence starts with "So..." the follow-on is never what the person said, or even meant to say, just a wild exaggeration, i.e., a strawman.
 
I think the Rule of So applies.

When a sentence starts with "So..." the follow-on is never what the person said, or even meant to say, just a wild exaggeration, i.e., a strawman.

So pools really are more dangerous than guns?
 
Now you've got a hang of it. But, we'll expect something a bit more original the next time you use it.:D

I needed something obvious to make sure I had tge basics down. Originally I was going to go with "So, Whitney Houston and her daughter were right?" but thought it might be too soon. :p
 
So according to you guys a 5 year wait ought to be constitutional.
Is there anyone seriously proposing a 5 year wait?

How long a wait would you feel would NOT infringe?
By definition, any wait cannot infringe. It's more about what wait would be reasonable. Personally, I'd say a month is the outer edge of what's reasonable.

And why do you support a wait? Methinks you want to infringe as much as possible.
What makes you say that?

Oh, it may be because I've already said before that I want to infringe as much as possible. Regardless, that's not the issue under discussion.

A waiting period means that someone who is angry won't go to the corner Walmart and buy a gun to use against the target of their anger. They will have time to "cool-off".

Never go food shopping hungry, and never go gun shopping angry.
 
What? How? :confused:

I honestly don't see where the infringement is supposedly occurring. If it's neither preventing you from keeping nor bearing a firearm (merely introducing a brief delay on acquiring a firearm from an authorised dealer), in what way is this infringing on your right to keep and bear firearms?

ETA: Or is there some kind of right to acquire firearms without delay that hasn't yet been mentioned?
"A right delayed is a right denied" - Martin Luther King Jr.

There has to be a valid reason for delaying a right, and a period for "cooling off" can hardly be considered valid for someone who already owns firearms or has already gone through a lengthy licensing process.
 
Actually, since pro-gun people are so fond of playing with the wording of the second, going so far as to deny that half of it has any meaning,
Who has said that? Not me, and not the Heller court. It's the anti-gun people who say that half of it has no meaning at all, and that "the people" are not really "the people".

and that you can't own a nuke because you can't "bear" it, it stands to reason that an argument that the amendment says nothing about the purchasing of weapons being uninfringed would be acceptable to you.
That you have a right to purchase a firearm is certainly implied by the 2nd Amendment, and the courts have ruled as such when they overturned Chicago's ban on gun stores, firing ranges, and the transfer of firearms and ammunition within the city.

A right has to have a mechanism to be exercised, you can't ban an abortion clinic (as opposed to abortions) or impose a 10 month waiting period on abortions and say you haven't; actually outlawed abortions for example.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom